Why Trick 'r Treat Deserves Cult Status

Sub-Cult is Nathan Rabin’s ongoing exploration of movies that have quietly attracted devoted followings and are on the verge of becoming full-on cult sensations.

by | October 27, 2015 | Comments


Even the worst theatrically released movie has countless advantages over the best direct-to-video fodder. As movies like Mac & Me, The Oogieloves In The Big Balloon Adventure, and Movie 43 attest, scoring a theatrical release is no guarantee of baseline competence, let alone quality. But unlike direct-to-video movies, theatrically released movies do not need to contend with a knee-jerk public suspicion that something must have gone awry with them, artistically or otherwise, to warrant being dumped ignominiously onto home video. Theatrically released movies also may not be critiqued kindly, but they are generally reviewed (even the ones written and directed by either Tyler Perry or the toxic team of Aaron Seltzer and Jason Friedberg), and there are plenty of publications and websites dedicated to covering every film that opens in theaters. This makes them part of an ongoing cultural conversation, even if that dialogue takes the form of, “How did that get made?” or, “Jesus, people will see anything these days, won’t they?”

Direct-to-video movies are generally seen as failures because, in a very concrete way, they have failed. They failed to occupy the cultural space every theatrical release is afforded, no matter how dire. They failed to be talked about by moviegoers afterwards, to be advertised on posters and billboards and promoted via talk show appearances and junkets and television interviews,  and to be debated by critics, both at the time of their release and at the end of the year, when all-important (to the ink-stained wretches assembling them, at least) lists of the best films are compiled and awards are given.


“Dylan Baker excels at embodying and dramatizing the white-bread evil of banality.”

In that respect, the well-loved horror anthology Trick ‘r Treat, which was completed in 2007 but only released in 2009, is the little direct-to-DVD movie that could. It sports a lush, autumnal gothic beauty and a slickness befitting a project that reunited a number of people involved in the X-Men franchise, most notably writer-director Michael Dougherty (who co-wrote X-Men 2, the best of the bunch before Days Of Future Past), producer Bryan Singer, and cast members Brian Cox and Anna Paquin. And after inexplicably being dumped onto home video, Trick ‘r Treat went on to do all sorts of things a direct-to-video movie isn’t supposed to do. It inspired merchandise in the form of multiple figurines based on its primary pint-sized ghoul, a creepy little menace in a burlap sack named Sam. It spawned a coffee table book, a graphic novel adaptation, and a one-off comic book entitled Trick R Treat: Days Of The Dead. It even produced a tardy sequel in the form of Trick ‘r Treat 2, which is reportedly in development, and will follow Dougherty’s similarly holiday themed horror romp Krampus to the big screen. Not bad for a movie that sat on a shelf for two years before being spat out onto the home video market.

In Trick ‘r Treat, first time director Dougherty takes great delight in upending expectations and sadistically toying with horror movie conventions. In the film’s morbid world, the adults who are called upon to protect, care for, and teach students aren’t just negligible in their duties; they are downright evil, and the kids they abuse and torment have a way of repaying their cruelty and abuse tenfold.

This is particularly true of Steven Wilkins (Dylan Baker), a small town principal who punishes a chubby trick-or-treater (Bad Santas butterball Brett Kelly) for taking more candy than is his share by feeding him a cyanide-laced treat that causes him to vomit blood before dying. Morbid physical comedy ensues as the harried murderer tries to dispose of the tubby little corpse while still fulfilling his Halloween duties.

As in Happiness, Baker excels at embodying and dramatizing the white-bread evil of banality. He’s a bloodthirsty sadist with the bland demeanor of a bank middle manager, and though he ends this segment with the film’s idea of a family activity — Wilkins and his adoring son carving the head of the chubby little dead boy as if it were a Jack-O-Lantern — the film has further punishment in store for him.

The violation of childhood innocence in the next story is even more gothic and severe. In it, a trick-or-treater tells the macabre tale of a group of mentally challenged children three decades earlier whose parents, exhausted by the demands of caring for their special needs progeny, embark on a gruesome and inexcusable collaboration: they pay a school bus driver to chain their costumed children to their seats while he drives the bus into a rock quarry, plunging his passengers to their watery deaths. This is, of course, not the last we see or hear of these unfortunate souls.


“In Trick ‘r Treat, female sexuality is a voracious, malevolent force, but it’s also a righteous one.”

What gives the segment its power and resonance is the idea of parents so overwhelmed and defeated by the extraordinary challenges of raising difficult children that they embrace the unthinkable crime of murder as their last, best, and only option. The image of helpless children, their identities and personalities obscured by the ghoulish Halloween costumes they’re wearing, shackled to the vehicle of their imminent deaths, is haunting in more than one sense, and the most poignant manifestation of the unconscionable evil adults visit upon children in Trick ‘r Treat, oblivious to the karmic blowback their actions will engender. They should know better, after all, as they are not just in a horror movie, but in a horror movie with a decidedly moralistic bent, where the evil are tormented and even minor misdeeds (such as unconsciously violating the rules of Halloween) lead to death sentences carried out by pint-sized vigilantes.

Trick ‘r Treat captures how Halloween is disorienting and scary for children not just because of the abundant spookery on display but also because adults — and particularly teenagers — have been given free reign to behave erratically, to drink too much, to get high, to be inappropriately and creepily sexual or violent in ways that can be alienating and disturbing to kids who expect adults to behave with a certain level of propriety.

There’s a great moment early in the film where a group of trick-or-treaters are visibly disturbed to see one of their teachers drunkenly addressing them while wearing a tragically ill-chosen “sexy cat” costume. The teacher isn’t obese or aged, just about 10 years too old and 10 pounds too heavy to be wearing a costume like that, and though the scene is pitched more for uncomfortable laughter than horror, it casually captures how Halloween can be creepy and unnerving for children for reasons that have nothing to do with serial killers or razor blades in candy bars.

Sex and violence are also inextricably intertwined in horror movies, and in the “Surprise Party” segment of the film, a group of fiendishly sexy young women are indulging in the real reason for the season: dressing provocatively and skimpily for the benefit of drooling, ogling man-children who, in keeping with our culture’s noxious double standards, are not expected to show any skin or be remotely sexy or provocative. They’re dressed as Sexy Snow White and Sexy Bo Peep (if you doubt the “Sexy _____” conceit has gone too far, bear in mind that a “Sexy Pizza Rat” now exists, and should not be worn by anyone, at any time), with the idea of revealing as much skin and cleavage as possible without crossing a blurry line into actual nudity.


“It has a bona fide horror icon in Sam, who is somehow scarier and more terrifying for being so small and seemingly unthreatening.”

The outlier of the group is a 22-year-old virgin played by Anna Paquin who doesn’t just eschew the requisite exhibitionism of her peers, she dresses as Little Red Riding Hood, that untouched icon of dewy innocence and purity. She wants her first time to be special, and her friends are concerned that by insisting that sex be special, reserved for the right one, she’s missing out on a whole world of gross, non-special sex with the wrong one, or the wrong ones.

In Trick ‘r Treat, female sexuality is a voracious, malevolent force, but it’s also a righteous one, and true to its title, “Surprise Party” ventures into unexpected territory once it becomes apparent that Paquin’s character is actually a lot more like another, scarier character in the Little Red Riding Hood saga, and I am not talking about grandma. Like Ginger Snaps and The Company Of Wolves, “Surprise Party” uses the conventions of horror films and fairy tales to comment upon our fears and desires regarding female sexual maturation and the complicated, alluring bodies and minds of desirable young women.

The stories in Trick ‘r Treat overlap, Pulp Fiction style, with characters from one segment making cameo appearances in others while the whole movie is tied together through the character of Sam, a tiny yet terrifying demonic sprite in threadbare footy pajamas and a burlap sack that vaguely resembles a pared-down Jack-O-Lantern over his head.

Sam has a small but crucial role in many of the segments, but he is front and center in “Meet Sam,” where he terrorizes a Halloween-hating old crank played by Brian Cox. Superior horror movies often rely upon an unforgettable icon of pure evil, whether it’s Michael Myers in his viscerally unnerving William Shatner mask or Freddy Krueger’s signature hat, ratty sweater and knife-glove. I suspect part of the reason Trick ‘r Treat has endured against long odds is because it has a bona fide horror icon in Sam, who, like Chucky or the Zuni fetish doll, is somehow scarier and more terrifying for being so small and seemingly unthreatening.

It’s a testament to how deeply fans of Trick ‘r Treat related to the movie that they didn’t just want to watch it or re-watch it, they wanted to own part of it symbolically in the form of a 15-inch vinyl figure of Sam, which Sideshow Collectibles released, and a 5.5-inch Sam figure that NECA put out.

I suspect that part of the film’s enduring, Shocktober-friendly appeal lies in the thrill of discovery fans experienced when they found a movie most of the world didn’t know existed. The horror movies that hit theaters tend to be a dire and derivative lot, so a superior horror film that cultists have to actively seek out has a special, furtive allure.

It’s a little bewildering that a movie as good and solid and tight as Trick ‘r Treat was doomed to a home video burial. Yet in true horror film fashion, this weird little sleeper rose from the grave, bloodied but unbowed, and went on to enjoy a shockingly robust and impressive afterlife. So many movies these days are much worse than they should be, so it is a wonderful surprise to stumble across a movie that’s far better than it has any right to be, although its ever-growing following ensures that Trick ‘r Treat’s quality won’t be too much of a surprise for much longer.

My Original Certification: Fresh
My Re-Certification: Fresh
Tomatometer: 86 percent

  • Kara Bara

    This is the first movie covered by SubCult that I actually think deserves cult status. I remember renting it when it first came out and convincing my partner that we should watch it because I had read a good review. We both loved it. After that we tried to get all our horror loving friends to see it as well. I think you’re right, it’s fun when you feel like you discover a little known gem that you want to share.

  • GodSentUs

    I think it hit cult status a few years back, but it’s a modern horror classic that will live on. The sequel will push things over the edge.

  • doug johnson

    I freakin’ love that movie and watch it every year. I don’t know why it never hit theaters. They should just market it and release it right now. Longtime fans would get to see it in on the big screen, and the uninformed would think it’s a new and highly rated horror flick.

  • akhan727

    Nothing is “deserving” of a cult status. It either is or it isn’t. Only time will tell.

  • Ray Stark

    Saw this movie a few years ago and it didn’t do much for me. The stories were too flat and the atmosphere appeared too fake and fabricated. Vastly overrated.

    • XAlecX

      agreed, watched it for the first time this past weekend and thought the stories were all uninteresting or waaay too long with no payoff. “Sam” battling the old man at the end was fun, but too little, too late.

  • Charlton

    It has got cult status. For something to be cult, it either is or isn’t. There is no in-between and no choices.

    There is the rare occasion something will go from cult to mainstream. Such as Breaking Bad. I myself bought the Season 1 DVD in 2011. Bought it for the writer, who I was familiar with. And the premise sounding extremely interesting. I didn’t know anyone else who had watched the show, and even my parents thought it was just some drug show, even though it took them two years to watch it as it appeared on Netflix. After finishing Season 1, the second season wasn’t out on DVD yet so I had to wait. Some time after it was, it was going to arrive on Netflix so I didn’t bother. Then, the rest of the story is obvious. Everybody I knew, on my friends list and twitter started to watch it and love it. The reason it was cult in the first place, is because it was a moderately original idea, and had a great new style to the show. A new pace. Something we hadn’t see before. It gathered acclaim, and the people who watched it were literally the only ones who watched it. Small groups (of course would be few million across the world, just not as many as there were by later seasons).

    Trick ‘r Treat is this. It has a small audience following. You’ll always remember the anthology of it. How weird and wonderful it is. The great design of the film. To enter a cult following you tell your friends about it, and if they enjoy it they love it too. Cults break the norm, either for the best or worst situations. Some films are so bad they are good, and receive cult.

    But by the look of the titles on your other articles about why other movies deserve cult, I’m not sure you fully understand the meaning. Just seems more like failed films (which can become cult!) but you want to be cult.

  • mj

    I think to declare something is a cult film, we must first come to a clear definition of what the author of the article’s interpretation of the phrase “cult film” means.
    If we go by the dictionary it would literally be, “of, for, or attracting a group of devotees to a film” and “a devoted and obsessive fanbase”. In that case, Star Wars or Lord of the Rings would be considered cult films due to their obsessive fanbase that are all devotees to these films.

    Now, many cinephiles would say the above definition is too broad. This is where things get tricky, because the definitions vary. The one thing that is underlining with all definitions is that there is a dedicated fanbase.
    Some would say a cult film is a film that is technically a bad film, but is celebrated for being “so bad it’s good”. This is the case for a film, like Troll 2.
    Some would say a cult film breaks cultural taboos, and many feature excessive displays of violence, gore, sexuality, profanity, or combinations thereof. This was the case with many grindhouse films in the 1970’s.
    Some would say a cult film is a theatrically released film that critics hated and audiences rejected initially, but over time the film has become appreciated and can be praised for the messages, social commentaries, and metaphors that become more clear over time. This is the case with Halloween 3: Season of the Witch.
    The list can go on and on, because the definition of a cult film is different to everyone.

    With that said, I would say Trick ‘R Treat is a holiday cult film. This merely a film that has a rabid fan base that comes out to celebrate the film during a certain holiday and may religiously watch that film at least once around that holiday, go to festivals or other events that celebrate that given film around a holiday, or anything else that supports the film around the given holiday. Trick R’ Treat is a holiday cult film for me, because I always watch it at least twice around the Halloween season. Unlike other horror films, like The Thing and Friday the 13th, where I watch them casually around the year, Trick ‘R Treat is a film I exclusively get excited about around Halloween and watch exclusively around that season. The film is almost like a love letter to Halloween and the modern traditions that surround it, so it is justifiable that the cult fanbase for this film come out like a raging hurricane around Halloween. Besides Halloween (1978), this is probably the best horror film that really gets individuals into the Halloween spirit.

    The film itself:
    Love “The Principal” story. Dylan Baker is both scary and eerie while being dorky and conservative at the same time. Love “Meet Sam” story. Sam became an iconic horror figure in this story about a figure that punishes those that don’t honor Halloween traditions. Didn’t like “The School Bus Massacre Revisited”. It was too predictable, no conflict and tension, and the payoff is lackluster. “The Conclusion” was kind of a letdown, because I figured the kids would come back for revenge once we found out Mr. Kreeg was the bus driver. “The Opening” and “Suprise Party” were good and enjoyable, but not great.

  • Marino Zajmi

    I thought it was cult movie

  • Samantha-Jo Maurino

    Couldn’t agree more! Majorly underrated modern day classic Halloween flick. One of the best straight-to-DVD B-category horror flicks to date. A true gem!

  • EB

    This film shouldn’t be a cult classic, it should be a mainstream smash hit. It is well directed, acted and highly entertaining and has a few legit scares to boot. I am always sad that this movie never got the theatrical release it deserved.

  • Parsa Hadidi

    I never got to see much of this film but I always loved Sam’s design. It manages to be equally innocent yet monstrous, childish yet terrifying.

  • Kyle Davidson

    The Saw series kept this instant classic from getting released during Halloween and gaining the attention it deserves. Hopefully more people will see it. Such a great cast, fun scares and awesome vignettes that make for a great seasonal horror flick.

  • Merkin Muffly

    Can’t believe I missed this one, watched it tonight, instant Halloween classic. I guess the violence against children made them not release it.

  • GreatWhiteRuffalo

    Meh. Neither good nor deserving of cult status. Worst so-called “cult” movie I’ve seen since the global travesty that is RHPS.

    • frank ford


  • James Allard

    For those of us in the life film section marked Horror, this one is already established as a cult hit. Then again, we were waiting for the release from the first trailer. It paid off, in diamonds and gold coins.

Tag Cloud

First Reviews TCA Winter 2020 Logo war American Society of Cinematographers Pop space Tarantino MSNBC slashers superhero ITV satire SXSW tv talk child's play crime dragons indiana jones FX OneApp Nominations Ellie Kemper Best and Worst sequels transformers nature Valentine's Day Tubi Extras casting Watching Series kids Masterpiece stand-up comedy Super Bowl films screenings robots TV renewals Bravo Star Wars The Witch DC Universe Adult Swim See It Skip It critics ESPN Syfy DGA Country blockbuster TIFF Marvel Television Elton John ghosts National Geographic Walt Disney Pictures talk show Binge Guide Warner Bros. biography ratings CMT Arrowverse BAFTA MCU children's TV Television Critics Association BET sag awards historical drama CBS All Access witnail social media werewolf dramedy RT History Calendar canceled TV shows Spike TruTV DirecTV 45 harry potter asian-american Disney Channel mockumentary Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Song of Ice and Fire 20th Century Fox zombies reboot Emmy Nominations south america dceu thriller cooking comiccon Animation Comics on TV technology First Look doctor who Apple Comedy spanish language hollywood Freeform Photos dc CW Seed Musicals Holidays Travel Channel Apple TV Plus Cartoon Network WGN Marvel Vudu spy thriller Funimation FXX Showtime Amazon documentaries Pet Sematary independent serial killer HBO Comedy Central Mindy Kaling Rocketman Video Games TNT breaking bad zombie Spectrum Originals natural history comic Baby Yoda Brie Larson Pop TV YouTube crime thriller Hear Us Out Heroines IFC disaster Set visit animated Mary Tyler Moore BBC America revenge HBO Go A24 Year in Review San Diego Comic-Con elevated horror History dark romantic comedy VOD diversity Teen Disney Sundance TV classics Avengers screen actors guild Lucasfilm justice league Christmas sequel chucky E! zero dark thirty Shudder Paramount directors Action Chilling Adventures of Sabrina hispanic twilight versus Mystery documentary Horror 2019 politics FOX Premiere Dates PlayStation anime crossover Netflix Awards DC Comics TLC Sundance teaser halloween Mary poppins 2016 NYCC Shondaland BBC One canceled El Rey The Purge Spring TV sports finale romance Discovery Channel die hard cancelled TV series President Women's History Month stoner spinoff comedies Tomatazos sitcom Hallmark Martial Arts period drama Reality Competition movies cancelled television The CW mission: impossible police drama worst VICE Cosplay Marvel Studios Emmys Mudbound Cannes 72 Emmy Awards ABC best Quiz foreign franchise Trivia Hallmark Christmas movies Western Character Guide psychological thriller cartoon medical drama crime drama APB Classic Film Universal Holiday green book GLAAD 2020 laika universal monsters Interview composers Podcast Toys video on demand Pixar rotten movies we love Trailer adaptation Turner Classic Movies stop motion Oscars TV what to watch travel 007 Pride Month Acorn TV 71st Emmy Awards Amazon Studios strong female leads Pirates YouTube Red Winners dogs Rock LGBTQ Certified Fresh Stephen King FX on Hulu Ovation spider-man Musical E3 SundanceTV 21st Century Fox Nat Geo news Reality Endgame Lionsgate Creative Arts Emmys Britbox book quibi cancelled TV shows jamie lee curtis award winner Columbia Pictures Awards Tour singing competition USA Network TCA Awards Election docudrama Marathons Summer Captain marvel TBS cops Anna Paquin GIFs cults miniseries Schedule richard e. Grant Food Network video Family blaxploitation latino IFC Films criterion cinemax golden globes Mary Poppins Returns batman parents streaming Lifetime fast and furious YA 2018 cancelled Opinion RT21 Starz supernatural Peacock based on movie Fox News rotten DC streaming service 24 frames A&E psycho GoT Chernobyl series Grammys Black Mirror X-Men scary movies New York Comic Con Sony Pictures AMC Writers Guild of America MTV Disney streaming service a nightmare on elm street indie Hulu Amazon Prime Turner Dark Horse Comics binge Netflix Christmas movies CNN TCA 2017 WarnerMedia theme song TV Land YouTube Premium Film aliens game show Television Academy name the review The Walking Dead Amazon Prime Video Drama Ghostbusters Biopics emmy awards unscripted Disney+ Disney Plus nbcuniversal Thanksgiving obituary Star Trek 2017 4/20 festivals toy story Polls and Games USA Superheroe Sneak Peek free movies science fiction Tumblr joker cars SDCC Kids & Family spain Red Carpet Crunchyroll political drama Fantasy anthology christmas movies Disney Plus NBC concert television hist BBC Sundance Now all-time Comic Book Epix Infographic Winter TV BET Awards true crime VH1 vampires Nickelodeon movie discovery Trophy Talk PBS Black History Month Rom-Com Esquire LGBT Box Office game of thrones Academy Awards Lifetime Christmas movies reviews boxoffice Fall TV Music TCM ABC Family cats Film Festival 2015 Crackle Rocky The Arrangement OWN mutant Sci-Fi CBS Superheroes TCA comics Apple TV+ PaleyFest renewed TV shows adventure Paramount Network Countdown facebook HBO Max