Westworld (HBO), Supergirl (The CW), Atlanta (FX)

Fall TV Scorecard 2016

As the holiday season approaches, it’s time to say goodbye to our Fall TV Scorecard, which ranks new and returning shows by Tomatometer, with a final update. Like a good drama, we’re leaving this season on a twist: Donald Glover’s freshman series Atlanta has finished the season at the highest position, while film legend Woody Allen’s Crisis in Six Scenes landed at the bottom of the Scorecard. Even though our TV Scorecard is taking a break until January, have a look at the most recent additions, tune in, and be sure to give us your audience score after you watch.

This week’s additions: The Walking Dead, Man With a Plan, Rectify, The Great Indoors, The Living and the Dead, Good Girls Revolt, Pure Genius, People of Earth.

#77

Crisis in Six Scenes: Miniseries

18%

65%

Critics Consensus: Woody Allen's filmmaking skills prove a poor fit for the small screen in Crisis in Six Scenes, a talk-heavy, unfunny, and overall disengaged production buried below numerous superior offerings.

Starring: Woody Allen, Miley Cyrus, Elaine May, Rachel Brosnahan

#76

Conviction: Season 1

20%

- -

Critics Consensus: While Hayley Atwell proves a strong and likable lead, her charisma alone cannot elevate Conviction from its worn and familiar trappings.

Starring: Hayley Atwell, Eddie Cahill, Shawn Ashmore, Merrin Dungey

#74

Man With a Plan: Season 1

21%

72%

Critics Consensus: Man with a Plan's flawed, unimaginative writing fails to properly showcase the charm of its unfortunately underperforming lead.

Starring: Matt LeBlanc, Liza Snyder, Kevin Nealon, Dianna Maria Riva

#73

Bull: Season 1

22%

64%

Critics Consensus: Michael Weatherly's performance is top-notch, but not enough to save a show that relies too heavily on a well-worn series of legal show tropes and an off-putting premise.

Starring: Michael Weatherly, Freddy Rodríguez, Geneva Carr, Jaime Lee Kirchner

#72

Pure Genius: Season 1

26%

84%

Critics Consensus: Pure Genius is weighed down by stereotypical doctor drama trappings, suffocating its chances of bringing anything compelling and entertaining to the genre.

Starring: Dermot Mulroney, Augustus Prew, Odette Annable, Reshma Shetty

#71

Notorious: Season 1

22%

70%

Critics Consensus: Implausible and populated with unlikable characters, Notorious forsakes dramatic credibility in favor of flash and fluff.

Starring: Piper Perabo, Daniel Sunjata, Kate Jennings Grant, Aimee Teegarden

#70

MacGyver: Season 1

25%

57%

Critics Consensus: Despite using spare parts from countless successful TV procedurals, the new MacGyver fails to cobble together a compelling show.

Starring: Lucas Till, George Eads, Sandrine Holt, Justin Hires

#69

Falling Water: Season 1

26%

80%

Critics Consensus: Falling Water attempts complexity and intrigue but churns out an unimaginative concept lacking a redeemable payoff.

Starring: David Ajala, Lizzie Brocheré, Will Yun Lee, Anna Wood

#68

Kevin Can Wait: Season 1

28%

44%

Critics Consensus: Kevin James proves a likable, funny lead, but Kevin Can Wait relies too heavily on predictable, unfunny jokes and a series of lackluster subplots to stand out from the crowd.

Starring: Kevin James, Erinn Hayes, Taylor Spreitler, Mary-Charles Jones

#67