Worst to Best: Ranking the Doctor Who Doctors

As Peter Capaldi faces his final season as the Doctor, we look back at the performances that contributed to the enduring series and invite you to choose your favorite. Plus: Who do you think should take over next?

by | April 14, 2017 | Comments

While most long-time Doctor Who fans will avoid trying to rank the Doctors, the truth is that every Whovian has their favorites. As Peter Capaldi returns as the Time Lord with a penchant for weird fashions and boiled sweets, we thought it might be fun to take a look back at the Doctor through his regenerations and see who wore the part best. Of course, that opinion will vary depending on when a person discovers the show, their appreciation for the series writing backing the actor, or whims as capricious as the Doctor himself.

13. Peter Davison (classic series, seasons 19-21)

Known for: A sprig of celery on his lapel; breathlessness.
Highlight: Uniting his previous selves to defeat his old teacher in “The Five Doctors.”

While charming and affable, Davison had the unenviable task of replacing Tom Baker after a seven-year reign. He also took over the part while appearing on two other BBC programs: the drama All Creatures Great and Small and the sitcom Sink or Swim. His era was marked by a stable of writers afraid of the storytelling complexity the show demanded and a producer looking to make the series more theatrical. Watching him in stories like “The Arc of Infinity” and “The Five Doctors,” he reveals a more vulnerable and thoughtful Doctor, but all too often, the rough scripts and overly lit sets illustrate a Doctor who was, unfortunately, unremarkable.

12. Colin Baker (classic series, seasons 21-23)

Known for: Hideous taste, a love for his own voice.
Highlight: His quiet dismay when he learns his companion Peri (Nicola Bryant) was killed due to a Time Lord plot in “The Trial of a Time Lord.”

Following the human and vulnerable Davison, Colin Baker was intended as a return to the crabby, spiteful Doctor of old. After a difficult regeneration, the Sixth Doctor tried to strangle his companion and chose an eye-sore patchwork coat as part of his costume. It is still hard to say which action was the greater crime. According to the actor, the intention was to mellow the Doctor out as he regained his human qualities. Sadly, audiences did not want to see an unpleasant Doctor and the BBC used the situation to put the show on an 18-month hiatus. It returned as “The Trial of a Time Lord” and its verdict cut Colin Baker’s time in the series short.

11. William Hartnell (classic series, seasons 1-4)

Known for: Flubbing lines, a quickness to anger.
Highlight: His farewell to his granddaughter Susan (Carole Ann Ford) in “The Dalek Invasion of Earth” still holds up as one of the great moments in the series’ history.

Despite being first, William Hartnell stands apart from his successors. Designed as a foil for the series’ real main characters at the time, the First Doctor is often crabby, selfish, and heartless. Once his original companions left and he became the lead, many of his rough edges softened. In hindsight, the first few seasons of Doctor Who reveal how he came to love the Earth, but the much slower pace of the stories and mid-60s production values make many of his stories difficult to enjoy. And while his performance as the Doctor is often enjoyable, it is a very different Doctor Who.

10. Christopher Eccleston (new series, season 1)

Known for: A short life, exclaiming “fantastic!”
Highlight: Announcing his plans to rescue Rose Tyler (Billie Piper) and defeat the Daleks in “The Parting of the Ways.”

The biggest problem with Christopher Eccleston as the Doctor is that we barely got to know him. A prematurely issued BBC press release revealed the actor would leave the series shortly before the revived program debuted. In the States, the series failed to find a broadcaster willing to carry it until after he was gone. And then there is the show itself. Still finding its footing, it goes from the highs of dealing with the Doctor’s PTSD to the lows of farting aliens assuming control of 10 Downing Street. All the while, the Ninth Doctor manically runs from situation to situation, madly grinning with his companion hand-in-hand. His one year of episodes only offers a glimpse of what the actor could have done with it if he had stayed the traditional three years.

9. John Hurt (new series, “The Day of the Doctor,” “The Time of the Doctor”)

Known for: Facing the end of the Time War, proper use of a sonic screwdriver.
Highlight: His relief as he realizes he doesn’t have to destroy his homeworld in “The Day of the Doctor.”

Perhaps an unfair ranking as the War Doctor only appeared in the 50th anniversary special, but Hurt’s few moments as a Time Lord are nothing short of magical. According to early storyboards, Eccleston’s Doctor was going to be revealed as the incarnation responsible for Gallifrey’s destruction. But his (understandable) reticence to return to the part led to Hurt becoming a secret regeneration in the Doctor’s life cycle, presenting all the qualities fans would expect from the Doctor on the worst day of his life. From Hartnell’s crabbiness to Davison’s vulnerability, he also echoed the classic series Doctors, becoming their avatar in the grandest of Doctor Who celebrations to date.

8. Sylvester McCoy (classic series, seasons 24-26)

Known for: Spoon playing; a panama hat.
Highlight: Coolly offering the Daleks the means of their own destruction in their final classic series appearance, “Remembrance of the Daleks.”

Initially presented as a clown, McCoy’s Doctor makes a startling transformation into a master manipulator by the end of the classic series’ final season. Warm and nurturing one moment, the Seventh Doctor could turn on his closest allies — but only if it meant furthering his long-term goals. McCoy reflected the change in the final season with a darker coat and a deepening of his voice, suggesting the Doctor was something older and more alien than we previously thought. Sadly, these ideas were never fully developed as the show entered its long hiatus.

7. Paul McGann (the TV movie)

Known for: Kissing girls, claiming to be half human on his mother’s side.
Highlight: Remembering his companions in “The Night of the Doctor.”

Unlike Eccleston and Hurt, Paul McGann’s brief tenure as the Doctor led to a very long association with the character and the most tantalizing of “what ifs” surrounding Doctor Who. As part of an attempt to import the series to the States in 1996, McGann was the first Doctor viewed consciously for his romantic appeal. And he plays that new dimension for the Doctor brilliantly. Sadly, his TV movie is one of the worst Doctor Who episodes ever produced, but it suggests an appealing, brilliant, and vulnerable Doctor you wanted to spend time with every week. McGann would build on the Eighth Doctor via numerous audio adventures, culminating in his brief return to screens in the short prelude scene, “The Night of the Doctor.”

6. David Tennant (new series, Season 2-4)

Known for: Kissing girls (and at least one boy), calling time a “ball of wibbley-wobbly, timey-wimey stuff.”
Highlight: His determination while punishing the aliens who forced him to return to his Time Lord ways in “The Family of Blood.”

The most popular of the new series Doctors benefits from some of the best scripts ever written in the show’s long history. From “School Reunion” to “Blink” to the final moments of “Journey’s End,” the Tenth Doctor revealed previously unseen depths in the Doctor’s psyche, none more startling than his deeply rooted fear of regeneration and losing his Tennant-ness. He fulfilled the potential for romance first glimpsed with McGann, but took it to a whole new level with his long coat and rail-thin build. He also built on the weariness of Eccleston, becoming “the man who regrets” in the process. And in his wake are plenty of fans who regret that he ever left the show.

5. Jon Pertwee (classic series, seasons 7-11)

Known for: Velvet jackets; Conjuring tricks
Highlight: Revealing a story from his childhood to calm his companion in “The Time Monster.”

Theatrical, yet more contained than just about any other Doctor, Pertwee used the role to break away from his reputation as a variety entertainer and played the part straight. In his era, the Doctor became a patrician hero. Exiled from Time Lord society and banned from travelling through time, he found a family with the United Nations Intelligence Taskforce. He could quarrel with them as intensely as the enemies they fought together, but it only reflected his fierce dedication to truth and a sense of righteousness beyond the self. At the same time, he could still have fun building gadgets and special cars, but it reflected as much about Pertwee’s own personality as it did the Third Doctor’s.

4. Peter Capaldi (new series, seasons 8-10)

Known for: Scottish accent, ordering people to shut up.
Highlight: His proclamation that “I’m an idiot in a box, passing through, helping out, learning” from “Death in Heaven.”

Though his time has not yet ended, Peter Capaldi’s Twelfth Doctor strikes an imposing figure as the show’s attempts to conjure up a regeneration closer to Hartnell finally paid off. Often as crabby and menacing as the First Doctor — and as a careless and self-involved as the Sixth — Capaldi also illustrates what the part looks like when a lifelong fan of the show and an Oscar-nominated actor takes possession of the TARDIS. Admittedly, a number of the storylines in the last few years have proved underwhelming, but Capaldi’s performance is a delightful return to the days when the Doctor was unpredictable and scary.

3. Matt Smith (new series, seasons 5-7)

Known for: Bow ties, devotion to friends.
Highlight: Giving Vincent Van Gough a moment of peace in “Vincent and the Doctor.”

Unlike Capaldi and Tennant, Smith grew up without Doctor Who. Nevertheless, he found the quirky charm and ancient gravitas of the character so quickly you would think he has vivid memories of the show from when it was in black and white. Choosing to dress and model the character after an eccentric professor, Smith’s mile-a-minute speech pattern and frantically gesticulating hands led the series to its greatest successes in the States. Both young and old all at once, Smith’s Doctor could make you laugh and break your heart within moments.

2. Tom Baker (classic series, seasons 12-18)

Known for: A very, very long scarf, Jelly Babies.
Highlight: Shouting “Cockneys!” when asked which tribe inhabits London at the beginning of “The Talons of Weng-Chaing.”

It is fair to say Tom Baker was born to play the Doctor. He’ll also tell you he never really stopped. Giving the Doctor some of his own alien mannerisms and vocal eccentricities, he became the definitive incarnation of the Doctor for decades. His place is well-deserved. Even in the worst stories of his era, Baker’s commitment to an outwardly flippant, but deeply concerned children’s hero never wavers. He also benefited from the continual presence of the show’s best writer, Robert Holmes, who either wrote or rewrote most of the Fourth Doctor tales from 1974 to 1976.

1. Patrick Troughton (classic series, seasons 4-6)

Known for: Getting his companions to run, check trousers
Highlight: Calming his new friend Victoria with the knowledge that “no one else in the universe can do what we do” during a tense night in “The Tomb of the Cybermen.”

Except for Hartnell, all of the actors who have played the Doctor owe a tremendous debt to Patrick Troughton. Besides being the first person to ever face the scrutiny and potential ridicule of Doctor Who fans by replacing the lead, he also established much of the Doctor’s core persona. The indignant retorts, puckish retreats and grave proclamations of doom uttered by his successors involuntarily — or voluntarily in some cases — echo his performance. With the Second Doctor, we meet the meddler in time who wants to see the universe, learn. and help out. But unlike some of his successors, Troughton’s Doctor was unafraid to reveal he was out of his depth. Some of the best moments in a Troughton story come from his confidence being shattered when he realizes he cannot rewire a rocket or complete a math quiz. At the same time, he could recover that confidence and win the day. Often confounding his enemies and allies alike, he could also center himself to reveal a steely intelligence or a surprising warmth. All of it was delivered with a slight tobacco quality in his voice and a twinkle in his eye. Truly the sort of person you would want to see step out of the TARDIS.

Who do you think should take over next? Tell us in the comments! Comments Here

Doctor Who season 10 kicks off Saturday, April 15 at 9/8C on BBC America, followed by spin-off series Class

Tag Cloud

Anna Paquin golden globes fresh Disney Plus scorecard TCA Apple TV+ spinoff RT21 cults Rock CMT Sneak Peek Musical popular Fantasy Star Wars Netflix finale Amazon 20th Century Fox E3 Rocketman adventure Shondaland 2021 movie ESPN The Academy zombies basketball Cosplay ID Broadway Western HBO Go American Society of Cinematographers mutant talk show Chernobyl Certified Fresh adenture lord of the rings Television Academy Mary Tyler Moore Pacific Islander Martial Arts ABC Family Pet Sematary First Reviews theme song Creative Arts Emmys doctor who Sundance Now pirates of the caribbean cancelled television laika romance critic resources RT History Legendary Spring TV robots BAFTA crime drama Britbox Disney+ Disney Plus San Diego Comic-Con Video Games indie hist PlayStation 007 ViacomCBS Christmas Film Festival FX YA Paramount Discovery Channel Podcast documentary based on movie unscripted joker Super Bowl razzies scene in color Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt rotten movies we love films boxoffice Warner Bros. Amazon Studios Travel Channel Academy Awards young adult hispanic heritage month Alien Disney streaming service Holiday ABC Signature Paramount Network Crackle APB The Arrangement women Exclusive Video spanish reviews stop motion TCA 2017 Fall TV ABC game of thrones best foreign Trophy Talk Rom-Com dragons international Horror Lifetime stand-up comedy japanese period drama New York Comic Con screen actors guild Esquire harry potter 2017 Adult Swim emmy awards 2018 posters directors Red Carpet zombie Women's History Month nbcuniversal psychological thriller VH1 comedies Epix Nat Geo Universal kong E! video on demand 45 Summer anthology Pride Month japan Dark Horse Comics 93rd Oscars Emmys BET Awards sports Brie Larson breaking bad IFC Films Character Guide worst movies Spike comics social media Stephen King BBC a nightmare on elm street Crunchyroll spain scary movies adaptation VOD Teen TV One SundanceTV twilight NYCC game show Quiz crime thriller Tarantino Musicals Opinion Binge Guide Schedule Comic Book dark Superheroe italian YouTube nfl Trivia Television Critics Association Mindy Kaling cancelled TV series archives blaxploitation VICE Logo History Comedy cats 24 frames Captain marvel National Geographic 2016 true crime Countdown Walt Disney Pictures rt labs critics edition Photos 99% spider-man canceled TV shows halloween parents A24 A&E The Purge crossover concert Mary Poppins Returns james bond sitcom ratings rt labs streaming movies casting golden globe awards serial killer sag awards CBS All Access Endgame rom-coms mockumentary Animation Tomatazos YouTube Red Mary poppins 2015 australia TV slashers kaiju science fiction Action X-Men aliens debate king arthur Arrowverse 71st Emmy Awards Box Office christmas movies asian-american satire travel Trailer Nickelodeon Ellie Kemper hidden camera Apple blockbusters TLC PaleyFest venice comiccon werewolf The CW series DC Comics 1990s Avengers Extras TNT President Hallmark Christmas movies BBC America latino witnail TV Land Heroines cancelled Sundance DC streaming service screenings heist movie streaming feel good fast and furious festivals PBS reboot LGBT dexter sequels black Country 90s Awards Tour BET docudrama BBC One crime Hallmark Disney natural history CW Seed Marvel spanish language Food Network rt archives dogs anime WGN Lifetime Christmas movies Lucasfilm prank DirecTV Masterpiece The Witch Shudder YouTube Premium Funimation Ovation Mudbound GLAAD monster movies HBO aapi ITV french universal monsters docuseries Chilling Adventures of Sabrina die hard Superheroes Pop Star Trek saw Election comic book movies cancelled TV shows Toys cars FOX Freeform Wes Anderson spy thriller deadpool Showtime hispanic strong female leads south america blockbuster franchise 73rd Emmy Awards space Turner The Walking Dead Winter TV nature Black History Month El Rey politics Baby Yoda First Look CNN ghosts mission: impossible halloween tv Acorn TV Hear Us Out Pop TV discovery Marvel Television book adaptation Reality Competition dc remakes festival LGBTQ FXX Comics on TV Black Mirror Mystery biography facebook Columbia Pictures comic book movie Set visit Year in Review IFC Pirates sequel Infographic tv talk new york political drama Film Vudu live action quibi USA Network See It Skip It 2020 romantic comedy Paramount Plus slasher SXSW criterion Emmy Nominations independent TCM cooking GIFs Grammys Polls and Games 72 Emmy Awards canceled green book police drama Hulu what to watch GoT superman child's play gangster indiana jones versus richard e. Grant worst dramedy SDCC zero dark thirty Tubi jurassic park documentaries movies cinemax vampires Comic-Con@Home 2021 television MTV chucky Peacock Spectrum Originals Tokyo Olympics Amazon Prime Video children's TV renewed TV shows name the review TIFF superhero diversity Reality football Turner Classic Movies godzilla historical drama WarnerMedia Winners Fox News 21st Century Fox Holidays elevated horror Amazon Prime comic Interview Oscars Watching Series dceu TCA Awards cops 4/20 Music thriller marvel comics justice league Classic Film new zealand toronto Valentine's Day Best and Worst news jamie lee curtis high school Sony Pictures psycho Kids & Family know your critic Sci-Fi free movies kids 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards MCU Comedy Central AMC boxing toy story wonder woman critics award winner rotten biopic Image Comics FX on Hulu book Marathons comic books Drama Disney Channel olympics war TCA Winter 2020 singing competition NBC batman USA composers medical drama Pixar video telelvision binge Bravo Apple TV Plus TBS Writers Guild of America Lionsgate legend king kong action-comedy TruTV miniseries hollywood TV renewals TV movies 2019 royal family obituary trailers CBS animated Biopics Nominations Tumblr marvel cinematic universe Rocky all-time Premiere Dates new star wars movies HBO Max Syfy MSNBC teaser stoner Ghostbusters Sundance TV Cannes DGA Starz Awards NBA mcc transformers DC Universe technology target OWN Song of Ice and Fire classics supernatural Elton John disaster Cartoon Network The Walt Disney Company cartoon Thanksgiving suspense Fox Searchlight Family OneApp Marvel Studios Netflix Christmas movies revenge Calendar