Sherlock Fans React to Big Twist of Season 4’s ‘The Lying Detective’

Villain Culverton Smith crashes the second episode

by | January 8, 2017 | Comments

Culverton Smith (TOBY JONES), Sherlock Holmes (BENEDICT CUMBERBATCH) in Sherlock (Photo courtesy of Ollie Upton/Hartswood Films & MASTERPIECE)

Fans ❤ Sherlock and the cereal killer (it’s funny ’cause it’s true). The killer in question is wealthy psychopath Culverton Smith introduced in episode two of Sherlock season 4 on Sunday night — and played with relish by guest star Toby Jones.

And fans ate it up.

Warning: Stop reading if you have not watched the episode — spoilers ahead!

Sherlock Holmes (Benedict Cumberbatch) is apparently having a breakdown. After a particularly damaging drug binge, he’s got only maybe weeks to live, according to faithful Molly Hooper (Louise Brealey).

He’s also accusing a philanthropist of being a serial killer.

Turns out this perverse philanthropist has an admiration for the work of Dr. H.H. Holmes (no relation), the 1893 Chicago World’s Fair serial killer (and subject of the excellent New York Times bestselling non-fiction book “The Devil in the White City” by Erik Larson).

Mrs. Hudson (Una Stubbs) wins the episode, telling Mycroft (Mark Gatiss), “Get out of my house, you reptile.” Buuuurrrrrn. Who knew it was possible to feel sorry for Mycroft?

But it turned out Mary — so glad you’re still with us in spirit, Amanda Abbington — told Sherlock to put himself in harm’s way to save John Watson (Martin Freeman). “Go to hell, Sherlock,” she said. “Go right into hell and make it look like you mean it,” she said. “Go and pick a fight with a bad guy,” she said. It would bring John running. And it did.

John Watson (MARTIN FREEMAN) in Sherlock season 4 (Hartswood Films & MASTERPIECE)


“Give Martin all the awards, he blew me away this episode…” said Lauryn on Tumblr.

But we haven’t been paying attention. John Watson’s bus “affair,” his therapist, and Sherlock’s mysterious visitor are all the same person: a third Holmes sibling, Euros (Sian Brooke) — it’s Greek, meaning “east wind.”

And the crowd goes wild!

Radio Times has a great discussion of the significance of “east wind” — Euros was a god in Greek mythology — including season 3 references and going back to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s original writings.

“The scene where Euros finally unveils herself, we’ve been sitting on that since we sat talking about it on the production bus… when we were shooting His Last Vow,” Moffat revealed following a screening of the episode, the news outlet reported. “We’ve been talking about it ever since then, so it’s kind of weird that in few hours time we won’t have to kill people to keep the secret.”

Euros responds to Watson’s shock: “It’s making a funny face. I think I’ll put a hole in it.”

Whatever could happen next? Head to the comments to tell us what you think the season finale holds.

Sherlock on Masterpiece airs Sundays at 9 p.m. on PBS


Tag Cloud

TruTV Fantasy New York Comic Con singing competition Pixar travel TCA Ghostbusters Super Bowl Song of Ice and Fire discovery Drama Animation PBS DC Universe Calendar Year in Review Creative Arts Emmys 007 Awards Tour Britbox diversity vampires CNN spy thriller Sneak Peek Teen based on movie El Rey TNT National Geographic Trophy Talk Country BBC Paramount Network The Arrangement DC Comics Logo Reality YouTube Red RT History crime SXSW Holidays Trivia Comics on TV dc Rom-Com Countdown DirecTV robots LGBTQ Amazon Epix medical drama The CW Starz Lionsgate Superheroe San Diego Comic-Con Ovation Lifetime Universal Disney TV Land technology Freeform APB AMC A&E thriller Biopics Mindy Kaling GIFs Lucasfilm television crime drama Best and Worst Certified Fresh Emmys See It Skip It cops Cartoon Network Esquire Toys Bravo Cosplay talk show Paramount zombies Syfy Writers Guild of America USA Dark Horse Comics sitcom Election politics TIFF Hulu Watching Series Superheroes jamie lee curtis WGN Fox News dramedy Star Trek SundanceTV ESPN comic Awards Action Walt Disney Pictures President ratings 20th Century Fox transformers crime thriller Tumblr crossover dceu social media Sundance Podcast political drama IFC Films Warner Bros. Opinion ABC Family cults Horror SDCC CW Seed Crackle TCA 2017 anime Thanksgiving Red Carpet blaxploitation Infographic festivals Extras IFC TLC period drama Netflix harry potter Winter TV CMT Acorn TV Spike Winners Video Games NBC Sundance Now mutant Martial Arts ABC GLAAD 2015 Grammys Marathons Kids & Family Quiz cooking Reality Competition cinemax Rock boxoffice Nominations HBO police drama 24 frames NYCC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt docudrama History 2017 Tomatazos Shudder binge CBS All Access comiccon Interview Music Musical Adult Swim Marvel Star Wars Spring TV Musicals VICE MTV OWN historical drama Set visit what to watch Sony Pictures serial killer TV aliens streaming VH1 CBS Oscars Pirates unscripted Character Guide Nickelodeon TCM Sci-Fi X-Men DC streaming service Columbia Pictures cats Summer GoT E3 USA Network 45 Comedy biography Chilling Adventures of Sabrina FX science fiction Pop American Society of Cinematographers finale Polls and Games golden globes Box Office Christmas adventure Photos Mary Tyler Moore Disney Channel Apple zombie 21st Century Fox Schedule Trailer Showtime Masterpiece Premiere Dates YouTube Premium FOX Ellie Kemper E! doctor who Food Network Nat Geo Comic Book Shondaland Fall TV BET 2016 YA FXX psycho sports composers Comedy Central justice league Rocky ITV MSNBC war Western BBC America First Look hist PaleyFest romance supernatural Mystery TBS Valentine's Day