Showdowns

Supernatural vs. Scooby-Doo

They're some of entertainment's most long-running monster hunters, but which team is greatest? We're breaking it down by Tomatometer, popularity, and more.

by | April 27, 2020 | Comments

Got a ghost problem? A rogue vampire keeping you up at night? A spawn of Satan disturbing your peace? If so, there are two teams you can rely on to crack the case: The Winchester Brothers of TV’s Supernatural or the “Scooby Gang” and its hilarious namesake, Scooby-Doo. But which is better suited to solve your supernatural issues? In our latest episode of Vs., we’re pitting the long-running series Supernatural against everything Scooby-Doo – the original cartoon, its spin-offs, and the live-action movies. Which mystery-solvers are more popular with the people and the critics? Which franchise features the richest characters? And which team has faced off against the most dastardly villains? Find out as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis breaks it down to decide whether you should hop in the Mystery Van or the Winchesters’ Chevy when the ghouls come a-calling.

As ever, if you don’t agree with our choice of winner, let us have it in the comments.


Scoob! will be released digitally May 15, 2020. Supernatural airs on the CW, next air dates are unknown. 

#1

SCOOB! (2020)
48%

#1
Adjusted Score: 56943%
Critics Consensus: Scoob! is fun enough for youthful viewers and some hardcore fans, but never quite solves the mystery of why audiences shouldn't watch old episodes instead.
Synopsis: With hundreds of cases solved and adventures shared, Scooby and the gang face their biggest, most challenging mystery ever --... [More]
Directed By: Tony Cervone

Thumbnail: CW / © Warner Bros.

Tag Cloud

Paramount Plus Marvel Studios 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Family Masterpiece art house football worst movies black Opinion stop motion animated Wes Anderson worst Reality President feel good boxoffice kong thriller Interview Acorn TV science fiction Nat Geo hidden camera Rock Pride Month tv talk NBC latino spinoff biopic Television Critics Association Tomatazos jamie lee curtis OneApp Drama cats Captain marvel unscripted Emmy Nominations medical drama Marvel Television social media Discovery Channel Year in Review CMT screen actors guild best Mary poppins Turner Classic Movies aapi Amazon Prime Winter TV criterion Comic-Con@Home 2021 PaleyFest singing competition TV TV movies Sundance Quiz Anna Paquin romance scary movies war toy story Ovation Disney Channel video politics rotten movies we love reboot zombies hollywood Binge Guide 2021 The Walt Disney Company Musical emmy awards zero dark thirty reviews international psychological thriller a nightmare on elm street Reality Competition Fox Searchlight Mudbound young adult anime olympics Fargo Song of Ice and Fire crime thriller Premiere Dates docudrama LGBT dexter stoner Mary Poppins Returns live action monster movies TCA Awards discovery Walt Disney Pictures TV Land 45 Black History Month finale twilight halloween tv 2019 MCU Showtime Rocketman Christmas royal family Alien rom-coms true crime YouTube Premium prank Crackle rt labs harry potter 2018 mutant cinemax Toys IFC Films comics facebook deadpool Apple TV Plus anthology razzies slasher universal monsters Elton John RT History 21st Century Fox SXSW Comedy The Arrangement Tokyo Olympics Extras Nickelodeon 4/20 biography Disney Instagram Live Certified Fresh fast and furious ViacomCBS ABC Signature Avengers Heroines concert new york high school Calendar blaxploitation movies Rom-Com Food Network Amazon Prime Video batman sag awards comedies kaiju talk show Hallmark Christmas movies 93rd Oscars laika Sci-Fi mcc Sneak Peek cartoon godzilla marvel cinematic universe Shudder spider-man quibi Superheroes Fox News festivals saw Paramount Network dceu Adult Swim italian Shondaland superman Syfy Watching Series remakes women Tumblr RT21 composers Photos Polls and Games BBC One Freeform dc theme song pirates of the caribbean name the review scary obituary Universal X-Men Set visit children's TV japan El Rey CNN video on demand docuseries hispanic VICE AMC Plus Paramount Hallmark critics vs. Crunchyroll mockumentary Action legend new star wars movies blockbuster Rocky Red Carpet Disney Plus ABC The Witch telelvision Pop TV YA witnail hist DC Comics Kids & Family crime drama Grammys halloween TV renewals The Walking Dead diversity Classic Film streaming First Look DirecTV 2015 rt archives trailers Epix Spring TV Emmys chucky ghosts Ellie Kemper DC streaming service action-comedy black comedy archives Vudu TLC Cannes Comic Book IFC Holiday TCA Winter 2020 Columbia Pictures cars comic book movie Disney streaming service 2016 cancelled TV shows book adaptation transformers dragons golden globes classics Neflix Writers Guild of America BET Mindy Kaling screenings debate indiana jones Tubi doctor who Cartoon Network Lifetime Funimation Film Awards 73rd Emmy Awards satire TNT crime Countdown television ratings FXX critic resources richard e. Grant historical drama Image Comics political drama festival Summer FOX Star Wars king arthur robots ABC Family adenture game show cancelled television SDCC BAFTA MTV heist movie dramedy Comics on TV Marvel USA Trailer TCA 2017 ID Character Guide FX First Reviews king kong Pop golden globe awards BBC America See It Skip It genre fresh GoT Television Academy The Academy foreign Pirates TruTV LGBTQ Best and Worst vampires PBS Broadway police drama cops Western hispanic heritage month Netflix spy thriller sequel USA Network franchise Holidays zombie basketball nature venice die hard travel Trivia rotten Hulu VOD SundanceTV technology BET Awards justice league dark sports series Teen WGN 72 Emmy Awards San Diego Comic-Con toronto Video Games comic book movies breaking bad Sundance TV TCA asian-american Election award winner superhero Sundance Now cults australia The CW HBO cooking nfl dogs IMDb TV MSNBC movie NBA news 90s aliens WarnerMedia Mystery comic ESPN cancelled parents 2017 teaser Comedy Central Super Bowl blockbusters rt labs critics edition Arrowverse 1990s BBC free movies Ghostbusters independent canceled TV shows natural history mob CW Seed Warner Bros. VH1 NYCC mission: impossible Dark Horse Comics TV One space indie films Awards Tour Musicals sequels DC Universe comiccon werewolf Academy Awards Pacific Islander TBS spanish language slashers gangster wonder woman Peacock south america comic books jurassic park strong female leads AMC sopranos American Society of Cinematographers Winners YouTube crossover sitcom spanish Biopics Pixar TCM serial killer documentary christmas movies Horror new zealand renewed TV shows live event directors binge 71st Emmy Awards Spectrum Originals target 007 E! 24 frames National Geographic canceled Amazon casting DGA ITV Superheroe james bond YouTube Red Exclusive Video Trophy Talk know your critic Apple TV+ FX on Hulu streaming movies The Purge Animation Bravo Fall TV PlayStation dreamworks Infographic Thanksgiving posters all-time CBS All Access lord of the rings green book nbcuniversal E3 elevated horror spain Legendary child's play based on movie Martial Arts cancelled TV series disaster Britbox HBO Max 2020 suspense 20th Century Fox HBO Go Mary Tyler Moore Turner OWN 99% Box Office miniseries Creative Arts Emmys Disney+ Disney Plus Film Festival joker Cosplay scorecard revenge Amazon Studios Starz what to watch Travel Channel History Marathons Netflix Christmas movies APB New York Comic Con Music Spike psycho TIFF kids Oscars spider-verse scene in color Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt book Chilling Adventures of Sabrina supernatural CBS Black Mirror A&E french popular Women's History Month Tarantino Lucasfilm adaptation Star Trek Baby Yoda Logo Endgame stand-up comedy Stephen King A24 Podcast Brie Larson adventure romantic comedy GLAAD Schedule game of thrones Valentine's Day Country boxing Universal Pictures Esquire GIFs japanese Lionsgate Hear Us Out Sony Pictures documentaries Apple marvel comics versus Fantasy period drama Chernobyl Nominations Pet Sematary Lifetime Christmas movies