News

Which Oft-Rebooted Story Yields the Highest Tomatometer Scores? We're Breaking Down the Ultimate Reboots

With new takes on Little Women and A Christmas Carol this month, we're doing a Tomatometer deep dive into reboots to ask whether TV is better than film, whether big changes work, and more.

by | December 18, 2019 | Comments

20th Century Fox

(Photo by 20th Century Fox)

In 1896, a 45-second clip featuring a segment from the book Trilby and Little Billee was produced and started a 123-year old trend of literary works being adapted into films or television shows (and being adapted again and again). With films Little Women (2019), West Side Story (2020, pictured above), Wendy (2020), Emma (2020), and television movie A Christmas Carol (2019) and limited series War of the Worlds (2020) on the horizon, we decided to take a deep dive into the Tomatometer to see which of the literary adaptations are the Freshest, and which are the Rottenest (it’s a word).

We pulled the data on 32 books that have at least three feature-length movies (80-plus minutes) or television shows with Tomatometer scores (don’t ask about Gone Girl, it’s only been adapted once) and created a dataset of 145 movies. We chose to exclude comic-book adaptations and movies like Godzilla that have copious reboots — it’s nothing personal, we just wanted to stick with literary adaptations.

Quick note: We also excluded short films such as the 16-minute, black-and-white Frankenstein (1910) that was technically the first adaptation of Mary Shelley’s book. Also, Nosferatu, which is basically Bram Stoker’s Dracula – but not. Also, there are many obscure or lost films that don’t have Tomatometer scores and weren’t feature-length, so they were excluded.


1. HENRY V RULES OVER ALL ADAPTATIONS WITH A 90% TOMATOMETER AVERAGE

Netflix

(Photo by Netflix)

With Laurence Olivier, Kenneth Branagh, David Michôd, and Thea Sharrock directing the Henry V adaptations, it’s no wonder adaptations based on William Shakespeare’s Henry V have the highest Tomatometer average. The first two major adaptations released in 1946 and 1989 have perfect 100% Tomatometer scores, and the 2012 BBC adaptation starring Tom Hiddleston has a 95% Tomatometer score. The lowest-rated adaptation, with a Fresh 70% Tomatometer score, is The King, the Netflix released film starring Timothée Chalamet (who also stars in the latest Little Women adaptation). Henry V has only known Freshness, and that’s why it’s the Fresh king of adaptations.


2. WITH A 43% TOMATOMETER AVERAGE, TARZAN ADAPTATIONS KEEP SWINGING ON ROTTEN VINES

Lionsgate

(Photo by Lionsgate)

If it weren’t for Tarzan the Ape Man (1932), Greystoke: The Legend of Tarzan, Lord of the Apes (1984), and Tarzan (1999), the adaptations of Edgar Rice Burroughs’ 1912 story would be super-Rotten. The three most recent attempts at retelling the fabled legend — 2013’s Tarzan, 2014’s Tarzan, and 2016’s The Legend of Tarzan — have a 24% Tomatometer average. On a random note, we know George of the Jungle isn’t Tarzan–related; however, Brendan Fraser is the best, and we think you should watch it again.


3. THE FIRST ADAPTATION OF LITERARY WORKS HAVE THE BEST TOMATOMETER AVERAGE — WITH AN EXCELLENT 86% AVERAGE

Walt Disney Pictures

(Photo by Walt Disney Pictures)

The 86% Tomatometer average for the 32 first adaptations of various literary stories proves it’s good to be first. Only four of these adaptations have Rotten scores — and their average is an almost respectable 50%. The Tomatometer average for the adaptations that follow the firsts falls to a still Fresh 61% (which isn’t bad). While there are superb follow-up adaptations, such as the Jon Favreau–directed The Jungle Book and Joss Whedon’s Much Ado About Nothing, there is a drop-off in quality that almost always happens with remakes or sequels, so it’s no shame that the Tomatometer average is lower. It just means there were more opportunities to water down the material (Hello Beastly or A Cinderella Story) or make something that pales in comparison to its predecessors.


4. TELEVISED ADAPTATIONS (74%) HAVE A HIGHER TOMATOMETER AVERAGE THAN THEATRICALLY RELEASED ADAPTATIONS (67%)

BBC One

(Photo by BBC One)

The 14 literary adaptations in our data set that were released on television or streaming services have a 74% Tomatometer average; whereas movie adaptations have a 67% Tomatometer score. The Fresh 74% average comes from a stacked lineup of adaptations such as 87% Tomatometer-rated War and Peace (2016) starring Lily James and Paul Dano and the epic 88%-rated Pride and Prejudice (1995) miniseries that propelled Colin Firth to superstardom and made striding out of lakes popular. The lowest-rated televised adaptations are the 25% Tomatometer-rated Tarzan (the less said, the better), and the 51%-rated Beauty and the Beast, that was released in 2013 on the CW, and actually got better as it progressed through its four seasons.


5. WHAT ARE THE HIGHEST TOMATOMETER-RATED ADAPTATIONS?

Continental Distributing

(Photo by Continental Distributing)

Thirteen films and television shows in our data set have 100% scores, which is impressive considering how exclusive the 100% club is. The movies and shows are The Three Musketeers (1921), Frankenstein (1931), Tarzan the Ape Man (1932),  Anna Karenina (1935), The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1939), Pride and Prejudice (1940), Henry V (1946), Oliver Twist (1951), War and Peace (1968), Mickey’s Christmas Carol (1983), Henry V (1989), and Hamlet (2009). There hasn’t been a 100% Tomatometer-rated adaptation in our data set since 2009 (and the last film with the score, Hamlet, has just six reviews). Let’s hope War of the Worlds or A Christmas Carol can join the club.


6. WHAT ARE THE LOWEST TOMATOMETER-RATED ADAPTATIONS?

Warner Bros. Pictures

(Photo by Warner Bros. Pictures)

When it comes to the lowest-rated literary adaptations in our data set, we noticed a trend. Movies that either place the story in modern times or add a new wrinkle often get the lowest scores: 2006’s Material Girls  (loosely based on Jane Austen’s Sense and Sensibility) with a 4% score, 2014’s I, Frankenstein at 5%, 2011’s Beastly with 20%, 2011’s Age of the Dragons at 9%, 2018’s Little Women at 27%, 2001’s The Musketeer at 11%, and 2004’s A Cinderella Story at 12%. The tendency to modernize a classic story often results in Tomatometer scores below 30%. Age of the Dragons is Moby Dick, but with dragons. Using modern fight choreography, The Musketeer claimed it was “As you’ve never seen it before” and received an 11% Tomatometer score. Sometimes the approach works – Clueless (79%),  Scrooged (70%), or 10 Things I Hate About You (68%) – and sometimes, well, it does not, which brings us to…


7. ADAPTATIONS THAT DRASTICALLY CHANGE THE SOURCE MATERIAL HAVE A 44% TOMATOMETER AVERAGE

United Artists Films

(Photo by United Artists Films)

When compared to the 74% Tomatometer average for the adaptations that stick closely to their source material, the 44% looks really bad; however, a number of movies and television shows that modernized their stories or added zombies into the mix have done pretty well. Movies like Ethan Hawke’s Hamlet from 2000 with an almost-Fresh 57%, 1961’s West Side Story at a Certified Fresh 93%, and Baz Luhrman’s Romeo + Juliet from 1996 with 72% successfully modernized the source material and gave the world some really cool visuals. If you haven’t watched the 45% Tomatometer-rated Pride and Prejudice and Zombies yet, just know that it features Lily James, Matt Smith, Lena Heady, Charles Dance, Sam Riley, Suki Waterhouse, and Bella Heathcote battling zombies. It’s weird, and sorta charming.


8. THE LITTLE WOMEN ADAPTATIONS HAVE A 77% TOMATOMETER AVERAGE

Sony Pictures

(Photo by Sony Pictures)

Any other upcoming literary adaptations will have a hard time competing with Greta Gerwig’s wonderful take on Little Women. It’s earning rave reviews (currently 97% on the Tomatometer with 67 reviews), and looks like it may stand right alongside the 1933 (94%) and 1994 (92%) films and the 2017 television adaptation (84%) as wonderful Little Women adaptations that have big Tomatometer scores. If it weren’t for the 2018 Little Women, which is a modern retelling of the story that has a 27% Tomatometer average, the Little Women set would be competing for the top spot among all the adaptations.


9. KENNETH BRANAGH IS THE KING OF LITERARY ADAPTATIONS

Picturehouse

(Photo by Picturehouse)

If you’re looking for someone to direct your literary adaptation you would be wise to consider Kenneth Branagh first. Why? His adaptations for Henry V, Much Ado About Nothing, Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, In the Bleak Midwinter (A Midwinter’s Tale), Hamlet, As You Like It, Love’s Labour’s Lost, Cinderella, and Murder on the Orient Express have an average  70.5% Tomatometer score, with Henry V, Much Ado About Nothing, Hamlet, and Cinderella having Tomatometer scores of 85% or higher.


10. ANIMATED LITERARY ADAPTATIONS HAVE A 70% TOMATOMETER AVERAGE

Walt Disney Feature Animation

(Photo by Walt Disney Feature Animation)

In the decades-long Tomatometer battle between live-action and animated literary adaptations, the animated adaptations have a slight 4% lead (70% > 66%). The averages are close, but the animated films, led by Cinderella (1950), Alice in Wonderland (1951), The Jungle Book (1967), Mickey’s Christmas Carol (1983), Beauty and the Beast (1991), and Tarzan (1999) put animated films in the top spot.

What are your favorite literary adaptations? Let us know in the comments!


Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Thumbnail image: A Christmas Carol (Kurt Iswarienko/FX), Cinderella (Jonathan Olley/©Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures), Little Women (Wilson Webb/2019 CTMG, Inc.)

Tag Cloud

USA indie Song of Ice and Fire San Diego Comic-Con Grammys ABC Schedule obituary TCM series Thanksgiving 2020 joker Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt X-Men Summer Turner Walt Disney Pictures halloween aliens cinemax Drama movies RT History dramedy SDCC comic Lionsgate Elton John mockumentary Rock MSNBC 2017 Sundance TV Writers Guild of America Nominations concert Year in Review chucky cooking TCA finale Emmy Nominations facebook adaptation supernatural Lifetime Election E3 christmas movies Disney streaming service sequels PBS documentaries Musical renewed TV shows psycho Martial Arts Cosplay BBC America indiana jones Arrowverse anthology OneApp Pop Mindy Kaling sitcom Esquire MCU Marathons cults First Reviews Opinion HBO comiccon documentary BBC One game of thrones screenings Discovery Channel Hallmark Christmas movies Kids & Family President Red Carpet WarnerMedia DC Comics thriller HBO Max Reality Competition GIFs cats batman Cannes SundanceTV universal monsters ghosts NBC Bravo crime nature E! 2016 FOX ABC Family Mary Poppins Returns cancelled TV shows casting Video Games worst what to watch discovery toy story Trophy Talk die hard Pop TV Ovation Academy Awards Rom-Com stoner Sony Pictures disaster adventure Avengers WGN spider-man FX cars Epix VH1 political drama 2018 CMT See It Skip It festival police drama true crime YA Valentine's Day YouTube Premium Shudder Syfy Star Trek nfl TV latino toronto nbcuniversal anime spy thriller classics APB elevated horror stand-up comedy 45 binge Captain marvel Infographic twilight comics ratings Crackle PaleyFest mission: impossible USA Network Funimation laika science fiction quibi Rocketman cops Crunchyroll remakes war Disney+ Disney Plus Pirates stop motion sag awards crime drama hist Pixar vampires History Music Hear Us Out New York Comic Con venice zombies politics Turner Classic Movies romantic comedy TBS Mary poppins Family video a nightmare on elm street independent robots Disney Plus medical drama Holidays Countdown boxoffice critics natural history DGA VOD Horror sequel spanish language game show The CW 4/20 Holiday social media BAFTA Rocky Oscars justice league werewolf Awards Tour Shondaland romance Tarantino YouTube Certified Fresh CBS All Access revenge south america psychological thriller A24 fast and furious italian LGBTQ El Rey First Look CNN Action unscripted Box Office Sundance name the review Sundance Now Star Wars cartoon Spectrum Originals Chernobyl scary movies 21st Century Fox kids 24 frames Peacock Film Festival doctor who historical drama SXSW Heroines GoT Lucasfilm reboot comedies Cartoon Network Ellie Kemper Black Mirror Pet Sematary GLAAD best Hallmark football Superheroes Animation rotten movies we love video on demand The Academy Ghostbusters Amazon Studios Marvel Western children's TV rotten Amazon hispanic witnail Winners The Arrangement travel LGBT Mudbound news Calendar Podcast Mary Tyler Moore Country Super Bowl Apple TV Land Mystery Logo Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TLC The Witch DC Universe Britbox emmy awards spinoff Pride Month BET FX on Hulu NYCC Quiz Musicals canceled Anna Paquin Starz BBC Character Guide composers Dark Horse Comics slashers Masterpiece reviews Premiere Dates Television Academy Columbia Pictures festivals Acorn TV Sci-Fi Best and Worst richard e. Grant Nickelodeon criterion parents Amazon Prime Video Winter TV The Walking Dead movie spanish space period drama crossover 2019 Polls and Games Creative Arts Emmys dc Marvel Television singing competition AMC Women's History Month American Society of Cinematographers dceu golden globes Netflix Hulu Spring TV blaxploitation MTV 72 Emmy Awards Paramount Network Classic Film zombie sports Toys Superheroe screen actors guild Food Network teaser CBS Vudu TV renewals Awards based on movie diversity Disney Channel RT21 mutant Disney HBO Go Paramount Warner Bros. television book franchise Interview ESPN cancelled Apple TV Plus green book TCA Winter 2020 Amazon Prime worst movies Brie Larson foreign halloween tv docudrama Spike Fox News Showtime Fantasy Tubi Fall TV BET Awards Nat Geo TruTV Stephen King superhero Marvel Studios talk show miniseries 71st Emmy Awards award winner free movies Teen Emmys scorecard The Purge 2015 Apple TV+ satire Christmas 20th Century Fox streaming directors Photos Reality Adult Swim zero dark thirty Film child's play YouTube Red Endgame dragons Freeform Watching Series Travel Channel Tomatazos archives jamie lee curtis 007 serial killer Comics on TV DirecTV Comic Book transformers cancelled TV series dogs Comedy films TCA 2017 french spain TCA Awards Black History Month Biopics tv talk Lifetime Christmas movies OWN Set visit Extras blockbuster PlayStation CW Seed TIFF National Geographic Tumblr Universal biography IFC Sneak Peek Fox Searchlight breaking bad strong female leads ITV crime thriller harry potter Television Critics Association Trailer TNT A&E all-time FXX Binge Guide canceled TV shows VICE versus hollywood cancelled television IFC Films technology Trivia animated Netflix Christmas movies DC streaming service Baby Yoda dark Comedy Central theme song asian-american