Video Interviews

Will The Irishman Earn Martin Scorsese His Next Best Picture Oscar?: The Ultimate Debate

Mark Ellis, Angie Han, and Scott Mantz are tackling the big one: How does The Irishman stack up against Scorsese's other films? Who's the movie's MVP? And is Scorsese bound for Oscar glory... again?

by | November 3, 2019 | Comments

Netflix released Martin Scorsese’s long-anticipated The Irishman into very select theaters this weekend ahead of the film’s digital release on the streaming platform November 27. And so the world is finally getting its first look at the epic three-and-a-half–hour gangster flick that reunites Scorsese favorites Robert De Niro and Joe Pesci and also features Al Pacino, starring in a Scorsese picture for the very first time. Critics are loving it so far: The movie is Certified Fresh at 97% on the Tomatometer, and the director and lead cast are all considered sure-things for nominations this awards season. But is this adaptation of I Heard You Paint Houses, the story of gangster Frank “The Irishman” Sheeran and his relationship with union leader Jimmy Hoffa, everything the buzz says it is? That’s the question Mark Ellis is asking critics Scott Mantz and Angie Han (Mashable) in this Irishman deep dive. The panel tackles all the big questions about Netflix’s big Oscar play: Is it Scorsese’s best movie? Who stands out in the cast? Does the movie completely sideline its female cast? And, of course, we ask if this movie will land the legendary director his second Best Picture statuette?

The Irishman is in select theaters now and available on Netflix November 27, 2019. 


Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

#1

The Irishman (2019)
96%

#1
Adjusted Score: 115.672%
Critics Consensus: An epic gangster drama that earns its extended runtime, The Irishman finds Martin Scorsese revisiting familiar themes to poignant, funny, and profound effect.
Synopsis: This biographical crime thriller follows Frank Sheeran (Robert De Niro) as he recalls his past years working for the Bufalino... [More]
Directed By: Martin Scorsese

Tag Cloud

comics Food Network Cosplay OWN vampires TV Land political drama space composers Sci-Fi cinemax cars binge YouTube 2020 IFC Films 2018 Masterpiece SDCC ghosts Travel Channel LGBTQ Amazon Studios free movies 72 Emmy Awards FOX New York Comic Con book NYCC First Reviews Film VICE Mindy Kaling Trivia Pop TV Elton John Rocky black Character Guide remakes Marathons fast and furious hollywood Comics on TV Universal spanish language Comedy christmas movies Epix TCM scary movies Comedy Central nbcuniversal Avengers Hallmark Christmas movies james bond Walt Disney Pictures Tomatazos 45 rotten movies we love technology archives Warner Bros. Academy Awards Captain marvel sports halloween Premiere Dates Hear Us Out Peacock Starz 2015 Netflix E! asian-american game show news 007 Musicals satire thriller mutant Turner Grammys Box Office true crime anime crossover comic books Rom-Com Superheroe mockumentary Sneak Peek FX Film Festival discovery Opinion TCA 2017 screenings Acorn TV 2016 medical drama Television Academy Mary poppins VOD Summer cops DC Universe Crackle Columbia Pictures zombies Ovation ID TCA Awards cancelled TV shows obituary Tarantino Sundance stoner festivals Britbox supernatural Polls and Games unscripted spain Awards Tour independent green book Teen Disney Plus Year in Review TLC theme song Nickelodeon golden globes streaming ABC Family Endgame zombie dramedy halloween tv comic USA The CW Fantasy AMC spider-man FXX Sundance Now Apple TV Plus latino HBO Go Rocketman mission: impossible RT History series what to watch Superheroes dragons Interview worst movies American Society of Cinematographers 4/20 Spike Fall TV Extras Crunchyroll E3 casting facebook Action slashers classics science fiction witnail VH1 indie Schedule serial killer Holiday ABC BAFTA war Trailer Women's History Month Winners Spring TV chucky DirecTV Tumblr diversity Calendar Vudu Esquire Reality Competition natural history MCU TNT PlayStation australia DC Comics Certified Fresh The Purge TruTV FX on Hulu Paramount Binge Guide werewolf social media tv talk Netflix Christmas movies Pirates comiccon Logo ESPN Election italian singing competition GLAAD Super Bowl Disney foreign The Witch Mary Poppins Returns hispanic blockbuster Quiz romantic comedy BBC America Black Mirror Anna Paquin See It Skip It revenge Hallmark politics Tubi psychological thriller Freeform docudrama Countdown psycho teaser Pixar Mystery Apple RT21 A&E Country award winner 20th Century Fox SundanceTV Best and Worst cancelled television Comic Book Music cancelled Mary Tyler Moore cults MTV Baby Yoda Lionsgate crime drama Arrowverse period drama HBO Max versus BBC children's TV stand-up comedy hist Marvel television jamie lee curtis sag awards Set visit canceled TV shows documentary A24 joker National Geographic toy story Valentine's Day DC streaming service child's play Shondaland CMT MSNBC quibi GoT SXSW cooking DGA reviews IFC spinoff rt archives Awards Horror USA Network scorecard The Walking Dead Amazon Turner Classic Movies Oscars sequels adventure Heroines movies indiana jones Disney streaming service Brie Larson ITV Stephen King 21st Century Fox Kids & Family Trophy Talk TIFF Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt strong female leads Sony Pictures Dark Horse Comics franchise Fox News The Academy justice league films based on movie Disney+ Disney Plus CBS japanese CW Seed best PaleyFest animated batman Adult Swim 24 frames Cartoon Network HBO Video Games screen actors guild Winter TV Star Trek french X-Men WarnerMedia spy thriller kids canceled robots Hulu adaptation spanish PBS name the review talk show worst nfl zero dark thirty TBS dark finale Christmas YouTube Red deadpool game of thrones Watching Series Ghostbusters historical drama breaking bad Lifetime Christmas movies Marvel Television The Arrangement Biopics Funimation Infographic cartoon Television Critics Association crime thriller laika superhero reboot all-time TCA Winter 2020 Pet Sematary comedies NBC sitcom Sundance TV Apple TV+ TV renewals parents LGBT Holidays APB Pride Month doctor who YouTube Premium Song of Ice and Fire Chernobyl Black History Month El Rey Syfy 2017 nature festival romance criterion boxoffice Shudder concert Writers Guild of America San Diego Comic-Con dc video on demand cats richard e. Grant Photos video GIFs BBC One police drama crime dceu Marvel Studios Mudbound Podcast Pop Bravo biography dogs aliens Spectrum Originals Toys Ellie Kemper WGN Star Wars renewed TV shows History directors Emmys Reality Emmy Nominations Martial Arts Family CNN Thanksgiving rotten CBS All Access disaster Creative Arts Emmys 71st Emmy Awards movie harry potter TV Amazon Prime BET Rock documentaries 2019 TCA Red Carpet twilight elevated horror Classic Film YA Animation Nat Geo anthology Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Showtime critics sequel Nominations Fox Searchlight miniseries First Look universal monsters Disney Channel travel cancelled TV series Amazon Prime Video Lucasfilm Lifetime President transformers Paramount Network venice emmy awards Western stop motion ratings toronto blaxploitation Musical a nightmare on elm street Cannes OneApp Discovery Channel die hard south america Drama football BET Awards