The 16 Scariest Horror Anthology Segments

With Ghost Stories releasing this week in New York and on VOD, we look back at the best parts of other horror compilations.

by | April 18, 2018 | Comments

There’s something very appealing about short stories — they’re to-the-point, filled with twists, and you can get through a bunch of them in one sitting. Yet when it comes to movies, only horror films seem to consistently warrant the anthology treatment. Oh, sure you’ll find a few comedic anthologies like New York Stories, The Ten, and the cult classics Kentucky Fried Movie and Amazon Women on the Moon. But for the most part the “cinematic omnibus” is the domain of the scary storytellers, and genre fans certainly seem to enjoy the format – doubly so when one or two of the terror tales stand out as something truly special.

With that in mind, we’ve cooked up a sort of Frankenstein’s Monster of horror anthologies; a collection of the best segments from much-loved horror compendiums, curated scream-by-scream and featuring established classics along with more recent frights. We’ve created this list partly because IFC Midnight’s kick-ass import Ghost Stories is about to hit theater screens and VOD — trust us, it’s great, and currently sits at 88% on the Tomatometer — but also because, well, there’s just something very appealing about scary-AF short stories.

So enjoy this massive anthology menu composed of the best of the best horror anthology segments. And, yes, we had enough left over for a Volume 2.

“The Ventriloquist’s Dummy” from Dead of Night (1945)

Arguably the Casablanca of horror anthology films, Dead of Night showcases a strong handful of creepy and darkly amusing tales, but it’s probably best remembered for its masterful story about a ventriloquist who is convinced that his dummy is not only alive but incredibly malicious. Fans of flicks like Magic (1978) and Dead Silence (2007) will certainly enjoy this mini-movie.

“The Telephone” from Black Sabbath (1963)

Mario Bava kicks of his celebrated anthology with a simple yet enjoyably twisty tale of two women, a mysterious phone caller, and a stalker who may or may not actually exist.

“Frozen Fear” from Asylum (1972)

Amicus Productions released seven anthology horror films between 1965 and 1974 (most of them quite entertaining), but this is the one my parents rented as a kid, and it scared the living hell out of me – particularly this simple story of murder, voodoo, and a bunch of dismembered body parts. The stories in this anthology get weirder as the film progresses, and then, of course, it all ends on a nifty little twist. If you enjoy this one, check out Dr. Terror’s House of Horrors (1965), Tales from the Crypt (1972), and Vault of Horror (1973).

“Amelia” from Trilogy of Terror (1975)

The first two stories in this TV movie –  based on the works of the great Richard Matheson – are passable, if a bit forgettable, but the third tale absolutely terrified an entire generation. Basically, a woman gets attacked, chased, and terrorized by what’s referred to as a “Zuni fetish doll,” and if you thought Chucky was a nasty plaything, wait until you get a load of this tiny monster.

“The Crate” from Creepshow (1982)

(Photo by Warner Bros. courtesy Everett Collection)

The collaboration between Stephen King and George Romero would, not surprisingly, lead to one of the finest horror anthologies of all time, but if we’re picking the best of this fantastic crop, we’re going with this story about a ravenous crate-bound monster who leaps out and devours anyone who gets too close. It’s a wonderful blend of jolts, dark comedy, and gruesome bits of gore.

“Nightmare at 20,000 Feet” from Twilight Zone: The Movie (1983)

This uneven adaptation features at least two fantastic tales: Joe Dante’s “It’s a Good Life,” about a spoiled kid who has godlike powers, and this simple story of a man, an airplane, and a horrible monster that nobody else can see. William Shatner played the troubled passenger in the original Twlight Zone episode, but here he’s played by the great John Lithgow.

“Quitter’s Inc.” from Cat’s Eye (1985)

On the whole, this King-penned anthology is a fairly slight affair, but it does feature a cat (which I love) and it does have a segment in which the ever-sleazy James Woods is stalked by the employees of a very ominous anti-smoking group. We mainly included this one for the cat.

“The Raft” from Creepshow 2 (1987)

This sequel may lack the polish, cast, and budget of its predecessor, but it does deliver at least one very memorable tale. It’s a simple story about a bunch of horny teenagers who find themselves trapped on a raft when a giant slimy… something surrounds them. The rest of the story is just a bunch of shocks, gore, and random devourings. Fun stuff.

“Cat from Hell” from Tales from the Darkside: The Movie (1990)

George Romero adapts a Stephen King story, which makes this a Creepshow reunion of sorts. The story follows an old man who hires an “exterminator” because he is convinced his kitty cat is a ruthless killer… and let’s just say it: he’s right.

“Boys Do Get Bruised” from Tales from the Hood (1995)

(Photo by Savoy Pictures courtesy Everett Collection)

A kind of darker take on the “magical kid” story from the Twilight Zone movie, this one’s about a boy who can seemingly injure people by destroying pictures of them. His abusive stepfather is about to discover this dark power.

“Dumplings” from Three… Extremes (2004)

A vain woman desperately wants to cling to her youth, so she acquires some very suspect “dumplings” from a mysterious old lady. And things get very ugly from there. There’s also a feature-length version of this disturbing story from the same director. Neither are for the faint of heart.

“The School Bus Massacre” from Trick ’r Treat (2007)

In some anthologies, the best chapters jump straight out at you. In the case of the fan favorite Trick ‘r Treat, it is a very tough call to just pick one. This short earns the nod for being both legitimately disturbing and creepily amusing – like an old horror comic. It’s about a bunch of kids who tell a campfire tale to play a prank, but, of course, things backfire in the most ironic fashion.

“10/31/98” from V/H/S (2012)

Three guys show up to the wrong house, expecting a Halloween party but stumbling across some freaky occult rites, and then do all they can to get the hell out while the cult members (and the house itself) start freaking out in highly unexpected ways. Not much in the story department here, true, but there’s a lot of clever filmmaking going on.

“Safe Haven” from V/H/S/2 (2013)

(Photo by Magnolia Pictures)

This miniature masterpiece may just be the finest “found footage” horror movie you’ll ever see. It begins as an investigation into a creepy Indonesian cult and quickly devolves into a nightmare that feels like a cross between Clive Barker and H.P. Lovecraft.

“Easter” from Holidays (2016)

This twisted little tale is light on plot, but makes up for it by tapping deeply into the fear of being little and seeing a creature that should be really cute… but really isn’t. Plus, let’s be honest: The Easter Bunny is only slightly less disturbing than clowns and ventriloquist dummies.

“The Way In” and “The Way Out” from Southbound (2016)

No good horror anthology is complete without a fitting “wrap-around” segment that ties all the short stories together, and this great indie flick has a very creepy one indeed. It’s about two guys who are being chased across the desert by some freaky floating creatures, and it’s pretty nifty how this prologue and epilogue manage to add an extra layer of eerie fun to an already very impressive collection.

Ghost Stories opens this week in limited release and on VOD. Read reviews for it here.

Tag Cloud

Image Comics Paramount Network Film Festival zero dark thirty Musical sitcom Summer 71st Emmy Awards classics Comedy war SXSW 2022 Podcast Exclusive Video worst PaleyFest Black History Month ABC Family BET Star Wars Rom-Com blaxploitation reboot sports travel Alien genre HFPA Toys The Witch Family suspense BBC One PBS First Look Ellie Kemper marvel comics discovery Amazon Prime Lionsgate kids Grammys canceled TV shows Superheroes south america DGA comics fresh boxing vs. jurassic park summer TV preview Tomatazos marvel cinematic universe Kids & Family what to watch FX TruTV ABC Signature Sci-Fi nature Comedy Central social media Disney Plus binge Binge Guide Country Superheroe Comic-Con@Home 2021 green book latino Martial Arts japanese IFC Films satire Shondaland series LGBTQ 93rd Oscars Ovation spanish language TV One cops serial killer cinemax HBO BET Awards X-Men children's TV new york news know your critic king arthur dceu Best Actress french SDCC Hallmark scorecard action-comedy thriller remakes Song of Ice and Fire BBC America psychological thriller Heroines Horror obi wan FX on Hulu theme song obituary high school dragons james bond directors Mary poppins Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt biopic Best Picture technology MSNBC Acorn TV streamig leaderboard mockumentary FXX Comics on TV dexter 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards stoner Netflix 2016 free movies Photos NBC talk show Peacock The Walking Dead Character Guide Fox News batman spinoff police drama composers Valentine's Day See It Skip It cults TV renewals franchise rotten Thanksgiving football Chernobyl Box Office Paramount Fox Searchlight VH1 italian Sundance TV deadpool Cartoon Network OWN Chilling Adventures of Sabrina USA Extras hollywood Sony Pictures finale SundanceTV docudrama Pop CMT spain popular Prime Video award winner canceled Year in Review First Reviews cancelled crime drama Captain marvel mob Spring TV worst movies Set visit game of thrones comiccon anime AMC fast and furious foreign Biopics Schedule vampires movie superhero video Paramount Plus legend crime thriller Black Mirror Focus Features singing competition El Rey 94th Oscars Nominations Drama scary movies New York Comic Con Pet Sematary Mary Poppins Returns jamie lee curtis TNT Spectrum Originals A24 CBS Best and Worst 1990s telelvision RT History Emmy Nominations 79th Golden Globes Awards science fiction lord of the rings gangster Reality Television Critics Association Classic Film 2018 YA dramedy Tokyo Olympics aliens Bravo Comic Book Crackle Dark Horse Comics Disney+ Disney Plus indie breaking bad Crunchyroll spider-man Hear Us Out christmas movies streaming child's play Trailer natural history TV Land comic book movies Lucasfilm rt labs Countdown Rocky Ghostbusters CW Seed black blockbusters politics Oscar spider-verse new zealand Marathons films Trophy Talk comic book movie zombies crossover book adaptation Disney streaming service 4/20 twilight ghosts Action adenture monster movies TCA Winter 2020 Best Actor razzies robots Marvel live event CBS All Access 2021 documentaries superman Freeform new star wars movies Tags: Comedy Food Network animated TV movies Animation spanish biography scary criterion Lifetime ABC festivals Legendary critics Epix tv talk GLAAD 20th Century Fox Winter TV Sundance Pirates dreamworks Rocketman mcc medical drama psycho South by Southwest Film Festival Sundance Now boxoffice Calendar quibi revenge king kong National Geographic Hollywood Foreign Press Association unscripted Paramount Pictures indiana jones Baby Yoda TV Wes Anderson live action comic books Pride Month trailers Amazon Studios hidden camera godzilla Disney stop motion ESPN Musicals werewolf Nickelodeon YouTube Red transformers MCU Interview debate elevated horror IFC pirates of the caribbean The Arrangement Tumblr American Society of Cinematographers 99% Universal Turner Discovery Channel japan slasher screen actors guild Nat Geo dark aapi richard e. Grant festival toronto 73rd Emmy Awards toy story sopranos Video Games docuseries posters Turner Classic Movies Christmas romantic comedy rt labs critics edition historical drama 90s Tarantino dc Quiz Lifetime Christmas movies Marvel Television Apple TV+ E3 cartoon BBC zombie 72 Emmy Awards DC Universe miniseries Mystery kaiju australia BAFTA art house mutant Opinion cancelled television Red Carpet reviews dogs Universal Pictures international heist movie parents supernatural chucky comedies MTV TCA feel good Warner Bros. Masterpiece Cannes USA Network The Academy Endgame DC streaming service cancelled TV series Mindy Kaling archives MGM Emmys independent GIFs a nightmare on elm street HBO Max RT21 HBO Go Watching Series Spike die hard TIFF Brie Larson hispanic CNN Mudbound APB television TBS VOD based on movie Elton John best VICE Music The Purge asian-american all-time ID President DC Comics diversity ITV renewed TV shows doctor who disaster summer TV versus Walt Disney Pictures saw Polls and Games TCA 2017 laika nbcuniversal harry potter olympics Adult Swim joker Election Western adaptation casting NYCC halloween tv video on demand trophy 007 The Walt Disney Company royal family Amazon Teen Funimation universal monsters Syfy target young adult Esquire venice Infographic cooking Fargo Reality Competition Vudu teaser E! Marvel Studios Avengers San Diego Comic-Con movies 24 frames summer preview screenings WarnerMedia facebook Trivia Writers Guild of America crime 45 Apple TV Plus broadcast WGN justice league comic witnail prank Best Director Television Academy romance Fantasy kong nfl Netflix Christmas movies Star Trek 2019 sag awards Film sequels OneApp Amazon Prime Video streaming movies Cosplay SXSW TCM rom-coms Logo cancelled TV shows TCA Awards women strong female leads Stephen King Oscars halloween space Sneak Peek mission: impossible blockbuster Pacific Islander period drama AMC Plus Instagram Live game show hist Pixar GoT golden globe awards rotten movies we love Columbia Pictures 2015 basketball Pop TV Tubi golden globes LGBT black comedy Awards Tour Starz adventure Showtime name the review Super Bowl rt archives spy thriller book YouTube Premium Broadway Neflix Creative Arts Emmys Hallmark Christmas movies Mary Tyler Moore slashers scene in color Hulu YouTube NBA emmy awards critic resources Shudder Arrowverse Anna Paquin FOX PlayStation Women's History Month ViacomCBS documentary History hispanic heritage month stand-up comedy IMDb TV Winners Disney Channel The CW concert A&E Rock political drama Apple Fall TV 2017 2020 Premiere Dates ratings DirecTV Holiday wonder woman Britbox true crime Holidays Academy Awards Awards cars Travel Channel anthology 21st Century Fox cats TLC sequel Certified Fresh