UK Critics Consensus: Is Burn After Reading A Coens Classic? Does Eagle Eye Have Enough Action, Man?

Plus, Does The Rocker Rock On Or Roll Off?

by | October 17, 2008 | Comments

In this week’s roster of UK cinema releases we have the latest addition to the Coen canon in the CIA comedy caper, Burn After Reading. Shia LeBeouf stakes a further claim to the Hollywood A-list in the high concept cyber-thriller Eagle Eye, and a washed up ’80s rockstar wannabe gets another stab at fame with his nephew’s band in The Rocker. But what did the UK critics have to say?

Last year, the Coen brothers picked up the Academy Award for Best Picture for their neo-western thriller No Country For Old Men, and at 94% on the Tomatometer, this was long-deserved acclaim for Joel and Ethan Coen, and set their already high standards to an even higher benchmark. It’s an oft-quoted theory that the Coens make two types of films; Screwball caper comedies a la Raising Arizona and The Big Lebowski or the ‘serious,’ tougher and more gritty efforts like Fargo and Miller’s Crossing. With No Country they made, arguably, their toughest and grittiest film yet, with great success, so it makes sense that with their follow up, instead of trying to outmuscle their modern masterpiece, they’ve stepped into screwball mode for Burn After Reading. To many this may have seemed a risk, with their last comedic outing, Ealing comedy remake, The Ladykillers taking a bit of a critical kicking at 55% on the Tomatometer, but the Coens’ gamble seems to have paid off with Burn After Reading, as it currently stands at a respectable 78% on the Tomatometer. Despite a few calls from the critics over the lightweight throwaway feel of the film due to its slender running time of 96 minutes, most have been raving about the daffy turns from all the actors involved, with many praising Brad Pitt’s brainless portrayal of fitness instructor Chad Feldheimer as comedy gold. With a killer one/two combo of their last two movies, fans all over will be waiting with baited breath for their next cinematic outing, A Serious Man, due for release next year.

Shia LeBeouf’s rise to the top of the pile in Hollywood surely hasn’t been hindered after being taken under the wing of Steven Spielberg. With a starring role in Spielberg’s Dreamworks Studio teen-thriller Disturbia, followed by a lead role in the Spielberg-produced, robots in disguise, action adventure hit Transformers and finally being cast as Indiana Jones Jr, Mutt Williams, in Indiana Jones and The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull, LeBeouf has become an instantly recognised presence on the big screen. In Eagle Eye,(produced by Spielberg unsurprisingly) he is back with Disturbia director DJ Caruso, and is out to carry on his winning streak in this cyber thriller, as Jerry Shaw, a slacker who gets embroiled in a terrorist plot, out to clear his name with help from the FBI. Unfortunately, the critics didn’t allow themselves to get carried away with the high octane, low brainer action, and many dismiss the film for its preposterous and implausible plotting, accusing it of borrowing too heavily from many other superior, and classic, films. The critics who liked it enjoyed the snappy and thrilling pace of the brainless entertainment on offer, but not enough to escape the ignominy of a measly 28% on the Tomatometer as it currently stands.

Rainn Wilson is probably not a name too well known to UK audiences, but he has a face that makes you think “Hmm, I recognise him from somewhere” thanks to small roles in Juno, and My Super Ex-Girlfriend, as well as a regular role in the American remake of The Office, and a recurring one in the critically-acclaimed Six-Feet Under. In The Rocker, Wilson takes centre stage as ex-rocker Robert ‘Fish’ Fishman, a drummer with fictitious ’80s rock band Vesuvius, who was given the boot moments before the band hit the big time, and who has been coming to terms with his near brush with superstardom ever since. He gets his second chance to reclaim his rock-god throne, when he joins his teenage nephews, high school rock band A.D.D., whilst showing his young band mates the merits of a rock and roll lifestyle in the process. The Rocker seems to have fared better with the UK critics than it did with the US critics, who, in the main had panned the film for its formulaic and unoriginal style, unfunny and forgettable script and shameless similarities to the vastly superior School Of Rock. UK critics weren’t so harsh, and many enjoyed the brisk humour, snappy one liners and good natured feeling to the whole proceedings, even if some of the slapstick doesn’t quite get the laughs it hopes for. Currently at 39% on the Tomatometer, The Rocker isn’t quite that rocking.

Also worth checking out this week…

Young@Heart – Full of endearing characters, this doc about a choir of “seniors behaving badly” is uplifting and delightful. 88% on the Tomatometer.

La Zona – A slick and smart Mexican thriller of middle-class panic and vigilantism, that is lean, mean and often shocking. 78% on the Tomatometer.

Quote Of The Week

“A worse film might be dismissed as sobsploitation.”

Young@Heart. Nigel Andrews, Financial Times.

Tag Cloud

Marvel cults Crackle USA Ovation ratings Winners Thanksgiving IFC Grammys GIFs 20th Century Fox justice league VH1 composers Rock Mary Tyler Moore political drama golden globes E3 Interview Dark Horse Comics RT History MTV Sneak Peek Trailer Universal SXSW Walt Disney Pictures Ellie Kemper crime drama cinemax Oscars DC streaming service Watching Series Extras aliens Disney Channel Reality Competition finale OWN Comedy GLAAD Shudder The Arrangement IFC Films Bravo VICE MSNBC 21st Century Fox BBC America TBS FOX Shondaland anime Adult Swim Song of Ice and Fire streaming DC Universe Esquire TV social media History Star Wars sitcom Western Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt BBC ABC robots Masterpiece American Society of Cinematographers E! dramedy Election PBS Certified Fresh technology TV Land 2016 Comedy Central biography 007 zombie Kids & Family science fiction Character Guide transformers NYCC 24 frames TCA Countdown CW Seed comiccon Musicals National Geographic crime GoT USA Network singing competition harry potter Syfy zombies Sony Pictures Country Lifetime Photos period drama Reality CBS Rom-Com CMT El Rey psycho Fox News Starz ABC Family Sci-Fi Rocky cats TIFF Biopics CBS All Access Creative Arts Emmys AMC Epix DirecTV PaleyFest Ghostbusters Animation Music BET Apple Martial Arts Polls and Games Teen cops A&E Action YouTube Premium Set visit President The CW See It Skip It Musical medical drama Infographic Hulu Lionsgate travel YouTube Red spy thriller thriller San Diego Comic-Con NBC Awards what to watch Writers Guild of America ESPN Warner Bros. Pop TCA 2017 Spike TCM vampires romance Winter TV police drama crossover Britbox Spring TV TLC crime thriller Comic Book 2015 Calendar docudrama dceu Holidays 2017 Netflix ITV Lucasfilm Super Bowl Showtime jamie lee curtis SundanceTV Sundance Paramount SDCC Opinion Sundance Now FX TNT sports Nickelodeon LGBTQ X-Men CNN Cartoon Network doctor who Podcast war Video Games discovery Red Carpet FXX historical drama Premiere Dates Drama Schedule Toys Nominations based on movie talk show binge festivals hist Superheroes Freeform Christmas Year in Review WGN Star Trek Logo Amazon Acorn TV Tumblr Pirates adventure Superheroe Mystery serial killer Best and Worst Fantasy unscripted Trivia cooking Disney Columbia Pictures 45 blaxploitation First Look Nat Geo YA HBO politics Emmys Paramount Network TruTV mutant Food Network Marathons Box Office boxoffice Fall TV Pixar supernatural Valentine's Day APB dc DC Comics Cosplay Horror Summer diversity Tomatazos Mindy Kaling