UK Critics Consensus: The Day The Earth Stood Still, Still Stinks

Plus, Inkheart Is Fantastic Fantasy

by | December 12, 2008 | Comments

With Christmas looming large, and no Potter on the schedule, we have two fantasy flicks in the UK cinemas jostling for your hard-earned galleons. We have sci-fi remake The Day The Earth Stood Still starring Keanu Reeves and Jennifer Connelly, and fantasy literary adaptation Inkheart, starring Paul Bettany and Brendan Fraser. But are either worth parting with your Christmas cash to see? This is what the British critics had to say…

The original Day The Earth Stood Still from 1951 is a bona-fide sci-fi classic, and tells the story of extra-terrestrial visitor Klaatu, who comes to Earth with a message of goodwill, accompanied by Gort, a large laser-sporting robot. When a film of this stature gets lined up for a remake, you have to ask yourself…why? Why don’t studios remake films that weren’t very good the first time round, instead of trying to repackage a film, so of its time, that will only be compared unfavourably to the original?

With the UK critics largely dismissing the film, for its lazy CGI, uninspiring performances and shoe-horned eco-warning message, they are all also asking… Why bother? Tim Robey of the Independent summed up the general consensus by saying “the cinematography is dismal, and the cocktail of lazy CGI and po-faced, sub-Al-Gore environment lecture leaves you light-headed with tedium.” The Day The Earth Stood Still is currently languishing at 24% on the Tomatometer. Klaatu Barada Rotten.

Inkheart is closer in tone to the Potter-esque fantasy that is missing from our winter schedule this year. Based on a hugely popular German childrens’ novel by Cornelia Funke, Inkheart stars Brendan Fraser as Mo, a man who discovers he has the power to bring literary characters to life by reading books aloud, whose daughter Meggie, knows nothing of her father’s bizarre and powerful talent.

Ably supported by some of the UK’s finest acting talents including Paul Bettany, Jim Broadbent, Andy Serkis and Helen Mirren, the critics gave Inkheart their blessing for its cheerful nature, praising the actors for their dependable turns with Daniel Etherington of Channel 4 films calling it “Solid fantasy fare, nicely performed and handsomely made.” With the US critics response not yet counted, the film stands at a healthy 73% on the Tomatometer. Check back on the 23rd of January in the new year to see what the US critics thought of Inkheart.

Quote Of The Week

“Not only is it 20th Century Fox’s first ‘carbon neutral’ production but its Earth-destroying special effects have less impact than a fart in a thunderstorm.”

The Day The Earth Stood Still. Larushka Ivan-Zadeh.

Tag Cloud

Valentine's Day women Ovation book adaptation know your critic Rom-Com The CW Oscars Peacock anthology rotten spy thriller 71st Emmy Awards adaptation HBO Max The Purge FOX Stephen King Chernobyl crime drama Pixar obi wan dexter Acorn TV Star Wars comic book movie Neflix strong female leads 45 spinoff FX on Hulu South by Southwest Film Festival Calendar Summer black Disney Channel elevated horror Classic Film stop motion Fantasy Apple vs. 2016 Image Comics Food Network ABC Signature Marvel Studios CBS high school 24 frames Amazon Star Trek biopic Rock Adult Swim canceled italian 2015 YouTube saw Country archives AMC Plus TBS king arthur TV Land political drama discovery 72 Emmy Awards Pet Sematary wonder woman ESPN APB sequels dark comedies Amazon Prime 73rd Emmy Awards japanese dc Hallmark LGBTQ GLAAD new york french Writers Guild of America popular YouTube Premium Kids & Family Photos scary Brie Larson movie ABC Interview Reality First Reviews WarnerMedia screenings revenge Nat Geo marvel comics Martial Arts Exclusive Video reboot Watching Series witnail MTV new star wars movies SundanceTV Infographic twilight The Walking Dead quibi doctor who technology feel good television Britbox FX game show kong Video Games marvel cinematic universe psycho obituary parents mob independent TV true crime video hispanic heritage month harry potter summer TV docudrama HBO Go ID worst movies disaster blockbuster Hear Us Out streaming Certified Fresh docuseries sopranos TNT Best and Worst VH1 Comics on TV OWN Spring TV Character Guide debate Thanksgiving ITV Best Actress CBS All Access Paramount Plus teaser boxing Superheroe cars RT21 National Geographic theme song Western Paramount Pictures Musicals mcc New York Comic Con Amazon Studios Universal Anna Paquin rt labs Ghostbusters Disney Plus news slasher TCM El Rey Turner Classic Movies Awards E! USA Schedule tv talk cancelled TV series Christmas cats MGM screen actors guild chucky worst canceled TV shows Cannes reviews Television Academy children's TV TCA rt labs critics edition thriller BBC One Countdown hist RT History justice league Sundance Freeform trailers Sony Pictures OneApp telelvision olympics Awards Tour cancelled TV shows emmy awards james bond trophy dceu classics SXSW 2022 CMT concert razzies Lionsgate Holiday indie adventure 94th Oscars Set visit diversity 2021 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina universal monsters HBO Best Actor Binge Guide lord of the rings rt archives Sneak Peek Tumblr E3 The Walt Disney Company Elton John christmas movies legend Universal Pictures Wes Anderson romantic comedy festival singing competition Fox News cancelled television TruTV Trophy Talk Heroines SXSW what to watch Instagram Live Family IFC Films Nominations asian-american Fargo war Animation X-Men zero dark thirty Grammys king kong based on movie comiccon renewed TV shows royal family police drama best Election Shudder PaleyFest social media Disney posters BET 20th Century Fox adenture genre Trivia Arrowverse ratings festivals australia versus franchise TLC Ellie Kemper DirecTV 007 Pride Month Song of Ice and Fire BBC Pirates Sci-Fi directors dragons A24 HFPA SDCC Tubi suspense Spectrum Originals Black Mirror streamig ghosts gangster Avengers slashers indiana jones TV renewals Black History Month Mindy Kaling new zealand monster movies mission: impossible Podcast richard e. Grant zombie YA documentaries satire summer TV preview DC Comics politics cooking TV One nature Hulu biography superhero VOD Shondaland Marathons Toys jurassic park NYCC travel 2017 medical drama crime name the review criterion breaking bad rom-coms Spike boxoffice Cosplay halloween tv Comedy action-comedy spider-man Tags: Comedy Netflix Christmas movies talk show The Arrangement 2019 Lucasfilm japan Film Mystery Winners football free movies 90s superman dreamworks PBS sports President PlayStation Crunchyroll American Society of Cinematographers TCA Winter 2020 crime thriller cancelled NBA Logo A&E child's play Pop basketball science fiction CW Seed batman Holidays mockumentary binge Extras nbcuniversal heist movie venice Mary Poppins Returns Dark Horse Comics target Travel Channel prank sitcom stoner miniseries leaderboard Epix DC Universe unscripted nfl werewolf Film Festival south america Netflix The Academy kids Marvel Polls and Games Sundance TV Mudbound golden globe awards facebook BBC America documentary 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards aapi hispanic series spider-verse DC streaming service award winner godzilla blockbusters Syfy TV movies DGA game of thrones Rocketman fast and furious 21st Century Fox History Box Office Academy Awards TCA Awards Reality Competition toy story psychological thriller art house Apple TV Plus Creative Arts Emmys green book Discovery Channel mutant Comic Book composers zombies Opinion Best Director Teen The Witch black comedy cults period drama die hard Mary Tyler Moore Drama Focus Features Warner Bros. kaiju Disney+ Disney Plus IFC laika Fox Searchlight FXX scene in color aliens video on demand Fall TV Showtime joker rotten movies we love transformers summer preview cinemax Captain marvel Emmy Nominations sequel Pop TV space sag awards romance Quiz Best Picture Legendary comics live event Tokyo Olympics anime toronto spanish halloween MCU pirates of the caribbean Red Carpet movies See It Skip It all-time deadpool Amazon Prime Video YouTube Red jamie lee curtis 99% critic resources Turner ViacomCBS a nightmare on elm street Sundance Now LGBT 2018 NBC critics serial killer Winter TV GoT 2020 USA Network Paramount Lifetime Music Endgame international vampires fresh Oscar Pacific Islander WGN Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Mary poppins Super Bowl Superheroes golden globes spanish language Vudu Broadway Hollywood Foreign Press Association comic VICE live action Biopics Masterpiece dogs book Prime Video robots ABC Family streaming movies San Diego Comic-Con foreign TCA 2017 Crackle MSNBC cops Horror Bravo AMC Tarantino supernatural Emmys blaxploitation BET Awards Action latino films Musical comic book movies Premiere Dates scorecard Trailer crossover casting dramedy spain 79th Golden Globes Awards broadcast Apple TV+ Nickelodeon Women's History Month GIFs Comic-Con@Home 2021 Television Critics Association historical drama animated BAFTA Disney streaming service First Look hollywood 4/20 Year in Review finale natural history Starz TIFF young adult Baby Yoda comic books remakes cartoon Paramount Network Rocky scary movies hidden camera interviews 1990s IMDb TV Tomatazos Walt Disney Pictures Alien Marvel Television CNN Columbia Pictures Esquire stand-up comedy Cartoon Network Comedy Central Hallmark Christmas movies 93rd Oscars Lifetime Christmas movies Funimation