Video Interviews

Will The Irishman Earn Martin Scorsese His Next Best Picture Oscar?: The Ultimate Debate

Mark Ellis, Angie Han, and Scott Mantz are tackling the big one: How does The Irishman stack up against Scorsese's other films? Who's the movie's MVP? And is Scorsese bound for Oscar glory... again?

by | November 3, 2019 | Comments

Netflix released Martin Scorsese’s long-anticipated The Irishman into very select theaters this weekend ahead of the film’s digital release on the streaming platform November 27. And so the world is finally getting its first look at the epic three-and-a-half–hour gangster flick that reunites Scorsese favorites Robert De Niro and Joe Pesci and also features Al Pacino, starring in a Scorsese picture for the very first time. Critics are loving it so far: The movie is Certified Fresh at 97% on the Tomatometer, and the director and lead cast are all considered sure-things for nominations this awards season. But is this adaptation of I Heard You Paint Houses, the story of gangster Frank “The Irishman” Sheeran and his relationship with union leader Jimmy Hoffa, everything the buzz says it is? That’s the question Mark Ellis is asking critics Scott Mantz and Angie Han (Mashable) in this Irishman deep dive. The panel tackles all the big questions about Netflix’s big Oscar play: Is it Scorsese’s best movie? Who stands out in the cast? Does the movie completely sideline its female cast? And, of course, we ask if this movie will land the legendary director his second Best Picture statuette?

The Irishman is in select theaters now and available on Netflix November 27, 2019. 


Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

#1

The Irishman (2019)
95%

#1
Adjusted Score: 123820%
Critics Consensus: An epic gangster drama that earns its extended runtime, The Irishman finds Martin Scorsese revisiting familiar themes to poignant, funny, and profound effect.
Synopsis: In the 1950s, truck driver Frank Sheeran gets involved with Russell Bufalino and his Pennsylvania crime family. As Sheeran climbs... [More]
Directed By: Martin Scorsese

Tag Cloud

Cosplay TruTV serial killer Sundance Food Network trailers TV movies Acorn TV Family BET social media Fargo NBA biography emmy awards 2019 IMDb TV 1990s Mudbound all-time comiccon Funimation Amazon Prime Video name the review quibi vampires Tubi deadpool Pet Sematary Musical Marvel Television superhero Disney Plus stand-up comedy new star wars movies Crunchyroll harry potter Certified Fresh Arrowverse werewolf joker GLAAD sports based on movie comedies slashers Sony Pictures 2018 El Rey 93rd Oscars Quiz nbcuniversal Holidays action-comedy Tomatazos YouTube Premium BAFTA japanese First Reviews ABC Family critics FX on Hulu reviews science fiction 90s franchise critic resources obituary Nat Geo indiana jones BET Awards Extras Reality Competition venice scary Summer Video Games rt labs target Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt travel Pacific Islander Starz Alien Women's History Month italian police drama elevated horror saw TV One Lucasfilm kong American Society of Cinematographers rt archives sag awards Discovery Channel Winter TV mockumentary History king arthur natural history war feel good game of thrones strong female leads ITV olympics movie FOX MTV FXX Horror Music blockbusters lord of the rings Rom-Com IFC fast and furious australia BBC America OWN Year in Review PlayStation Paramount Plus popular Interview Ovation DC Universe MSNBC Universal Mindy Kaling die hard cancelled TV shows GIFs Polls and Games HBO Go dc LGBT justice league dreamworks TV 72 Emmy Awards Opinion Creative Arts Emmys WarnerMedia Hallmark Oscars best scary movies Stephen King Spike Peacock versus sopranos comic books The Walt Disney Company book cats Valentine's Day Cartoon Network Pop TV Disney Classic Film Hallmark Christmas movies TCA Winter 2020 A24 Fall TV FX YouTube Amazon Prime Superheroe Legendary screenings CBS All Access dramedy The Purge telelvision docudrama VOD cooking VICE canceled TV shows Film 2017 DirecTV Apple TV Plus chucky dark cancelled TV series wonder woman Tumblr Chilling Adventures of Sabrina jamie lee curtis Academy Awards christmas movies Spring TV Lifetime Television Academy Country Syfy stop motion Netflix Christmas movies richard e. Grant ghosts Song of Ice and Fire politics japan CNN black comedy Sneak Peek AMC Plus 007 Action films Nickelodeon Hulu television comic book movies anime 20th Century Fox tv talk BBC boxoffice hist 2016 rotten french IFC Films period drama TLC MCU Tarantino spider-man Lifetime Christmas movies TIFF asian-american RT21 ID psycho RT History APB mission: impossible halloween comic vs. Turner Classic Movies doctor who 45 streaming transformers psychological thriller 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Set visit robots crime drama adaptation marvel comics laika talk show finale Box Office Esquire New York Comic Con Mary Poppins Returns Disney streaming service cancelled television south america know your critic The Arrangement zombies mob king kong Election singing competition Awards high school space godzilla Star Trek sitcom CMT ABC Signature SXSW Ellie Kemper supernatural Lionsgate Amazon Studios Shondaland NYCC Marathons Star Wars docuseries football disaster genre remakes independent CBS Pixar legend 24 frames Television Critics Association Podcast spider-verse casting live action The Academy spain 21st Century Fox witnail DC streaming service composers zombie Film Festival Red Carpet Christmas Comics on TV E! PBS zero dark thirty Trivia crime Instagram Live Superheroes free movies spanish National Geographic Heroines Sundance Now video Apple technology 99% E3 Elton John toy story Animation Nominations comics news Comic-Con@Home 2021 spinoff festivals Epix criterion indie teaser romantic comedy Teen sequel Trailer Showtime kids concert Musicals new york Adult Swim Mary poppins 2020 Turner a nightmare on elm street SDCC thriller San Diego Comic-Con 71st Emmy Awards breaking bad pirates of the caribbean james bond scene in color toronto Bravo Black Mirror comic book movie women The Witch canceled fresh marvel cinematic universe political drama scorecard Netflix international sequels Pop rom-coms Rock 2021 blockbuster cops adventure 73rd Emmy Awards unscripted jurassic park Black History Month SundanceTV Apple TV+ Martial Arts prank Exclusive Video stoner documentary live event Baby Yoda crime thriller archives spanish language First Look dragons green book Writers Guild of America aapi Rocketman Infographic Brie Larson YouTube Red ABC slasher DGA USA CW Seed ESPN binge Awards Tour Chernobyl TV renewals PaleyFest Kids & Family golden globe awards foreign Comic Book streaming movies universal monsters facebook Vudu spy thriller Marvel Studios award winner cartoon YA game show The CW dogs LGBTQ renewed TV shows Disney+ Disney Plus Thanksgiving posters batman Wes Anderson Drama boxing heist movie Broadway festival Toys Amazon A&E Columbia Pictures black HBO Sundance TV Winners OneApp VH1 Mystery Paramount Network Marvel TCA 2017 hidden camera worst movies hispanic screen actors guild series Premiere Dates cars art house diversity GoT razzies medical drama Grammys TV Land Western 4/20 Paramount Spectrum Originals Photos Cannes monster movies royal family ratings miniseries HBO Max The Walking Dead Warner Bros. Holiday X-Men Calendar children's TV book adaptation Pride Month See It Skip It mcc TCM rotten movies we love Shudder biopic discovery twilight BBC One Best and Worst Freeform Sci-Fi Endgame child's play worst Trophy Talk Avengers superman halloween tv new zealand nfl Schedule what to watch Binge Guide historical drama WGN Dark Horse Comics Biopics Logo anthology Watching Series Crackle Super Bowl TBS TCA Masterpiece President Walt Disney Pictures ViacomCBS aliens Pirates AMC blaxploitation Britbox Mary Tyler Moore Fox News Fantasy dceu Reality USA Network Anna Paquin Ghostbusters Emmys parents gangster Captain marvel suspense trophy satire cults dexter cinemax Neflix TCA Awards Comedy nature reboot NBC Disney Channel basketball Comedy Central romance 2015 documentaries rt labs critics edition Emmy Nominations Universal Pictures hispanic heritage month Countdown hollywood DC Comics leaderboard Hear Us Out crossover TNT Tokyo Olympics Character Guide revenge theme song Rocky mutant Fox Searchlight Image Comics directors debate cancelled latino animated Travel Channel young adult kaiju classics adenture video on demand true crime golden globes movies