The Walking Dead Season 8 Midseason Finale: What Critics Thought About That Major Cliffhanger

Critics' have mixed thoughts about the midseason finale of AMC's zombie series and its possible impact on the rest of season 8.

by | December 11, 2017 | Comments

(Photo by AMC)

The first seven episodes of The Walking Dead‘s season 8 were a critical mixed bag, but the midseason finale, titled “How It’s Gotta Be,” concluded with a major (and heartbreaking) character development that will undoubtedly affect the series moving forward.


Rick (Andrew Lincoln) and the rest of the AHK crew were once again on the defensive when Negan (Jeffrey Dean Morgan) and the Saviors escaped the Sanctuary and sought revenge, but the real twist occurred at the very end of the episode. As Rick and Michonne (Danai Gurira) saw that most of the Alexandrians were safe in the sewers underneath the town, they came across a weakened Carl (Chandler Riggs), who revealed a nasty zombie bite to the torso (which he probably got when he was saving new recruit Saddiq in the woods).

Although people are devastated by the Carl twist, he isn’t actually dead yet, as star Riggs and showrunner Scott M. Gimple (on the post-finale episode of Talking Dead) were quick to remind us in post-show interviews. The writing is on the wall, though — meaning there probably isn’t going to be a bait-and-switch à la Glenn and the dumpster.

With a Tomatometer score of 64 percent (updated), season 8’s mid-season finale isn’t quite as Fresh as season 7 (78 percent), but a whole lot better than season 6 (35 percent). Here’s what the critics had to say.


The finale delivered the requisite dropped-jaw response.

“It turns out, as usual, that a big heart is a relatively fast track to death in this post-apocalyptic, rotting world.” – Laura Bradley, Vanity Fair

“Subtlety is a long forgotten and extinct practice on TWD. That means eight seasons in, it’s hard for the writers to find ways to surprise us. They did with this fall finale.” – Jeffrey Lyles, Lyles’ Movie Files

The Walking Dead always tries to hold a big reveal for the end of their mid-season finale, and I think it’s safe to say that this one delivered fairly well.” – Jim Vorel, Paste Magazine

“Director Michael E. Satrazemis’ use of close-ups is visually striking, and shifts the emphasis to individual reactions to a crisis, which has always been the show’s strong suit.” – Noel Murray, Rolling Stone


This turn of events with Carl should finally shake things up.

“The mid-season finale is as long and tedious as so much of season 8, but a game-changing cliffhanger is a terrifying reminder that no one is ever safe.” – Sarah Moran, Screenrant

“While this has been one the more energetic episodes this year, it’s the small preview of the back half of season 8 that looks far more exciting and enticing than what we’ve seen so far this season.” – Nick Romano, Entertainment Weekly

“It was a pretty shocking twist to an otherwise-frustrating episode… Without Carl, anything might be possible. That might just be exactly what The Walking Dead needs.”  – Kelly Lawler, USA Today


“Whoo-hoo-hoo, look who knows so much. It just so happens that your friend here is only MOSTLY dead. There’s a big difference between mostly dead and all dead. Mostly dead is slightly alive.” – Miracle Max, The Princess Bride

Stupid Is as Stupid Does

Andrew Lincoln as Rick Grimes, Chandler Riggs as Carl Grimes, Danai Gurira as Michonne - The Walking Dead _ Season 8, Episode 8 (Gene Page/AMC)

Plenty of critics thought the slow burn and nonsensical action were still too tedious.

“This is all just characters acting dumb for no reason, and it’s all too much for this episode to bear, especially when it plays out so slowly over 90 minutes.” – Jeff Stone, IndieWire

“Man, does this feel empty. Despite all the big events, so much of ‘How It’s Gotta Be’ is boring, and so little of it makes sense.” – Zack Handlen, AV Club

“The stakes in the finale didn’t feel nearly as high as they needed to (sorry Carl). It’s hard to invest emotionally in characters when they seem to be running around toting assault rifles / bin lorries etc. to no clear purpose.” – Ed Power, The Daily Telegraph

“By the end of the episode’s ‘shocking’ reveal, I could only shake my head in disgust. What a joke this show has become. A bad joke.” – Erik Kain, Forbes

The Walking Dead returns Sunday, Feb. 25 at 9 p.m. on AMC.

Tag Cloud

E! Mindy Kaling USA Mary poppins indiana jones Lucasfilm Schedule christmas movies Avengers asian-american docudrama Pop TV GoT Amazon Prime Video 2016 Character Guide unscripted witnail ratings 24 frames Logo joker justice league Mystery all-time CBS All Access Disney+ Disney Plus PBS Cosplay Martial Arts dramedy ITV critics Spring TV latino Netflix Christmas movies MCU Nat Geo Infographic Crackle true crime Acorn TV Television Critics Association nbcuniversal Anna Paquin football Red Carpet 72 Emmy Awards 45 Cartoon Network foreign cancelled Trophy Talk Best and Worst cops diversity Mudbound italian Pixar transformers Podcast VICE Bravo police drama spider-man die hard Box Office anime serial killer 007 YouTube Red Fox News First Reviews werewolf breaking bad video on demand Television Academy Emmys Animation robots Elton John Awards Nickelodeon composers Certified Fresh Fantasy Turner Classic Movies Ghostbusters Comic Book south america Columbia Pictures green book Amazon Prime richard e. Grant Adult Swim HBO Go franchise DC Universe New York Comic Con APB best romance politics FXX Kids & Family game show award winner anthology Hulu Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt LGBT films Crunchyroll Classic Film Super Bowl Calendar Travel Channel 71st Emmy Awards GLAAD CBS OneApp 21st Century Fox SDCC zero dark thirty screen actors guild Pride Month Chernobyl TV Land Valentine's Day casting CW Seed Trivia cancelled TV series spy thriller Pop Video Games elevated horror 20th Century Fox reviews BET Awards Stephen King war Biopics ABC Family CNN Quiz directors jamie lee curtis Superheroes E3 emmy awards dceu rotten movies we love YA Lifetime Christmas movies Extras toronto cartoon Britbox DC Comics stop motion technology Tubi disaster Comedy Walt Disney Pictures See It Skip It NYCC sag awards ABC SundanceTV discovery golden globes Marvel Funimation A&E Food Network documentary supernatural IFC Films TLC Watching Series Turner blockbuster based on movie DirecTV Winter TV harry potter Oscars RT History toy story Disney Channel movie concert TCA 2017 FX on Hulu festivals Apple TV+ Comics on TV HBO animated halloween Binge Guide Women's History Month Fox Searchlight canceled TV shows Vudu Black History Month WarnerMedia Brie Larson Freeform Drama adaptation Song of Ice and Fire Summer universal monsters Spectrum Originals Musical History PaleyFest tv talk spinoff YouTube Premium hist Marathons Discovery Channel TCA Winter 2020 satire Grammys spain 2020 psycho Academy Awards Endgame cinemax crime 2019 zombies Winners spanish language Esquire Showtime cats child's play Countdown Shudder National Geographic book IFC renewed TV shows romantic comedy Film Festival a nightmare on elm street slashers Shondaland streaming video AMC Starz versus FOX Emmy Nominations reboot Black Mirror dc comedies Ovation Awards Tour Family Amazon Studios Film binge news The Purge Arrowverse Disney spanish cars TV renewals TCA Awards movies Thanksgiving space psychological thriller SXSW Apple worst movies period drama children's TV finale sitcom Polls and Games quibi Disney Plus HBO Max Syfy political drama singing competition Cannes remakes Rocky VOD french kids science fiction MSNBC Set visit CMT biography Amazon Netflix Writers Guild of America theme song talk show ghosts The Academy stand-up comedy rotten Sundance TV independent Tumblr El Rey Action Masterpiece Marvel Television archives Photos ESPN Reality Competition Paramount aliens American Society of Cinematographers Superheroe Christmas Sundance screenings venice zombie Country twilight game of thrones stoner MTV Nominations documentaries 2017 Dark Horse Comics cooking PlayStation batman DGA fast and furious Paramount Network criterion mutant Tomatazos social media Music GIFs A24 BBC Rom-Com Hallmark adventure comics BAFTA Premiere Dates teaser Sneak Peek Hallmark Christmas movies laika WGN Mary Tyler Moore Year in Review thriller hollywood scorecard San Diego Comic-Con Sundance Now Apple TV Plus Baby Yoda 4/20 festival 2018 indie Ellie Kemper mission: impossible Pirates doctor who natural history sequel Trailer cancelled television comiccon crossover President Holidays travel Creative Arts Emmys medical drama vampires The Witch NBC Teen Lifetime Western crime drama Lionsgate TruTV Sony Pictures boxoffice Reality 2015 The Arrangement obituary television comic VH1 Heroines cancelled TV shows sequels BBC One Fall TV nfl FX sports DC streaming service Holiday parents mockumentary BET Sci-Fi TNT Star Trek Musicals TCM Epix Opinion revenge superhero Disney streaming service strong female leads Rock crime thriller canceled series blaxploitation Warner Bros. hispanic USA Network Spike TIFF Rocketman Mary Poppins Returns The CW First Look TCA Pet Sematary cults Interview Universal what to watch Captain marvel worst dragons halloween tv Tarantino dark OWN TBS free movies facebook BBC America Comedy Central The Walking Dead Toys Hear Us Out classics RT21 YouTube LGBTQ chucky Peacock scary movies nature Star Wars miniseries TV name the review Election Marvel Studios Chilling Adventures of Sabrina X-Men Horror dogs historical drama