The Best Musical Moments From the Cast of Supergirl, The Flash, Arrow, and Legends of Tomorrow

Melissa Benoist, Jeremy Jordan, Darren Criss, Grant Gustin, John Barrowman, and more sing their hearts out in these clips.

by | March 19, 2017 | Comments

The Arrrowverse has a lot of musical talent. Two of their title heroes, Supergirl and The Flash, came from Glee. Many others cast members were on Broadway, and some have released albums. So when The Flash was doing a musical episode, it just had to crossover with the stars of Supergirl, Arrow, and Legends of Tomorrow.

At the end of Supergirl‘s episode Monday night, “Star-Crossed,” The Music Meister (guest star Darren Criss) puts Kara (Melissa Benoist) into a coma. J’onn J’onzz (David Harewood) and Mon-El (Chris Wood) take Kara over to The Flash’s Earth for help in episode “Duet.” Music Meister gets Barry (Grant Gustin), too, and the rest of the episode will play out as a musical fantasy featuring the characters from all four shows, including Malcolm Merlyn (John Barrowman) and Dr. Stein (Victor Garber).

Here’s a breakdown of the musical cred of the stars of Supergirl, The Flash, Arrow, and Legends of Tomorrow, starting with Team Supergirl, with a clip highlighting each singer. (J’onn J’onzz and Mon-El have reportedly have non-singing roles in “Duets.”)


There were so many cast members in Glee, it was sometimes hard to give them all a song. Marley (Benoist) performed in a lot of group songs and shared a killer duet mashup of “Crazy/Drive Me Crazy.” She got to be Sandy in Grease until Rachel (Lea Michele) took over halfway through “You’re the One That I Want.” She even got to be Posh Spice with a zig-a-zig-ah in “Wannabe.” Her solo of “Wrecking Ball” really let Benoist belt it out and ride the ball. Hopefully, The Flash gives her a bravura solo like this one.


Smash allowed Jeremy Jordan to cross over from Broadway to television, employing his triple threat acting/singing/dancing skills. The fictional show on NBC’s Broadway drama couldn’t compete with Jordan’s real theater cred. Having appeared in the ensemble of Rock of Ages, Jordan then played the leads Bonnie and Clyde (Clyde) and Newsies (Jack Kelly, the Christian Bale role in the movie). The only downside of Supergirl is it kept Jordan from singing. Until now!


Criss was a theater kid and recording artist. With his University of Michigan friends, Criss co-founded StarKid Productions in which Criss played Harry Potter in a trilogy of musicals. On Glee, he introduced the show’s all boy a cappella group, The Warblers, which briefly recruited Kurt (Chris Colfer) in season 2. After Glee, Criss has earned raves for his title role in the revival of Hedwig and the Angry Inch on Broadway and on tour. Hedwig had a sex change operation to escape pre-WWII Germany with a G.I., but the operation was botched leaving Hedwig feeling like neither gender, and the G.I. left. The songs encompass anger, sorrow, and bittersweet joy. If you want to see any more, you’d have to buy a ticket.


Sebastian Smythe (Gustin) popped in and out of Glee so he didn’t get to do as many songs as the regulars. Plus, he was a villain! Under Smythe’s leadership, The Warblers covered some classic Billy Joel like “Uptown Girl” and Michael Jackson from “Bad” all the way back to The Jackson 5’s “I Want You Back.” One Jackson song gave him a one-on-one with Santana (Naya Rivera) doing “Smooth Criminal” to a cello accompaniment.


John Barrowman’s stage credits are as impressive as his run on Doctor Who and its spinoff Torchwood. Anything Goes, Phantom of the Opera, Hair, Miss Saigon, Beauty and the Beast, Godspell, Putting It Together, and many nonmusical dramas too. He’s even released albums covering classic showtunes and standards. So many to choose from, but above is the song he calls his anthem. Here’s Barrowman performing it live at the Royal Albert Hall in concert.


Jesse L. Martin was part of the original company of Rent when it conquered Broadway in the ’90s. He even reprised his role for the movie. Since Rent he’s had a long TV career with a steady gig on Law & Order. When he returned to stage, it was for Shakespeare, not musicals. So The Flash will hopefully be the first chance to hear him sing a song like “I’ll Cover You” again.


Valdes studied musical theater and performed in High School Musical, The Wedding Singer, and Jersey Boys on stage. Cavanagh was in Grease, A Chorus Line, Cabaret, and more on Broadway. Cavanagh has even appeared in some videos on Valdes’s music YouTube channel for his jazz band The Los. You can find The Los’s tracks and EP on iTunes as well as Band Camp, Spotify, and other audio services. Valdes’ goes solo in his smoldering video for “Night Off!”


Victor Garber had a long musical history before he ever appeared on camera. He was in the Canadian folk band The Sugar Shoppe and on stage in Godspell, Sweeney Todd, and Tony-nominated musical roles in Little Me and Damn Yankees. Fortunately, many of Garber’s ’90s performances are preserved on YouTube and televised awards shows. One could fall down a rabbit hole watching old Garber performances, so here’s Garber singing George Michael’s “Freedom” on the short-lived Eli Stone.

Supergirl episode “Star-Crossed” kicks off The CW’s musical crossover event on Monday, March 20 night at 8/7 C; The Flash episode “Duets” airs Tuesday, March 21 at 8/7 C on The CW


Tag Cloud

Christmas Calendar Oscars Summer TCA 2017 Creative Arts Emmys Rock Nickelodeon TLC TV Land Red Carpet SundanceTV Video Games harry potter supernatural OWN Super Bowl GLAAD Columbia Pictures Musical National Geographic CNN based on movie hist Box Office transformers cops DGA PaleyFest Premiere Dates VICE 2016 Opinion CBS All Access Teen Rom-Com CMT Star Trek Trophy Talk Universal Photos 20th Century Fox Thanksgiving Sneak Peek PBS Trailer Crackle binge psycho Winter TV 24 frames medical drama Extras romance singing competition Sundance SDCC Comic Book Character Guide NBC Epix YouTube Premium Action Certified Fresh Year in Review BBC America Musicals Drama Adult Swim Sci-Fi History Spike 45 HBO Winners serial killer Apple The CW adventure Pop what to watch political drama APB Awards Black Mirror Comics on TV social media Paramount Network science fiction See It Skip It Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TCM Mindy Kaling RT History YA period drama Brie Larson jamie lee curtis FXX San Diego Comic-Con unscripted DC Universe spider-man Music American Society of Cinematographers AMC Ovation dceu TCA Dark Horse Comics aliens Country casting justice league Lifetime DC streaming service docudrama Bravo Countdown Polls and Games President Comedy Central ABC MSNBC comic cooking Star Wars FX Election Mary poppins Reality Cartoon Network X-Men Pixar Comedy dc Reality Competition Shondaland Nat Geo festivals Song of Ice and Fire CW Seed Logo Amazon Prime zombies war Schedule FOX Quiz Starz WGN Emmys 2015 Fall TV Nominations robots Hulu 007 IFC Films crime MCU golden globes ESPN Mystery cats Holidays Biopics Awards Tour Writers Guild of America USA Network Trivia Ellie Kemper crossover MTV Lionsgate The Arrangement Toys Britbox SXSW politics Captain marvel Disney Syfy Netflix dramedy 2019 TNT Rocky Kids & Family Western travel doctor who TBS Fox News Sundance Now Cosplay El Rey ITV LGBTQ CBS TIFF E3 VH1 Mary Tyler Moore 2018 Animation diversity Martial Arts biography green book Warner Bros. thriller cinemax A&E ABC Family Horror police drama talk show DC Comics miniseries Valentine's Day Superheroes Pirates vampires GIFs TruTV NYCC streaming Chilling Adventures of Sabrina GoT sitcom comiccon Grammys zombie Marvel award winner E! crime thriller Set visit TV USA Podcast BET Freeform facebook 2017 New York Comic Con sports Watching Series Best and Worst finale Shudder Walt Disney Pictures anime Ghostbusters Showtime Fantasy Disney Channel Infographic Interview spy thriller Tumblr historical drama Tomatazos ratings IFC Lucasfilm blaxploitation boxoffice technology Acorn TV cults Sony Pictures YouTube Red crime drama Marathons Superheroe Esquire BBC First Look 21st Century Fox Amazon Paramount Masterpiece television discovery DirecTV mutant Mary Poppins Returns Spring TV composers Food Network