Best-Reviewed TV Sci-Fi/Fantasy/Horror 2017

The horror! The horror! The top five series in this category for 2017 share a certain bloodlust, though each in its own peculiar or fantastical way. Game of Thrones, meanwhile, finds itself locked out of the category’s top spots for the first time since RT began awarding TV Golden Tomato prizes in 2013.

The order of the rank below reflects the Adjusted Score as of December 31, 2017. Scores might change over time.

Adjusted Score: 103.466%
Critics Consensus: Stranger Things' slow-building sophomore season balances moments of humor and a nostalgic sweetness against a growing horror that's all the more effective thanks to the show's full-bodied characters and evocative tone.
Synopsis: It's 1984 and the citizens of Hawkins, Indiana are still reeling from the horrors of the demagorgon and the secrets... [More]

Bates Motel: Season 5 (2017)

Adjusted Score: 100.495%
Critics Consensus: Bates Motel's final season brings the franchise full circle, with a satisfyingly creepy conclusion to the trials and tribulations of Norman Bates.
Synopsis: Two years after the events of Season 4, "Bates Motel" returns in Season 5 to a still murderous Norman (Freddie... [More]

Adjusted Score: 101.275%
Critics Consensus: With reliably ambitious storytelling and outstanding performances from its cast, Season 3 of The Leftovers approaches the series' conclusion as thoughtfully, purposefully, and confidently as it began.
Synopsis: Season 3 begins three years after the Guilty Remnant descended on Miracle, Texas, where Kevin is now chief of police,... [More]

Adjusted Score: 90.764%
Critics Consensus: Black Mirror proves with its fourth season that the series still has ample source material to terrify fans with technology that is now -- or soon could become -- an integral part of our lives.
Synopsis: Black Mirror is an anthology series that taps into our collective unease with the modern world, with each stand-alone episode... [More]

Adjusted Score: 99.764%
Critics Consensus: Surreal, suspenseful, and visually stunning, this new Twin Peaks is an auteurist triumph for David Lynch.
Synopsis: New mysteries unfold 25 years after the shocking death of homecoming queen Laura Palmer in a quaint northwestern town.... [More]

Tag Cloud

Winners Certified Fresh Tomatazos Walt Disney Pictures Ghostbusters romantic comedy mission: impossible Stephen King Lifetime Reality Competition Bravo DC Comics Rocky sequel Comic Book golden globes 4/20 stand-up comedy comedies SDCC social media cars Mary Tyler Moore canceled TV shows Cannes Cosplay spy thriller VH1 Television Academy Schedule TCA Winter 2020 USA 2015 San Diego Comic-Con unscripted Nickelodeon Valentine's Day spider-man universal monsters BBC America Oscars TIFF IFC Films natural history dceu RT21 Mindy Kaling Hallmark Christmas movies Rock ABC Pride Month based on movie HBO dc Mary Poppins Returns cancelled psychological thriller Lucasfilm Tarantino werewolf criterion screen actors guild adventure screenings Awards Tour technology Elton John Star Trek series cancelled TV series FOX Christmas President 20th Century Fox Amazon First Reviews TNT FX Epix Turner Classic Movies FX on Hulu children's TV Apple TV+ renewed TV shows USA Network Polls and Games CBS All Access Disney TV renewals AMC Adult Swim Chernobyl revenge Film Festival GLAAD period drama Photos free movies what to watch Warner Bros. Star Wars police drama FXX toy story Baby Yoda anthology dragons rotten movies we love Horror comiccon YA Tumblr green book Awards crossover Britbox Pirates Arrowverse asian-american reviews HBO Max cinemax Starz politics Hallmark hist serial killer blockbuster E! batman mutant TV hispanic MSNBC Black History Month 2017 Sony Pictures Pixar historical drama The Witch zero dark thirty Thanksgiving 2020 Rocketman Freeform Best and Worst Family Mystery Heroines independent Discovery Channel quibi chucky CMT Amazon Prime psycho dogs OneApp Binge Guide cancelled television ESPN mockumentary Logo BBC indie Paramount Trophy Talk comic Box Office true crime Paramount Network Marvel LGBTQ strong female leads Shondaland 2016 crime drama Turner Superheroes GIFs Universal book New York Comic Con ratings Martial Arts 2018 witnail Fantasy scary movies elevated horror Amazon Prime Video TruTV Crackle tv talk Netflix anime NYCC Trailer Action Anna Paquin child's play SXSW Pop TV cats disaster Marathons TCA Emmys TCM Pop movie CBS reboot Musicals CW Seed Rom-Com 21st Century Fox supernatural YouTube Premium cops PBS WarnerMedia Brie Larson Interview Academy Awards Women's History Month Comedy Disney Channel parents Opinion Avengers Amazon Studios Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt aliens BET Country Super Bowl foreign Superheroe war ITV Comedy Central cooking Sci-Fi Writers Guild of America theme song talk show teaser thriller The Purge Winter TV TCA 2017 video Reality History Lionsgate streaming 007 game show best sitcom Netflix Christmas movies Comics on TV Cartoon Network Spike versus Chilling Adventures of Sabrina American Society of Cinematographers Endgame Nominations Emmy Nominations singing competition 71st Emmy Awards adaptation Showtime blaxploitation Premiere Dates GoT spinoff doctor who See It Skip It CNN Character Guide TV Land X-Men breaking bad Ellie Kemper political drama YouTube Red award winner biography Set visit nature crime thriller Apple RT History First Look 45 cancelled TV shows festivals spain YouTube Teen finale Video Games Shudder game of thrones cults Esquire Black Mirror comics Fall TV Toys cartoon Food Network Extras Holidays medical drama Hear Us Out DGA documentary Summer Masterpiece MCU Mary poppins Musical Trivia binge Hulu boxoffice Vudu transformers concert dramedy richard e. Grant WGN The CW Tubi Pet Sematary Calendar Ovation canceled sag awards television Nat Geo Peacock facebook Election movies A24 The Walking Dead harry potter El Rey DC Universe romance Infographic diversity Red Carpet Disney streaming service robots directors Sundance TV stoner Crunchyroll E3 Animation franchise kids composers Biopics Acorn TV Western casting a nightmare on elm street spanish language Fox News Disney+ Disney Plus name the review die hard vampires DirecTV Sneak Peek Travel Channel slashers 2019 IFC Apple TV Plus justice league crime Classic Film DC streaming service christmas movies zombie The Arrangement TLC Creative Arts Emmys Music sports Funimation Disney Plus latino National Geographic Watching Series Marvel Television space dark Quiz science fiction Countdown TBS Podcast Captain marvel Mudbound Drama animated Holiday jamie lee curtis Spectrum Originals Spring TV Year in Review A&E Song of Ice and Fire OWN docudrama joker Sundance Now halloween 24 frames Syfy Kids & Family Lifetime Christmas movies ghosts Columbia Pictures SundanceTV LGBT south america travel miniseries APB ABC Family zombies Sundance PaleyFest NBC Film discovery Dark Horse Comics Marvel Studios VICE Grammys MTV