Showdowns

Supernatural vs. Scooby-Doo

They're some of entertainment's most long-running monster hunters, but which team is greatest? We're breaking it down by Tomatometer, popularity, and more.

by | April 27, 2020 | Comments

Got a ghost problem? A rogue vampire keeping you up at night? A spawn of Satan disturbing your peace? If so, there are two teams you can rely on to crack the case: The Winchester Brothers of TV’s Supernatural or the “Scooby Gang” and its hilarious namesake, Scooby-Doo. But which is better suited to solve your supernatural issues? In our latest episode of Vs., we’re pitting the long-running series Supernatural against everything Scooby-Doo – the original cartoon, its spin-offs, and the live-action movies. Which mystery-solvers are more popular with the people and the critics? Which franchise features the richest characters? And which team has faced off against the most dastardly villains? Find out as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis breaks it down to decide whether you should hop in the Mystery Van or the Winchesters’ Chevy when the ghouls come a-calling.

As ever, if you don’t agree with our choice of winner, let us have it in the comments.


Scoob! will be released digitally May 15, 2020. Supernatural airs on the CW, next air dates are unknown. 

#1

Scoob! (2020)
47%

#1
Adjusted Score: 53.006%
Critics Consensus: Scoob! is fun enough for youthful viewers and some hardcore fans, but never quite solves the mystery of why audiences shouldn't watch old episodes instead.
Synopsis: "SCOOB!" reveals how lifelong friends Scooby and Shaggy first met and how they joined with young detectives Fred, Velma and... [More]
Directed By: Tony Cervone

Thumbnail: CW / © Warner Bros.

Tag Cloud

PBS TV renewals Creative Arts Emmys video on demand GLAAD Freeform critics American Society of Cinematographers Cartoon Network Rocketman Premiere Dates war MTV dceu stop motion Quiz Certified Fresh christmas movies VICE based on movie Awards Nat Geo Disney Plus franchise Paramount crime telelvision Drama Starz Sneak Peek Sundance Film Festival ABC Signature dc Binge Guide diversity breaking bad elevated horror classics The Academy series kaiju Ghostbusters television ViacomCBS Marvel Television Bravo Hear Us Out DC streaming service Pirates adaptation crime drama Tumblr spy thriller CW Seed Amazon Prime Video werewolf dark Marvel Studios Cannes casting Comic Book Apple BET Awards festivals boxoffice Photos Logo Anna Paquin sequel 21st Century Fox FX zombie HBO Go BAFTA Superheroe Baby Yoda Calendar Endgame Holiday X-Men 4/20 Walt Disney Pictures Disney YA Music Mystery President obituary cancelled TV shows indie football historical drama TCM Winners Musicals cults space Interview thriller cancelled true crime 2017 Kids & Family RT21 Infographic facebook TV Land Crackle Academy Awards Opinion Schedule tv talk Classic Film Reality superman Esquire godzilla social media cartoon Writers Guild of America Fall TV ratings Lucasfilm Broadway Comics on TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Star Wars australia BBC One versus Women's History Month Elton John Spectrum Originals TCA Winter 2020 parents anime animated IFC Films 20th Century Fox asian-american RT History ESPN superhero transformers strong female leads Extras Oscars TCA Mudbound emmy awards CMT Super Bowl canceled chucky Netflix Christmas movies The Witch AMC cancelled TV series romantic comedy crime thriller Disney streaming service scorecard a nightmare on elm street period drama Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TV One MCU technology Columbia Pictures binge halloween tv Fantasy comiccon Chernobyl nbcuniversal monster movies CBS Grammys Valentine's Day Lifetime Christmas movies sports blaxploitation USA GoT laika child's play Exclusive Video spanish language latino DC Universe Emmys name the review ID Discovery Channel hispanic Hulu children's TV DirecTV universal monsters Emmy Nominations halloween Crunchyroll Song of Ice and Fire Trivia Epix The Purge Amazon Prime Alien APB TCA Awards TIFF foreign rt archives movie NYCC BET Biopics ghosts Musical Thanksgiving award winner dragons WarnerMedia revenge 99% kong serial killer Mary Poppins Returns The Walking Dead WGN streaming movies rotten best Mary Tyler Moore VOD IFC miniseries Pet Sematary Mary poppins Election Western 71st Emmy Awards Tomatazos Year in Review 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards FX on Hulu TCA 2017 slashers doctor who Captain marvel First Reviews Lionsgate The Walt Disney Company YouTube Premium History HBO Max Sony Pictures CBS All Access Action sitcom unscripted fresh razzies king kong Spring TV Travel Channel El Rey The Arrangement game show Nickelodeon disaster CNN Podcast aliens FXX TLC adventure Britbox Amazon cinemax Avengers indiana jones finale romance 2019 Sundance TV Pop TV Rom-Com Black Mirror stoner zero dark thirty Rock blockbusters satire renewed TV shows crossover teaser archives vampires zombies Set visit comedies singing competition reboot Holidays Universal travel Animation Country See It Skip It Teen Pixar nfl trailers E! Sci-Fi reviews composers LGBT VH1 Dark Horse Comics Ellie Kemper comic books kids E3 Martial Arts biography The CW Masterpiece docuseries Cosplay toy story sag awards Nominations OWN Awards Tour worst sequels prank what to watch discovery cars Comedy GIFs Vudu Netflix quibi Peacock japanese directors spinoff HBO Mindy Kaling Funimation toronto 2015 PaleyFest Syfy Reality Competition Disney Channel science fiction First Look mockumentary spain Family Comedy Central SDCC Polls and Games concert films justice league hollywood cops Marvel game of thrones video witnail Tarantino green book free movies Video Games criterion TBS black natural history festival 2016 Countdown Superheroes Acorn TV ABC Family cats golden globes TruTV venice comic Sundance Now Spike screenings MSNBC Ovation Stephen King richard e. Grant Film Fox News Trailer 007 spanish joker canceled TV shows spider-man comics LGBTQ YouTube Red talk show boxing medical drama Warner Bros. mission: impossible National Geographic A24 Best and Worst New York Comic Con BBC America Horror popular Pop stand-up comedy remakes jurassic park DGA Legendary Paramount Plus rotten movies we love ABC Lifetime dogs die hard TNT Turner Classic Movies 72 Emmy Awards jamie lee curtis SXSW Paramount Network Fox Searchlight batman Marathons Christmas theme song Character Guide ITV Amazon Studios Box Office south america Television Critics Association YouTube Apple TV+ pirates of the caribbean james bond Toys cancelled television FOX 2018 Arrowverse Trophy Talk screen actors guild NBC Watching Series PlayStation Summer scary movies italian TV independent Showtime Hallmark Christmas movies blockbuster dramedy golden globe awards BBC Hallmark OneApp police drama all-time documentary mutant cooking documentaries Red Carpet hidden camera Brie Larson book psychological thriller 2021 Black History Month USA Network french 2020 Shondaland fast and furious Apple TV Plus Disney+ Disney Plus DC Comics San Diego Comic-Con 45 harry potter 24 frames Winter TV A&E SundanceTV hist political drama Pride Month anthology Rocky women Tubi supernatural rom-coms Turner Star Trek Heroines worst movies Shudder psycho Television Academy twilight Adult Swim nature politics deadpool docudrama robots Food Network news