News

Is Master of None the Most Socially Intelligent Comedy on TV Right Now?

by | November 24, 2015 | Comments

During the season finale of Master of None, Netflix’s new comedy from Aziz Ansari, Dev (Ansari) finds himself at a friend’s wedding with a date. It’s a perfect, sunny day at a fancy New York City location, with a waterfront view of the skyline and the Statue of Liberty.

As the couple enjoys their drinks and the sights, the father of the groom walks up to Dev and greets him by name. Then the man, Mr. Ryan, introduces himself to Dev’s date Rachel (Noel Wells).

Mr. Ryan then decides to open their slice of cocktail conversation with, “Aw, that’s nice. I love seeing ethnically mixed couples. You two are beautiful together.”

After that, he turns to Rachel – who happens to be white — ceasing to acknowledge Dev altogether. “Had you ever dated an ethnic man before this, Rachel?”

It’s exchanges like this that make Master of None possibly the most socially intelligent comedy series on TV right now. That’s because Ansari and his co-writer Alan Yang don’t make a big deal out of these moments and others like them; they’re just part of what Dev and his friends encounter in daily life.

Master of None premiered in early November and has since received wide critical acclaim, particularly for two episodes: “Indians on TV,” in which Dev navigates a brutal audition process that exposes him to the racial barriers imposed within the entertainment industry; and “Parents,” which takes a poke at first-generation kids who underappreciate the struggles faced by their immigrant parents. (“Parents” also made minor celebrities out of Ansari’s father Shoukath and his mother Fatima, who stole the show as Dev’s dad and mom.)

But Netflix doesn’t promote Master of None as a show about what it means to be Indian in America, or about any kind of racial prejudice, because it isn’t. This bears pointing out, not just because racial tensions have once again hit a boiling point — something a broadcast network, NBC, attempted to capitalize on this season with its comedy Truth Be Told. That show is a standard network half-hour sitcom featuring two best friends – one white, and one black – who joke about race all the time. (And truth be told, its initial episode order has been cut from 13 to 10; the series currently is gasping for air on Friday nights.)

Ansari’s viewpoint in Master of None, in contrast, makes the challenges of cultural relations part of a broader conversation about the bounty of choices available to thirty-something urbanites. If Seinfeld, still considered to be a quintessential New York-based series, was a show about nothing that featured unlikable people, Master of None is a comedy of microaggressions, one that mirrors urban life as it truly is, with diverse cultures and socio-economic groups rubbing shoulders with one another and still failing to blend with ease.

Master of None also is intentionally diverse, an issue about which Ansari has been vocal while promoting the show, even in front of audiences as broad as that of CBS’s The Late Show with Stephen Colbert. Dev’s main clique consists of his friends Brian (Kelvin Yu), Denise (Lena Waithe), and Arnold (Eric Wareheim). Brian is Asian, while Denise is black and, we eventually discover, a lesbian. Arnold is a childlike, awkward white giant, creating a stark contrast with Ansari’s short, wiry Dev.

Dev’s friends look as if they’ve been hanging out for years. And in the same way that their individual relationships with Dev appear natural and genuine, the situations they deal with — and the microaggressions that come out of them — feel equally realistic.

Dev’s exchange with the well-meaning if casually bigoted father of the groom was a brief scene in an episode that examined the meaning of commitment.  Yet to stand back and think about this moment and others Dev faces in aggregate, these tiny doses of ignorance speak volumes about where we are as a culture. In that conversation, a man Dev obviously knows reduces him to a category, “an ethnic.” He’s no longer his son’s friend, but an exotic spice that the nice white girl decided to sprinkle into her life.

“I think his heart’s in the right place,” Dev remarks after Mr. Ryan walks away, “but he really shouldn’t be saying ‘ethnic’ that much.”

So, as one character put it…there’s a thing.

The beauty of Ansari and Yang’s approach is that it demonstrate that these small slights, intentional or otherwise, are part of human nature. Everybody gets to be a target, and even Dev finds himself as the aggressor, or an accessory, at various points during the season.

The episode that best demonstrates this, “Ladies and Gentlemen,” isn’t about racism, but the covert sexism and dangerous objectification women have to deal with on a regular basis. Rachel becomes angry at Dev when he refuses to acknowledge that a guy intentionally ignored her and Denise as he stopped to shake the hands of the men around them.

“Seems like you might be reading a bit much into it,” Dev tells her.

“We’re telling you that this is something that definitely happens to women, all the time,” Rachel retorts, “but, fine. Deny our perception of the world.”

A subsequent observation drives home the message of witnessing all of these small snubs and how they affect Dev and others: “There are a lot of subtle little things that happen to me, and all women, even in our little progressive world. And when somebody, especially my boyfriend, tells me that I’m wrong without having any way of knowing my personal experience, it’s insulting.”

Thankfully, Master of None also shows us that every offender can learn from his or her mistakes. Upon meeting Rachel’s grandmother for the first time, Dev admits he was afraid that she’d be prejudiced about him at first sight, to which she replies with a smile, “Oh, I see. You assumed I was a racist just because I’m old! That’s nice.”

Again, this is a blip in a larger story about Dev and Rachel’s grandma. The pair go on to have a wild time hanging out together, telling each other stories about their lives, and eventually indulging in one of Dev’s favorite pastimes: eating pasta.

Life is full of barbs, and all of us toss in our share of sharpness in one way or another. But as Master of None proves, sometimes the best that we can do is acknowledge these stumbles and keep moving along to get to the good stuff.

Melanie McFarland is a Seattle-based TV critic and an executive member of the Television Critics Association. Follow her on Twitter: @McTelevision

 

  • Watched the pilot and was not impressed at all. I didn’t laugh (or even smile) once. This is one VERY over-rated program.

    • PUNFUCIUS

      Watching the pilot and judging a program is like making out with someone and assuming how they are in relationships
      You can do it, but it’s not an accurate portrayal
      It gets much better…

      • I’ve been told the same. I’ll watch a few more episodes and hope for the best.

      • Marcello Abbatangelo

        or much, much worse. in fact the odds are in favor that it will only get worse

    • Mario

      Yeah, it’s so overrated. I watched the first 5 episodes and only laughed a few times. It seems like they tried so hard to replicate Louie and it feels like a clunky, unfunny knock off.

      • Oh no, this thing doesn’t even come close to Louie’s clever subtlety.

    • ralphlaw

      Yes, I honestly don’t get this show, or “Jessica Jones”. Found “River” entertaining though.

    • Ocuyo

      Its a story as old as, well, the invention of stories. The internet, like it usually does, went crazy for this show, and spewed some generous, hyperbolic, and completely undeserved hype that no show can ever live up to. And you fell for it. I was lucky enough to watch it early on, with only one review as a reference. And, I think, its a great show.

  • Brian

    One of my fav shows of the year. Very much a modern comedy but brings in many influences – from art house flicks to stoner comedy to Girls, Woody Allen and the better rom-coms.

  • ralphlaw

    Not only is it not funny, it’s ironic that the show’s White and Black characters were all stereotypes. The very thing this ‘socially intelligent’ comedy is suppose to be standing against.

    As the star complains about being forced an ‘Indian Accent’ black characters spot potty-mouthed ebonics rather than anything that resembles standard english. And the White characters are also caricatures.

    • bradbrad

      Huh? Have seen every episode multiple times and have yet to encounter “ebonics.” Black characters might “sound black” due to their manner of speech but it’s not like they’re saying n*gga this, n*gga that etc. If you have trouble understanding them it honestly sounds like a personal problem lol. Characters of ALL races on this show are potty-mouthed. Would love to hear more about those so-called white caricatures though.

    • ricson

      It’s not supposed to be “standing against” anything. It’s supposed to be a portrayal of. Which I think based on these stereotypes, is.

  • Brewster

    Nothing would make me watch this. NOTHING. Netflix is wasting my money and their time with this.

    • Johnny

      yet here you are..commenting on a review of the show…

  • Really enjoyed it. It’s much better than Ansari’s stand up and deals with so many issues people in their late 20s and early 30s can relate to. This reminds me of Seinfeld, Curb, and Louie but for a younger more inclusive generation. Also the music in this is unbelievable, especially if you are from that afforementioned demographic.

  • NORMAN DOSTAL

    hes not that funny-its one of those “like this comedian because he was on a tv show” guys-not much here…

Tag Cloud

ratings The Walt Disney Company cancelled Discovery Channel cancelled TV series halloween tv talk show Musical Film Festival unscripted period drama streaming dceu BBC America TCM BBC One ITV Red Carpet Elton John Freeform Broadway australia directors comic hollywood disaster The Purge aliens james bond HBO Reality Competition Esquire Mudbound 2017 natural history prank japan best japanese worst movies Hear Us Out sequels Pirates social media cars dragons OneApp Watching Series sports GIFs cartoon Disney Plus The Walking Dead Reality screenings NYCC Fox News CBS All Access docudrama Trivia saw Britbox south america The CW laika Countdown nfl Nickelodeon all-time cooking indiana jones doctor who TCA Awards Winter TV LGBTQ History christmas movies RT History stand-up comedy spanish language National Geographic CMT jamie lee curtis know your critic critics Pixar Writers Guild of America Travel Channel 24 frames Tomatazos dc Warner Bros. cats psycho hispanic Certified Fresh rom-coms new zealand fast and furious spy thriller documentaries BAFTA strong female leads Syfy Film Anna Paquin cops TIFF APB ESPN high school Teen Pop TV Cartoon Network Oscars Stephen King Heroines crime drama Fall TV WGN ViacomCBS docuseries Creative Arts Emmys Classic Film quibi Photos Sci-Fi Cannes YA concert Family science fiction series blaxploitation 1990s See It Skip It singing competition Apple Amazon SDCC Endgame ABC Family comedies Legendary Star Wars blockbuster 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards canceled TV shows SundanceTV The Witch deadpool reviews DirecTV Spike romantic comedy nbcuniversal Ellie Kemper cinemax screen actors guild AMC IFC Martial Arts FXX Set visit Extras Amazon Prime Video Showtime films DGA crime Ovation Cosplay Vudu Sundance Television Academy joker Marvel Television HBO Go Captain marvel FX Calendar TLC Best and Worst miniseries new star wars movies facebook Video Games criterion VOD finale Ghostbusters hist Disney+ Disney Plus Nominations latino canceled spider-man documentary RT21 biography Marathons TCA Pop Universal movie Holiday The Arrangement 2018 child's play superhero TV movies television Marvel cults ID lord of the rings stoner toronto 90s rotten Lifetime Christmas movies zombies renewed TV shows Funimation DC Universe Food Network Kids & Family versus movies 45 sequel First Reviews technology Holidays Columbia Pictures golden globe awards psychological thriller Hallmark Christmas movies animated dogs Podcast Trailer ABC Academy Awards kaiju reboot Lifetime Arrowverse die hard basketball 71st Emmy Awards Music Interview monster movies werewolf archives parents Mary Poppins Returns Action Winners sag awards Fox Searchlight TBS olympics scary movies toy story telelvision sitcom target Emmys book adaptation The Academy Bravo remakes Comedy Opinion Pacific Islander richard e. Grant jurassic park Polls and Games ABC Signature indie Walt Disney Pictures foreign Quiz black Schedule 93rd Oscars TNT Hallmark book Amazon Studios Comics on TV Pride Month Mindy Kaling Peacock crime thriller Comedy Central Dark Horse Comics transformers spanish Awards Tour 21st Century Fox streaming movies Paramount Plus a nightmare on elm street Character Guide Infographic Netflix Christmas movies Image Comics Shondaland game show HBO Max anthology Exclusive Video nature Grammys FX on Hulu politics San Diego Comic-Con award winner godzilla cancelled TV shows festival Christmas Tubi Rom-Com Tokyo Olympics Crunchyroll king kong spinoff breaking bad Adult Swim A&E heist movie vampires venice independent MCU Box Office zombie free movies E! 2016 Amazon Prime spain OWN diversity Sundance Now 4/20 Women's History Month 20th Century Fox comic books 2021 Spring TV slashers Song of Ice and Fire children's TV American Society of Cinematographers Shudder Mary Tyler Moore 2015 CW Seed Superheroe BET true crime E3 First Look 2019 99% worst green book name the review TV One mockumentary New York Comic Con X-Men Wes Anderson Acorn TV justice league scene in color TCA 2017 Premiere Dates theme song supernatural teaser Super Bowl witnail YouTube festivals Nat Geo Trophy Talk Sundance TV DC streaming service adventure NBC Apple TV Plus Binge Guide Western kong thriller Valentine's Day Animation Apple TV+ DC Comics VICE Sneak Peek mutant SXSW Comic Book suspense MSNBC based on movie Rock Fantasy universal monsters robots elevated horror Hulu Masterpiece Tumblr Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt war Rocky President aapi USA zero dark thirty Marvel Studios Emmy Nominations 007 PlayStation historical drama emmy awards Spectrum Originals CNN Chernobyl Election Television Critics Association Horror satire obituary travel TV Land USA Network medical drama franchise italian fresh Starz Netflix chucky Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Paramount stop motion game of thrones twilight asian-american political drama international popular police drama TV renewals trailers space Thanksgiving Turner Classic Movies Pet Sematary Rocketman news Star Trek TV Avengers FOX 2020 marvel cinematic universe serial killer PaleyFest dark Toys Paramount Network anime mission: impossible blockbusters dramedy Epix video boxoffice YouTube Premium PBS Comic-Con@Home 2021 classics crossover football Superheroes Turner Disney Baby Yoda Biopics casting Alien comiccon tv talk Disney streaming service Mystery Summer kids halloween discovery YouTube Red WarnerMedia Year in Review women ghosts IFC Films Musicals composers 72 Emmy Awards comics boxing golden globes Brie Larson adaptation live action Lionsgate rt archives BET Awards Logo Country MTV binge A24 NBA hidden camera french CBS superman adenture rotten movies we love romance pirates of the caribbean video on demand batman Lucasfilm new york TCA Winter 2020 revenge Black Mirror El Rey Black History Month LGBT Crackle BBC Awards TruTV Mary poppins cancelled television GoT Sony Pictures Disney Channel what to watch VH1 razzies GLAAD Tarantino Drama harry potter scorecard