Critics Consensus

Tomb Raider Is an Aggressively Average Adventure

Plus, Love, Simon is a refreshing romance, 7 Days in Entebbe is hijacked by mediocrity, and we can only imagine the Tomatometer for I Can Only Imagine.

by | March 15, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have a rebooted Lara Croft (Tomb Raider, starring Alicia Vikander, and Dominic West), a coming-of-age romance with a twist (Love, Simon, starring Nick Robinson and Katherine Langford), the fact-based tale of a military raid to rescue hostages taken by terrorists (7 Days in Entebbe, starring Rosamund Pike and Daniel Brühl), and a father-son drama inspired by a hit song (I Can Only Imagine, starring J. Michael Finley and Dennis Quaid). What are the critics saying?

Tomb Raider (2018) 51%

Movies based on video games haven’t exactly had an easy time of it with critics over the years, but as technological advancements continue to blur the line between immersive entertainment we control and/or passively consume, we could be getting closer to the point where a film inspired by a game manages to capture the essence of its source material while still offering an engaging viewing experience. On paper, this weekend’s Tomb Raider reboot looks like it has what it takes: the long-running video game series has spun a globetrotting yarn that’s nothing if not cinematic, and in new franchise lead Alicia Vikander, this Raider stars the sort of Oscar-winning talent that isn’t typically attracted to this type of project. Unfortunately, it doesn’t seem to have added up to the paradigm shift the game-to-film genre has been looking for — critics say Tomb Raider is sadly less than the sum of its parts, with an uninspired story and frenetic direction that undermine this installment’s added realism and talented cast. Filmgoers in the mood for some adventurous derring-do at the cineplex may still wish to give Tomb a try — but unlike the game, it doesn’t appear to have much in the way of replay value.

Love, Simon (2018) 91%

With her 2015 novel Simon vs. the Homo Sapiens Agenda, author Becky Albertalli earned awards and critical acclaim by tracing the time-honored coming-of-age arc with a twist: her book’s protagonist, 16-year-old Simon Spier, is a closeted gay high school student who’s exploring an anonymous online relationship with a young man he’s never met. It isn’t the type of premise that would have gotten much traction at a major studio until recently, but times have changed — and critics say that the film adaptation, retitled Love, Simon, marks a potential turning point for mainstream movies while functioning as a pretty solidly entertaining outing in its own right. Although some reviews have pointed out that director Greg Berlanti‘s TV roots are a little too visible in the film’s overall aesthetic, and others have noted that this may not be the most accurate representation of the gay community or experience, those end up being relatively minor quibbles against an affecting story told from a refreshingly different perspective.

7 Days in Entebbe (2018) 24%

In the summer of 1976, terrorists hijacked an Air France flight in Athens and took the plane to Uganda, where a number of passengers were freed and the rest — largely Jewish — were held in exchange for the release of Palestinian political prisoners. A weeklong standoff ensued, culminating with a daring nighttime raid on Entebbe Airport in Uganda — and if all this sounds familiar, it might be because it’s been the basis for more than one movie over the last 40-plus years. Director José Padilha adds a fourth film to the list with this weekend’s 7 Days in Entebbe, and while he may deserve points for moxie when it comes to taking a whack at previously well-told stories, critics say the end result really doesn’t add all that much to previous dramatizations. Daniel Brühl and Rosamund Pike are certainly a pair of talented leads, and Gregory Burke‘s screenplay adds a few fresh narrative wrinkles, but on the whole, this Entebbe is neither tense nor intelligent enough to justify the return trip.

I Can Only Imagine (2018) 62%

If your musical tastes don’t run toward Christian contemporary, you may never have listened to — or even heard of — the group MercyMe. But their 2001 single “I Can Only Imagine” has proven an impressively long-lasting crossover success, climbing into the top five of the Billboard Adult Contemporary chart months after its initial release — and now it’s the basis for the new faith-based film I Can Only Imagine, which dramatizes the relationship between singer Bart Millard (played by J. Michael Finley) and his father Arthur (Dennis Quaid). If you’ve heard the song — or, to be fair, even looked at the poster — you’re probably aware that there’s a heartstring-tugging story waiting to be told here; given the involvement of Quaid and Cloris Leachman, one might also be willing to surmise that this will end up being a few cuts above the type of stuff mainstream Christian cinema is known for. Alas, we can’t say for sure just yet, because only a handful of reviews have trickled in. While we wait, how about a round of Guess the Tomatometer?

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Keep the Change (2018) , about an aspiring filmmaker whose court-ordered service work leads to an unexpected love connection, is at 100%.
  • Journey's End (2018) , a new adaptation of the classic play about life on the front lines during World War I, is Certified Fresh at 96%.
  • 12 Days (12 Jours) (2018) , a documentary look at French citizens unwillingly placed in psychiatric care, is at 92%.
  • Maineland (2018) , a documentary that observes the lives of Chinese teens after they’ve immigrated to Maine, is at 86%.
  • Ramen Heads (2018) , a documentary about Japanese ramen chefs, is at 80%.
  • Us and Them (2018) , a black British comedy fueled by rage against economic inequality, is at 63%.
  • Flower (2018) , starring Zoey Deutch as a teenager at a potentially disastrous crossroads, is at 58%.
  • Dear Dictator (2018) , starring Michael Caine as a fleeing dictator who takes refuge with his teen American pen pal and her family, is at 18%.

Tag Cloud

San Diego Comic-Con Sci-Fi Best and Worst 2019 Oscars Winter TV APB Emmys AMC Musicals Mindy Kaling 24 frames docudrama CMT 45 ABC Family Calendar Brie Larson Thanksgiving Creative Arts Emmys medical drama Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt First Look President Winners SundanceTV El Rey Sundance Nat Geo Biopics Nominations The CW Podcast See It Skip It boxoffice Apple Freeform romance Masterpiece Set visit television Tumblr cops Song of Ice and Fire National Geographic war hist Syfy dc Action unscripted Columbia Pictures SXSW ITV History Shondaland Music Valentine's Day Comics on TV New York Comic Con American Society of Cinematographers Rock VH1 TIFF Video Games Sony Pictures USA spy thriller vampires Anna Paquin based on movie composers Toys Mystery HBO Sneak Peek Pixar Ghostbusters supernatural TV Land Quiz Disney Channel Star Trek GIFs miniseries FX 2017 DC streaming service Marathons Opinion Showtime Crackle Comedy DirecTV cats IFC Musical Countdown Red Carpet Amazon Prime DGA Awards Tour Esquire sports LGBTQ dramedy sequel Chilling Adventures of Sabrina SDCC TNT technology Polls and Games TLC TBS Fall TV CW Seed crime drama OWN Spring TV Pop Grammys ratings Awards Holidays transformers adventure NYCC diversity WGN 20th Century Fox zombies CNN TCA The Arrangement Dark Horse Comics BET Martial Arts Drama zombie Kids & Family 2015 USA Network BBC America adaptation E3 casting Pirates Shudder MTV justice league cooking DC Universe Interview Starz Ellie Kemper PBS Cartoon Network Nickelodeon ABC Tomatazos Marvel TCM blaxploitation Bravo Year in Review 2016 aliens streaming mockumentary anthology YouTube Red Super Bowl politics Comedy Central Hulu Horror Reality Competition dceu cinemax Comic Book Epix Mary Poppins Returns Spectrum Originals Mary Tyler Moore BBC Reality CBS All Access anime 21st Century Fox FXX sitcom true crime Fantasy social media singing competition science fiction Logo TV YouTube Premium thriller Character Guide mutant Warner Bros. festivals crime historical drama psycho E! Cosplay TruTV finale MCU RT History VICE Mary poppins spider-man Photos ESPN Teen harry potter Box Office biography political drama Acorn TV Lionsgate Animation what to watch golden globes Universal Disney Lucasfilm award winner Rom-Com Star Wars DC Comics Walt Disney Pictures talk show Netflix X-Men Infographic Rocky discovery Food Network binge green book jamie lee curtis Sundance Now Captain marvel Trivia Spike Lifetime 007 MSNBC A&E Extras Paramount Network Black Mirror Premiere Dates Fox News IFC Films travel PaleyFest Ovation Country period drama NBC Schedule Amazon FOX Superheroe cults Christmas Summer Trailer crime thriller YA Watching Series facebook doctor who TCA 2017 GLAAD Paramount Election GoT crossover CBS serial killer 2018 Western Superheroes Trophy Talk Britbox robots Writers Guild of America police drama Adult Swim Certified Fresh comic comiccon