Westworld (HBO), Supergirl (The CW), Atlanta (FX)

Fall TV Scorecard 2016

As the holiday season approaches, it’s time to say goodbye to our Fall TV Scorecard, which ranks new and returning shows by Tomatometer, with a final update. Like a good drama, we’re leaving this season on a twist: Donald Glover’s freshman series Atlanta has finished the season at the highest position, while film legend Woody Allen’s Crisis in Six Scenes landed at the bottom of the Scorecard. Even though our TV Scorecard is taking a break until January, have a look at the most recent additions, tune in, and be sure to give us your audience score after you watch.

This week’s additions: The Walking DeadMan With a PlanRectifyThe Great IndoorsThe Living and the DeadGood Girls RevoltPure GeniusPeople of Earth.

Adjusted Score: 19.108%
Critics Consensus: Woody Allen's filmmaking skills prove a poor fit for the small screen in Crisis in Six Scenes, a talk-heavy, unfunny, and overall disengaged production buried below numerous superior offerings.
Synopsis: Woody Allen wrote, directed and appears in this six-episode comedy series.... [More]

#76
Adjusted Score: 19.703%
Critics Consensus: While Hayley Atwell proves a strong and likable lead, her charisma alone cannot elevate Conviction from its worn and familiar trappings.
Synopsis: A woman heads an agency that attempts to reverse cases where innocent people were jailed for crimes.... [More]

Adjusted Score: 6.757%
Synopsis: An in-depth examination of the still-unsolved murder of 6-year-old beauty pageant winner JonBenet Ramsey, who was killed in her family's... [More]

#74
Adjusted Score: 21.892%
Critics Consensus: Man with a Plan's flawed, unimaginative writing fails to properly showcase the charm of its unfortunately underperforming lead.
Synopsis: A contractor becomes a stay-at-home dad after his wife goes back to work.... [More]

Bull: Season 1 (2016)
26%

#73
Adjusted Score: 26.554%
Critics Consensus: Michael Weatherly's performance is top-notch, but not enough to save a show that relies too heavily on a well-worn series of legal show tropes and an off-putting premise.
Synopsis: In Season 1 of this drama, a renowned psychologist heads a prolific trial consulting service in this drama series based... [More]

#72
Adjusted Score: 27.487%
Critics Consensus: Pure Genius is weighed down by stereotypical doctor drama trappings, suffocating its chances of bringing anything compelling and entertaining to the genre.
Synopsis: The medical drama "Pure Genius" follows the inner life of Bunker Hill, a private hospital where a team of doctors... [More]

Notorious: Season 1 (2016)
23%

#71
Adjusted Score: 24.027%
Critics Consensus: Implausible and populated with unlikable characters, Notorious forsakes dramatic credibility in favor of flash and fluff.
Synopsis: A drama that goes behind the scenes of the murky relationship between criminal law and the media as an influential... [More]

MacGyver: Season 1 (2016)
26%

#70
Adjusted Score: 27.365%
Critics Consensus: Despite using spare parts from countless successful TV procedurals, the new MacGyver fails to cobble together a compelling show.
Synopsis: In Season 1 of this action/adventure series, a resourceful former special forces operative is recruited into a clandestine organization to... [More]

#69
Adjusted Score: 28.216%
Critics Consensus: Falling Water attempts complexity and intrigue but churns out an unimaginative concept lacking a redeemable payoff.
Synopsis: Three seemingly ordinary people – trend-spotter Tess (Lizzie Brochere), NYPD detective Taka (Will Yun Lee), and security expert Burton (David... [More]

#68
Adjusted Score: 29.622%
Critics Consensus: Kevin James proves a likable, funny lead, but Kevin Can Wait relies too heavily on predictable, unfunny jokes and a series of lackluster subplots to stand out from the crowd.
Synopsis: In Series 1 of "Kevin Can Wait," recently retired Kevin Gable tries to settle into life away from the police... [More]

StartUp: Season 1 (2016)
33%

#67
Adjusted Score: 26.757%
Critics Consensus: StartUp is a LetDown.
Synopsis: An FBI agent targets the son of a financial swindler who hides his father's money by investing it in a... [More]

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Next

Tag Cloud

period drama Trivia finale comiccon DC Comics Opinion First Look aliens Syfy Comic Book USA romance justice league Sci-Fi MTV Columbia Pictures Western AMC GLAAD Cartoon Network Drama medical drama LGBTQ MSNBC cults cooking Sneak Peek Action thriller Photos TCM crime Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt USA Network crossover Superheroes Video Games Super Bowl RT History Nominations Netflix Apple Song of Ice and Fire dceu El Rey singing competition Christmas APB Oscars docudrama politics Country FOX Star Wars HBO TruTV Tumblr crime drama E3 Reality zombies Biopics Walt Disney Pictures Awards Esquire Thanksgiving Freeform Rock Logo psycho Warner Bros. dc hist CBS Interview DC streaming service Paramount Network IFC historical drama police drama sports mutant TCA cinemax VICE supernatural PaleyFest Musicals Paramount Comedy Central Trailer DC Universe zombie SDCC robots Pop Pirates Martial Arts Amazon Superheroe Toys Best and Worst Star Trek YouTube Red Universal CNN Premiere Dates 2016 GoT technology Animation Lifetime Rom-Com 2017 Character Guide BBC America Mindy Kaling Mary Tyler Moore FX Summer Starz Lucasfilm travel Rocky Tomatazos Sundance Teen Fox News science fiction Winners Showtime unscripted Comedy SXSW GIFs Spring TV Grammys President boxoffice cops war Certified Fresh Set visit Ghostbusters Mystery TLC Winter TV binge Reality Competition BBC ABC Family social media Writers Guild of America Marvel ratings Watching Series blaxploitation Lionsgate discovery Musical Marathons festivals harry potter TV ITV Nickelodeon golden globes Cosplay Spike streaming Ellie Kemper Music Hulu 45 CBS All Access Fantasy YouTube Premium adventure ESPN TIFF composers See It Skip It Countdown what to watch Podcast Extras TCA 2017 Election CW Seed Ovation biography FXX crime thriller PBS Pixar Masterpiece Kids & Family sitcom spy thriller Calendar political drama American Society of Cinematographers Emmys ABC IFC Films BET 007 Schedule Food Network dramedy Disney Disney Channel X-Men Sony Pictures talk show VH1 CMT Adult Swim 24 frames Infographic OWN Acorn TV Crackle Holidays SundanceTV Britbox NYCC History diversity Shondaland A&E Creative Arts Emmys Red Carpet 21st Century Fox Year in Review YA National Geographic The CW NBC Bravo The Arrangement Valentine's Day TBS Horror DirecTV cats Box Office serial killer TV Land vampires based on movie 2015 Polls and Games Fall TV Nat Geo TNT WGN Sundance Now transformers E! Dark Horse Comics 20th Century Fox