Total Recall

The 10 Worst Christmas Day Releases of the Past 30 Years

In this week's Total Recall, we look at biggest critical failures that opened on December 25.

by | December 23, 2014 | Comments

Heading to the cineplex has grown into a Christmas Day tradition over the years, encouraged by a rising tide of December 25 releases that includes some of the more critically acclaimed films of the last few decades — as well as some of the most infamous stinkers. In honor of the latter tradition, we’ve sorted through 30 years of Hollywood’s Christmas gifts to filmgoers, and arranged a list of the releases that were pelted with the biggest lumps of critical coal. Can’t make it to the theater this week? Here are 10 times when staying home for the holidays turned out to be a pretty good idea.

10. Cheaper by the Dozen (2003) 24%

Few would argue that Steve Martin is a dramatic and comedic actor without peer; unfortunately, by the mid-’90s, his gift for choosing scripts seemed to have abandoned him all but entirely, leading to a rather abysmal run of releases that stretched from 1992’s Housesitter into the 21st century, only periodically broken up by sporadic roles in rewarding reminders like The Spanish Prisoner and Bowfinger. Among the worst of Martin’s late-period offenders is 2003’s Cheaper by the Dozen, a slapstick-heavy comedy that takes its loose concept and title — and little else — from the bestselling nonfiction book (and hit 1950 film) inspired by the lives of a New Jersey family with a dozen offspring. Arriving on Christmas Day of 2003, the Martin-led Cheaper wrangled an unlikely-seeming cast (including Bonnie Hunt, Piper Perabo, Hilary Duff, and Ashton Kutcher) around a plot that seemed to exist for no other reason than to string together a series of thuddingly unfunny (and occasionally crude) pratfalls; not surprisingly, although enough ticket buyers showed up to generate a 2005 sequel (which, it should be noted, received even worse reviews), critics were almost uniformly unimpressed. “It’s not that Cheaper by the Dozen is awful,” bemoaned the Apollo Guide’s Brian Webster. “Worse than that, it’s just plain dull.”

9. Patch Adams (1998) 22%

Given the right script, Robin Williams was capable of melding humor and genuine pathos as well as anyone — and on its face, a movie based on the real-life story of Hunter “Patch” Adams, a doctor whose youthful struggles with suicidal depression helped inform a groundbreaking medical career highlighting the therapeutic value of humor, seemed like the perfect vehicle for Williams’ singular gifts. There’s a thin line between inspirational and mawkish, however, and it’s one that screenwriter Steve Oedekerk and director Tom Shadyac stomped all over while making the 1998 Christmas Day drama Patch Adams. Wholeheartedly indulging the heartstrings-tugging nature of Adams’ story without taking sufficient care to create three-dimensional characters or build genuine narrative stakes, Patch quickly soured critics and dimmed some of the buzz Williams had built with his Oscar-winning work in Good Will Hunting. “Williams pulls out all the stops in a lead role that gives him carte blanche to careen between extremes of silliness and sentimentality,” observed Variety’s Joe Leydon. “He tries too hard, too obviously, much like the pic itself.”

8. Gulliver’s Travels (2010) 20%

On paper, a Jack Black-led Gulliver’s Travels looks like a potentially great idea. The original story seems uniquely well-suited to a big-budget update fueled by slick modern special effects, and as we’ve seen in Tenacious D and School of Rock, Black’s very good at going from arrogant and oafish to eminently likable — sometimes within the same scene. Precious little of that promise, however, made it to the screen in the 2010 edition of Travels, directed by Rob Letterman and co-written by Nick Stoller (Forgetting Sarah Marshall) and Joe Stillman (Shrek); instead, viewers were bombarded with crude, unfunny slapstick, strung together with CG graphics and set to the strains of one of Black?s most grating performances. “I will tell you there’s a cast credit for a character described only as ‘Butt-crack man,'” grumbled the Washington Post’s Michael O’Sullivan. “Consider yourself warned.”

7. Black Christmas (2006) 15%

It’s never going to be mentioned in the same breath as, say, Citizen Kane, but the original Black Christmas, released in 1974 and starring Olivia Hussey and Margot Kidder, is arguably the first slasher flick — and a pretty good one at that. Minus that groundbreaking spirit and talented cast, there wasn’t really any reason to remake it; unfortunately, that didn’t stop director Glen Morgan from taking a (cough) stab at it with his updated take on the story, released in 2006. The results were predictably brutal and lacking in transgressive wit — and were soundly thrashed by critics like Peter Howell of the Toronto Star, who didn’t mince words in a review reading in part, “Creativity is a stranger to this sick excuse for entertainment, which pounds a ridiculous back story into a butchered rehash that includes incest, cannibalism, eyeball gouging and impossibly dumb plot contrivances.”

6. 47 Ronin (2013) 16%

Keanu Reeves with a samurai sword — in 3D! What could go wrong? Pretty much everything, according to critics who screened 47 Ronin prior to its wide release on December 25, 2013. Helmed by debuting commercial director Carl Rinsch, Ronin attempted to make a blockbuster out of the real-life story of 18th-century Japanese samurai who avenged their dead master’s honor — knowingly condemning themselves to death in the process — but succeeded only in serving up yet another in the seemingly endless line of big-budget critical punching bags in Reeves’ post-Matrix filmography. Calling the result “Solemn as a funeral march, humorless as your junior high principal, as Japanese as a grocery-store California roll,” the Village Voice’s Alan Scherstuhl dismissed the picture as “Keanu Reeves’s let’s-mope-about-and-kill-ourselves samurai drama.”

5. The Spirit (2008) 14%

Will Eisner’s The Spirit is one of the more distinctive and beloved characters in comics history, a masked vigilante whose adventures served as a springboard for a series of stories — mostly published between 1940-’52 — that used an expansive noir-inspired backdrop incorporating a wide variety of elements, including horror and comedy. Sadly, little of what made the Spirit special translated to the big-screen adaptation helmed by Frank Miller in 2008; deliberately cartoonish and devoid of Eisner’s gift for narrative or ear for dialogue, it proved equally inept either as a tribute to the comic or as a bid for a modern-day continuation of the franchise. “Miller’s directing chops, er, chop, is non-existent, offering up a muck of amateurish posturing, weak storyline and tedious characters,” sighed Kimberly Gadette for Indie Movies Online. “As for the title? Ouch, that’s some irony.”

4. Aliens vs. Predator: Requiem (2007) 12%

Pitting the slavering stars of the Alien and Predator franchises against one another for a sci-fi action thriller battle royale is a pretty cool idea — just ask the publishers behind the sprawling array of comics, novels, and video games that have run wild with the concept. Do not, however, ask anyone who’s seen either of the AVP movies; the first one, 2004’s Alien vs. Predator, whiffed with critics, but made enough money to justify a sequel, directed by FX specialists Greg and Colin Strause and written by Shane Salerno (Armageddon). Somewhat unbelievably, 2007’s Aliens vs. Predator: Requiem did even worse, taking an epic Christmas Day pounding from just about every critic who screened it. “The door is left open for another sequel,” warned Scott Tobias for the AV Club. “If someone would kindly shut it and board it up, that would be much appreciated.”

3. Revolution (1985) 10%

Take the director of Chariots of Fire, the screenwriter of The French Connection II, and the star of The Godfather II, and you should have yourself a pretty good picture, right? Not based on the evidence presented in Revolution, a thoroughly misbegotten attempt to portray a commoner’s-eye view of the events leading up to the War of Independence waged by American colonists against the British crown. One of the earliest in a series of shockingly misguided films that would eventually dot leading man Al Pacino’s filmography, it united a tremendous amount of talent (including a cast boasting Nastassja Kinski and Joan Plowright) in what appeared to be a war against a good time for filmgoers who traipsed out to see it on December 25, 1985. Saying that Pacino “often looks as if he were an 18th-century Rambo and sounds as if he were speaking 20th-century David Mamet,” the New York Times’ Vincent Canby opined, “Mr. Pacino has never been more intense to such little effect. It’s like watching someone walk around in a chicken costume.”

2. Mr. Magoo (1997) 7%

By the late ’90s, Leslie Nielsen had cornered the Hollywood market on bumbling, white-haired klutzes — and for very good reason, as anyone who’s seen his wonderful work as Lieutenant Frank Drebin in Police Squad!, Airplane!, and The Naked Gun will tell you. However, not all slapstick comedies are created equal, and over time, Nielsen was sadly called upon to test the limits of his gifts by straining to overcome the deficiencies of scripts that offered little more than the merest framework for one of the industry’s greatest physical comics to work his magic. Case in point: 1997’s Mr. Magoo, which started from a decent idea — Leslie Nielsen as a legendary cartoon dunderhead! — and never bothered to go any further. The Houston Chronicle’s Jeff Millar summed up the dispirited response expressed by many of his colleagues when he sighed, “Here’s where I’m supposed to suggest how the film might be better. But I can’t think of anything to say other than to make the film again, with different writers and a new director.”

1. Pinocchio (2002) 0%

Like plenty of other Oscar-winning actors, Roberto Benigni used the clout he earned with his awards (Best Actor and Best Foreign Film for Life Is Beautiful) to help get his passion project made. And it had plenty of potential, too — Carlo Callodi’s The Adventures of Pinocchio is a classic book, but the character has become more closely identified with its somewhat bowdlerized Disney counterpart, and Benigni could have channeled his love for the book into a more faithful film. Alas, he chose instead to create one of the strangest (and vaguely creepiest) family movies of the 21st century, starring Benigni himself (who also directed and co-wrote the script) as the impish wooden boy. In fairness, it should be pointed out that the international version of Pinocchio did fairly well, but in the States, the English overdubs only compounded the overall weirdness of what unfolded on the screen. As an incredulous Edward Guthmann asked for the San Francisco Chronicle: “What can one say about a balding 50-year-old actor playing an innocent boy carved from a log?”


Finally, here’s a nice hot fire for you to warm yourself after reading those chilly reviews:



Tag Cloud

Binge Guide AMC Plus 79th Golden Globes Awards comics Comic Book video justice league posters finale Holidays Polls and Games Stephen King slasher Comedy summer TV preview royal family Star Wars zombies Music casting Mary poppins based on movie Apple TV Plus Grammys VICE Food Network asian-american talk show Action ESPN animated Disney Plus wonder woman rt archives crime drama BET Awards deadpool classics Netflix Christmas movies criterion SundanceTV spain singing competition anthology Fall TV green book composers Dark Horse Comics new zealand saw Broadway BET technology crime thriller Paramount IFC mission: impossible science fiction doctor who foreign Apple TV+ action-comedy Amazon Prime Video Fargo NBC quibi Legendary trophy New York Comic Con MTV Paramount Plus Election australia summer TV facebook obi wan ABC FX vampires films BBC Britbox Star Wars Celebration rotten Disney+ Disney Plus Freeform GoT IMDb TV serial killer summer preview international 2017 archives VH1 The Witch political drama Ovation witnail DirecTV ViacomCBS Writers Guild of America rt labs critics edition spy thriller 73rd Emmy Awards Rocketman Nat Geo Trivia Emmy Nominations diversity joker christmas movies kaiju Apple book Discovery Channel sequel Hallmark die hard biography 45 young adult Comedy Central telelvision Chilling Adventures of Sabrina olympics critic resources TNT Photos children's TV scary HFPA Anna Paquin Pixar Superheroe satire The Arrangement sag awards kids HBO reboot MCU Universal Paramount Network obituary Best Actress Marvel Studios toy story MGM Columbia Pictures Mystery Tubi japanese Biopics golden globes Reality Hallmark Christmas movies live event dramedy BBC One SDCC Superheroes 007 Crunchyroll versus sports Western Teen The Purge name the review mob American Society of Cinematographers DGA halloween TIFF revenge Mudbound best Super Bowl know your critic TBS cops Marathons Best Picture TCA Winter 2020 HBO Max TV One pirates of the caribbean cancelled television Rock Brie Larson rom-coms Wes Anderson The Academy Logo 2018 BAFTA TV movies blockbuster razzies DC streaming service streaming movies 99% 4/20 golden globe awards comiccon prank 21st Century Fox latino breaking bad Prime Video Calendar zero dark thirty suspense Amazon Countdown dragons Shondaland CMT Vudu television Alien ghosts video on demand Pop feel good franchise Song of Ice and Fire Academy Awards worst movies YouTube Red documentary king kong Best Actor Peacock Tokyo Olympics Funimation 71st Emmy Awards fast and furious emmy awards Winter TV interviews psychological thriller social media Indigenous slashers Quiz biopic docudrama award winner Oscar 20th Century Fox Fantasy Nickelodeon comic Lifetime Avengers free movies First Reviews Awards Tour DC Comics TCM nbcuniversal Sony Acorn TV GLAAD documentaries Sundance Now Fox Searchlight PaleyFest 94th Oscars Oscars dogs A&E child's play Premiere Dates italian TV renewals movie TCA Awards Podcast Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt cats Shudder Christmas Sci-Fi heist movie Ellie Kemper President FXX Amazon Prime spider-verse Infographic YouTube superman comic book movie A24 mcc remakes adventure South by Southwest Film Festival fresh broadcast See It Skip It Lifetime Christmas movies sequels news travel FOX directors scary movies Exclusive Video miniseries reviews Disney game show all-time Pop TV streamig medical drama universal monsters Image Comics 24 frames comic book movies mockumentary National Geographic parents Esquire scene in color series ABC Family Epix thriller Mindy Kaling target scene in color Turner Classic Movies APB dceu japan Creative Arts Emmys Star Trek Starz OWN jurassic park trailers marvel comics Geeked Week USA Network Interview transformers Disney Channel boxing TruTV Tarantino lord of the rings venice Netflix high school Masterpiece blockbusters superhero Turner Certified Fresh TLC leaderboard live action SXSW 2022 south america game of thrones adaptation indiana jones 90s art house halloween tv 2020 Summer movies DC Universe godzilla Adult Swim black comedy war CW Seed Pirates hist The CW Sony Pictures NYCC blaxploitation Opinion critics Musical chucky Film Spring TV 1990s Horror Black History Month police drama TCA 2017 king arthur Captain marvel 2015 Comics on TV Extras period drama james bond spinoff Year in Review stop motion Women's History Month Awards aliens festival gangster HBO Go Comic-Con@Home 2021 Cartoon Network canceled TV shows cults Paramount Pictures CBS All Access debate discovery monster movies Crackle Disney streaming service Travel Channel VOD genre screen actors guild Reality Competition binge El Rey BBC America Emmys Baby Yoda popular ITV Heroines Focus Features X-Men Set visit The Walt Disney Company kong NBA indie Nominations rotten movies we love strong female leads Native worst Pacific Islander streaming Tomatazos nfl AMC spanish language Mary Tyler Moore space ID screenings independent football zombie concert GIFs CNN what to watch PlayStation Box Office black dexter Bravo Trailer Pride Month Neflix Red Carpet festivals richard e. Grant werewolf TCA crime docuseries Martial Arts CBS harry potter legend Tumblr psycho toronto Best Director Mary Poppins Returns Television Academy 2019 natural history SXSW YA RT21 comic books Character Guide cancelled tv talk sitcom 2016 Instagram Live supernatural mutant unscripted Schedule Cannes E3 Sundance TV PBS elevated horror Video Games FX on Hulu Watching Series E! LGBT adenture cancelled TV series teaser Hollywood Foreign Press Association Country The Walking Dead jamie lee curtis Pet Sematary series vs. 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards politics hollywood TV Land women WarnerMedia new york aapi RT History Thanksgiving ratings Drama Lionsgate Classic Film scene in color IFC Films twilight 2021 Cosplay Rom-Com Hulu stand-up comedy romantic comedy Holiday Sneak Peek Trophy Talk target Universal Pictures cartoon canceled First Look USA dark hispanic heritage month Family book adaptation Best and Worst Marvel cars sopranos scorecard Endgame new star wars movies Television Critics Association 93rd Oscars LGBTQ OneApp Hear Us Out Spectrum Originals ABC Signature historical drama 72 Emmy Awards batman Musicals Film Festival cooking YouTube Premium stoner Warner Bros. Toys dreamworks laika renewed TV shows TV hispanic Spike Kids & Family true crime Chernobyl rt labs Lucasfilm Elton John Animation disaster Valentine's Day Marvel Television Amazon Studios nature MSNBC robots WGN History a nightmare on elm street Winners theme song Ghostbusters hidden camera Walt Disney Pictures Sundance crossover Tags: Comedy cancelled TV shows romance boxoffice dc Fox News anime San Diego Comic-Con basketball spanish cinemax Black Mirror Showtime comedies french Syfy spider-man Rocky marvel cinematic universe scene in color film series Arrowverse