The 16 Scariest Horror Anthology Segments

With Ghost Stories releasing this week in New York and on VOD, we look back at the best parts of other horror compilations.

by | April 18, 2018 | Comments

There’s something very appealing about short stories — they’re to-the-point, filled with twists, and you can get through a bunch of them in one sitting. Yet when it comes to movies, only horror films seem to consistently warrant the anthology treatment. Oh, sure you’ll find a few comedic anthologies like New York Stories, The Ten, and the cult classics Kentucky Fried Movie and Amazon Women on the Moon. But for the most part the “cinematic omnibus” is the domain of the scary storytellers, and genre fans certainly seem to enjoy the format – doubly so when one or two of the terror tales stand out as something truly special.

With that in mind, we’ve cooked up a sort of Frankenstein’s Monster of horror anthologies; a collection of the best segments from much-loved horror compendiums, curated scream-by-scream and featuring established classics along with more recent frights. We’ve created this list partly because IFC Midnight’s kick-ass import Ghost Stories is about to hit theater screens and VOD — trust us, it’s great, and currently sits at 88% on the Tomatometer — but also because, well, there’s just something very appealing about scary-AF short stories.

So enjoy this massive anthology menu composed of the best of the best horror anthology segments. And, yes, we had enough left over for a Volume 2.

“The Ventriloquist’s Dummy” from Dead of Night (1945)

Arguably the Casablanca of horror anthology films, Dead of Night showcases a strong handful of creepy and darkly amusing tales, but it’s probably best remembered for its masterful story about a ventriloquist who is convinced that his dummy is not only alive but incredibly malicious. Fans of flicks like Magic (1978) and Dead Silence (2007) will certainly enjoy this mini-movie.

“The Telephone” from Black Sabbath (1963)

Mario Bava kicks of his celebrated anthology with a simple yet enjoyably twisty tale of two women, a mysterious phone caller, and a stalker who may or may not actually exist.

“Frozen Fear” from Asylum (1972)

Amicus Productions released seven anthology horror films between 1965 and 1974 (most of them quite entertaining), but this is the one my parents rented as a kid, and it scared the living hell out of me – particularly this simple story of murder, voodoo, and a bunch of dismembered body parts. The stories in this anthology get weirder as the film progresses, and then, of course, it all ends on a nifty little twist. If you enjoy this one, check out Dr. Terror’s House of Horrors (1965), Tales from the Crypt (1972), and Vault of Horror (1973).

“Amelia” from Trilogy of Terror (1975)

The first two stories in this TV movie –  based on the works of the great Richard Matheson – are passable, if a bit forgettable, but the third tale absolutely terrified an entire generation. Basically, a woman gets attacked, chased, and terrorized by what’s referred to as a “Zuni fetish doll,” and if you thought Chucky was a nasty plaything, wait until you get a load of this tiny monster.

“The Crate” from Creepshow (1982)

(Photo by Warner Bros. courtesy Everett Collection)

The collaboration between Stephen King and George Romero would, not surprisingly, lead to one of the finest horror anthologies of all time, but if we’re picking the best of this fantastic crop, we’re going with this story about a ravenous crate-bound monster who leaps out and devours anyone who gets too close. It’s a wonderful blend of jolts, dark comedy, and gruesome bits of gore.

“Nightmare at 20,000 Feet” from Twilight Zone: The Movie (1983)

This uneven adaptation features at least two fantastic tales: Joe Dante’s “It’s a Good Life,” about a spoiled kid who has godlike powers, and this simple story of a man, an airplane, and a horrible monster that nobody else can see. William Shatner played the troubled passenger in the original Twlight Zone episode, but here he’s played by the great John Lithgow.

“Quitter’s Inc.” from Cat’s Eye (1985)

On the whole, this King-penned anthology is a fairly slight affair, but it does feature a cat (which I love) and it does have a segment in which the ever-sleazy James Woods is stalked by the employees of a very ominous anti-smoking group. We mainly included this one for the cat.

“The Raft” from Creepshow 2 (1987)

This sequel may lack the polish, cast, and budget of its predecessor, but it does deliver at least one very memorable tale. It’s a simple story about a bunch of horny teenagers who find themselves trapped on a raft when a giant slimy… something surrounds them. The rest of the story is just a bunch of shocks, gore, and random devourings. Fun stuff.

“Cat from Hell” from Tales from the Darkside: The Movie (1990)

George Romero adapts a Stephen King story, which makes this a Creepshow reunion of sorts. The story follows an old man who hires an “exterminator” because he is convinced his kitty cat is a ruthless killer… and let’s just say it: he’s right.

“Boys Do Get Bruised” from Tales from the Hood (1995)

(Photo by Savoy Pictures courtesy Everett Collection)

A kind of darker take on the “magical kid” story from the Twilight Zone movie, this one’s about a boy who can seemingly injure people by destroying pictures of them. His abusive stepfather is about to discover this dark power.

“Dumplings” from Three… Extremes (2004)

A vain woman desperately wants to cling to her youth, so she acquires some very suspect “dumplings” from a mysterious old lady. And things get very ugly from there. There’s also a feature-length version of this disturbing story from the same director. Neither are for the faint of heart.

“The School Bus Massacre” from Trick ’r Treat (2007)

In some anthologies, the best chapters jump straight out at you. In the case of the fan favorite Trick ‘r Treat, it is a very tough call to just pick one. This short earns the nod for being both legitimately disturbing and creepily amusing – like an old horror comic. It’s about a bunch of kids who tell a campfire tale to play a prank, but, of course, things backfire in the most ironic fashion.

“10/31/98” from V/H/S (2012)

Three guys show up to the wrong house, expecting a Halloween party but stumbling across some freaky occult rites, and then do all they can to get the hell out while the cult members (and the house itself) start freaking out in highly unexpected ways. Not much in the story department here, true, but there’s a lot of clever filmmaking going on.

“Safe Haven” from V/H/S/2 (2013)

(Photo by Magnolia Pictures)

This miniature masterpiece may just be the finest “found footage” horror movie you’ll ever see. It begins as an investigation into a creepy Indonesian cult and quickly devolves into a nightmare that feels like a cross between Clive Barker and H.P. Lovecraft.

“Easter” from Holidays (2016)

This twisted little tale is light on plot, but makes up for it by tapping deeply into the fear of being little and seeing a creature that should be really cute… but really isn’t. Plus, let’s be honest: The Easter Bunny is only slightly less disturbing than clowns and ventriloquist dummies.

“The Way In” and “The Way Out” from Southbound (2016)

No good horror anthology is complete without a fitting “wrap-around” segment that ties all the short stories together, and this great indie flick has a very creepy one indeed. It’s about two guys who are being chased across the desert by some freaky floating creatures, and it’s pretty nifty how this prologue and epilogue manage to add an extra layer of eerie fun to an already very impressive collection.

Ghost Stories opens this week in limited release and on VOD. Read reviews for it here.

Tag Cloud

joker vampires Polls and Games Masterpiece Summer reviews Action disaster dramedy game show TCA 2017 Broadway Mary poppins slashers Interview Comics on TV canceled TV shows Nominations justice league kaiju films hist Reality Showtime comic books video 2016 Amazon Studios HBO Go hispanic Winners Cosplay Trophy Talk The Purge TCA Alien The Academy batman documentary Premiere Dates PlayStation animated spinoff The Witch indiana jones indie 2017 Mudbound TV Land Kids & Family ID Lucasfilm docuseries spider-man christmas movies blockbuster streaming italian Marvel Television 007 french Awards docudrama kong FOX Watching Series singing competition award winner high school stand-up comedy new star wars movies Freeform critics Heroines 2018 foreign Lifetime Christmas movies Western directors screenings obituary blaxploitation robots Schedule sequel Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt space free movies The Arrangement nbcuniversal Quiz Britbox hidden camera romantic comedy Starz Turner Classic Movies popular Holidays best werewolf Rocky 2021 superman strong female leads rotten FX on Hulu sag awards BAFTA diversity Fox Searchlight E! 2015 Pet Sematary Shudder FXX emmy awards Mindy Kaling Discovery Channel television richard e. Grant reboot game of thrones Rocketman toy story revenge Spectrum Originals jamie lee curtis OneApp Shondaland Brie Larson Apple TV+ Amazon TNT BBC America TV First Look Academy Awards A&E Martial Arts Thanksgiving The CW Hear Us Out crime cars women dark king kong Black History Month jurassic park halloween 2020 Mary Poppins Returns anime Podcast Sundance Now 20th Century Fox Comedy Netflix Christmas movies Dark Horse Comics Oscars AMC Horror Biopics BBC One VH1 ghosts anthology stop motion cooking Netflix Chilling Adventures of Sabrina dogs spanish language Superheroe Captain marvel Hallmark Paramount Logo rom-coms Certified Fresh latino 72 Emmy Awards GLAAD romance Spike Black Mirror TIFF Pride Month Lionsgate boxing Drama rt archives Crunchyroll twilight movie SundanceTV Pop TV spain dc BBC ESPN Turner Pirates Exclusive Video pirates of the caribbean TV renewals franchise NYCC Trivia Election TBS Disney+ Disney Plus worst casting spy thriller mutant MSNBC Comedy Central National Geographic Paramount Plus trailers Bravo USA Apple TV Plus Lifetime CBS IFC GoT heist movie criterion Year in Review Tarantino deadpool TLC Red Carpet TCA Awards El Rey cartoon die hard GIFs Mystery Calendar adaptation green book San Diego Comic-Con halloween tv talk show japanese History Teen blockbusters saw SDCC Fantasy travel Nickelodeon Star Wars MCU a nightmare on elm street Creative Arts Emmys child's play Emmy Nominations mission: impossible quibi 45 Pop serial killer HBO Max 21st Century Fox BET war Tumblr screen actors guild Winter TV golden globes Women's History Month Amazon Prime Video CBS All Access true crime Sundance TV golden globe awards Cartoon Network Valentine's Day comic Travel Channel ABC Family what to watch ViacomCBS Tubi Anna Paquin facebook Chernobyl aliens teaser Emmys Box Office Rom-Com First Reviews historical drama video on demand social media hollywood Writers Guild of America E3 breaking bad fresh scary movies series Adult Swim comiccon laika football adventure independent LGBT Amazon Prime HBO Epix psycho VICE biography Legendary venice Binge Guide fast and furious Stephen King DC streaming service cats witnail concert Hulu south america zombies Trailer remakes Toys ABC Signature comics TCA Winter 2020 political drama Comic Book harry potter DC Universe worst movies crime thriller Crackle period drama Ellie Kemper Esquire RT21 SXSW Elton John DirecTV unscripted Cannes Musical Avengers transformers FX cults satire Television Critics Association Hallmark Christmas movies New York Comic Con chucky ABC Song of Ice and Fire all-time based on movie asian-american Classic Film Fox News NBC nature canceled police drama Tomatazos Reality Competition australia cancelled TV series Film Festival documentaries Character Guide 24 frames USA Network crossover Music Fall TV Television Academy Awards Tour festival cancelled television children's TV PaleyFest boxoffice cops TruTV PBS book finale VOD monster movies cancelled TV shows MTV Sony Pictures A24 2019 DC Comics 99% cancelled black Musicals TCM BET Awards Baby Yoda thriller Film APB Paramount Network Sci-Fi Warner Bros. natural history technology doctor who binge classics composers Country Set visit discovery Infographic The Walt Disney Company renewed TV shows Pixar Countdown name the review archives Syfy ITV 4/20 crime drama Rock sitcom YouTube Red politics The Walking Dead psychological thriller science fiction Marathons godzilla Ovation 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards razzies WarnerMedia American Society of Cinematographers OWN versus RT History X-Men Super Bowl Opinion Nat Geo elevated horror Best and Worst Acorn TV Sundance TV One toronto Endgame zombie YouTube Premium Holiday YA stoner rotten movies we love Disney Channel Columbia Pictures Disney streaming service Peacock Spring TV theme song superhero Grammys dragons Family supernatural prank IFC Films Walt Disney Pictures scorecard news kids Photos nfl telelvision Food Network mockumentary book adaptation Apple LGBTQ spanish Vudu Funimation sequels CW Seed 71st Emmy Awards parents CMT Arrowverse Superheroes Sneak Peek festivals 93rd Oscars Star Trek See It Skip It CNN YouTube cinemax medical drama DGA Marvel tv talk sports Disney ratings Extras WGN movies Mary Tyler Moore james bond miniseries Christmas zero dark thirty Universal universal monsters Video Games Disney Plus dceu President Marvel Studios Animation comedies Ghostbusters