What Was the Best Year Ever for Horror?

We combed through RT data to figure out what year resonated most with critics, audiences, and both.

by | October 25, 2017 | Comments

Vera Miles in Psycho (1960)

What is the greatest year ever for horror? The debate has raged endlessly and will continue long into the future. However, to offer a point of discussion, we dug through RT data to discover which years had the best Tomatometer, Audience, and overall average scores. The rules we employed were as follows:

  1. Each film must be listed as “horror” on Rotten Tomatoes.
  2. Each film must have at least 20 reviews counted.
  3. Each year is represented by the five films that hold the highest average of Tomatometer and Audience scores.

Before we get into figuring out which year is the greatest for horror, we did a couple of quick breakdowns just for fun, and we noticed an interesting tidbit as we crunched the numbers. There are almost 900 films in our data set, from 1920 all the way up to the present day, and the overall average Audience score is 53.2%. The overall average Tomatometer score, however, is 54.4%. Conventional wisdom would seem to indicate that audiences tend to rate horror films higher than critics, but the data doesn’t bear that out. Instead, our numbers show that not only do critics and fans have pretty similar taste, but critics generally like horror movies more. Who would’ve thought?

Then, we also decided to take a look at the data by decade. For each decade, we gathered the films with the 10 highest Tomatometer scores and the 10 highest Audience scores, took the average of each of them, and then averaged those two scores to arrive at a single percentage (in other words, rule #3 above). It’s not an exact science, of course, and only a small sample was taken, but the results were very close:

1930s — 89.75%
1940s — 85%
1950s — 84.4%
1960s — 91.75%
1970s — 90.9%
1980s — 90.6%
1990s — 88.5%
2000s — 90.9%
2010s — 90.1%

According to these numbers, the 1960s — which included PsychoEyes Without a FaceRosemary’s Baby, and Night of the Living Dead, just to name a few — were the scariest decade in cinema, but the 1970s, 1980s, 2000s, and 2010s (which, by the way, aren’t over yet) could all stake a reasonable claim at the top.

But what about individual years? That took a bit more work, and the results were surprising. Read on to see what years reigned supreme with critics, audiences, and both.

Highest Audience Score Average

Winner: 1987
Average Audience Score: 81.6%

At first glance, 1987 might not immediately strike you as an obvious fan favorite year for horror. However, one look at the directors and films should clear things up a bit. The top five horror films of 1987 according to Audience score have some impressive directors behind them, namely Sam Raimi, Kathryn Bigelow, Clive Barker, Joel Schumacher, and John McTiernan. Their films rise above genre and incorporate horror elements beautifully.

The biggest reason why 1987 was victorious is Evil Dead 2: Dead by Dawn’s 89% Audience score. In fact, the Evil Dead franchise has the highest average Tomatometer (81.75%) and Audience score (80.75%) of any horror franchise with at least four theatrical releases. The Evil Dead, Evil Dead 2: Dead by Dawn, Army of Darkness, and the Evil Dead remake are the only foursome in which the box office nearly doubled with each successive film — a rare feat for any genre, let alone horror. Not bad for a tiny franchise featuring a blowhard named Ash being beaten silly.

Evil Dead 2: Dead by Dawn
Audience Score – 89%
Tomatometer Score –  98%

Audience Score – 87%
Tomatometer Score – 78%

The Lost Boys
Audience Score – 85%
Tomatometer Score – 73%

Near Dark
Audience Score – 74%
Tomatometer Score –  88%

Audience Score – 73%
Tomatometer Score – 66%

1987’s Audience score top five also includes a handful of fun pairings:

  • Evil Dead 2 and Predator feature people losing appendages in the woods.
  • The Lost Boys and Near Dark tell modern vampire tales.
  • Hellraiser and Evil Dead 2 feature books and puzzle boxes that should never be opened.
  • This is a bit of a stretch, but Bill Paxton was in Near Dark and he later met a very angry alien in Predator 2 (1990). Incidentally, Paxton also eventually worked with Sam Raimi in A Simple Plan (1998).

Highest Tomatometer Average

(Photo by Kit Fraser/Vertical Entertainment)

Winner: 2016
Average Tomatometer Score: 97%

We realize Nina Forever and The Love Witch aren’t traditional horror films, but even if we removed them from the list and replaced them with The Witch (91%) and Green Room (90%), 2016 would still be the winner here. 2016 figures heavily in our Top 100 Horror Movies list (The Witch, The Love Witch, Green Room, Under the Shadow, Train to Busan, The Autopsy of Jane Doe, Don’t Breathe), and with other recent hits like Get OutIT, and a number of acclaimed smaller films, it’s safe to say we’re currently experiencing something of a horror renaissance, at least according to critics.

That said, it’s interesting to note that The Love Witch and The Witch had a combined average Tomatometer score of 93.5% but an average Audience score of just 58%. Both are unique, meticulously directed, auteur-driven visions that push the boundaries of the genre, and they’re straight-up bonkers, so it’s likely audiences didn’t know what to expect.

Under the Shadow
Tomatometer Score – 99%
Audience Score – 74%

The Wailing
Tomatometer Score – 99%
Audience Score – 81%

Nina Forever
Tomatometer Score – 96%
Audience Score – 56%

The Love Witch
Tomatometer Score – 96%
Audience Score – 60%

Train to Busan
Tomatometer Score – 95%
Audience Score – 88%

Highest Average of Tomatometer and Audience Scores

(Photo by Well Go USA Entertainment)

Winner: 2016

Tomatometer Score Average: 97% (Under the Shadow, The Wailing, Nina Forever, The Love Witch, Train to Busan) 
Audience Score Average: 81.8% (Train to Busan, The Wailing, The Conjuring 2, Don’t Breathe, 10 Cloverfield Lane)
Combined Average: 89.4%

It took some teamwork for 2016 to be victorious in this category. The Tomatometer was exceptionally high, but Nina Forever, Under the Shadow, and The Love Witch weren’t universally loved by audiences. Luckily, Don’t Breathe, The Conjuring 2, and 10 Cloverfield Lane stepped up to the plate and helped carry 2016 over the top with their Audience scores.

Train to Busan
Tomatometer Score – 95%
Audience Score – 89%

The Wailing
Tomatometer Score – 99%
Audience Score – 81%

The Conjuring 2
Tomatometer Score – 79%
Audience Score – 81%

Don’t Breathe
Tomatometer Score – 87%
Audience Score – 79%

10 Cloverfield Lane
Tomatometer Score – 90%
Audience Score – 79%

Miscellaneous Stats

(Photo by Gordon Timpen/Screen Gems)

With 2016 sitting comfortably atop two of the three metrics we examined, we took a deeper dive into some fun odds and ends. Here are the results.

Victims of Animal Attacks – 89.4% (Green Roon, Don’t Breathe, The Wailing, The Witch, The Shallows)

Victims Attacked Mostly in a Single Location – 84.6% (10 Cloverfield Lane, The Invitation, Don’t Breathe, Green Room, The Autopsy of Jane Doe, The Shallows, 31, Under the Shadow)

Victims of Witches 75% (The Witch, Blair Witch, The Love Witch)

Victims of Zombies66.8% (Train to Busan, Pride & Prejudice & Zombies, JeruZalem, Cell, The Wailing, Nina Forever)

Victims of Another Sequel or Prequel – 61.7% (The Conjuring 2, Oiuja: Origin of Evil, 10 Cloverfield Lane, Blair Witch, The Purge: Election, Boo! A Madea Halloween, Phantasm: Remastered)

Victims Murdered in a Forest – 52.6% (The Witch, Green Room, Hush, the Wailing, The Monster, The Eyes of My Mother, The Mind’s Eye, Cell, Pride & Prejudice & Zombies, The Forest, Morgan, Blair Witch, Cabin Fever)

Victims of Unnecessary Remakes – 3% (Martyrs, Cabin Fever)

So now that you’ve seen what critics and audiences at large think, what’s your favorite year for horror?

Tag Cloud

dragons Disney Comedy Central Musicals Masterpiece Toys Academy Awards Comic Book SXSW TCA Winter 2020 sports Lucasfilm cults Film Festival VH1 CBS All Access screenings First Look Infographic TV Land Tubi WarnerMedia based on movie Comedy zombies richard e. Grant Mary Tyler Moore Anna Paquin Thanksgiving Certified Fresh Vudu theme song Film OWN Cartoon Network 2020 Hallmark History disaster anime MSNBC Fall TV cancelled television strong female leads Walt Disney Pictures CMT hist Travel Channel Trophy Talk crime universal monsters thriller dceu Horror National Geographic Lionsgate Election Sundance Now San Diego Comic-Con justice league American Society of Cinematographers 21st Century Fox composers Kids & Family Turner Opinion TV renewals Disney streaming service Bravo Teen free movies Ovation Heroines elevated horror Lifetime Christmas movies Tomatazos YouTube Premium canceled Dark Horse Comics travel rotten movies we love Funimation politics Starz Women's History Month zero dark thirty 2017 Podcast Biopics reviews CW Seed Winter TV cinemax First Reviews Christmas Freeform Television Academy Martial Arts docudrama serial killer harry potter Year in Review dramedy LGBTQ spy thriller DC Comics TCM ABC Family Black Mirror Discovery Channel Netflix Classic Film MCU 007 binge YouTube Red Valentine's Day Watching Series comics Star Trek Red Carpet LGBT The Witch RT History Oscars medical drama Awards supernatural Spike foreign Binge Guide Paramount Peacock Emmy Nominations indie Marathons ratings Marvel Studios sequel teaser Columbia Pictures crime drama Lifetime DGA E3 Best and Worst award winner Musical BET The Purge Syfy Action Apple cops Drama BBC America TIFF Amazon Rom-Com batman police drama PBS Spring TV joker children's TV NBC Ellie Kemper Creative Arts Emmys jamie lee curtis Comics on TV IFC Films Polls and Games GoT kids Pop TV Western witnail cars Summer 2015 werewolf Stephen King social media aliens talk show spider-man quibi The Arrangement Crackle Avengers Pride Month independent Rocky romance dogs robots cancelled spain diversity Endgame The Walking Dead Black History Month BBC Pirates 2016 video tv talk facebook Showtime SDCC Sneak Peek Elton John Disney Plus green book Nickelodeon Sundance period drama Family Animation HBO Max Mystery PaleyFest Disney+ Disney Plus space Interview south america nature cancelled TV series boxoffice cooking Chernobyl Marvel Television blaxploitation Sony Pictures Country streaming 20th Century Fox Fox News Pet Sematary cancelled TV shows psycho FX on Hulu Holidays unscripted franchise GLAAD TCA ABC Mary poppins blockbuster Arrowverse game of thrones Marvel scary movies 71st Emmy Awards Crunchyroll CBS 45 Holiday DC Universe latino natural history Ghostbusters Warner Bros. TCA 2017 Rock Countdown New York Comic Con christmas movies Reality Cannes Cosplay zombie what to watch finale A24 game show Mary Poppins Returns book dc slashers toy story TV movies Mudbound X-Men canceled TV shows breaking bad Sundance TV spinoff Shondaland Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt crime thriller reboot APB FX Grammys Amazon Studios Box Office Rocketman technology Set visit Sci-Fi USA Network miniseries E! Nat Geo adventure SundanceTV Winners MTV ESPN See It Skip It Baby Yoda mockumentary GIFs AMC DirecTV revenge NYCC 2019 casting psychological thriller Chilling Adventures of Sabrina CNN HBO Tarantino golden globes Logo sag awards festivals screen actors guild halloween name the review Acorn TV Pixar Photos Paramount Network 24 frames Universal comiccon crossover cats Schedule DC streaming service adaptation sitcom Reality Competition Quiz Trivia hispanic Spectrum Originals TruTV Disney Channel series Tumblr Star Wars mutant ITV comic TLC romantic comedy President USA VICE A&E spanish language Extras TNT transformers biography science fiction Superheroes Music RT21 YouTube FOX directors Hulu Nominations Amazon Prime Britbox cartoon Adult Swim Apple TV Plus OneApp war stand-up comedy YA true crime The CW Apple TV+ documentary Captain marvel Turner Classic Movies Shudder Trailer anthology renewed TV shows Fantasy versus vampires discovery doctor who WGN Awards Tour Video Games Netflix Christmas movies 2018 animated FXX Food Network singing competition Super Bowl Brie Larson Calendar Character Guide Hallmark Christmas movies Superheroe ghosts Esquire Epix Premiere Dates IFC Mindy Kaling El Rey Writers Guild of America television Emmys historical drama Song of Ice and Fire political drama Pop TBS movie Amazon Prime Video