Critics Consensus

Suicide Squad Shoots Itself in the Foot

Plus Nine Lives wasn't screened for critics, and The Little Prince is Certified Fresh.

by | August 4, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a team of villains (Suicide Squad, starring Will Smith and Margot Robbie) and a man in a cat’s body (Nine Lives, starring Kevin Spacey and Jennifer Garner). What do the critics have to say?


Suicide Squad (2016) 26%

Everyone wants their own shared cinematic universe these days, and on paper, Warner Bros. has a better shot than most, but their DC Extended Universe — DCEU for short, natch — has had a bumpy early go of it. Suicide Squad  was supposed to be the movie that finally turned things around, with a killer cast (including Viola Davis, Margot Robbie, Will Smith, and Jared Leto) and an entertaining premise assembling a team of superpowered villains to save the world from an even greater threat. Unfortunately, the DCEU remains DOA among critics; while more than a few reviews spare some kind words for the performances (particularly Robbie and Smith’s) and the welcome influx of humor, none of it’s enough to rescue what most scribes describe as a muddled, mind-numbingly over-the-top, and overall unpleasant affair. Diehard fans may find a few fun set pieces among the noisy wreckage, but on the whole, it’s hard to see much more than missed opportunities here.


Nine Lives (2016) 14%

It’s been an awfully long time since Hollywood gave us a good old-fashioned heartwarming comedy about a person whose spirit gets trapped in the body of an animal, and we’d love to be able to tell you that this weekend’s Nine Lives — starring Kevin Spacey as a billionaire whose consciousness ends up in a cat — lives up to the time-honored standard set by the classics of the genre. Alas, the picture hasn’t been screened for critics, so you know what that means: it’s time to Guess the Tomatometer!


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Little Men (2016) , about a friendship between two boys that’s threatened by a conflict between their parents, is at 95 percent.
  • The Little Prince (2015) , an animated adaptation of Antoine de Saint-Exupéry’s classic tale featuring voice performances by Rachel McAdams and Jeff Bridges, is Certified Fresh at 93 percent.
  • Neither Heaven Nor Earth (2015) , about a troop of soldiers targeted by a mysterious threat in Afghanistan, is at 93 percent.
  • Richard Linklater: Dream Is Destiny (2016) , a documentary portrait of the director of Boyhood and Dazed and Confused, is at 91 percent.
  • Sun Choke (2015) , about the troubling aftermath of a woman’s nervous breakdown, is at 87 percent.
  • Citizen Soldier Birds Eye View (2016) , a documentary offering a soldier’s-eye view of modern warfare in the Middle East, is at 80 percent.
  • The Tenth Man (2016) , which explores the fraught parent-child dynamic through a narrative set against a religious backdrop, is at 78 percent.
  • The Mind's Eye (2015) , about a pair of people with psychokinetic powers on the run from an unscrupulous doctor, is at 73 percent.
  • Five Nights in Maine (2015) , starring David Oyelowo and Dianne Wiest in a drama about a grieving man who visits his mother in law after his wife’s death in a car accident, is at 33 percent.

Tag Cloud

politics technology comiccon MCU VICE Film Festival Amazon Nat Geo canceled TV shows Endgame CNN scary ViacomCBS transformers Paramount Plus rt archives versus movies Awards Crunchyroll Heroines Video Games crime thriller casting Holidays toy story biography latino Disney+ Disney Plus concert jamie lee curtis know your critic Apple Sundance batman Marvel Television basketball Pacific Islander Fox Searchlight Trailer DGA comics Pride Month Discovery Channel MTV critics National Geographic Turner Classic Movies ID movie psychological thriller festivals Paramount Network gangster Reality Competition See It Skip It 99% TV PlayStation docuseries Britbox Neflix Lifetime Lucasfilm Tokyo Olympics Arrowverse renewed TV shows Sneak Peek strong female leads BBC One indie Walt Disney Pictures tv talk Dark Horse Comics singing competition independent new york Amazon Prime Video book italian Drama DirecTV LGBT black obituary comic sag awards cancelled theme song 71st Emmy Awards cooking LGBTQ unscripted Captain marvel IFC Films Pixar comic books Pirates 2016 ESPN Netflix 4/20 crime drama olympics archives crossover Ghostbusters films art house Wes Anderson supernatural Marathons doctor who Horror documentary Adult Swim witnail Comics on TV Star Wars DC Universe TLC PaleyFest kaiju Apple TV+ Christmas AMC mockumentary Disney international blaxploitation boxoffice NBC justice league WarnerMedia Masterpiece hispanic Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt period drama spain saw werewolf robots Certified Fresh halloween tv Superheroes sports Oscars Comedy Central Lionsgate X-Men 2021 Calendar The Academy YouTube Premium diversity dreamworks Acorn TV adventure trophy FX on Hulu AMC Plus spinoff First Reviews action-comedy children's TV spider-verse Rocky Ovation high school criterion Peacock Avengers facebook Prime Video australia dark 73rd Emmy Awards rom-coms Sundance TV OWN spy thriller Sundance Now USA Network Food Network Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Alien Comedy television CBS All Access Biopics trailers ITV telelvision San Diego Comic-Con Lifetime Christmas movies prank blockbuster HBO Go animated streaming movies best binge Disney streaming service Legendary Stephen King Elton John TCA 2017 new zealand TBS critic resources boxing 93rd Oscars dragons Freeform 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards twilight HBO Max serial killer Best and Worst DC Comics Martial Arts fresh Superheroe fast and furious remakes popular Exclusive Video cinemax award winner Mystery marvel comics sopranos based on movie Amazon Studios VOD news romantic comedy YouTube miniseries GIFs TV movies 2018 free movies Starz Epix french universal monsters Summer crime canceled screenings FOX 007 BAFTA The Purge kids Shudder A24 Pop TV golden globes APB heist movie Mary Tyler Moore james bond mission: impossible Comic-Con@Home 2021 Trivia slashers hidden camera BBC Mary poppins christmas movies Mary Poppins Returns Polls and Games godzilla space posters Premiere Dates dogs festival reviews cults NYCC SDCC ABC stop motion vs. YA 2017 OneApp game of thrones Winners Baby Yoda 2015 Star Trek mutant WGN chucky true crime Spike GoT marvel cinematic universe Kids & Family name the review cars Character Guide Emmys adenture Infographic die hard superhero genre Chernobyl Year in Review laika directors 90s lord of the rings video Amazon Prime stoner target Rock rotten slasher kong USA Esquire Funimation Women's History Month mcc PBS Pet Sematary History Black Mirror 79th Golden Globes Awards dceu Awards Tour dc Image Comics pirates of the caribbean Academy Awards Tumblr scene in color Shondaland Comic Book screen actors guild Syfy Toys sitcom spanish talk show king arthur 21st Century Fox anthology Spring TV MSNBC king kong TV Land Musicals all-time Set visit cats joker Classic Film nbcuniversal Travel Channel breaking bad Tomatazos Film cartoon Countdown Nominations Cosplay police drama hollywood psycho 1990s BBC America anime Action Fantasy video on demand historical drama RT21 Family Box Office Columbia Pictures Fall TV Winter TV book adaptation 2020 Watching Series Writers Guild of America dexter Apple TV Plus nfl The Arrangement parents Disney Plus franchise Ellie Kemper Photos cancelled television scorecard E! game show leaderboard ABC Signature Tubi Tags: Comedy CW Seed Nickelodeon halloween venice Musical Bravo spider-man mob Universal VH1 vampires Teen sequel Mudbound green book aliens Pop zombie Grammys romance Rom-Com Interview 72 Emmy Awards monster movies Fox News Showtime ABC Family Cartoon Network Extras TV One young adult japan social media debate The CW The Witch emmy awards travel Opinion CBS royal family TNT hispanic heritage month FXX Spectrum Originals blockbusters science fiction The Walking Dead YouTube Red Crackle IMDb TV Anna Paquin new star wars movies American Society of Cinematographers SXSW wonder woman child's play satire BET women natural history NBA DC streaming service revenge Broadway aapi Schedule live action composers Quiz Creative Arts Emmys spanish language FX TCA Winter 2020 Universal Pictures black comedy The Walt Disney Company hist finale TCM football Instagram Live El Rey zombies cancelled TV series elevated horror HBO stand-up comedy richard e. Grant Holiday razzies RT History rt labs critics edition documentaries Song of Ice and Fire nature A&E dramedy ghosts TIFF worst movies asian-american Binge Guide Mindy Kaling HFPA thriller Rocketman comic book movies docudrama series President Fargo ratings cancelled TV shows Western Turner TruTV Hollywood Foreign Press Association disaster classics Election Marvel biopic Hallmark Christmas movies Sony Pictures Vudu Country japanese indiana jones legend Warner Bros. Emmy Nominations Animation foreign Hulu Red Carpet First Look 45 IFC Music TCA Awards political drama BET Awards Black History Month Reality what to watch reboot comic book movie deadpool 20th Century Fox Cannes Television Academy SundanceTV quibi Brie Larson streaming scary movies cops TCA medical drama worst superman Television Critics Association Tarantino adaptation CMT Sci-Fi Logo Hallmark New York Comic Con Paramount discovery a nightmare on elm street Valentine's Day GLAAD Podcast rotten movies we love Netflix Christmas movies Hear Us Out Thanksgiving Super Bowl harry potter 24 frames zero dark thirty teaser south america TV renewals suspense E3 rt labs golden globe awards jurassic park feel good Marvel Studios 2019 war live event toronto Disney Channel Trophy Talk comedies sequels