Star Wars Prequels vs. Star Wars Sequels: Which Trilogy Is Better?

Fandoms, unite: We're finally settling the Prequels vs. Sequels debate with a deep dive into box office results, Tomatometer scores, and the characters and moments that make us love Star Wars so damn much.

by | February 26, 2020 | Comments

OK, commenters: Fire up your engines because we’re tackling a big one in our latest edition of Vs., pitting the Star Wars Prequels against the Star Wars Sequels and declaring definitively which galactic triptych is the superior set of films. We’re looking at box office data and Tomatometer scores for Episodes 1-3 and 7-9, as well as which trilogy delivered the best moments and gave us the most memorable characters. Are you a Darth Maul vs. Qui-Gon vs. Obi-Wan person? Or do you prefer your lightsaber battles more of the Throne Room variety? Does a Jar Jar Binks outweigh the awesomeness of Ewan McGregor’s young Obi-Wan? And how do they compare to Babu Frik? Watch above as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis lays out the case for both trilogies and – bravely – declares a winner.

Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is available digitally on March 17, 2020. 

Adjusted Score: 84134%
Critics Consensus: Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker suffers from a frustrating lack of imagination, but concludes this beloved saga with fan-focused devotion.
Synopsis: When it's discovered that the evil Emperor Palpatine did not die at the hands of Darth Vader, the rebels must... [More]
Directed By: J.J. Abrams

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

live action DirecTV streaming movies gangster Sci-Fi New York Comic Con Disney Pop TV saw women art house Photos Anna Paquin laika mcc Tags: Comedy young adult Britbox CNN Avengers Kids & Family cancelled TV shows series foreign 2016 Showtime Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt OneApp Paramount Pictures Premiere Dates 24 frames comic book movie The Arrangement game show know your critic parents renewed TV shows anthology Adult Swim Acorn TV Calendar cats based on movie YouTube debate Syfy Lifetime Christmas movies transformers Star Trek festivals 21st Century Fox high school slashers sitcom DGA ABC Family sequels South by Southwest Film Festival Fall TV Captain marvel legend Logo Fox News Netflix Christmas movies travel marvel comics Cosplay trophy dragons Elton John President Academy Awards godzilla Best and Worst Rocketman news critic resources Funimation ABC Signature Awards Tour Film Food Network Music 99% OWN Television Academy dc sag awards scary 2020 blockbusters Binge Guide composers 2021 Apple Hallmark Christmas movies rotten movies we love CW Seed Black Mirror screenings SXSW 2022 ESPN aliens war adenture Netflix 93rd Oscars criterion ID south america Comic-Con@Home 2021 james bond 90s book adaptation NYCC joker scorecard Reality 4/20 venice A&E period drama BBC America VOD TV psycho spinoff Disney streaming service Character Guide halloween tv blockbuster canceled Spectrum Originals binge dark festival reviews VICE new zealand TCA Winter 2020 toy story comiccon telelvision streamig Quiz crime Cartoon Network Travel Channel genre rom-coms a nightmare on elm street technology movie First Reviews Hear Us Out Black History Month Apple TV+ fast and furious romance Trophy Talk Baby Yoda Mary Poppins Returns diversity nature comic book movies richard e. Grant worst movies strong female leads 79th Golden Globes Awards remakes Hulu mockumentary kids spain Shondaland FX comics latino biopic Best Director Holiday new york royal family theme song PBS Sony Pictures adventure superhero popular Sundance TV Image Comics suspense Country Oscar Winter TV LGBTQ green book FOX Chernobyl king kong unscripted live event ghosts American Society of Cinematographers Musical Marvel Studios wonder woman cartoon SundanceTV Interview YouTube Red docudrama book Trivia See It Skip It rt archives 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards spider-verse worst 45 E3 biography HFPA kong Exclusive Video TCA Awards elevated horror Tubi Teen Extras zombie Lionsgate Holidays new star wars movies Star Wars cinemax WGN cults Spring TV superman Pride Month FX on Hulu Amazon Studios spanish language Amazon hispanic heritage month twilight 72 Emmy Awards Rock summer TV preview jamie lee curtis Fargo reboot YA Turner Classic Movies Lifetime Valentine's Day Ovation french Hallmark television broadcast Grammys Vudu Broadway Sundance Toys Pet Sematary science fiction Comic Book space HBO Go stop motion E! Certified Fresh Cannes CMT summer TV TNT Reality Competition First Look BBC One sports spy thriller hidden camera Dark Horse Comics cancelled television Disney+ Disney Plus casting Freeform Superheroes heist movie rotten singing competition Marvel Sneak Peek historical drama Opinion Countdown 2018 jurassic park National Geographic movies Super Bowl TruTV emmy awards 94th Oscars WarnerMedia San Diego Comic-Con golden globe awards football Amazon Prime Video social media Wes Anderson Arrowverse Election Mudbound supernatural Tarantino docuseries all-time Lucasfilm Thanksgiving RT21 stoner breaking bad TCA 2017 Mindy Kaling 1990s GLAAD IFC Comedy Central Best Picture cooking Mystery chucky PlayStation TCM Video Games razzies crime drama what to watch CBS All Access Watching Series anime australia Crackle 2015 Superheroe TLC Christmas Mary Tyler Moore Comics on TV Writers Guild of America crime thriller Television Critics Association Pixar Peacock revenge action-comedy Musicals slasher ratings black comedy true crime Brie Larson History Martial Arts Epix YouTube Premium leaderboard police drama Paramount Network obi wan TV renewals Marvel Television comic books crossover Biopics Rom-Com 73rd Emmy Awards Western Starz Discovery Channel Tumblr talk show christmas movies IMDb TV fresh archives films mission: impossible indie Creative Arts Emmys vampires 2017 scary movies cops The Purge Universal GoT Heroines Awards BBC streaming pirates of the caribbean CBS witnail posters teaser comedies Fantasy Drama GIFs Animation Instagram Live Universal Pictures toronto Nickelodeon prank MCU Winners Sundance Now LGBT cancelled TV series 2019 name the review boxing versus deadpool TCA japan international japanese scene in color asian-american politics Podcast critics award winner Amazon Prime aapi 71st Emmy Awards The Walking Dead satire VH1 child's play trailers Polls and Games nfl Chilling Adventures of Sabrina sequel MGM Emmys Focus Features Ellie Kemper canceled TV shows The CW TV One werewolf comic Disney Plus Tokyo Olympics rt labs critics edition Rocky Summer PaleyFest Schedule psychological thriller italian finale Song of Ice and Fire die hard Classic Film Red Carpet Family AMC Plus miniseries TBS Horror NBA romantic comedy Year in Review franchise discovery Neflix Paramount Plus dogs Spike Women's History Month screen actors guild Nominations AMC TV movies Oscars basketball dexter golden globes justice league harry potter USA Infographic nbcuniversal target Paramount black RT History The Witch thriller FXX Ghostbusters Alien Fox Searchlight dreamworks universal monsters quibi The Academy Disney Channel hollywood concert Best Actress Nat Geo 20th Century Fox video on demand Walt Disney Pictures mutant hispanic dceu Legendary Turner cars TV Land video zombies BAFTA ITV spider-man lord of the rings Trailer APB MTV Marathons best Emmy Nominations Warner Bros. Tomatazos Crunchyroll indiana jones HBO Max king arthur feel good monster movies NBC cancelled documentaries natural history marvel cinematic universe HBO mob spanish obituary ViacomCBS classics disaster USA Network Hollywood Foreign Press Association Film Festival DC Comics kaiju tv talk facebook Columbia Pictures rt labs zero dark thirty animated Pop Mary poppins El Rey olympics Prime Video directors sopranos robots BET Awards serial killer Apple TV Plus free movies Bravo ABC Comedy The Walt Disney Company independent Esquire vs. X-Men boxoffice TIFF game of thrones Action Best Actor summer preview documentary DC streaming service BET medical drama children's TV batman 007 Shudder political drama doctor who SXSW SDCC Masterpiece Pirates adaptation Box Office Stephen King Pacific Islander DC Universe Set visit halloween Endgame MSNBC stand-up comedy blaxploitation IFC Films dramedy A24 hist