Which Song Performance Was Your Favorite in The FlashSupergirl Musical Crossover?

Fans react to the performances by Melissa Benoist, Grant Gustin, Darren Criss, John Barrowman, and more.

by | March 22, 2017 | Comments

Even though many actors on The Flash and Supergirl series on The CW have sung before, some fans heard them sing for the first time Monday night during the long-awaited musical-crossover episode “Duet” on The Flash.

The songs included covers and originals and were revealed as Barry (Grant Gustin), Kara (Melissa Benoist), Cisco (Carlos Valdes), Joe West (Jesse L. Martin), and guest stars Music Meister (Darren Criss), Malcolm Merlyn (John Barrowman), and Dr. Stein (Victor Garber) sang them.


Music Meister visited Supergirl first to whammy her with his hypnotic, spiralling eyes. She woke up as a ’20s moll about to go on stage. Mon-El (Chris Wood) and J’onn J’onzz (David Harewood) followed Music Meister to The Flash’s Earth, but the tuneful mischief-maker proved too fast for the heroes and whammied Barry as well.

In their own minds, Kara and Barry conjured a world of a movie musical, thanks to Barry’s childhood love of Singin’ in the Rain and Kara’s of The Wizard of Oz. She had also suggested Funny Face for a movie night with Mon-El on the Supergirl episode “Star-Crossed” the previous night. Sans powers, Barry and Kara had to follow the musical script, with Winn Schott (Jeremy Jordan), Cisco, Merlyn, Stein, Joe and Iris West (Candice Patton) playing different characters in the story.

So what did the fan think of the show-stopping numbers? Here are some standout reactions to each performance.

UPDATE: Music from the episode is now available to purchase on iTunes.


Kara got the first solo of the night and threw down the gauntlet for the next hour!


This song goes back to Jackie DeShannon’s 1969 recording, but everyone remembers it most from Scrooged. When Bill Murray finally learns to stop being a Scrooge, he leads the entire cast in a cover on live television. In “Duet,” Criss led Barrowman and Valdes in a new rendition.


From Guys and Dolls, one of the only classic Broadway musicals Garber hasn’t already done.

Not everyone was impressed, though.


An original! Flash fans today may have grown up with the Super Friends cartoon, a kiddie version of The Justice League. Kara also set this up with a “Super Friends” high-five on this week’s Supergirl. This is also the tap dance number Gustin told Rotten Tomatoes about.

Although it was maybe a little too on the nose for some:

“Running Home to You” – GRANT GUSTIN

Barry didn’t let waking up from the musical to top him from singing. He had this original cued up to sing to Iris. Get it? Because The Flash runs fast! Crazy Ex-Girlfriend‘s Rachel Bloom co-wrote both “Super Friends” and “Running Home to You.”

But dude, that proposal is going to be a tough act for regular guys to follow.

So that’s all the songs, but each singer made an impression too. Here’s what the fans had to say about each of the Arrowverse stars.


Before her first number ended, Benoist had her fans rapt.


Some had a fan theory about how Gustin’s natural vocal talents make sense with Barry’s super powers. This is one power Gustin has in real life too.



Criss may have gotten the most love of the night by live tweeting along with the fans.


More than his pipes, fans appreciated Jordan’s piano playing.

But his pipes too.


Valdes is developing a loyal following for his band Tha Los, and they came out to support him tonight.

And when Cisco asked for a GIF, the fans were there to provide.


Barrowman has a legion of fans who’ve followed his singing since before and after the Doctor Who days.


They may have their own fans on Broadway, but they shared a duet, and shared the love on “Duets.”

Which performance was your favorite in “Duet?” Vote in the poll and tell us why in the comments!

Supergirl airs Mondays at 8/7 C; The Flash airs Tuesdays at 8/7 C on The CW

Tag Cloud

canceled TV shows festivals Disney Plus Columbia Pictures TCA Winter 2020 2015 biography ESPN Lifetime BAFTA FOX renewed TV shows HBO Max CBS American Society of Cinematographers Marathons Avengers justice league Universal RT21 all-time TruTV NYCC A&E dceu Countdown A24 Western docudrama FXX AMC crime drama Emmy Nominations screenings a nightmare on elm street Martial Arts CBS All Access X-Men blaxploitation TCM Comedy romance Apple TV+ Infographic Apple TV Plus Action dogs dc Shudder Pixar Freeform MSNBC YouTube Red Bravo Film 20th Century Fox spain Trivia MTV discovery Reality Competition war series reviews video PlayStation dragons Tarantino cops Amazon Prime Vudu HBO TNT aliens spanish language Sneak Peek screen actors guild San Diego Comic-Con Captain marvel Rom-Com Set visit DC streaming service Teen 2016 dramedy Academy Awards Arrowverse BET Awards golden globes psycho cars christmas movies spider-man quibi Video Games cats Interview toy story Cannes 4/20 Marvel Television Disney Cartoon Network Lionsgate Hallmark Christmas movies TV renewals revenge diversity Comedy Central BET Syfy Nat Geo sports Ellie Kemper travel Netflix Christmas movies movie richard e. Grant documentaries The Witch 71st Emmy Awards teaser Christmas mission: impossible crime thriller GLAAD The CW Marvel Studios Rocketman President Winter TV DirecTV zombie Musicals cinemax Tubi Trailer book cults USA Network GoT stoner Black Mirror SXSW VICE Mary Poppins Returns foreign Heroines Creative Arts Emmys elevated horror LGBT The Purge films TLC sag awards PBS Holiday Spectrum Originals breaking bad USA Ovation cancelled TV series Disney Channel Shondaland Dark Horse Comics cancelled television El Rey VOD game show Adult Swim Hear Us Out Certified Fresh jamie lee curtis die hard YA Endgame Pop Superheroes Tumblr BBC zero dark thirty Comics on TV Television Academy tv talk Calendar Walt Disney Pictures Sony Pictures news Biopics witnail Emmys Hallmark Oscars kids Animation Awards animated History YouTube Song of Ice and Fire streaming werewolf 45 Character Guide Hulu Chilling Adventures of Sabrina supernatural miniseries Premiere Dates psychological thriller Photos RT History WGN Mystery concert Grammys Warner Bros. children's TV National Geographic Crunchyroll Masterpiece disaster See It Skip It franchise Turner crossover Mudbound sequel Awards Tour Ghostbusters free movies Best and Worst game of thrones political drama canceled Food Network Brie Larson hist E3 ITV FX adaptation Crackle Toys Winners Lucasfilm 2018 dark New York Comic Con movies stand-up comedy GIFs Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt slashers TIFF E! politics halloween Disney+ Disney Plus facebook robots based on movie doctor who WarnerMedia CNN Box Office SundanceTV Country Amazon Writers Guild of America finale comiccon twilight Spring TV theme song NBC anthology Elton John Sundance TV zombies science fiction Rock television what to watch MCU Amazon Studios Thanksgiving batman Mary poppins 007 Lifetime Christmas movies parents Discovery Channel ABC Family LGBTQ TCA TV APB indiana jones Opinion CW Seed Esquire comics Pop TV romantic comedy universal monsters anime Superheroe joker Anna Paquin Logo First Reviews green book comic space latino composers Binge Guide technology Chernobyl transformers Extras period drama Valentine's Day video on demand Drama spy thriller VH1 chucky Travel Channel Election Peacock Showtime name the review Television Critics Association cancelled DC Universe Summer Music Fall TV ghosts Epix PaleyFest south america Holidays crime Watching Series First Look Rocky 2019 DC Comics OWN criterion TBS cancelled TV shows Classic Film TCA Awards singing competition versus true crime Mindy Kaling BBC America Family Schedule CMT Fox News blockbuster Marvel Paramount Network Pet Sematary Disney streaming service directors satire Reality critics unscripted Acorn TV Podcast Kids & Family indie IFC Tomatazos Stephen King historical drama Star Trek Musical asian-american strong female leads comedies casting reboot independent SDCC Mary Tyler Moore Super Bowl serial killer Baby Yoda Cosplay best rotten movies we love 24 frames Star Wars 2020 OneApp social media police drama thriller mutant Fantasy Spike 2017 spinoff harry potter mockumentary adventure cooking The Arrangement nature Pirates Pride Month ratings Starz ABC Britbox Year in Review binge Comic Book documentary sitcom medical drama Paramount BBC One 21st Century Fox hispanic Horror HBO Go boxoffice Apple Netflix Amazon Prime Video Polls and Games DGA TCA 2017 talk show YouTube Premium Quiz scary movies Turner Classic Movies cartoon Film Festival natural history Red Carpet vampires child's play The Walking Dead Sundance Funimation TV Land Women's History Month FX on Hulu Sci-Fi IFC Films Trophy Talk Nominations Black History Month Sundance Now award winner Nickelodeon