Why What We Do in the Shadows Became an Instant Cult Classic

Taika Waititi's vampire mockumentary brilliantly crosses the comedy of Flight of the Conchords with the films of Christopher Guest.

by | October 19, 2016 | Comments


Flight Of The Conchords’ eponymous HBO vehicle was about a deadpan immigrant duo who led lives of perverse banality despite being handsome, charming, talented, and dynamic rock stars. Band members Jemaine Clement and Bret Mckenzie ended the show when it seemingly had at least a few seasons left in it, but considering the insane workload endemic in creating both a TV series and a never-ending stream of new music to accompany it, you can’t really begrudge the gents for going out on top.

Clement and Mackenzie have done well since the show ended. Mackenzie won an Academy Award for his songwriting work on The Muppets and Clement has thrived in film — his flashy, out-of-character villain turn helped make Men In Black III better than it had any right to be, and in Gentleman Broncos he gave a great performance in a terrible movie.

But Clement’s biggest post-Conchords triumph is undoubtedly his co-directorial debut What We Do In The Shadows, in no small part because it reflects the Flight Of The Conchords sensibility so purely. True, the film finds Clement working with rising writer/director/star Taika Waititi, but Waititi worked extensively on Conchords, and his chemistry with Clement is just as strong as Clement’s chemistry with Mackenzie, which perhaps should not be surprising, considering Waititi and Clement once had a comedy duo of their own called The Humourbeasts.

While Flight Of The Conchords concerned itself with the incongruously mild misadventures of a pair of unassuming blokes who are also talented rock stars, Shadows is about vampires, the blood-sucking, hard-living, over-sexed rock stars of the supernatural world. And because this is a Jemaine Clement movie, these vampires do things like ride buses, argue about chores, and frequent tacky nightclubs.

Waititi stars as Viago, a nearly four hundred-year-old vampire and all-around fussbudget — he’s the Felix Unger of the undead world — still trying to find a way to be with a soulmate who, in a complete reversal of Matthew McConaughey’s oft-quoted line in Dazed and Confused, keeps getting older while he stays the same age.

Thanks to Waiiti’s moon-faced innocence, it’s about something more than just delivering a never-ending stream of big laughs.

Waititi brings a disarming sweetness to the role. With his cherubic babyface, he at times suggests a New Zealand version of Andy Kaufman, with all of the manic, child-like exuberance and none of the angsty provocation. That sweetness and the core of genuine romantic yearning underpinning Viago’s seemingly doomed love lends an underlying emotional element to what otherwise could just have been a mere joke-fest. That is not to say that Shadows is lacking in jokes. On the contrary, it’s pretty much wall-to-wall jokes, but thanks to Waiiti’s moon-faced innocence, it’s about something more than just delivering a never-ending stream of big laughs.

Thematically and structurally, co-writers, co-directors, and co-leads Waititi and Clement don’t just borrow a few pages from the Christopher Guest playbook so much as they steal the whole damn thing. Like Guest’s most celebrated films (I’m specifically not talking to you, Almost Heroes), it’s a mockumentary that delves into an insular, hermetic world filled with colorful caricatures, obsessives, and exquisitely unselfconscious goofballs oblivious to how the world sees them. Also like Guest’s films, the movie documents the furious activity leading up to a climactic event.

Here the event in question is an “Unholy Masquerade” that brings together blood-suckers, werewolves, zombies, and other things that go bump in the night. The film’s premise is that a documentary group protected by crucifixes has been given access to a secret society of vampires in the months leading up to the celebration.

We open on Viago awaking at 6 PM, checking that the sun is down, and then waking up his housemates, but not before pointedly explaining to the audience that he shares a house with other vampires because he enjoys the company, and, with touching sincerity, “I just really like having a good time with my friends.”

Viago’s housemates suggest a supernatural version of The Real World. Only, instead of reality show archetypes (the troublemaker, the black guy, the wild girl), we have different vampire archetypes. There’s Vladislav (Clement), a Bram Stoker’s Dracula-style playboy introduced in an orgy with his vampire harem. There’s also Deacon (Jonathon Brugh), the 183-year-old bad boy of the group. Then there’s Petyr (Ben Fransham), a Nosferatu-style bloodsucker who resembles a bat more than he does a human being. He’s 8,000 years old and pretty much feral. He consequently cannot be counted upon to show up at house meetings.

In Shadows, a vampire’s life is about trying to balance the insatiable need for blood with responsibilities like taking out the trash, cleaning dishes, and generally behaving like a considerate housemate. The funky interplay between the mundane and the fantastical continues as we’re introduced to our leads’ superhero-style origin stories. We learn Deacon was a Nazi vampire, something that was doubly frowned upon by good people after Germany lost World War II. Vladislav was turned when he was sixteen and had to curb his once-strong appetite for torturing and murdering masses.

Viago, meanwhile, came to New Zealand for love. He fell for a human woman whose family was emigrating to New Zealand and instructed his servant to send him to New Zealand to woo her. Alas, the servant put the wrong postage on the coffin, delaying Viago’s arrival for 18 months, at which point the object of his affection had found someone else. As origin stories for supernatural star-crossed love go, this is both operatic and adorably rooted in human error.

Waititi and Clement don’t just borrow a few pages from the Christopher Guest playbook so much as they steal the whole damn thing.

Shadows has enormous fun integrating vampire mythology into its wonderfully banal universe. We learn, for example, that Deacon has an exquisitely passive-aggressive relationship with Jackie (Jackie Van Beek), his “familiar,” a stubborn human woman hoping to prove herself to Deacon so he will turn her into a vampire and grant her eternal life. As one might expect from a former Nazi, Deacon abuses his power to get his wanna-be to do as much as possible for him without giving anything back in return. It is an utterly ridiculous relationship, but the emotions at play are real, and that makes everything funnier.

We learn that Vladislav used to be a sexy, hip, terrifying, monster who hypnotized crowds, killed without pity or remorse, and presided over massive orgies before encountering a humiliating defeat at the hands of an arch-enemy known as “the Beast.” Now he’s such a shell of his former self that he can barely muster up the sinister power to get a bored middle-aged man to look up from his laptop long enough to invite him inside.

Like Guest’s films, Shadows embraces the comedy of awkwardness. The relationship between Deacon and his familiar is wonderfully tense, as is a set-piece where she invites a man named Nick (Cori Gonzalez-Macuer) and another woman to the vampire lair, ostensibly for a dinner party, but really so that their vampire hosts can feast on their blood.

The evening results in the foursome acquiring a new vampire in Nick, a Bro who is really into flying but isn’t too keen on the whole discretion thing. This new, expanded version of the crew has a run-in with a pack of werewolves, led by Rhys Darby, who are, if anything, even more concerned with appearances than Viago. When some of his pack curse, his milquetoast head werewolf schoolmarmishly reminds them, “We’re werewolves, not swearwolves.”

The film’s final act centers on the Unholy Masquerade and the revelation that “the Beast,” rather than a demonic figure of pure evil, is actually Vladislav’s ex-girlfriend Pauline, who understandably did not appreciate her unflattering nickname and left Vladislav impaled on a night post during their violent breakup.

The immortality of vampires can’t help but cast our own mortality in a starker, more dramatic light. That’s true even of a goofy romp like Shadows. When Stu appears to be destroyed by werewolves, it’s genuinely sad, and prompts a monologue on the fragility of life (at least among the mortal) from Deacon, of all people, that’s both melancholy and hilarious. Deacon’s monologue begins comically tone-deaf but grows accidentally poignant as a meditation on the nature of aging and mortality and death, of the agony of watching someone you love wither and decay and lose their faculties until, “You wish they were dead, and then they do die.” But it doesn’t take long for the tone to shift back to gleeful absurdity when Deacon then proposes that Stu’s loss is mitigated by the fact that he clearly died the way he desired: being “disembowled by werewolves.”


The abundant laughs here are rooted in character and relationships more than they are in jokes.

When Viago ends up with his long-ago, long-in-the-tooth soulmate, it’s similarly genuinely touching. Outsized, melodramatic romances that stretch beyond time, geography, and morality are a fixture of vampire stories, particularly of the gothic romantic variety. Here, they amount to a profoundly dysfunctional relationship between an aging woman and a vampire who waited close to a century so he could finally woo her. These men might be monsters, but they’re also the kind of true romantics who never got over having their hearts being broken long ago. Shadows is one of the funniest films of the decade, but it also has a heart; the abundant laughs here are rooted in character and relationships more than they are in jokes.

Not surprisingly, the growing cult for Clement and Waititi’s deadpan laugh riot isn’t satisfied with merely re-watching and quoting the film. So the film’s universe is expanding with the announcement of a sequel/spin-off focused on werewolves and a television show in New Zealand focusing on cops, who play a small but memorable role in the proceedings here.

As for Waititi, he wrote and directed the critically acclaimed recent comedy Hunt For The Wilderpeople and is tackling a project at once utterly surprising and weirdly perfect for him. With a handful of modest but beloved cult comedies on his résumé, Waititi will be directing the third Thor movie, a cosmic buddy comedy following Thor and the Incredible Hulk on a trippy tour through the galaxy in the tradition of Midnight Run.

It’ll be fascinating to see if Waititi’s idiosyncratic genius comes through despite the commercial considerations and huge financial expectations greeting such an epic project. But I take comfort in knowing that, as he proved in Shadows, few filmmakers are more adept at getting big laughs out of the interplay between the fantastic and the mundane, or at articulating the surprising humanity of larger-than-life characters (in the Incredible Hulk’s case, way larger than life) who sometimes aren’t even human, yet reflect our foibles and insecurities and desires and fears all the same.

Original Certification: Fresh
Tomatometer: 96 percent
Re-Certification: Fresh

Nathan Rabin is a freelance writer, columnist, the first head writer of The A.V. Club and the author of four books, most recently Weird Al: The Book (with “Weird Al” Yankovic) and You Don’t Know Me But You Don’t Like Me.

Follow Nathan on Twitter: @NathanRabin

Tag Cloud

Adult Swim dc Netflix Christmas movies Paramount Video Games free movies strong female leads adventure Emmys rotten dceu asian-american Arrowverse PBS spider-man game show YA Mindy Kaling toy story YouTube mockumentary critics animated E3 popular HBO Max crime Bravo TruTV Super Bowl Ellie Kemper Nominations true crime prank Musical satire The Witch Drama President rotten movies we love Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ITV miniseries japanese cats slashers Polls and Games Marvel dragons X-Men telelvision 72 Emmy Awards Family Alien Sundance Now comics San Diego Comic-Con VICE Thanksgiving casting technology breaking bad CW Seed Emmy Nominations Disney+ Disney Plus Britbox Tumblr 45 Horror monster movies spanish supernatural historical drama Warner Bros. TV Land 99% AMC Baby Yoda quibi 4/20 Spring TV worst DirecTV Apple TV Plus Apple TV+ king kong Fantasy Red Carpet First Reviews based on movie 2020 20th Century Fox franchise ratings Rocketman PaleyFest facebook renewed TV shows news Writers Guild of America revenge MCU Amazon Prime crime drama MTV Nickelodeon universal monsters Winter TV obituary classics stand-up comedy rt archives Walt Disney Pictures VH1 IFC Superheroe SXSW Pride Month OneApp Oscars cancelled television PlayStation Crackle teaser Star Wars thriller Kids & Family The Arrangement joker foreign Schedule CBS All Access cinemax 2019 cults boxing zero dark thirty Reality Competition superhero TCA Winter 2020 mission: impossible spy thriller Grammys hist Nat Geo sequels nfl ABC Family Pop TV SundanceTV HBO Go BBC One romance australia Hulu ghosts BET Awards Mystery The Academy New York Comic Con Lionsgate Valentine's Day Mary Poppins Returns DGA nbcuniversal YouTube Premium concert TCA 2017 singing competition fast and furious Sundance TV TV renewals Film Hallmark Food Network die hard FX on Hulu Photos Television Critics Association zombies Turner Classic Movies The Walt Disney Company Paramount Plus movie OWN Endgame Tarantino 2017 natural history Amazon Studios Peacock SDCC series period drama BBC See It Skip It Sci-Fi book stoner Amazon Prime Video Chernobyl Women's History Month psychological thriller police drama dark blockbuster venice History Netflix aliens Election comiccon dramedy nature anime Amazon romantic comedy Awards Spike children's TV blockbusters Spectrum Originals binge ID razzies Anna Paquin Martial Arts Elton John TLC robots Marvel Studios Binge Guide halloween tv El Rey 2015 USA Network Winners Disney Plus name the review hollywood TBS elevated horror LGBTQ theme song Pixar spanish language boxoffice YouTube Red Quiz Broadway Esquire Year in Review Universal Vudu Star Trek Christmas Masterpiece political drama A&E Interview GIFs Black History Month APB fresh disaster docuseries Country Song of Ice and Fire Heroines rom-coms Funimation First Look Trailer Paramount Network Watching Series versus TCM james bond parents comedies movies cars Ghostbusters cooking TV Calendar ABC CMT werewolf halloween Pet Sematary BAFTA ABC Signature crossover child's play sequel cancelled Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt mutant WarnerMedia christmas movies kong unscripted Extras National Geographic DC streaming service GLAAD science fiction serial killer a nightmare on elm street finale Captain marvel The Purge Hear Us Out Legendary TIFF Discovery Channel Toys NBC screen actors guild Certified Fresh game of thrones Music pirates of the caribbean comic Black Mirror spinoff Trivia Dark Horse Comics remakes sports Syfy trailers scary movies independent GoT Best and Worst Animation war talk show Academy Awards IFC Films jamie lee curtis Fox Searchlight doctor who Biopics Film Festival indie LGBT Opinion ViacomCBS Pop stop motion toronto Shondaland DC Universe Rocky Mary poppins kids Classic Film Comic Book transformers emmy awards witnail 21st Century Fox American Society of Cinematographers green book Cartoon Network jurassic park spain reboot TCA scorecard Western all-time CNN Action films video football discovery indiana jones documentary diversity canceled adaptation Cosplay politics 2016 Sneak Peek anthology Tubi chucky 2021 E! french godzilla USA Logo biography south america Stephen King harry potter Superheroes Sony Pictures Travel Channel Brie Larson TCA Awards crime thriller Lifetime Christmas movies Rock Holidays Marathons laika Turner batman sag awards medical drama Hallmark Christmas movies festivals justice league festival hispanic comic books 2018 superman 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards composers italian Avengers Set visit CBS Exclusive Video golden globe awards latino RT21 Disney Channel Disney streaming service Summer Mudbound travel Television Academy Apple The Walking Dead what to watch black cartoon golden globes Crunchyroll Fall TV cops A24 streaming Teen Columbia Pictures twilight TNT Comedy Infographic hidden camera Mary Tyler Moore MSNBC FOX Ovation Freeform canceled TV shows archives Lifetime Lucasfilm Pirates Creative Arts Emmys kaiju reviews cancelled TV shows Box Office zombie Musicals Character Guide directors Podcast Showtime vampires NYCC Rom-Com Reality TV One Disney FXX Comics on TV HBO social media BBC America dogs Premiere Dates psycho richard e. Grant Comedy Central 007 criterion Holiday Trophy Talk docudrama screenings sitcom Marvel Television best Tomatazos DC Comics Shudder Awards Tour ESPN worst movies 24 frames documentaries Countdown tv talk blaxploitation television Sundance The CW deadpool women video on demand RT History Epix Starz 71st Emmy Awards Fox News WGN Acorn TV VOD cancelled TV series award winner BET space Cannes FX