UK Critics Consensus: The Day The Earth Stood Still, Still Stinks

Plus, Inkheart Is Fantastic Fantasy

by | December 12, 2008 | Comments

With Christmas looming large, and no Potter on the schedule, we have two fantasy flicks in the UK cinemas jostling for your hard-earned galleons. We have sci-fi remake The Day The Earth Stood Still starring Keanu Reeves and Jennifer Connelly, and fantasy literary adaptation Inkheart, starring Paul Bettany and Brendan Fraser. But are either worth parting with your Christmas cash to see? This is what the British critics had to say…

The original Day The Earth Stood Still from 1951 is a bona-fide sci-fi classic, and tells the story of extra-terrestrial visitor Klaatu, who comes to Earth with a message of goodwill, accompanied by Gort, a large laser-sporting robot. When a film of this stature gets lined up for a remake, you have to ask yourself…why? Why don’t studios remake films that weren’t very good the first time round, instead of trying to repackage a film, so of its time, that will only be compared unfavourably to the original?

With the UK critics largely dismissing the film, for its lazy CGI, uninspiring performances and shoe-horned eco-warning message, they are all also asking… Why bother? Tim Robey of the Independent summed up the general consensus by saying “the cinematography is dismal, and the cocktail of lazy CGI and po-faced, sub-Al-Gore environment lecture leaves you light-headed with tedium.” The Day The Earth Stood Still is currently languishing at 24% on the Tomatometer. Klaatu Barada Rotten.

Inkheart is closer in tone to the Potter-esque fantasy that is missing from our winter schedule this year. Based on a hugely popular German childrens’ novel by Cornelia Funke, Inkheart stars Brendan Fraser as Mo, a man who discovers he has the power to bring literary characters to life by reading books aloud, whose daughter Meggie, knows nothing of her father’s bizarre and powerful talent.

Ably supported by some of the UK’s finest acting talents including Paul Bettany, Jim Broadbent, Andy Serkis and Helen Mirren, the critics gave Inkheart their blessing for its cheerful nature, praising the actors for their dependable turns with Daniel Etherington of Channel 4 films calling it “Solid fantasy fare, nicely performed and handsomely made.” With the US critics response not yet counted, the film stands at a healthy 73% on the Tomatometer. Check back on the 23rd of January in the new year to see what the US critics thought of Inkheart.

Quote Of The Week

“Not only is it 20th Century Fox’s first ‘carbon neutral’ production but its Earth-destroying special effects have less impact than a fart in a thunderstorm.”

The Day The Earth Stood Still. Larushka Ivan-Zadeh.

Tag Cloud

documentaries Broadway anthology Holidays Election all-time Film Martial Arts Women's History Month vs. TV screen actors guild films mockumentary hollywood series Avengers Polls and Games sag awards women docudrama strong female leads docuseries jurassic park Best and Worst know your critic APB Wes Anderson Premiere Dates Pet Sematary Pride Month chucky pirates of the caribbean justice league SundanceTV finale ViacomCBS TCA Winter 2020 comic book movie OWN revenge Hallmark Christmas movies boxing Lifetime Christmas movies 21st Century Fox VICE Epix 2018 National Geographic Columbia Pictures See It Skip It NYCC Black History Month spinoff debate First Look Trivia Turner TCA 2017 green book Ellie Kemper emmy awards christmas movies NBA political drama 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Discovery Channel Character Guide Amazon Studios international Sci-Fi parents dogs nfl award winner what to watch Thanksgiving The Walt Disney Company Cannes Infographic Red Carpet 1990s halloween biopic New York Comic Con aliens CW Seed ABC Family Anna Paquin fast and furious Disney+ Disney Plus AMC Plus BBC Stephen King Western The CW discovery ratings HBO Go Animation deadpool MCU sitcom Fantasy Apple TV+ psycho romance legend YouTube breaking bad versus Spring TV Writers Guild of America book adaptation video on demand PlayStation HBO FOX ITV Rock hidden camera book Pop Mudbound crime thriller target MSNBC Fox News X-Men Comic Book cars Calendar Captain marvel prank Country comic 72 Emmy Awards rotten classics fresh cancelled TV shows stoner latino politics halloween tv based on movie new zealand dc unscripted robots Musical Grammys japanese TLC Peacock joker RT History nature binge Adult Swim LGBT Sony Pictures 99% new york theme song die hard IFC canceled laika transformers name the review Opinion FX Brie Larson BET Heroines blockbusters Marathons E! The Arrangement Hulu The Academy WarnerMedia space dreamworks Box Office DirecTV nbcuniversal criterion talk show Mary poppins TBS movie Comedy Central Superheroes Tarantino zero dark thirty period drama ID harry potter Mystery Fox Searchlight Nominations slashers YouTube Premium romantic comedy asian-american TruTV Television Academy BBC America universal monsters kong a nightmare on elm street dramedy 93rd Oscars spanish documentary LGBTQ reviews Comic-Con@Home 2021 animated TIFF A24 true crime thriller italian comedies worst Food Network video movies scene in color police drama Shudder FX on Hulu genre cinemax Showtime Amazon historical drama Lionsgate 007 remakes IMDb TV Awards Tour mission: impossible royal family dragons high school YouTube Red wonder woman Cartoon Network archives Awards television hist doctor who Holiday toy story Sneak Peek Image Comics Reality Competition Set visit jamie lee curtis posters adventure Music Crunchyroll Mary Poppins Returns cancelled TV series monster movies USA Network kaiju 90s casting 24 frames President Drama Tomatazos singing competition Shondaland Video Games Summer Walt Disney Pictures The Witch cops TV renewals BAFTA SDCC CMT young adult Superheroe El Rey Chernobyl psychological thriller Podcast IFC Films GIFs adenture VH1 feel good 4/20 BET Awards slasher olympics football Tokyo Olympics WGN Lifetime RT21 ghosts independent science fiction festival AMC Dark Horse Comics cats james bond Sundance TV new star wars movies boxoffice rt labs critics edition American Society of Cinematographers VOD franchise comics Apple TV Plus indiana jones 20th Century Fox Vudu Photos Quiz composers dexter Travel Channel Cosplay dceu spain black comedy Sundance Now DC Universe critic resources Rom-Com Acorn TV Comedy festivals Legendary Classic Film Television Critics Association king arthur Alien game of thrones Disney Channel Mindy Kaling Baby Yoda Bravo south america TCM scorecard Exclusive Video scary Interview Black Mirror miniseries Rocky venice mutant cancelled television Schedule Valentine's Day Sundance superhero E3 Winners spanish language Emmy Nominations technology Funimation war TV movies cooking medical drama golden globe awards worst movies Creative Arts Emmys CBS indie supernatural The Walking Dead Marvel Studios crime A&E streaming TV One toronto cartoon Teen comiccon History Amazon Prime obituary Academy Awards vampires cancelled rom-coms Ghostbusters japan First Reviews dark werewolf Warner Bros. facebook TCA Arrowverse foreign Reality suspense free movies richard e. Grant directors Freeform hispanic spy thriller OneApp Marvel Television Paramount Plus DC streaming service Christmas Instagram Live superman screenings canceled TV shows Lucasfilm sequel telelvision NBC witnail Disney streaming service Trailer Paramount king kong Song of Ice and Fire australia children's TV Paramount Network Mary Tyler Moore quibi Ovation Neflix Countdown 2017 BBC One Action Spike streaming movies Musicals Emmys gangster 71st Emmy Awards rt archives live action Winter TV TCA Awards marvel comics Watching Series 2021 sequels action-comedy ESPN GoT Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt travel sports Pixar Toys basketball batman tv talk Masterpiece zombie Year in Review San Diego Comic-Con rt labs 2019 spider-verse Turner Classic Movies biography disaster kids Pirates adaptation Hallmark 45 MTV satire child's play ABC Trophy Talk popular crossover Certified Fresh SXSW blockbuster godzilla game show Film Festival Extras TNT 2020 Syfy Disney Plus Tumblr trailers natural history spider-man Rocketman rotten movies we love PBS Horror stand-up comedy Kids & Family Nickelodeon mcc black golden globes teaser saw Starz CNN Star Wars The Purge cults reboot Hear Us Out Comics on TV stop motion critics Star Trek Fall TV TV Land Nat Geo HBO Max Disney comic book movies marvel cinematic universe Family Amazon Prime Video Spectrum Originals razzies twilight GLAAD Tubi FXX concert ABC Signature 2016 PaleyFest serial killer scary movies Netflix Universal hispanic heritage month best french Britbox YA aapi Endgame Chilling Adventures of Sabrina social media Super Bowl Esquire diversity blaxploitation 73rd Emmy Awards comic books sopranos anime Oscars DGA Apple Binge Guide news Marvel CBS All Access zombies Universal Pictures art house elevated horror renewed TV shows Pacific Islander Netflix Christmas movies Pop TV mob crime drama live event Elton John heist movie 2015 DC Comics USA lord of the rings Biopics Logo Crackle