The Zeros

Staying Alive Should Have Kept Saturday Night Fever's Dark, Sweaty, Coked-Up Soul

Sylvester Stallone's 0%-rated follow-up is a watered-down fantasy that tames John Travolta's sexy, raging id, and it's officially 35 years old.

by | July 11, 2018 | Comments

Behind the Zero

(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

One of the many things that made 1978’s Saturday Night Fever so enduring — as well as achingly sad — was the strong implication that, for all of his talent, swagger, sexiness, and charisma, teenaged anti-hero Tony Manero (John Travolta) would probably never realize his dreams and become a hotshot professional dancer.

There’s simply too much fierce competition for just a tiny number of slots, and Tony lacked the training, polish, and connections to set him apart from the rest of the fray. Furthermore, in director John Badham’s grim masterpiece (which Rocky director John G. Avildsen was slated to direct before parting ways over creative differences), Tony generally proved to be his own worst enemy, with a smart mouth, explosive temper, and penchant for violence that collectively had a way of slamming shut the doors that his talent, charm, and looks opened for him.

In other words, Tony Manero was a small-time loser with big-time ambitions. He was racist, virulently misogynistic, narcissistic, and indifferent to the suffering of others, most notably Annette (Donna Pescow), a vulnerable, heartbreakingly sad admirer who followed him like a lost puppy the entire film and was repaid for her devotion with a sexual assault by two members of Tony’s creepy gang, who had all of his many horrible flaws and none of his redeeming virtues. Even Tony’s climactic dance contest win in Saturday Night Fever was tainted by the racism of a crowd that only voted for him and his partner because they were white, unlike the couple that deserved to win.

Movies are full of purehearted dreamers who overcome formidable obstacles through talent, will, and a ferocious determination never to give up, no matter how bleak things might look, and Saturday Night Fever, to its eternal credit, is not one of those movies. Staying Alive, however, to its eternal detriment, most assuredly is. It shamelessly embraces all of the hoary show business and dance movie cliches its predecessor boldly eschewed.

To put things in animation terms, between John Badham’s Oscar-nominated 1978 film and Sylvester Stallone’s 1983 follow-up, the vibe went from Ralph Bakshi‘s New York grit and grime to Walt Disney’s sweetness, polish, and shine. Alternately, if the classic Italian neorealist milestone The Bicycle Thieves had spawned a sequel in which struggling father Antonio recovered his bike, trained under the mentorship of a gruff but kindly veteran cyclist, and won the Tour de France, the tonal shift would have been every bit as jarring, insane, and shameless as Staying Alive’s brazen switch from hard-edged realism to gaudy wish fulfillment fantasy. Staying Alive was a commercial success, to be sure, but at the cost of Saturday Night Fever’s dark, sweaty, coked-up soul.

The Zero

Paramount Pictures courtesy Everett Collection

(Photo by Paramount Pictures courtesy Everett Collection)

Staying Alive trades Brooklyn for Broadway as its primary setting and a very 1970s darkness and social consciousness for 1980s upbeat flash. Tony is no longer a pill-popping degenerate who lives with his folks, works at a hardware store, and wows the ladies at dance clubs, but a focused, disciplined winner ferociously devoted to chasing his dreams.

Tony has similarly ditched the posse of poignantly pathetic, drug-addled, violently misogynistic bigots in order to pursue his noble aspirations to Broadway stardom. He’s off drugs and high on life. He doesn’t curse anymore. He doesn’t smoke, he doesn’t drink, and he doesn’t beat up people of color. His only real remaining vice is women, and even in that department he’s evolved from Neanderthal cretin to nice guy, though he finds it exceedingly difficult to stay faithful, and his affections are split between a pair of love interests who fall rather neatly into the categories of devilish diva and girl next door.

The better Tony is as a human being, though, the worse he is as an anti-hero, and that is not good for the movie as a whole. Staying Alive shaves away all the rough edges that made Tony so compelling, rendering him another generic dreamer distinguished only by the fact that he looks, moves, and talks like John Travolta near the prime of his youth.

The girl next door is Jackie (Cynthia Rhodes), a sweet, modestly talented dancer and singer Tony likes enough to string along — but not enough to commit to her, although he does get awfully jealous when he sees Carl, with whom Jackie has sizzling musical chemistry onstage, gazing longingly at her. Incidentally, Carl is played by Frank Stallone (i.e. brother to Sylvester), who also wrote and performed much of the music on the soundtrack, and whose song “Far from Over” landed in the top 10 and earned him both Golden Globe and Grammy nominations.

The other, more important love interest is Laura (future soap opera queen Finola Hughes), a posh British dancer and woman of wealth and taste who takes a fancy to Tony, but only as a boy toy, a sexual conquest to be used and then discarded when she tires of him. That proves more difficult than anticipated when, due to Tony’s unbelievable, irrepressible talent, as well as the time-honored cliches frequently found in movies like this, he’s promoted to male lead of Satan’s Alley, the hilariously overwrought Broadway extravaganza at the film’s core.

(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

Saturday Night Fever benefited from an almost documentary-like sense of verisimilitude — it was pop sociology you could dance to — whereas Staying Alive hilariously depicts the Broadway world of the early 1980s as overwhelmingly heterosexual and drug-free, even as Satan’s Alley is comically over-the-top in its homoeroticism. The big closing production number is one third proto-Showgirls kitsch minus the satire, irony, and self-consciousness; one third singing, dancing outtake from William Friedkin’s notorious drama Cruising; and one third knock-off of The Apple. The sexed-up, scowling choreography, meanwhile, suggests something Bob Fosse might come up with if he were hit in the head and suffered a neurological malady that removed all his talent.

It speaks to the profound disconnect in tone and quality between Saturday Night Fever and its dopey, widely despised follow-up that Tony spends much of the film apologizing for the way he behaved in the first film, for being a potty-mouthed (no place for that in a PG-rated, family-friendly film like Staying Alive!), woman-hating, pill-popping, disrespectful creep.

In real life, that would be an admirable gesture. Here, it feels like Tony is apologizing for everything that made his character complicated and interesting in Saturday Night Fever. When he apologizes to his skeptical mother in Staying Alive, Tony even tells her that the sober, hardworking young mensch she sees before her is the real Tony.

“That wasn’t the real you back then?” she inquires earnestly, to which Tony answers, “Yeah.”

In actuality, the real Tony Manero is the sexy, darkly magnetic monster of id and ego from the first film. It’s this domesticated clone, who looks like the old Tony but doesn’t talk or act anything like him, who seems egregiously phony, as does Staying Alive as a whole.

Final Verdict

(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

Travolta may be playing a perversely cleaned up and watered down version of one of his signature characters, a kinder, gentler striver you would be happy to bring home to mother, but the Grease superstar and pop icon nevertheless oozes boyish charm, sexiness, and blinding movie star charisma.

He’s almost too appealing and likable here, since it was precisely that air of incoherent, bottomless rage that made his Oscar-nominated performance in Saturday Night Fever so riveting and endlessly rewatchable. As a follow-up to an unexpected American classic, Staying Alive is an insult to everything its predecessor stood for. As a vehicle for Travolta’s movie star magnetism, however, it’s full of breezy pleasures. 

Ultimately, Staying Alive is ragingly imperfect, and it does many things very, very wrong, but there is at least one thing that it does very right.

At the very end of the movie, after he’s triumphed in Satan’s Alley and really stuck it to his co-star and director with an elaborate, impromptu solo against their wishes, Tony decides to celebrate by strutting down the Manhattan sidewalk to the Bee Gees’ all-time great “Staying Alive.” Travolta shakes off the strictures of cliche, convention, and formula, and the film ends on a note of unexpected victory.

In a film ferociously devoted to doing whatever it thinks its audience wants, this final moment marks the only time when pandering to the audience turns out to be the right move. The ending, and only the ending, of Staying Alive is absolutely perfect. It cannot be improved upon. That alone is enough to distinguish it from every other film I’ve written about for this column so far.

Nathan Rabin is a freelance writer, columnist, the first head writer of The A.V. Club and the author of four books, most recently Weird Al: The Book (with “Weird Al” Yankovic) and You Don’t Know Me But You Don’t Like Me. Follow Nathan on Twitter: @NathanRabin

Tag Cloud

zombie black comedy Paramount Plus Pop TV political drama CNN revenge composers Black History Month movies Quiz Star Wars prank First Reviews BET Awards stand-up comedy IFC Films Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Animation TruTV 2019 Television Academy kids mutant spain X-Men italian President Chernobyl Nat Geo Sneak Peek green book Calendar hollywood TV One BBC One Syfy Reality Comics on TV australia book pirates of the caribbean mob halloween tv toy story justice league thriller TV renewals spanish MCU crime Star Trek black hispanic heritage month sopranos a nightmare on elm street slasher rt archives Teen finale 45 deadpool critics dc golden globe awards biography posters crime drama PlayStation foreign TCM chucky theme song NBC Comedy Central Trailer SundanceTV talk show Film police drama disaster 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Spike Pacific Islander Columbia Pictures Black Mirror Tarantino comics Oscars Thanksgiving streaming 71st Emmy Awards breaking bad YouTube Red fresh Funimation Amazon Prime cancelled television VICE Esquire Adult Swim know your critic Writers Guild of America Pet Sematary aliens National Geographic Fall TV olympics television adventure casting Best and Worst Marvel Television DC Comics serial killer award winner spanish language gangster Extras unscripted criterion HBO Go TNT YA name the review TBS crossover The Arrangement dramedy FOX E3 football comic Broadway Music sequel south america lord of the rings The Purge Mudbound 73rd Emmy Awards Image Comics films supernatural action-comedy spider-verse international BAFTA DC Universe TV Land CW Seed Tubi BBC satire halloween Instagram Live game of thrones Binge Guide ABC elevated horror Martial Arts Opinion Universal Pictures dexter TCA Awards hidden camera The CW dogs Biopics telelvision joker BET superman Stephen King Marvel Studios Classic Film El Rey TV Fox News festivals Musicals latino aapi king arthur blockbuster TCA 2017 OWN Legendary Comedy archives San Diego Comic-Con free movies dark canceled TV shows indiana jones universal monsters Freeform WGN Hear Us Out travel what to watch razzies canceled Reality Competition FX comic book movie Crackle Holiday witnail Mary Tyler Moore Wes Anderson Superheroes VOD kaiju fast and furious ABC Family festival animated Certified Fresh Tokyo Olympics 93rd Oscars HBO Pixar Film Festival Sundance TV zombies Rocketman Mary poppins sitcom superhero ID Amazon adaptation Rock AMC Ovation Year in Review legend Disney+ Disney Plus romance biopic Ghostbusters SXSW toronto true crime Family rotten New York Comic Con parents Marvel harry potter Pride Month comiccon all-time Cartoon Network Walt Disney Pictures The Walking Dead Bravo Pop kong scary movies Country Horror LGBTQ BBC America Rocky teaser ITV USA 007 Summer book adaptation APB scary Ellie Kemper wonder woman E! TCA Winter 2020 werewolf FXX historical drama DirecTV Holidays french Musical ABC Signature The Witch Vudu CBS All Access anime die hard diversity Countdown 2017 cartoon suspense crime thriller Watching Series twilight batman HBO Max Fox Searchlight live event Comic-Con@Home 2021 adenture remakes Captain marvel new star wars movies Awards Tour Awards new zealand 2016 women The Academy Valentine's Day Epix cinemax nbcuniversal Premiere Dates cops Set visit Schedule Peacock LGBT 1990s screenings Comic Book rt labs critics edition Exclusive Video Disney Mystery indie Neflix Super Bowl video on demand ratings nature Masterpiece Election comic book movies nfl science fiction transformers DGA Discovery Channel IMDb TV A24 OneApp 2015 2020 war Endgame Pirates hispanic series monster movies YouTube Premium cancelled TV series mcc Arrowverse comic books Cannes MTV AMC Plus renewed TV shows vs. Sundance Now game show stoner Amazon Prime Video docuseries DC streaming service vampires TCA Sundance Academy Awards anthology art house Netflix Christmas movies basketball reviews Heroines YouTube screen actors guild Apple TV+ christmas movies CBS Sony Pictures Anna Paquin ghosts 2021 quibi psychological thriller streaming movies feel good Alien Disney Channel strong female leads PaleyFest worst movies miniseries genre Christmas period drama IFC 2018 robots Red Carpet Drama Lifetime Christmas movies target directors CMT marvel comics American Society of Cinematographers sports sequels Interview independent 24 frames Mindy Kaling cults child's play jurassic park VH1 comedies social media Video Games Travel Channel saw Logo discovery NYCC Song of Ice and Fire Crunchyroll stop motion Grammys 21st Century Fox Lionsgate Paramount Network Mary Poppins Returns franchise boxoffice Toys new york See It Skip It japanese Character Guide Photos Dark Horse Comics 4/20 heist movie technology rotten movies we love trailers news documentaries Lifetime golden globes asian-american Emmys Nickelodeon king kong 20th Century Fox Food Network Trophy Talk The Walt Disney Company FX on Hulu WarnerMedia popular obituary video Superheroe Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt singing competition USA Network TV movies ViacomCBS Baby Yoda dragons spinoff Creative Arts Emmys RT History Box Office docudrama worst cats 90s Disney Plus richard e. Grant movie Kids & Family Cosplay Universal binge medical drama best Hallmark Christmas movies young adult History Brie Larson doctor who Starz ESPN Winter TV versus Tumblr Polls and Games 99% laika rom-coms japan rt labs TLC Podcast emmy awards venice Spectrum Originals blaxploitation mission: impossible spider-man Britbox Warner Bros. jamie lee curtis natural history zero dark thirty tv talk based on movie reboot Trivia Action GoT MSNBC children's TV blockbusters Turner boxing Elton John spy thriller royal family Avengers hist 72 Emmy Awards Apple TV Plus Apple Showtime classics Turner Classic Movies Tomatazos A&E dreamworks godzilla cancelled scorecard RT21 Acorn TV Television Critics Association First Look romantic comedy politics Winners Women's History Month Hulu concert GIFs NBA live action cooking GLAAD Shudder Paramount Rom-Com TIFF SDCC Marathons space Amazon Studios Spring TV high school documentary Lucasfilm cars mockumentary PBS psycho critic resources slashers sag awards Emmy Nominations debate scene in color james bond Hallmark dceu Sci-Fi facebook Netflix marvel cinematic universe Shondaland Western Disney streaming service Nominations Infographic cancelled TV shows Fantasy