Showdowns

Star Wars Prequels vs. Star Wars Sequels: Which Trilogy Is Better?

Fandoms, unite: We're finally settling the Prequels vs. Sequels debate with a deep dive into box office results, Tomatometer scores, and the characters and moments that make us love Star Wars so damn much.

by | February 26, 2020 | Comments

OK, commenters: Fire up your engines because we’re tackling a big one in our latest edition of Vs., pitting the Star Wars Prequels against the Star Wars Sequels and declaring definitively which galactic triptych is the superior set of films. We’re looking at box office data and Tomatometer scores for Episodes 1-3 and 7-9, as well as which trilogy delivered the best moments and gave us the most memorable characters. Are you a Darth Maul vs. Qui-Gon vs. Obi-Wan person? Or do you prefer your lightsaber battles more of the Throne Room variety? Does a Jar Jar Binks outweigh the awesomeness of Ewan McGregor’s young Obi-Wan? And how do they compare to Babu Frik? Watch above as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis lays out the case for both trilogies and – bravely – declares a winner.


Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is available digitally on March 17, 2020. 

#1
Adjusted Score: 79424%
Critics Consensus: Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker suffers from a frustrating lack of imagination, but concludes this beloved saga with fan-focused devotion.
Synopsis: Finn and Poe lead the Resistance to put a stop to the First Order's plans to form a new Empire,... [More]
Directed By: J.J. Abrams

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

women Photos WarnerMedia Mary Tyler Moore political drama french PBS sitcom video VICE 2015 comics razzies scary movies ratings Awards crossover spain See It Skip It Musical superman screen actors guild television The Purge dogs Summer james bond kids Rock Comedy boxoffice cults Action ABC Signature disaster Avengers kaiju cancelled TV shows OWN blockbusters Hulu Women's History Month worst movies sequel children's TV Video Games A24 best game show Rocky Red Carpet boxing zombies trailers hidden camera FOX feel good universal monsters Comic Book Mary poppins name the review TV movies 4/20 target Sundance versus Extras Toys olympics dramedy Reality Competition new star wars movies ID President reviews 71st Emmy Awards Grammys cooking 24 frames PaleyFest joker criterion San Diego Comic-Con SXSW Apple hispanic heritage month nfl miniseries slasher adventure ViacomCBS TV renewals Crackle Drama Box Office Pop TV true crime black action-comedy laika supernatural Kids & Family Amazon Studios Cosplay 1990s golden globes biopic anthology Best and Worst Quiz Musicals DC Comics 2016 mission: impossible king arthur 2021 Baby Yoda 2020 Funimation richard e. Grant SundanceTV Sneak Peek cars 2019 zero dark thirty Comedy Central dragons aliens Certified Fresh Masterpiece RT History Pet Sematary franchise Tubi Superheroe Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Stephen King streaming movies psycho sag awards monster movies BBC One revenge NBA book adaptation Marvel Television Freeform Sundance Now hist Thanksgiving E! harry potter kong The Arrangement Super Bowl APB justice league free movies Television Academy OneApp classics GIFs ABC chucky AMC Spike teaser award winner Tomatazos politics Bravo transformers legend Mystery 73rd Emmy Awards doctor who Classic Film DC Universe Hallmark Film The Witch TCA 2017 die hard FXX Fox News biography TV Warner Bros. Teen First Reviews Christmas Discovery Channel Disney Alien travel Binge Guide Paramount Plus quibi 45 BET what to watch spinoff Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Polls and Games cancelled Amazon Prime Video CMT mutant Music Arrowverse cancelled TV series hollywood Trivia singing competition 93rd Oscars emmy awards Western halloween tv debate royal family First Look documentaries films 2017 based on movie E3 binge obituary X-Men Disney Plus medical drama godzilla TCA marvel comics italian stoner Ellie Kemper Valentine's Day TLC posters Family international comedies social media YouTube Red science fiction YouTube Premium japan Premiere Dates HBO Go popular Interview Set visit Superheroes nbcuniversal telelvision Year in Review Black Mirror CBS All Access cancelled television Pirates high school LGBT Netflix Christmas movies Winners Vudu dexter crime thriller spanish jamie lee curtis asian-american National Geographic Starz Lifetime Christmas movies Animation Ovation Countdown deadpool diversity canceled football 2018 New York Comic Con parents Tokyo Olympics war facebook video on demand comic books Shudder independent spider-man comic Biopics Adult Swim comiccon stand-up comedy mcc documentary discovery Britbox Watching Series ESPN movie wonder woman Logo DGA Fall TV zombie SDCC Marvel Spectrum Originals Endgame Dark Horse Comics The Academy FX docudrama animated venice rt archives Hear Us Out Infographic Election Columbia Pictures comic book movies aapi strong female leads blaxploitation Black History Month ghosts TCA Awards Character Guide breaking bad CBS Pride Month tv talk Country El Rey Star Wars BET Awards comic book movie Spring TV rotten movies we love foreign Winter TV slashers Academy Awards BBC critic resources docuseries BAFTA concert stop motion CW Seed American Society of Cinematographers spy thriller prank DC streaming service USA Network 20th Century Fox Disney streaming service The Walking Dead Holiday adaptation satire 99% Fantasy A&E Tumblr Paramount Walt Disney Pictures period drama dceu new york screenings spanish language Horror TBS Tarantino Turner Trophy Talk Lionsgate IFC Chernobyl Hallmark Christmas movies indiana jones TNT Amazon Mudbound natural history Mary Poppins Returns book basketball pirates of the caribbean Writers Guild of America Song of Ice and Fire Sci-Fi TIFF superhero Disney+ Disney Plus fresh BBC America space crime adenture thriller Nat Geo fast and furious marvel cinematic universe series YouTube 90s Rocketman live action festivals Shondaland Crunchyroll nature MCU unscripted DirecTV TruTV rotten child's play jurassic park remakes Broadway new zealand theme song Netflix a nightmare on elm street RT21 HBO Max NYCC scorecard Brie Larson renewed TV shows rom-coms FX on Hulu talk show festival History WGN Nominations rt labs Opinion ABC Family heist movie Reality Cannes Mindy Kaling news Captain marvel 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards ITV vampires romantic comedy young adult king kong movies IFC Films psychological thriller Fox Searchlight CNN VOD Comic-Con@Home 2021 Apple TV Plus Lifetime anime Comics on TV Emmy Nominations 72 Emmy Awards mockumentary Sony Pictures Universal batman romance Podcast HBO Marvel Studios crime drama christmas movies sports suspense Schedule Heroines lord of the rings GoT TV Land Esquire The CW Film Festival cops Syfy PlayStation Acorn TV Calendar Legendary Sundance TV Image Comics witnail saw Trailer cartoon directors indie LGBTQ Emmys GLAAD TCM south america MTV Marathons TV One Showtime finale Food Network gangster blockbuster Rom-Com Cartoon Network Turner Classic Movies all-time Elton John reboot elevated horror technology Disney Channel latino streaming dark Travel Channel Martial Arts composers VH1 Paramount Network Star Trek twilight casting Creative Arts Emmys The Walt Disney Company green book Epix Nickelodeon cinemax Holidays police drama australia canceled TV shows robots scene in color dc historical drama MSNBC 007 TCA Winter 2020 know your critic Exclusive Video golden globe awards NBC sequels Amazon Prime worst toy story werewolf serial killer rt labs critics edition 21st Century Fox halloween critics toronto Awards Tour japanese game of thrones Television Critics Association Ghostbusters archives Pop USA Pacific Islander Apple TV+ Anna Paquin YA cats Oscars Pixar Wes Anderson Lucasfilm Peacock hispanic