Sub-Cult

How Role Models Made Paul Rudd a Bankable Leading Man

Before he was Ant-Man, Paul Rudd scored his first hit as a leading actor with a not-so-family-friendly -- but surprisingly warm and welcoming -- comedy that played to his strengths.

by | July 24, 2018 | Comments

(Photo by Universal Pictures)

When it was announced that Edgar Wright, the beloved cult auteur behind Spaced, Shaun of the Dead, Hot Fuzz, The World’s End, and previous Sub-Cult entry Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World, would be directing Paul Rudd in a feature film adaptation of Marvel’s cult comic book character Ant-Man, it created a whirlwind of excitement among comic book fans. At the very least, this particular team promised a low-level cult classic.

But the pairing of Wright and Rudd in a mega-budgeted blockbuster about one of Marvel’s quirkiest do-gooders delighted non-comic book fans just as much, if not more, than it did superhero geeks. With a bona fide auteur like Wright in the director’s chair and a brilliant comic actor like Rudd in the lead, Ant-Man promised to be something much more than a typical superhero movie. It promised to break the mold the way Deadpool, LoganThor: Ragnarok, and Black Panther later would.

Unfortunately, Wright and Marvel parted ways over the proverbial “creative differences.” Wright rebounded niftily with his first flat-out box office smash, the groovy sleeper hit Baby Driver, and after replacing Wright with the dependable Peyton Reed (Bring It On, Down With Love), Ant-Man went on to become a critical and commercial success, even if it didn’t quite shatter the mold as expected. Reed’s Ant-Man wasn’t bad by any means, but there was no way it could possibly have compared to the Edgar Wright-directed potential masterpiece that, alas, exists only in the minds and fevered imaginations of the writer-director’s fans.

For his part, Rudd was an inspired, if unexpected, choice to play Ant-Man. He’d appeared in a number of box-office hits like Anchorman, The 40-Year-Old Virgin, and Knocked Up, but as an invaluable member of the repertory companies of Judd Apatow and David Wain, he was generally best utilized as a supporting character, rather than a conventional leading man, much less an action hero. Rudd is, after all, legendary for showing a de-contextualized clip of the hilariously terrible E.T. knock-off Mac & Me every time he appears on Conan, rather than a clip from whatever movie he’s supposed to be promoting. He’s obviously more interested in amusing himself and satisfying his wandering id than in pursuing conventional movie stardom.

(Photo by Universal Pictures)

Yet Rudd has emerged as a star almost in spite of himself, thanks to movies like 2008’s Role Models, which he co-wrote and in which he starred, just as he co-wrote Ant-Man and its sequel and co-created the beloved cult TV comedy Party Down. Role Models began life as a directorial vehicle for The Animal helmer Luke Greenfield before Wain, who directed Rudd in Wet Hot American Summer and The Ten, and would go on to direct him in They Came Together, Wanderlust, and A Futile and Stupid Gesture, came onboard as director, co-screenwriter, and supporting player.

The family-unfriendly comedy feels like a latter-day descendant of Bad News Bears, another wonderfully profane, irreverent, hard-R comedy about brash, irresponsible, foul-mouthed kids and the even more brash, even more irresponsible, and even more foul-mouthed adults mentoring them.

Rudd stars as Danny, a 35-year-old curmudgeon eking out a silly, embarrassing living traveling from school to school in a truck designed to look like a minotaur and encouraging children to stay off drugs by substituting the toxic, caffeine-plagued energy drink poison he and his sidekick are cynically peddling. American Pie’s Seann William Scott plays said sidekick, Wheeler, as a gleeful doofus, a sex-crazed man-child so ferociously unambitious that, by his own admission, he’d be content to wear a minotaur costume and quasi-entertain children “forever.”

Danny’s already crappy life as an underemployed depressive takes a turn for the worse when his ambitious live-in girlfriend Beth (Elizabeth Banks, one of many Apatow and Wain fixtures in the cast) tires of his stormy moods and persistent negativity and breaks up with him. A despondent Danny enters a state of freefall and, in despair, nearly kills a security guard when he drives the promotional minotaur truck into a statue.

Role Models’ central conceit demands suspension of disbelief, so instead of doing hard time for a pretty serious crime, these world-class screw-ups are instead sentenced to 150 hours of community service at Sturdy Wings, a Big Brothers/Big Sisters-like organization that pairs kids in need with older mentors.

(Photo by Universal Pictures)

Superbad  breakout star Christopher “McLovin” Mintz-Plasse proves he’s more than just a sentient meme here with a surprisingly textured performance as Danny’s charge, Augie, a gawky teen misfit who finds escape from the tyranny of everyday life by disappearing into a world of fantasy live-action role-playing (i.e. “larping”). Wheeler, meanwhile, whose life is a never-ending, frequently successful hunt for sexual conquests, is paired with the hilariously profane Ronnie (Bobb’e J. Thompson), who is every bit as obsessed with sex as his mentor but is somehow even cruder than Wheeler. Scott is a profoundly limited actor, but his role here plays to his strengths as a lovable slob, and Thompson is an impish, ribald delight, stealing scenes from a cast full of ringers and seasoned professionals.

Wain filled the rest of the film with fellow alumni from sketch-comedy show The State, including co-screenwriter Ken Marino and Kerri Kenney-Silver as Augie’s tacky parents and Joe Lo Truglio as a role-playing fanatic who has internalized the faux-medieval aesthetic of his pastime to a pathological degree. Bit parts are filled out by people like Louis C.K., The Lonely Island’s Jorma Taccone, and Keegan-Michael Key, while Ken Jeong scored one of his juiciest roles as the king of the make-believe world Augie is obsessed with, a petty tyrant who hangs out at The Burger Hole with his royal sycophants and hangers-on, flagrantly abusing his imaginary power.

Rudd’s The 40-Year-Old Virgin co-star Jane Lynch steals the film as Gayle, the lunatic head of Sturdy Wings and an emotional exhibitionist who finds a way to shoehorn references to her former life as a drug-addicted prostitute into every conversation. Lynch infuses the character with her trademark weird intensity and loopy aggression; if Gayle goes easy on our ramshackle heroes, it might be because she’s even more glaringly inappropriate than they are.

Role Models depicts the rigidly hierarchical, rule- and protocol-obsessed realm of LARP as inherently ridiculous and laughable but also as a source of comfort, identity, and community for a lonely misfit in desperate need of all three. It laughs at its characters’ foibles and absurdity, but like its heroes, it moves from a place of glib mockery to empathy and understanding.

(Photo by Universal Pictures)

The film’s use of music and mythology is similarly nuanced and savvy. Wheeler’s obsession with KISS is a tribute to the crazy, theatrical world of make-believe and pretend — not terribly dissimilar, really, from the world of Dungeons & Dragons — created by Paul Stanley and Gene Simmons, as well as a loving send-up. Role Models accomplishes the formidable feat of making the famously cynical and mercenary rock outfit seem incongruously lovable by association.

Danny may initially look askance at Augie and his dorky passions, but he’s ultimately saved by taking the big leap and embracing his inner geek, his inner freak, his inner Kiss Army rock-and-roll warrior. For a movie centered on a cynical, ornery bastard, Role Models is ultimately very inclusive and welcoming in its warm depiction of underdogs triumphing through cooperation and acceptance. 

The wonderfully sardonic underachiever Rudd plays here feels like the sarcastic yet charming stepbrother/love interest he played in his star-making turn in Clueless — after fifteen years of failure, low-level depression, and resignation have all but extinguished his inner light and rendered him a joyless crank. For much of the film, he’s a sour misanthrope deeply unimpressed with everything life has to offer, but because he’s played by Rudd, we end up sympathizing with him and feeling his pain despite his prickliness and rough edges.

Role Models is a goofy, commercial, feel-good comedy, but its portrayal of depression — as represented both by Danny’s never-ending mid-life crisis and personal/professional funk — and Augie’s clammy discomfort in his own skin, that palpable anxiety when he’s around his parents and bullies, rings surprisingly and refreshingly true.

Rudd can currently be seen playing a tiny hero in a giant movie, but Role Models’ enduring appeal and growing cult is inextricably linked to its modest scope and ambition. Role Models is not too big or too small. It’s the perfect size, an eminently rewatchable sleeper destined for a long, happy life as the kind of casually irresistible charmer you can’t help but finish watching every time you come across it on basic cable.


Nathan Rabin is a freelance writer, columnist, the first head writer of The A.V. Club and the author of four books, most recently Weird Al: The Book (with “Weird Al” Yankovic) and You Don’t Know Me But You Don’t Like Me.

Follow Nathan on Twitter: @NathanRabin

Tag Cloud

stand-up comedy Film Festival Comics on TV BBC America Film TNT justice league Spring TV NBC zombies NYCC FX Extras singing competition Trophy Talk 24 frames Classic Film Certified Fresh A&E adaptation Western facebook GoT Podcast adventure DC Universe werewolf crime thriller documentary Infographic Box Office Pop Sci-Fi miniseries The Witch A24 CMT E3 Universal Reality Competition TLC Brie Larson WGN festivals Shudder USA Network nature Teen streaming Turner Watching Series rotten movies we love President Amazon ABC cars Creative Arts Emmys TBS Nominations Premiere Dates TIFF composers Emmys Lionsgate ITV Musical Video Games 2015 National Geographic Mindy Kaling political drama comics Peacock SXSW Discovery Channel Polls and Games free movies anthology Disney+ Disney Plus Star Wars directors romance BBC Crackle Superheroe Disney Plus video TCA kids Elton John breaking bad Syfy screen actors guild Mary Poppins Returns American Society of Cinematographers Mary Tyler Moore Apple TV Plus Animation cancelled TV shows Fall TV Amazon Prime ABC Family APB latino game of thrones LGBT book Awards Captain marvel historical drama Walt Disney Pictures Starz Shondaland renewed TV shows TCA Winter 2020 Stephen King Biopics Awards Tour christmas movies talk show mutant Netflix Christmas movies Music IFC Films travel Showtime Freeform robots spanish language USA Crunchyroll Ellie Kemper Apple Family Hallmark psycho Mudbound Nickelodeon MCU Netflix Apple TV+ casting Sneak Peek jamie lee curtis The Purge Adult Swim Valentine's Day YouTube 45 zero dark thirty Avengers harry potter New York Comic Con versus movies MTV Schedule TruTV Bravo Writers Guild of America PaleyFest Grammys First Look Quiz Tubi 71st Emmy Awards medical drama Pixar DC streaming service supernatural theme song ghosts sequel anime CBS All Access Paramount Network based on movie Winter TV Action Vudu Hulu Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Thanksgiving foreign cancelled TV series DGA OWN spy thriller Marvel Studios Spectrum Originals Toys war TV Land cartoon Logo El Rey YA boxoffice spain Trivia See It Skip It south america Musicals screenings San Diego Comic-Con joker YouTube Premium canceled Food Network Photos canceled TV shows First Reviews Ghostbusters Cannes YouTube Red Horror Epix cancelled television science fiction witnail revenge Cosplay Christmas TV renewals Sundance Now Ovation Tumblr Sundance TV Pet Sematary spinoff reboot crime social media Masterpiece The Arrangement Arrowverse richard e. Grant animated Martial Arts cults Fox News LGBTQ Calendar Dark Horse Comics FXX disaster sag awards AMC The CW thriller technology natural history batman Star Trek RT History Rock comic true crime sports Super Bowl BET unscripted Lifetime Christmas movies Pride Month aliens police drama green book serial killer Pirates biography Best and Worst romantic comedy dragons Set visit teaser 2017 Tarantino Hallmark Christmas movies Britbox Holiday Amazon Prime Video hist Red Carpet Oscars Holidays Heroines cats MSNBC ESPN vampires Marvel Television Chernobyl Binge Guide Mystery The Walking Dead Fantasy crime drama discovery 2020 slashers binge WarnerMedia DirecTV IFC mockumentary Spike Comic Book period drama FOX strong female leads quibi X-Men zombie diversity space halloween cinemax independent dramedy comiccon 20th Century Fox Rom-Com 21st Century Fox Tomatazos Rocketman Character Guide E! Warner Bros. Song of Ice and Fire Esquire VH1 Lifetime finale Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Cartoon Network blockbuster cops Countdown what to watch Rocky sitcom Marathons Opinion docudrama Mary poppins Drama CNN indie 2016 Academy Awards Women's History Month Television Academy DC Comics toy story Lucasfilm Endgame Acorn TV tv talk Trailer doctor who CBS name the review cancelled golden globes GIFs Emmy Nominations Reality Marvel Country award winner Summer 2019 Superheroes politics Winners Paramount psychological thriller Comedy Central 007 Sundance SDCC OneApp dc hispanic elevated horror dceu Anna Paquin Turner Classic Movies HBO Max Disney Channel blaxploitation Baby Yoda Columbia Pictures PBS HBO children's TV TV CW Seed Year in Review Disney TCM VICE Election television Sony Pictures GLAAD game show TCA 2017 crossover Kids & Family History SundanceTV spider-man cooking Disney streaming service transformers Comedy Nat Geo Interview 2018 series RT21 ratings Black Mirror