Video Interviews

Will The Irishman Earn Martin Scorsese His Next Best Picture Oscar?: The Ultimate Debate

Mark Ellis, Angie Han, and Scott Mantz are tackling the big one: How does The Irishman stack up against Scorsese's other films? Who's the movie's MVP? And is Scorsese bound for Oscar glory... again?

by | November 3, 2019 | Comments

Netflix released Martin Scorsese’s long-anticipated The Irishman into very select theaters this weekend ahead of the film’s digital release on the streaming platform November 27. And so the world is finally getting its first look at the epic three-and-a-half–hour gangster flick that reunites Scorsese favorites Robert De Niro and Joe Pesci and also features Al Pacino, starring in a Scorsese picture for the very first time. Critics are loving it so far: The movie is Certified Fresh at 97% on the Tomatometer, and the director and lead cast are all considered sure-things for nominations this awards season. But is this adaptation of I Heard You Paint Houses, the story of gangster Frank “The Irishman” Sheeran and his relationship with union leader Jimmy Hoffa, everything the buzz says it is? That’s the question Mark Ellis is asking critics Scott Mantz and Angie Han (Mashable) in this Irishman deep dive. The panel tackles all the big questions about Netflix’s big Oscar play: Is it Scorsese’s best movie? Who stands out in the cast? Does the movie completely sideline its female cast? And, of course, we ask if this movie will land the legendary director his second Best Picture statuette?

The Irishman is in select theaters now and available on Netflix November 27, 2019. 

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.


The Irishman (2019)

Adjusted Score: 124315%
Critics Consensus: An epic gangster drama that earns its extended runtime, The Irishman finds Martin Scorsese revisiting familiar themes to poignant, funny, and profound effect.
Synopsis: In the 1950s, truck driver Frank Sheeran gets involved with Russell Bufalino and his Pennsylvania crime family. As Sheeran climbs... [More]
Directed By: Martin Scorsese

Tag Cloud

cinemax American Society of Cinematographers nbcuniversal interviews Creative Arts Emmys Spike pirates of the caribbean anthology japan Tubi Summer doctor who ViacomCBS National Geographic sopranos video 2019 king arthur GIFs Star Wars zombies high school The Arrangement 2018 1990s Trivia superhero tv talk The Walt Disney Company Sundance Turner Classic Movies Classic Film harry potter Paramount Network Nat Geo jamie lee curtis spanish Mary Tyler Moore Nickelodeon 2017 cancelled TV shows Lifetime Christmas movies Stephen King A24 adenture YouTube new york serial killer renewed TV shows 24 frames festival El Rey hist Pirates Ellie Kemper Food Network Pop golden globes comiccon Funimation Interview concert blaxploitation boxing asian-american IFC Superheroes Thanksgiving venice young adult video on demand AMC Neflix a nightmare on elm street scary Nominations CNN thriller Super Bowl Apple TV+ political drama Chernobyl screen actors guild movies Walt Disney Pictures TLC The Witch FX Crackle cars Freeform Discovery Channel archives Netflix Christmas movies documentaries IMDb TV suspense 94th Oscars critics TV X-Men genre Premiere Dates Musicals The CW streaming 90s Sony adventure Elton John 93rd Oscars Cannes rt archives comics Hulu FOX 72 Emmy Awards Tomatazos Tumblr Infographic Shudder VOD dark Geeked Week Tags: Comedy TruTV Anna Paquin 4/20 space Vudu spanish language CW Seed SXSW 2022 South by Southwest Film Festival Pixar Film Festival international batman Disney twilight football new zealand scene in color film series broadcast Bravo saw science fiction Song of Ice and Fire Legendary action-comedy Year in Review Emmy Nominations Arrowverse legend Mudbound true crime Hollywood Foreign Press Association Musical royal family Amazon Prime italian IFC Films Star Trek Extras comic USA Network zombie Ghostbusters HBO Go die hard Film witnail movie RT21 First Look Grammys biography Oscars MTV 2016 Women's History Month Baby Yoda Syfy YouTube Premium Teen rom-coms New York Comic Con obituary Martial Arts Red Carpet art house Wes Anderson Tarantino emmy awards japanese 007 dramedy adaptation Britbox Rocky Best Picture Schedule DC streaming service toy story dc obi wan Mary Poppins Returns hidden camera Music french Oscar Star Wars Celebration TCM Acorn TV marvel cinematic universe Action spider-man YouTube Red APB 45 Mystery BBC One Fall TV franchise crime drama natural history Cartoon Network boxoffice spy thriller satire Travel Channel Rom-Com Valentine's Day target scene in color Pet Sematary Mary poppins singing competition live event Podcast all-time Character Guide laika stoner DirecTV award winner 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards VICE mockumentary Toys Fox Searchlight sports BAFTA parents Native Hear Us Out Apple NBA feel good wonder woman WarnerMedia Calendar Kids & Family razzies Awards Tour LGBT halloween comic book movies BBC scene in color series vs. rotten movies we love king kong Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Reality trophy south america TCA Winter 2020 finale summer TV preview MCU SundanceTV 2015 deadpool PaleyFest dexter cancelled black MGM streaming movies TV One spinoff Christmas 79th Golden Globes Awards cancelled television E3 critic resources children's TV WGN The Purge Pacific Islander hispanic heritage month robots basketball festivals cancelled TV series BET game of thrones Instagram Live theme song Trophy Talk gangster prank elevated horror streamig Disney+ Disney Plus E! Apple TV Plus book Fox News unscripted documentary know your critic mutant Starz Hallmark Ovation Dark Horse Comics rt labs Country black comedy monster movies Amazon Studios war spain Comedy latino Indigenous historical drama FX on Hulu scary movies sag awards versus game show Marvel Studios TV renewals Columbia Pictures 71st Emmy Awards travel PBS Adult Swim animated Certified Fresh Writers Guild of America Comedy Central godzilla Heroines indiana jones Crunchyroll Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Best Actor Rock Paramount Pictures HFPA quibi stand-up comedy fast and furious disaster ITV Election target police drama biopic dreamworks Esquire politics chucky Avengers crossover Photos strong female leads Countdown Image Comics Academy Awards revenge what to watch debate scorecard teaser DC Comics directors First Reviews Hallmark Christmas movies BET Awards romantic comedy diversity HBO See It Skip It 73rd Emmy Awards christmas movies Marvel Television blockbuster Universal superman Sneak Peek Comics on TV halloween tv casting rotten cults Lucasfilm Family kong sequels Comic-Con@Home 2021 FXX NYCC kaiju Warner Bros. Amazon Prime Video VH1 Black History Month Spectrum Originals Shondaland medical drama Lifetime Netflix Tokyo Olympics GoT Best and Worst Turner AMC Plus Set visit Polls and Games TCA 2017 CBS All Access discovery Cosplay TCA Awards Logo Binge Guide Opinion History free movies new star wars movies comedies summer preview ABC Signature films social media slashers GLAAD Pride Month period drama green book Focus Features ratings hollywood rt labs critics edition golden globe awards remakes best Reality Competition aapi posters HBO Max dceu nature summer TV richard e. Grant comic book movie indie Brie Larson olympics Holidays cops worst movies spider-verse CMT hispanic trailers Drama Disney streaming service 21st Century Fox Comic Book technology news Black Mirror women live action jurassic park LGBTQ Universal Pictures breaking bad docudrama foreign Quiz sitcom docuseries Masterpiece name the review reviews romance Video Games YA Spring TV fresh Alien NBC The Academy cooking crime thriller Winners ESPN universal monsters TBS Epix Animation ABC Family Awards TIFF lord of the rings 2021 A&E Endgame telelvision TCA OWN Fargo RT History Prime Video Broadway australia SXSW Television Academy criterion ABC OneApp CBS leaderboard Horror Trailer psychological thriller classics comic books binge werewolf Box Office Best Director zero dark thirty nfl Lionsgate Pop TV DC Universe Television Critics Association The Walking Dead mcc mission: impossible independent Paramount Mindy Kaling cartoon blockbusters facebook joker TNT composers marvel comics USA SDCC canceled TV shows MSNBC San Diego Comic-Con toronto ID heist movie reboot justice league Watching Series ghosts Rocketman miniseries series television Showtime PlayStation TV movies dogs DGA Best Actress crime based on movie Sundance Now anime 99% Disney Channel book adaptation psycho supernatural stop motion transformers Sci-Fi Captain marvel cats Exclusive Video worst TV Land child's play Marathons canceled Disney Plus Peacock BBC America Emmys mob Holiday sequel Amazon Sony Pictures aliens Superheroe scene in color Winter TV Paramount Plus slasher Marvel Biopics Sundance TV dragons 20th Century Fox james bond Western talk show President popular vampires 2020 kids screenings Fantasy