The 6 Biggest Mid-Season Uncertainties of The Walking Dead

Is Alexandria stable? When will Negan appear? And what are the odds on Glenn's survival these days?

by | February 11, 2016 | Comments


Five-and-a-half seasons into AMC’s The Walking Dead, viewers have come to expect a few certainties.

We know that Rick, Carl, Michonne, Carol, Glenn, Daryl, Maggie and the rest of the core survivors may get off the road for a little while, but they can never rest. Hershel’s farm, the prison, the church, and now, Alexandria — none of these places stays safe for long. The moment our survivors start making long term plans to grow crops, build bigger walls, or expand, something or someone comes along to blow all of that to Hell. That’s one of main themes woven through The Walking Dead.

Another certainty is the inevitability of death — an obvious statement, since being stalked by the dead is part of daily living. But that also refers to the idea of death as a metaphor: Just as central to the show as the theme of hunger is that of expendability and impermanence. Whenever we think the most terrible thing possible has just happened, something even more nightmarish shambles out of a blind corner to make things worse.

Sunday marks the midseason return of The Walking Dead with an episode titled “No Way Out.” As always, the channel has asked that those of us fortunate to preview new episodes refrain from revealing any specifics about new episodes. We intend to honor that. But it’s not a spoiler to say that the situation is still as grim as ever — and consider that title.  Read on for the six greatest uncertainties we can rely upon in the back half of season six.

This should go without saying, but if you are not caught up with The Walking Dead, STOP READING NOW.



The last time we checked in with Alexandria, the settlement’s remaining leader, a bitten and dying Deanna Monroe (Tovah Feldshuh) was screaming defiantly at a group of famished zombies about to feast on her. Hundreds of undead flooded the streets. Rick (Andrew Lincoln), Michonne (Danai Gurira), and Carl (Chandler Riggs) were leading Gabriel (Seth Gilliam), Jessie (Alexandra Breckenridge), and her sons into the fray, lightly camouflaged in sheets soaked in walker guts.

Elsewhere Morgan (Lennie James) and Carol (Melissa McBride) had been knocked out by Morgan’s secret prisoner, a badly hurt, nihilistic member of the “W” gang that attempted to destroy the town. Said guest also overpowered Rosita (Christian Serratos), Eugene (Josh McDermitt) and Tara (Alanna Masterson), taking the town doctor, Denise (Merritt Wever), with him as a hostage.

Just beyond the walls, Glenn (Steven Yeun) and Enid (Katelyn Nacon) witnessed Maggie (Lauren Cohan) trapped atop a lookout post. And even further afield, Daryl (Norman Reedus), Abraham (Michael Cudlitz) and Sasha (Sonequa Martin-Green) struggled to return from their mission to lead the horde away from Alexandria, getting separated before finding one another again.

The most pressing concern, obviously, is the longterm viability of Alexandria itself.  Too reliant on the supposed invulnerability of the walls, the relationship between Rick’s people and blissfully sheltered townsfolk was already dangerously strained before the zombies rolled into town.  Their ranks were already thinned by the “W” invaders, their sense of community fractured.  Not a terribly ideal way to face down an invading force, especially one so many have never intentionally engaged.



You may notice the very large roster of characters listed by name above. Only one of them won’t be back in Sunday’s episode. With so many stories to service, some of which garner more fan interest than others, it’s almost inevitable that somebody in the main group won’t make it to the finale unharmed or unchomped.

However, our favorite survivors do have a bit of insulation, if you will, in the form of Alexandria’s residents, a number of whom we’ve begun to care about. (This writer would be fairly upset if something were to happen to Alexandria’s scout Aaron or Denise.)

Even so, there are only a few of those residents who have been imbued with enough character development to make us become unhinged at the thought of their loss. Most of Rick and Carl’s neighbors may as well be to The Walking Dead what red shirts were to Star Trek — useful on a mission, but largely there to demonstrate the deadliness of a scenario by example. Feel free to bond, but don’t get too close to women with whom Carol shares casserole recipes.



Let’s be clear — we don’t want Glenn to die, and we’re not about to tempt fate by placing actual Vegas odds on him continuing to breathe. Experiencing the emotional turmoil incited by the possibility that Glenn was killed by walkers in this season’s third episode, “Thank You,” was really enough for a while.

Yet it bears mentioning that Glenn has escaped death a lot, and occasionally inexplicably so. Remember when Nicholas left him to be eaten by a group of zombies in the woods? We’re glad Glenn made it out of that situation but… how did Glenn make it out of that situation?

Tension born of near-death experiences is a staple ingredient in The Walking Dead’s plot pantry, but one has to wonder whether we’re being intentionally set up to witness Glenn’s story end with a gigantic, gnarly death sooner rather than later. One fears there will come a point at which the producers will have to stop crying wolf and actually produce a deadly predator that Glenn won’t be able to escape, bringing us to…



One of biggest fan favorites from the comic book series — and one of the franchise’s most fearsome villains — Negan officially steps into the game with the mention of his name within the first four minutes of “No Way Out.” As shown in the preview clip AMC released earlier this week, we don’t actually see the ruthless dictator, but the sinister threat posed by his agents is enough to convey that he’s not to be toyed with.

The casting of Jeffrey Dean Morgan as Negan is thrilling; he’s a magnetic actor adored by many. He’s also the kind of person a show’s casting director hires with the expectation of having him around for a while. Reportedly Morgan will make his onscreen debut before the end of the season.

In this series, however, the arrival of a heavy caliber Big Bad usually coincides with the departure of a core character. We applauded the casting of David Morrissey as The Governor — he was truly fantastic — but ultimately the cost was saying goodbye to Andrea and Hershel.

As such, there has been a tremendous amount of discussion as to whether the beginning of Morgan’s time with the series means the end of Yeun’s — who, like Lincoln, Reedus, McBride and Riggs, has been with The Walking Dead as a regular since the first season.

Plus, there’s that widely-reported, stomach churning detail that Negan ends Glenn with his bat Lucille in the comic book. You don’t have to search that much to find a few of the grislier frames depicting that confrontation. And the fact that Maggie is pregnant does not necessarily save Glenn. It didn’t save Lori, did it?



Hope remains — at least for Glenn and a few others — because as The Walking Dead’s producers often point out, the plot deviates from the comic books, and some of those iconic scenes from the pages play out differently on the screen. Andrea, for instance, is still alive in the comic book universe; on the other hand, several key characters who are physically whole on the TV series are missing body parts in the comics, and others besides Glenn who are alive on our televisions are already deceased in the books. All of this is to say, we simply don’t know for whom the bell tolls — and do we really want to know?



Ever notice that when certain characters reach a certain level of wisdom about the meaning of life, they acquire a target on their backs? Recall the smile on Hershel’s face after Rick pleads with the Governor to let him and Michonne go, proposing they live together in peace — you know, right before the Gov beheaded him.

Or Bob, who schooled Rick on maintaining his humanity before dying, and Dale, who did his best to keep his companions on a righteous path when paranoia was testing them, but could not escape those wandering walkers. These moral compasses, these hearts of the group, survive just long enough to make a mark on the souls around them but ultimately prove themselves to be too good to live.

Several of our current favorites are coming perilously close to having their moment of Zen, aren’t they?

But we could run down every possible scenario and endlessly prep ourselves to face any kind of tragedy, and The Walking Dead will still prove it has the ability to shock and surprise. That’s the finest expectation any of us can have for our favorite shows, one we hope keeps Rick Grimes and his people fighting on for many seasons to come.

Melanie McFarland is a Seattle-based TV critic and an executive member of the Television Critics Association. Follow her on Twitter: @McTelevision

Season six of The Walking Dead is currently Certified Fresh at 89 percent, and it returns with a new episode on Sunday, Feb. 14 at 9p.m. on AMC; read reviews here.

  • Johnny Vineyard

    In Uncertainty #4, the name Morgan is used where it should be Negan.

    • Mr. Majora

      I think she was talking about the actor, Jeffrey Dean Morgan.

      • Johnny Vineyard

        I see, but given the importance of the character Morgan in the show, I still think it should be changed.

  • James

    I’m hoping Glenn meets his fate with Lucille when Negan appears in the last episode of this season. Kirkman was teasing fans when AMC “killed” off Glenn early in the season. It meant it left the door open for Daryl to meet Lucille. I want Daryl to live to the end of the series because I like to see how Daryl and Negan and his Saviors interact with each other since they’re both motorcycle biker types. Will Daryl and Negan and his Saviors respect each other as admired enemies? Will Negan adopt Daryl as a member of the Saviors the way Joe and his gang did in season 4? Also, Glenn has to meet his fate with Lucille so that Maggie can be a bitter pregnant woman and punch out Rick twice in the face and so she can take over as leader of the Hilltop Colony from Gregory the coward.

    • Sabine Andris

      I think either Daryl or Carol are going to die by Negan’s hand or bat. On the other hand, that might be exactly what they want people to believe, Glenn cant die bc he was once already perceived to be dead. Cant wait, its going to be awesome.

  • Always Texan

    I think we’ve learned enough from how TWD goes to say that maybe it isn’t Glenn who dies when Negan finally shows. But almost certainly someone will.

  • Psycold

    You mention losing Andrea like it was a bad thing, the show became infinitely better when they killed off her and Lori. Neither of them added much of anything except annoyances and they were both so poorly written that if I was a woman I would have thrown my TV out the window. Now I feel like the show is on another decline. This new episode was full of the same old idiotic decisions. I mean how long have they been out there, fighting bad people and zombies? They see a bunch of bikers on the middle of a well lit road (all holding guns including ak47’s which would clearly be visible) and what do they do? They proceed to pull their vehicle within about 5 feet of these people then get out without guns drawn. How did Daryl get stabbed, kill a guy, then pull out an RPG without a single one of those bikers even blinking an eye? It’s getting harder and harder to watch because the characters are so unbelievable.

    • Sir Baronish

      Motorcycles can catch a deuce-and-a-half with a giant tank on the back. You expect them to outrun to bikers?

  • Sir Baronish

    I feel like Negan will have Glenn and Morgan on their knees, and he will choose to brain Morgan, like some odd symbolism between each character’s chosen wooden weapon.

Tag Cloud

television Brie Larson cancelled television spider-man First Reviews American Society of Cinematographers Trailer toy story Film Festival Martial Arts revenge Western Animation Box Office disaster The Arrangement Nickelodeon cars TBS Video Games spinoff space award winner 2015 talk show Mindy Kaling dceu CW Seed Sci-Fi Music FXX APB Binge Guide Britbox comic Walt Disney Pictures CBS All Access Crackle Esquire Fall TV halloween anthology game of thrones mockumentary DC streaming service Television Academy The CW cooking YouTube Red Fox News Columbia Pictures golden globes Shudder nature Sony Pictures elevated horror Cartoon Network A&E Star Trek ABC Family TCM Fantasy WarnerMedia cancelled TV series police drama Chilling Adventures of Sabrina zombies canceled Emmy Nominations FX vampires Year in Review social media Cosplay DirecTV blaxploitation boxoffice WGN politics Disney Channel TruTV Mary Poppins Returns BBC Film Premiere Dates PBS spain San Diego Comic-Con miniseries Rom-Com Tumblr New York Comic Con Valentine's Day Awards green book Cannes TNT Watching Series ITV joker Comic Book Comedy Schedule TV HBO Max Marathons medical drama Disney Vudu psychological thriller GLAAD HBO hispanic 71st Emmy Awards free movies Syfy robots Extras war Teen Spectrum Originals what to watch crossover mutant historical drama Apple Superheroe Paramount Network TCA 2017 TIFF canceled TV shows The Walking Dead Polls and Games TV renewals docudrama psycho Shondaland DC Comics Arrowverse Pet Sematary 24 frames Comedy Central X-Men adventure cancelled TV shows Pirates Toys YA VICE TCA YouTube Premium Amazon 21st Century Fox transformers CMT Ghostbusters LGBTQ cinemax Starz Black Mirror Freeform jamie lee curtis Peacock cats zero dark thirty cancelled Amazon Prime Best and Worst animated Adult Swim 2018 Disney Plus CNN festivals unscripted sequel Women's History Month period drama Anna Paquin Infographic stand-up comedy foreign Pop sports YouTube NYCC Amazon Prime Video History batman Trophy Talk ESPN Lucasfilm TLC SundanceTV kids E3 Epix Disney streaming service series biography Tarantino supernatural binge Mudbound CBS richard e. Grant Election Red Carpet Awards Tour casting Elton John Set visit Summer tv talk 20th Century Fox GIFs Winter TV MSNBC Creative Arts Emmys crime thriller book ABC USA Network Rocky Thanksgiving Sundance Now NBC facebook Opinion comiccon National Geographic Interview Musical Star Wars Mary poppins Universal Tomatazos Marvel Reality Captain marvel Drama justice league Paramount Dark Horse Comics renewed TV shows crime Character Guide Apple TV+ RT21 adaptation Podcast Reality Competition dc harry potter streaming technology Showtime Lionsgate cops Pixar theme song SDCC Rocketman Pride Month USA hist game show BET Heroines Acorn TV PaleyFest Nominations dramedy singing competition MCU Warner Bros. sitcom south america 007 Superheroes movies RT History Lifetime zombie Mystery Calendar cults true crime See It Skip It Countdown Logo GoT Ovation finale FOX Masterpiece romance natural history strong female leads composers Chernobyl IFC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 2017 LGBT Action DGA OWN serial killer Nat Geo doctor who teaser Food Network Trivia children's TV slashers SXSW Song of Ice and Fire video latino Horror political drama Spring TV Country Musicals discovery Biopics Super Bowl Grammys aliens President Netflix Holidays Sneak Peek 45 spy thriller First Look The Witch spanish language dragons based on movie Winners DC Universe 2019 diversity Oscars science fiction Stephen King Quiz ratings witnail Emmys Spike Certified Fresh Sundance Rock anime Writers Guild of America Ellie Kemper travel Christmas VH1 BBC America Mary Tyler Moore thriller 2016 Photos quibi Kids & Family IFC Films TV Land Hulu Comics on TV AMC crime drama Bravo E! El Rey Family ghosts MTV