Total Recall

Total Recall: Diane Keaton's Best Movies

We count down the best-reviewed work of the Big Wedding star.

by | April 25, 2013 | Comments

Diane Keaton

If you’re the type of film fan who goes in for all-star romantic comedy extravaganzas, this weekend’s The Big Wedding could be the cinematic event of the season — a good old-fashioned, light-hearted look at all the horseplay, tomfoolery, and shenanigans that lead up to one bride and groom’s betrothal, with the added bonus of the familiar faces of Robert De Niro, Robin Williams, Susan Sarandon, and Diane Keaton. Cinematic legends, all of them, but this week we’re focusing on Keaton’s contributions, and when you take a look at the amazing array of films she’s appeared in, we think you’ll understand why. Break out your favorite vests, baggy pants, and fedoras — it’s time for Total Recall!


93%

10. Manhattan Murder Mystery

The most recent of the eight films she’s made with Woody Allen, 1993’s Manhattan Murder Mystery, almost didn’t come Keaton’s way; initially, the part of Carol Lipton, an amateur detective whose efforts to solve the mystery of a neighbor’s death draw in her neurotic husband (Allen) and a family friend (Alan Alda), was supposed to go to Allen’s longtime muse Mia Farrow — but when their notorious breakup forced him to find a new leading lady, he reached out to a dependable friend. The result was decidedly one of his more lightweight films, but for quite a few critics, that was part of its affable charm; as Owen Gleiberman wrote for Entertainment Weekly, “Nobody labors quite like Woody Allen to produce a modest entertainment.”


90%

9. Reds

An epic 194-minute biopic about the tortured affair between radical journalists John Reed (Warren Beatty) and Louise Bryan (Keaton) during the early 20th century, set against the backdrop of the Russian Revolution, Reds wasn’t exactly the most commercially friendly film of 1981 — but thanks to positive word of mouth and a stellar cast that also included Jack Nicholson, Paul Sorvino, Gene Hackman, and M. Emmet Walsh, it ended up grossing more than $50 million during its theatrical run, on the way to picking up three Academy Awards (against a dozen nominations). Calling it “Political drama and sweeping romance in one,” Carol Cling of the Las Vegas Review-Journal marveled, “Only Warren Beatty would, or could, do it.”


97%

8. Play It Again, Sam

Woody Allen didn’t direct the 1972 film adaptation of his Broadway hit Play It Again, Sam, but he did star in it and write the screenplay — and he did make sure to bring over Keaton, his leading lady from the stage. While the whole thing still didn’t amount to much more than an affable homage to Casablanca, there’s no denying the strength of that impeccable source material, or the skill and affection with which Sam pays tribute to an assortment of scenes, lines, and characters that every film buff knows by heart. “Maybe the movie has too much coherence, and the plot is too predictable; that’s a weakness of films based on well-made Broadway plays,” admitted Roger Ebert. “Still, that’s hardly a serious complaint about something as funny as Play It Again, Sam.”


95%

7. Manhattan

By the end of the 1970s, Keaton had starred in six Woody Allen films — with the fifth, Annie Hall, sending her home with an Academy Award for Best Actress. She didn’t repeat the feat with their sixth collaboration, 1979’s Manhattan, but it’s safe to say audiences and critics responded to the end result; Allen’s story of a neurotic TV writer character caught in a(n admittedly unlikely-seeming) love triangle between a teenager (Mariel Hemingway) and an intellectual (Keaton) is regarded as one of the high points of his distinguished career. As Vincent Canby wrote for the New York Times when Manhattan was released, “Mr. Allen’s progress as one of our major filmmakers is proceeding so rapidly that we who watch him have to pause occasionally to catch our breath.”


97%

6. Annie Hall

Keaton’s career was already well on its way in 1977, but her turn as the title character in Woody Allen’s Annie Hall rocketed her into Hollywood’s upper echelon, earning her a Best Actress Oscar and heaps of critical accolades for a performance of a character who’d form the (often misunderstood) template for countless quirky-but-lovable leading ladies in subsequent rom-coms. While Keaton’s affinity for the character makes sense, given that Allen constructed it based on what she’s described as an “idealized version” of herself, that doesn’t detract from the sheer winsomeness in the film; as Vincent Canby observed for the New York Times, “There will be discussion about what points in the film coincide with the lives of its two stars, but this, I think, is to detract from and trivialize the achievement of the film, which, at last, puts Woody in the league with the best directors we have.”

97%

5. The Godfather, Part II

In the closing moments of The Godfather, trouble loomed for the marriage of Michael Corleone (Al Pacino) and his wife Kay (Keaton), as Kay watched Michael assume the mantle of his father’s responsibility for their family’s criminal empire in spite of his promise to make their business legal. But that was just foreshadowing for the full-on rupture between the young couple in The Godfather Part II, which finds Kay increasingly hostile toward her husband’s lifestyle — especially after a botched assassination attempt leaves their bedroom riddled with bullet holes. The movie’s silent final moments drive home the price of life as a Corleone, adding an intimate denoument to a sequel that often reaches for — and achieves — epic status. “This film has an even broader scope than the original,” mused Jeffrey M. Anderson for Combustible Celluloid, “but does not fail in its depiction of small, intimate moments and surprising emotional reveals.”


100%

4. Lovers and Other Strangers

After kicking off her stage career with a Tony-nominated performance in Woody Allen’s stage version of Play It Again, Sam, Keaton made a graceful transition to film with a supporting role in Cy Howard’s ensemble dramedy Lovers and Other Strangers, a triple Oscar nominee that united an enormously talented corps of actors (including Richard Castellano, Cloris Leachman, Bea Arthur, and Bonnie Bedelia) to portray the romantic trials and tribulations endured by the friends of one couple (played by Bedelia and Michael Brandon) during the days leading up to their wedding. “This might have been an opening for a good deal of cynicism, but the movie is optimistic at heart,” observed Roger Ebert. “Not optimistic that love can survive unchanged throughout a lifetime, but that love and lovers can occasionally reach an accommodation that is not positively painful.”


100%

3. Love and Death

Between Sleeper and Annie Hall, Keaton and Woody Allen starred in Love and Death, a satire on Russian literature that used the story of a reluctant war hero (Allen) and his equally reluctant bride (Keaton) to offer a cockeyed, tightly scripted take on Tolstoy, Dostoyevsky, and Eisenstein, melding satirical philosophical debates with visual homages only a film buff could truly love — and became one of the more unlikely hits of the 1970s in the process. As Vincent Canby argued for the New York Times, “Besides being one of Woody’s most consistently witty films, Love and Death marks a couple of other advances for Mr. Allen as a film maker and for Miss Keaton as a wickedly funny comedienne.”


100%

2. Sleeper

After making a big splash in 1972 with The Godfather and Play It Again, Sam, Keaton continued her hot streak the following year with Sleeper, a reunion with Sam writer/director Woody Allen that swapped out that film’s Humphrey Bogart pastiche for a futuristic comedy about a health food store owner (Allen) who’s cryogenically frozen after dying during a gall bladder operation, thawed out 200 years later, and becomes an unlikely leader in a resistance movement — while falling in love with the woman who briefly thought he was a robot (Keaton). Mused Filmcritic’s Christopher Null, “Pound for pound and minute for minute, Sleeper may just have more laughs in it than any other Woody Allen movie.”


98%

1. The Godfather

While it wasn’t her first film role, Keaton’s appearance as the future Kay Corleone in Francis Ford Coppola’s The Godfather is generally regarded as her breakout performance — and for good reason, because while it isn’t one of the more substantial parts in her career, Keaton’s work provides a crucial component of the trilogy-to-be’s sprawling, multi-generational saga. It also doesn’t hurt that The Godfather enjoyed blockbuster success, briefly earning the distinction of being the top-grossing film of all time, or that it was impeccably cast overall, employing the talents of James Caan, Robert Duvall, Al Pacino, and Marlon Brando (the latter two of which were nominated for and won Academy Awards) to deliver what TIME’s Jay Cocks praised as “that rarity, a mass entertainment that is also great movie art.”


In case you were wondering, here are Keaton’s top 10 movies according RT users’ scores:

1. The Godfather — 97%
2. The Godfather, Part II — 96%
3. Annie Hall — 92%
4. Manhattan — 91%
5. Love and Death — 88%
6. Play It Again, Sam — 86%
7. Manhattan Murder Mystery — 81%
8. Reds — 80%
9. The Godfather, Part III — 79%
10. Sleeper — 79%


Take a look through Keaton’s complete filmography, as well as the rest of our Total Recall archives. And don’t forget to check out the reviews for The Big Wedding.

 

Tag Cloud

Marathons 24 frames CMT Cosplay thriller animated Box Office toy story Endgame Certified Fresh Bravo CBS All Access theme song Esquire Starz dramedy Infographic 2020 natural history Spectrum Originals Mary poppins Spike Rom-Com Hulu spinoff Mary Poppins Returns directors Black History Month Paramount Quiz Freeform Musicals mutant spider-man Showtime Amazon Prime Video The Walking Dead kids FXX talk show Anna Paquin Trophy Talk Family historical drama Pet Sematary Emmy Nominations TBS Paramount Network batman crime thriller Stephen King A&E Teen YouTube Red period drama space rotten movies we love CBS blaxploitation robots zero dark thirty television Pop 2019 National Geographic Awards halloween 007 finale YA cancelled TV shows werewolf HBO science fiction History children's TV TNT FOX Pirates scary movies miniseries TCA screen actors guild Superheroe Acorn TV singing competition technology AMC BET Epix Walt Disney Pictures Fox News Calendar binge universal monsters Disney+ Disney Plus what to watch Reality SXSW cats USA Network TLC Trivia hispanic strong female leads facebook Disney dragons crime Fantasy Mystery dc Star Trek joker BBC sag awards streaming Britbox cults Women's History Month Tomatazos Music canceled richard e. Grant cancelled TV series Vudu revenge Mindy Kaling E! book Hallmark Christmas movies slashers Superheroes RT21 quibi sequel Netflix Opinion Martial Arts serial killer Baby Yoda Lionsgate Columbia Pictures Reality Competition Dark Horse Comics The Arrangement Universal A24 Turner Classic Movies Film See It Skip It name the review witnail GIFs Set visit DGA Photos south america Nat Geo based on movie Netflix Christmas movies The Purge dogs LGBT Emmys reboot Discovery Channel Comics on TV war aliens TCA 2017 American Society of Cinematographers anime romantic comedy Toys Captain marvel composers USA spy thriller zombie VICE boxoffice cancelled television DC Universe Star Wars GLAAD Best and Worst Amazon Studios MCU SDCC Apple justice league spanish language adaptation game show Marvel Studios Disney streaming service Arrowverse documentary Musical 2017 franchise Crackle President Western Spring TV Trailer 2018 cartoon psycho medical drama mockumentary Academy Awards blockbuster ABC transformers ESPN Lifetime romance movie Black Mirror TV Holiday video docudrama Interview Character Guide FX Masterpiece supernatural Nominations TV renewals Amazon cops VH1 jamie lee curtis Awards Tour FX on Hulu Crunchyroll award winner Nickelodeon TruTV GoT 2015 Year in Review E3 Comedy Central unscripted harry potter Tumblr Horror Amazon Prime Sci-Fi tv talk Summer 20th Century Fox Apple TV Plus Sundance PaleyFest christmas movies Pixar Ellie Kemper Fall TV series vampires Extras dceu APB ITV Animation Television Academy Comic Book First Reviews canceled TV shows MTV TV Land 45 Cannes foreign Turner TIFF 21st Century Fox Shondaland Winter TV ABC Family NBC Funimation Chilling Adventures of Sabrina independent Peacock anthology Food Network politics First Look Video Games The Witch WGN Adult Swim hist crime drama OneApp DirecTV Tarantino Creative Arts Emmys TCM Kids & Family X-Men Chernobyl Polls and Games DC streaming service 71st Emmy Awards Elton John Marvel Television biography Rocky HBO Max Red Carpet Pride Month Shudder Lifetime Christmas movies screenings stand-up comedy sitcom Ovation reviews DC Comics Winners The CW WarnerMedia Pop TV teaser YouTube Premium MSNBC Disney Plus New York Comic Con Holidays casting Rock doctor who Drama NYCC Sneak Peek Logo Sony Pictures RT History comic psychological thriller diversity Cartoon Network YouTube police drama Lucasfilm crossover cooking Thanksgiving OWN Apple TV+ Classic Film Hallmark TCA Winter 2020 Country discovery cancelled true crime CW Seed Tubi elevated horror festivals disaster green book 2016 Sundance TV IFC Ghostbusters Action CNN Mudbound SundanceTV Rocketman comics Heroines latino comiccon breaking bad cinemax ratings renewed TV shows Writers Guild of America Sundance Now Schedule travel Disney Channel Biopics IFC Films BBC America versus movies Film Festival Watching Series Comedy Brie Larson game of thrones Mary Tyler Moore Grammys political drama Song of Ice and Fire Valentine's Day Countdown social media Syfy Premiere Dates ghosts Oscars LGBTQ Travel Channel sports Warner Bros. indie zombies PBS Election nature adventure cars Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt free movies Christmas spain Binge Guide Avengers Podcast El Rey San Diego Comic-Con Marvel golden globes Super Bowl