Showdowns

Supernatural vs. Scooby-Doo

They're some of entertainment's most long-running monster hunters, but which team is greatest? We're breaking it down by Tomatometer, popularity, and more.

by | April 27, 2020 | Comments

Got a ghost problem? A rogue vampire keeping you up at night? A spawn of Satan disturbing your peace? If so, there are two teams you can rely on to crack the case: The Winchester Brothers of TV’s Supernatural or the “Scooby Gang” and its hilarious namesake, Scooby-Doo. But which is better suited to solve your supernatural issues? In our latest episode of Vs., we’re pitting the long-running series Supernatural against everything Scooby-Doo – the original cartoon, its spin-offs, and the live-action movies. Which mystery-solvers are more popular with the people and the critics? Which franchise features the richest characters? And which team has faced off against the most dastardly villains? Find out as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis breaks it down to decide whether you should hop in the Mystery Van or the Winchesters’ Chevy when the ghouls come a-calling.

As ever, if you don’t agree with our choice of winner, let us have it in the comments.


Scoob! will be released digitally May 15, 2020. Supernatural airs on the CW, next air dates are unknown. 

#1

Scoob! (2020)
50%

#1
Adjusted Score: 54.793%
Critics Consensus: Scoob! is fun enough for youthful viewers and some hardcore fans, but never quite solves the mystery of why audiences shouldn't watch old episodes instead.
Synopsis: "SCOOB!" reveals how lifelong friends Scooby and Shaggy first met and how they joined with young detectives Fred, Velma and... [More]
Directed By: Tony Cervone

Thumbnail: CW / © Warner Bros.

Tag Cloud

Fall TV series 4/20 cancelled Hulu Martial Arts YA The Walking Dead Endgame Sneak Peek Opinion GoT Rocky SDCC romantic comedy screen actors guild Academy Awards harry potter supernatural Amazon Prime Video TBS Rocketman Funimation PaleyFest Crackle APB Apple Acorn TV GIFs TCA Comedy ITV Sci-Fi Tumblr 2017 zero dark thirty canceled TV shows technology ratings National Geographic USA Network Nominations period drama quibi HBO Max cops south america chucky Horror spider-man Showtime Calendar CW Seed NYCC Spectrum Originals richard e. Grant science fiction Turner Christmas Rock crossover comic New York Comic Con ABC WarnerMedia Trailer Winners History witnail Grammys concert a nightmare on elm street sitcom Hallmark Christmas movies parents batman NBC DC Comics dc TLC LGBT Superheroes joker ghosts Family Shondaland crime thriller Cosplay MCU President streaming Film Festival free movies Photos SXSW critics rotten movies we love foreign Columbia Pictures The Witch Disney Fox News Pixar werewolf TV renewals Elton John Mary Tyler Moore Cartoon Network PBS 20th Century Fox IFC Films award winner police drama sports Extras slashers TV Certified Fresh Year in Review Pirates Oscars political drama nature Lionsgate Schedule criterion Tarantino comiccon Pop Shudder versus Emmys Musical FX on Hulu DC Universe Kids & Family finale boxoffice Interview Lucasfilm justice league romance Sundance child's play tv talk canceled reboot robots Star Trek American Society of Cinematographers MSNBC movies breaking bad crime drama DirecTV Ovation YouTube Premium war Ellie Kemper cancelled television Trivia animated 2018 cults Lifetime Christmas movies TCA 2017 X-Men Apple TV Plus Star Wars children's TV Set visit television Walt Disney Pictures Turner Classic Movies cooking Paramount Network Travel Channel Netflix Awards Paramount miniseries GLAAD blockbuster Song of Ice and Fire Esquire Mary poppins RT History dogs universal monsters screenings Marvel Television Film stand-up comedy Biopics sequel See It Skip It renewed TV shows Holiday Watching Series Peacock Best and Worst hispanic Comics on TV Holidays Valentine's Day Toys documentary hist anthology diversity dragons The Arrangement E! indie TCM 71st Emmy Awards comedies Mudbound USA Disney+ Disney Plus Hallmark Television Academy book what to watch A&E Avengers Discovery Channel FOX 21st Century Fox Amazon Bravo mutant based on movie LGBTQ zombies Emmy Nominations TCA Winter 2020 green book Starz Premiere Dates Quiz true crime Superheroe Election WGN 2020 E3 Food Network discovery social media Amazon Studios dceu Western Creative Arts Emmys Heroines Apple TV+ game show directors FXX Marathons cars Comedy Central Epix anime CMT natural history Nickelodeon The CW independent die hard dramedy Syfy El Rey VH1 Mystery Arrowverse Cannes binge name the review 2019 DGA docudrama RT21 Crunchyroll Sundance TV 007 blaxploitation Spike Disney Plus reviews Dark Horse Comics Nat Geo Podcast Character Guide Captain marvel biography spinoff Polls and Games mission: impossible stoner sag awards golden globes Tubi TV Land politics historical drama San Diego Comic-Con Sundance Now Tomatazos psycho Teen festivals asian-american Reality unscripted Marvel CBS Animation VICE crime Thanksgiving Lifetime Baby Yoda Warner Bros. First Reviews video kids doctor who Reality Competition aliens Pride Month Winter TV teaser facebook Mary Poppins Returns Logo adventure MTV Freeform transformers franchise Amazon Prime movie game of thrones dark CNN HBO YouTube Red singing competition Sony Pictures Fantasy 45 ABC Family Universal cancelled TV series medical drama adaptation Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Awards Tour Action 24 frames A24 thriller revenge talk show Super Bowl space ESPN Countdown Drama CBS All Access Masterpiece jamie lee curtis Ghostbusters First Look serial killer IFC Music cats Disney streaming service Trophy Talk scary movies Pet Sematary Chernobyl Country Box Office comics BBC BET halloween spanish language TIFF FX DC streaming service AMC The Purge Disney Channel Vudu Infographic Anna Paquin latino spain toy story Black Mirror Women's History Month OneApp Video Games Writers Guild of America Red Carpet psychological thriller Comic Book cinemax cancelled TV shows Musicals vampires spy thriller Marvel Studios BBC America travel casting 2015 Pop TV Spring TV zombie Adult Swim Rom-Com Black History Month TruTV best Stephen King Hear Us Out mockumentary Britbox theme song Netflix Christmas movies composers 2016 Classic Film all-time christmas movies YouTube Brie Larson Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt SundanceTV cartoon elevated horror disaster OWN Mindy Kaling Binge Guide strong female leads Summer TNT