What Is the Most Underrated MCU Movie?

Between a pair of origin stories, an offbeat Christmas movie, and even a couple of Avengers team-ups, which one deserves more love than it gets?

by | May 19, 2020 | Comments

Thor, Captain America, Iron Man, Ultron, and Thanos

(Photo by ©Paramount Pictures, Zade Rosenthal/©Walt Disney Pictures, ©Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, ©Marvel Studios)

The decade-long (and counting) grand experiment known as the Marvel Cinematic Universe has proven to be both a critical and commercial success, and with 23 movies to the franchise thus far, there are bound to be entries that were overshadowed or outright dismissed. With the next big Marvel movie — Black Widow — now delayed until November 6, effectively creating a domino effect and pushing back all other planned entries, fans are free to catch up on all the movies as they self-quarantine at home. But what are those unsung — or underappreciated — movies in the franchise?

We asked staff members here at RT what they thought were the most underrated MCU movies, and a handful responded with some interesting selections. We should clarify that this isn’t simply a list of the worst-reviewed movies in the franchise with arguments amounting to, “It’s secretly good!” The five choices below represent films that either never managed to gain the kind of fanbase that others did, or irked audiences in one way or another, or became lost in the shadows of even bigger entries. Read on for the five most underrated MCU movies according to RT staff, and then vote in the poll below for which one you think deserves more love than it gets!

Thor (2011) 77%

When Thor was announced and Kenneth Branagh was tapped to direct it, many were more than little a skeptical. Branagh, who was best known for Shakespearean adaptations like Hamlet, Henry V, and Much Ado About Nothing, had never helmed a middle-range budgeted film, let alone a $150 million CGI-heavy fantasy flick for the Marvel Cinematic Universe. However, that inspired albeit risky choice in the director’s chair is why the film is better than it’s often credited to be. In truth, Thor set a formula that would be repeated by many of the most beloved superhero films yet to come. Logan, Ant-Man, and Captain America: The Winter Soldier all borrowed from the blueprint set by Thor and thrived because of it. Thor proved that the heart of every successful superhero film had to be story and theme, and the superhero part is less important.

Logan is a western but with superheroes; Ant-Man is a heist movie with superhero tech; and Captain America: The Winter Solider is a spy thriller with some really super soldiers. This is why Thor sticks out and feels slightly out of place with early MCU films — and why it’s often dismissed as mediocre. Up to that point, putting Robert Downey Jr. in a suit or making Edward Norton go green was all the audience needed. Thor gave us more, including the pitch-perfect casting of Chris Hemsworth as the God of Thunder himself, Anthony Hopkins as Odin, Natalie Portman as Jane, and one of the best villains ever, Tom Hiddleston as Loki. You can’t get actors of that pedigree without a director like Branagh, who understood the film was, in fact, a Shakespearean drama more akin to Hamlet than Iron Man. Secret parentage, a path to succession, and a spoiled little prince in need of redemption sound more like an episode of The Tudors than a comic book movie, but a comic book movie it is, and one that deserves our respect. – Jacqueline Coley

Captain America: The First Avenger (2011) 80%

Like Thor, this isn’t your typical superhero movie, and that’s why it’s so great. It doesn’t have supersuits or alien invaders, or even cell phones. It’s an origin story of a good man becoming a great hero. The film feels like one of the old Hollywood serials that would have been popular during the era in which the film itself is set, which is part of its charm, and it celebrates the campiness of the Cap comics while also embracing the heart. We get to see a scrawny Steve Rogers turn into the mighty Captain America (with some not-so-bad CGI), some fun action sequences, a lot of Bucky bromance, a little Peggy romance (Agent Carter is the most underrated hero), and of course, the origins of one of the best MCU lines ever, “I can do this all day.” And if we hadn’t seen how it all began, there’s no way we would have been as invested in his character — one of the linchpins of the entire franchise —  or as touched when he made his bittersweet exit. – Jennifer Jevons

Iron Man 3 (2013) 79%

Yes, we’re going there. And yes, we’re going to… deep breath… defend its take on the Mandarin. Iron Man 3 may only be the third-best threequel in the MCU – how could it compete with Ragnarok and Civil War? – but it’s never deserved the fury with which some fans greeted it back in 2013, nor the indifference with which many reflect on it today. Indeed, it belongs in the upper tiers of any fair MCU ranking for a whole host of reasons. First up, it continued arguably the most creatively rich trend in the franchise: the risky hiring of unique, auteur-type directors, not necessarily tested in the superhero genre, to helm these things. Without Shane “Kiss Kiss Bang Bang” Black putting his mark on Iron Man, you don’t get Taika Waititi’s take on Thor, James Gunn’s Galaxy, or Chloe Zhao helming The Eternals. In other words, you don’t get the current all-Fresh-no-Rotten, genre-bending shape of the MCU. Black made the film the most distinctive MCU offering up to that point, infusing it with many of his ticks and trademarks: a Christmas setting – yes, Iron Man 3 is a Christmas movie and we think we just won the argument right there – plus plenty of rapid-fire dialogue and some clever voice over. And he did it all while delivering some of the MCU’s best bang-bang set pieces, including the breathtaking destruction of Tony Stark’s home.

Now, to address the simpering, British elephant in the room: Black and co.’s treatment of the Mandarin is, far from a crime against the character’s comic-book legacy, one of the best surprises Marvel has ever given us on screen. Precisely because it is that: a genuine, refreshing, hilarious surprise. After the battering we’d all received from The Avengers, and a string of grandiose to tedious villains (remember Malekith? Neither do we), the Mandarin bait-and-switch is an ingenious subversion, and one that showed a $200 million blockbuster from Disney and Marvel could still mess with our expectations. Oh, and Sir Ben Kingsley is great. So, yes, we get it: It wasn’t the Mandarin you wanted, but it was the Mandarin – and Iron Man 3 was the film – the MCU needed. And it’s time the movie was shown a bit more respect. – Joel Meares

Avengers: Age of Ultron (2015) 76%

We already made a case here for why Avengers: Age of Ultron could be the most important movie in the MCU, but allow us to reiterate. While it sports one of the lower Tomatometer scores in the MCU and it’s frequently cited as something of a disappointment in the franchise, it also happens to be the foundation upon which the latter half of the Infinity Saga is built. This is the film that sowed the seeds of Bruce Banner assuming some control over the Hulk, a story arc that came to full fruition in Endgame. It’s also when the meet-cute between the two halves of WandaVision took place, as well as the first indication that Cap might be worthy to wield Mjolnir, a throwaway sight gag that would later pay off in a major way. We meet Hawkeye’s family, see visions of potential futures that hint at the events of Infinity War and Thor: Ragnarok, and get a few pointedly ominous lines (“That’s the endgame”). But perhaps the most crucial development in Age of Ultron is the rift that begins to develop between Tony Stark and Steve Rogers as they argue over ideology and literally come to blows over the creation of Vision. The cracks in their relationship would grow into giant fault lines when the final confrontation between the Avengers and Ultron here later ultimately leads to the events of Captain America: Civil War, and that division, in part, is what allows Thanos to succeed in his plan to the extent that he does. So while it may not be the most beloved film in the MCU, Age of Ultron absolutely deserves more respect than it regularly gets, even if only because it represents a crucial turning point in the Infinity Saga. – Jacqueline Coley

Avengers: Infinity War (2018) 85%

It’s true that Avengers: Infinity War was a huge box office winner and a hit with critics, but its success was largely trumped by the film it served to set up, and we think its reputation deserves better than that. In Infinity War, we finally meet the big baddie of all the MCU villains. While Thanos’ goal — to wipe out half the galaxy — doesn’t appear to be so different from that of any other major villain, he believes he’s saving the galaxy by destroying it, and he dispatches anyone who dares to stand in his way as a mere casualty in his “quest for good.” One of the overlooked strengths of Infinity War is that you walk in already knowing and loving the Avengers, but it’s Thanos you spend the most time with. He’s an unknown quantity, and that uncertainty immediately makes you afraid for the lives of your favorite heroes, because you don’t know exactly what this purple villain is capable of.

In Infinity War, Thanos experiences something that’s usually reserved for heroes: a moment of personal sacrifice. From Tony in New York to Groot in the Dark Aster, our heroes have found themselves making choices that could end their own lives in order to save others, and Infinity War subverts this trope in an unexpected way. Throughout the film, the Avengers spend a lot of time telling each other to protect the Infinity Stones — and Earth — at all costs, but their initial unwillingness to accept loss of life in exchange for Thanos’ defeat limits their ability to effectively fight the Mad Titan. We’re left seeing them unable to come to grips with whether their choice was really for the greater good — or if it was for themselves. Meanwhile, unlike our heroes, Thanos makes the painful decision to sacrifice a life — that of his daughter Gamora — to obtain the Soul Stone. By the end, Infinity War leaves viewers debating whether the Avengers should have traded lives for the sake of the universe. That’s not how a Marvel movie “should” end. Yes, it’s a setup for Endgame, but it has prescience — and for a blockbuster studio film, it’s a hell of an ending to chew on. – Daisy Gonzalez

Tag Cloud

Biopics dark cars game of thrones festivals Mystery RT History Disney Plus GIFs Amazon Prime Video CW Seed Awards Mudbound USA Spectrum Originals TV Toys Calendar Logo renewed TV shows Broadway Rocky Country streaming Fall TV justice league Epix blockbusters Shudder Comedy zombies E! TCA Winter 2020 USA Network MSNBC DC Comics anime Oscars docudrama discovery boxoffice Character Guide Anna Paquin PlayStation OWN revenge Cannes CBS miniseries cancelled spain HBO Go President screenings what to watch name the review hist concert SXSW Song of Ice and Fire comic Black Mirror Reality Competition Exclusive Video Martial Arts rom-coms MCU Travel Channel Trailer fast and furious directors saw 2021 YA The Walt Disney Company 93rd Oscars GoT 2019 social media Apple TV Plus Summer Comics on TV spy thriller 72 Emmy Awards worst Shondaland war adventure E3 finale NBC Spring TV screen actors guild NYCC Film Festival Holiday mission: impossible pirates of the caribbean Starz Showtime news slashers Box Office cinemax Arrowverse kids El Rey video on demand Trophy Talk Cosplay 99% Classic Film VICE werewolf game show award winner critics AMC TNT A24 sequel jurassic park The Witch dceu The Purge Women's History Month true crime movies black CBS All Access Premiere Dates theme song Marathons french indie 2020 Watching Series nfl Family Music New York Comic Con strong female leads cops Fantasy National Geographic Fox News FX on Hulu Netflix crime thriller Disney YouTube book joker series nbcuniversal Film TCA 2017 PaleyFest australia cults psychological thriller telelvision Amazon Walt Disney Pictures Hulu Musicals Extras Apple Paramount Plus 2018 Interview harry potter Alien Food Network Best and Worst toy story DC Universe 71st Emmy Awards zombie prank TCA Awards Pop TV teaser Trivia spider-man Writers Guild of America Masterpiece Warner Bros. cats American Society of Cinematographers all-time 20th Century Fox canceled TV shows nature asian-american foreign reviews Action Podcast superman APB X-Men See It Skip It TBS hispanic doctor who mutant Certified Fresh Pride Month sitcom hollywood emmy awards Television Academy RT21 witnail trailers movie Avengers spanish language Thanksgiving History south america deadpool Pirates Mary Tyler Moore 4/20 diversity Columbia Pictures Disney+ Disney Plus First Reviews Fox Searchlight ID 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Grammys women OneApp cooking Turner worst movies historical drama composers stoner BAFTA best films Holidays 24 frames Marvel Studios DGA criterion Amazon Studios Video Games Teen Pop monster movies rotten HBO Max HBO Rom-Com Winners free movies video stand-up comedy children's TV Emmy Nominations ABC Signature Esquire latino Opinion Rocketman Valentine's Day halloween Drama parents Hallmark Christmas movies television quibi chucky hidden camera new star wars movies football natural history Polls and Games Star Trek Comedy Central ghosts ESPN ABC Amazon Prime venice vampires dramedy Binge Guide Ellie Kemper king kong Spike science fiction LGBTQ popular Tomatazos TCA halloween tv 007 kong unscripted elevated horror Superheroe MTV indiana jones TIFF mockumentary A&E police drama comiccon ABC Family GLAAD The Academy Legendary Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt adaptation boxing Comic Book Disney Channel Paramount facebook animated period drama Endgame Schedule LGBT Horror 2016 Hallmark twilight spanish Black History Month crime 21st Century Fox james bond japanese Discovery Channel book adaptation Nickelodeon comedies First Look scary movies archives Quiz space SundanceTV thriller Disney streaming service remakes Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Paramount Network Bravo dogs TV Land zero dark thirty Animation spinoff superhero comics FX Apple TV+ fresh VH1 rotten movies we love IFC TCM Awards Tour Hear Us Out Heroines scorecard sequels TruTV IFC Films romantic comedy talk show Year in Review franchise Western Sony Pictures cancelled television Christmas aliens obituary political drama VOD christmas movies CNN reboot PBS italian Lucasfilm 2017 WarnerMedia godzilla BBC One sports breaking bad Tumblr Election Crackle TV One DC streaming service ITV Cartoon Network ratings cancelled TV series Crunchyroll The Arrangement classics Nominations Elton John comic books Vudu Countdown golden globes Academy Awards based on movie dc Ovation heist movie anthology BBC America Reality laika Infographic technology Universal BET BET Awards BBC robots biography satire Funimation dragons kaiju Musical travel richard e. Grant Pet Sematary Peacock Dark Horse Comics Set visit cartoon Turner Classic Movies Sci-Fi crime drama 2015 DirecTV Captain marvel green book San Diego Comic-Con independent Baby Yoda Brie Larson WGN jamie lee curtis Marvel Star Wars high school Nat Geo singing competition binge supernatural Sundance TV Ghostbusters Mary Poppins Returns Emmys Kids & Family FOX Chernobyl medical drama Mindy Kaling Winter TV Sundance Now Lionsgate universal monsters romance Sneak Peek a nightmare on elm street Super Bowl blaxploitation rt archives Lifetime Creative Arts Emmys crossover Tarantino die hard Rock Britbox Mary poppins tv talk TV renewals documentary golden globe awards Lifetime Christmas movies versus TLC Adult Swim toronto Sundance stop motion Red Carpet YouTube Premium Netflix Christmas movies casting Photos canceled cancelled TV shows psycho YouTube Red SDCC ViacomCBS serial killer Superheroes The CW Stephen King festival FXX Marvel Television docuseries politics razzies Freeform Syfy documentaries transformers blockbuster Acorn TV sag awards Television Critics Association child's play batman Tubi The Walking Dead 45 CMT disaster Pixar