RT-UK: Patrick Marber Interview

by | February 12, 2007 | Comments

Adapting the Notes
Oscar nominated screenwriter, Patrick Marber, talks Notes on a Scandal exclusively with Rotten Tomatoes UK.

Notes on a ScandalIt’s not yet lunchtime, but Patrick Marber looks exhausted. Today’s international press junket for Notes on a Scandal is clearly taking its toll on the Oscar nominated screenwriter.

Nevertheless he’s keen to welcome Rotten Tomatoes UK warmly into the room – thrilled to be chatting to the staff of one of his favourite Web resources, or so he says. We’re touched. So warm is his welcome that when his publicist brings a plate of biscuits in for him he wastes no time in insisting we take a couple. And let this be a lesson to budding journalists the world over; talking with a biscuit in your mouth is not the easiest task in the world.

And talk is what we’ve come here to do and we’re keen to get on with it. Over half an hour, Patrick Marber takes Rotten Tomatoes UK exclusively through the process of shaping Notes on a Scandal.

RT-UK: How did you become involved originally with the adaptation?

Patrick Marber: I was sent the book, originally, by the producer Scott Rudin. I read the book and pretty much accepted right there. I thought the book was fantastic; very funny, very odd and I thought Barbara was an amazing character. She was an unusual movie character, potentially. It’s very rare you get such a tough, bitchy, funny older woman driving a film. It’s not On Golden Pond! I thought she’d be fun to write.

I thought Sheba needed a bit of work to make her a fully-realised movie character because in the book she’s only seen from Barbara’s point of view. She doesn’t fully come alive as an entity.

RT-UK: I guess when she’s referring to Sheba you’re actually learning more about Barbara.

PM:Exactly. Yeah, so I knew that in the film I needed a way to access who Sheba was and invent scenes with her and the kid and the family that weren’t necessarily in the book.

RT-UK: I get the impression from the novel that it wasn’t an easy task to make that dynamic work in a different medium.

PM: It was a difficult job to do; I did many, many drafts and I think we shot the twelfth draft. But it was quite rewarding. Not financially, but artistically! It was a fun job but it was tough.

RT-UK: As challenging as it was to write, it had to be the sort of material writers would just jump to adapt; it’s controversial and charged but at the same time not a bit hackneyed or formulaic.

PM: That’s the most exciting thing; the story didn’t play out as a genre piece should. I don’t quite know what the story would be if it was predictable but it was a completely unpredictable series of events. I suppose you know that it’s all going to end horribly on some level – it can’t all work out – but it’s a story where you’re waiting for the car crash to happen. And then when it does happen it’s quite satisfying but it happens in a way that you hadn’t quite predicted.

Notes on a Scandal

RT-UK: Its real strength is that it handles its controversial aspects without ever judging its characters. You leave with whatever you put in; Barbara’s ultimately no more the villain than Sheba is.

PM: That’s right, and I think that Fox Searchlight were very encouraging of what we were doing. They never said, “Make it clearer that the film is condemning Sheba.” They just trusted us and they encouraged and let us get on with it; they were really brilliant with this film, I’ve got to say.

RT-UK: Which has got to be pretty risky for a big studio like Fox, even if it is going through its independent production wing…

PM: Yeah, well this is the thing; however many times Fox Searchlight says it, and no matter how many examples of it you see, you find it hard to believe that they’d be so willing. And they genuinely want to make challenging films that, in Hollywood parlance, “Push the envelope.” And you think, “Yeah, yeah, but they don’t really,” but they really do. So you keep waiting for the call that goes, “No, no, no, we’re cutting all this stuff.” And it never comes.

But it was the same with Closer and Sony. I kept thinking, “When’s the call going to come when, ‘F*ck off and die you f*cked-up slag,’ gets cut? Or the internet scene gets toned down?” And it never came. I think because the studios are realising that there is an audience who want to see this stuff. And that, for years, Hollywood has made assumptions about who the audience is. They’re just copping to the fact that there is another audience; a film like Borat just wouldn’t have been made ten years ago.

RT-UK: Perhaps an audience that’s a little less politically-correct than their mainstream audience.

PM: Yeah, but I think that audience is becoming their mainstream audience. The gross for Borat is a sort of mini revolution. I knew it would happen because I know who that audience is – I’m part of that audience. It’s the audience who turn out for comedy gigs and movies like Closer; I know those people.

Notes on a Scandal

RT-UK: There’s a school of thought that says the Fox Searchlights and the Warner Independent Pictures and the Sony Classics of the world aren’t about independent film; they’re as interested in making money as their mainstream wing.

PM: Perhaps but I think the majors are going to absorb the niches and it’s all going to change. Sony made Closer; that was a major and they made it without skimping on it. Logically that would have been a Sony Classics or a Fox Searchlight or a Paramount Vantage but the major wanted it. It did have Mike Nichols and Julia Roberts and that really helped, but I think it’s pretty clear that there are the high-end boffo-budget films that are going to make money but then there’s also films like Closer, Notes on a Scandal, Little Miss Sunshine, Sideways… The sort-of fifteen to twenty million dollar films and they’re making money too. I think it’s the midrange films – the films that, as it were, are “good for you” – that are going to find it hard. Those forty-million-dollar, get-a-couple-of-movie-stars, crank-out-some-bullsh*t-script movies.

I think the way it’s going is that people either want the authentic real thing that is low-budget, or the authentic big thing that knows what it is and says, “I’m an effects movie, and I’m a ride.” It’s one or the other and everything in between will die! [Laughs] And the studios get it. They are there to make money, they’re not there to be nice to filmmakers, but vicariously they are by making those low-budget films.

RT-UK: As hands-off as they were though, did you manage to avoid the test screening process?.

PM: No, we still had tests but fortunately the tests went well. I mean, listen, we could be having a totally different conversation if the tests had been bad because then the studio might have reacted in a different way.

RT-UK: Was that the same on Closer?

PM: Closer tested badly. But nothing happened! [Laughs] They released the film and it did well. It did more than $150 million worldwide, it was a great big movie. But then it did have movie stars in it!

The thing about the test screening, though, is that it must mean something because it’s human beings watching your film and telling you what they think of it. You’ve gotta learn from that. Whether you want to accept what they tell you is a whole other board game! Generally speaking, when friends of mind have tested movies and they’ve tested badly they’ve gone, “Test are bullsh*t, they don’t mean a thing,” but when their films test well they go, “Oh yeah, great test. Fantastic.”

RT-UK: You said you shot the twelfth draft of the script; how much changed during production? Were you involved once you’d handed in the shooting script?

PM: Yeah I was on set and there was a lot of writing work in post-production. The film always had voiceover in it from the first draft but the voiceover changed depending on the picture. Richard would cut a scene and I’d have to rewrite a voiceover. That shifted a lot. There was a lot of extra work in the end.

RT-UK: Is there something harrowing about opening up the script having been so isolated before production?

PM: No, I’m used to it. I’ve gotten used to it over the years with plays and I’ve travelled abroad and seen foreign productions of my work so I’m very used to seeing something I wrote get done in lots of different ways and it’s really nice.

I like the varying rhythm of being a writer that you have a period of being in complete isolation where it’s just you and the book and your screenplay and no-one can read it. I love that time, but I also love the period where it becomes public and suddenly a hundred people have read it and they’ve all got opinions. As long as you hold your nerve and you listen to those you think are authentic it’s great. That can be difficult but that’s where experience helps. Experience doesn’t help the writing but it really helps the handling of the notes and the handling of the input which I wasn’t good at handling ten years ago. I’ve gotten better at handling it now.

RT-UK: I guess working with Richard Eyre anyway, who you’ve worked with numerous times in the past, helps.

PM: He’s very respectful and he knows me – we go back years – so that really helps. When he expresses a strong opinion about a line or a scene I take it very seriously.

RT-UK: Is it still exciting to see your work brought to life by tremendously talented people like Judi Dench and Cate Blanchett?

PM: Really exciting. I mean that’s kind-of what it’s about. I’ve got a play on in London at the moment that Rhys Ifans is starring in – Don Juan in Soho – and he’s giving this amazing performance. There’s no greater pleasure than writing a scene or a line and then seeing an actor do it and it’s exactly what you wanted but better. It’s fantastic; it makes you feel as a God! Judi Dench and Cate Blanchett doing it was one of the biggest thrills of my writing life; they’re amazing.

I’ve been really lucky with the actors that have brought my work to life. I hope some of it is talent too; but what it is is that I’m a bit of an actor myself so I write parts for actors. The one thing I know is that they don’t want parts where the character tells you who they are. The actor wants to give a performance; to have good things to say while the writer has trusted them to understand who the character is without having to do a speech. And so I write minimally for them and I think they feel respected that their job is to bring the character to life; not mine. I think I give them a certain amount of freedom.

RT-UK: Which I should imagine is largely where the attraction lies for them…

PM: The upside is you get good actors, the downside is people say that there are too many loose ends, “What are you saying? What is this?” Nothing I write presents the audience with the little gem at the centre of it that is the meaning of it all. I hate that kind of writing. This film doesn’t tell you what to think or what to feel; it just says, “This is what happened, now do with it what you will.”

And Nichols did that with Closer; he absolutely honoured the sort-of mess at the heart of my writing. Though I must admit when I watch other films that come from a similar place to my own I do sometimes get frustrated. I sort-of think, “Why am I watching this? Come on, what’s the thing?” [Laughs] I’m not elusive to kind-of pose, it’s just the way I am. I think I’m a writer because I don’t know exactly what I think about a whole range of things so I want to explore it. I don’t necessarily come to a conclusion.

Notes on a Scandal

RT-UK: Are you still doing comedy writing?

PM: Well, I’m sort-of having semi-regular meetings with Steve Coogan to talk about an Alan Partridge film. We talk about and… we’re still talking about it.

RT-UK: And how long has that been going on for?

PM: A couple of years! [Laughs] But we’re never in the same country for long enough to sit down and get any work done.

I think we’re quite enjoying, and will continue to enjoy, years of speculation about it without actually having to actually do anything about it!

RT-UK: Lovely… We’re all just dying to see something happen!

PM: Is the world really desperate for an Alan Partridge movie? It’d have to be something spectacularly surprising for it to be anything other than a disappoint. And we’re conscious of that so we don’t want to do it unless the idea is so compelling that it has to be done. And Steve has had a brilliant movie idea for the character. So, you know, it may happen.

RT-UK: It must be difficult to break out of the half-hour format TV comedy… It certainly didn’t work for Ali G…

PM: It worked for Borat though! But it’s really hard. But we know that about Alan and in a way I think you can make it a strength. There is a way of saying to an audience, “It is ludicrous that this man is on the big screen. He shouldn’t be; what’s he doing there?” He doesn’t belong there – we know that, but he doesn’t know that! I think there’s a way of making that part of the fun of it.

One day!

RT-UK: Hopefully soon…

PM: Anticipation is half of the fun of it! [Laughs]

RT-UK: Steve seems to be all over the place; he popped up in Night at the Museum!

PM: Yeah! [Laughs] Talk to his agent! I still think he’s at his best when he works with Michael Winterbottom. I suppose it’s important – if you want to have a career – you have to work with lots of people, but I think they work brilliantly together.

RT-UK: Have you thought about working with Winterbottom before?

PM: Oh yeah, I know him, I’ve sat down with him and talked about doing stuff together. I’d love to write something for him. We’ve had long, long chats and nearly done stuff but he’s someone I’d absolutely love to work with.

RT-UK: Watching his films you do get the impression that the writer/director collaboration is very important to him.

PM: Absolutely. Usually one absorbs the other. But you never know until you get in a room with someone and start writing; people will amaze you!

RT-UK: As far as the comedy goes; is it good to keep your toes dipped in that water?

PM: It is, and in fact the play that I’m doing with Rhys is essentially a comedy. And, actually, I think Notes on a Scandal is comedy. In the end I think it’s comedy because I define comedy as something in which the world sort-of rights itself; a natural order and a natural justice. It sort-of affirms itself at the end and life goes on. Whereas I think a tragedy is something where the natural order of things is completely interrupted and doesn’t right itself. I’d say Notes on a Scandal is a black comedy.

RT-UK: Accepting that Alan Partridge is a maybe; what’s next on the agenda?

PM: An adaptation of Ian McEwan’s novel, Saturday. Not many laughs in that one; but a great story and it’s a ridiculously difficult thing to do. I was offered it quite a while ago and I can’t get it out of my head as a piece of material that I want to work on. The idea of a story set on a day in which London marched on the Iraq War seems to be to be increasingly more potent with each dreadful day and I’m very intrigued to write a protagonist who is by-and-large contented. I’ve never done that before; to have a guy who is happy with his lot at the centre of a story. Plus I think it’s so ridiculously difficult to adapt. It’s a novel set on one day in 2003; it’s about this guy who’s a brain surgeon with his family and chaos enters his life on this particular day. It’s a sort-of life-in-a-day story.

Tag Cloud

20th Century Fox Mary Tyler Moore Biopics sequel Trophy Talk A24 streaming Music TV One TCA Winter 2020 universal monsters BBC book adaptation cooking Song of Ice and Fire black satire suspense PaleyFest Apple TV+ WarnerMedia History adenture DGA Action Arrowverse TIFF cancelled TV shows spider-man Super Bowl animated political drama CMT First Reviews Pride Month TV movies GIFs Box Office strong female leads singing competition Shondaland discovery Musicals popular Mindy Kaling Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Ellie Kemper cancelled television BBC One stoner godzilla Reality blockbusters YouTube Premium marvel cinematic universe concert cancelled El Rey monster movies toronto boxoffice Food Network cops Marvel Television Reality Competition know your critic foreign Comedy Central Black Mirror TruTV Mary poppins harry potter BAFTA Hulu fast and furious halloween tv finale ITV venice Watching Series Drama USA biography franchise Marvel travel dark Syfy social media Rocketman sag awards hidden camera king kong french Valentine's Day FOX independent rotten movies we love christmas movies Sneak Peek spy thriller Universal teaser Amazon Studios Travel Channel Apple Election Vudu Fox News a nightmare on elm street nfl richard e. Grant TNT twilight lord of the rings crime drama award winner game of thrones WGN Masterpiece docudrama talk show Horror Cannes OneApp romance rotten documentary USA Network Alien comics comic books cats NBA CBS boxing politics scorecard 2021 Wes Anderson Walt Disney Pictures thriller mockumentary Toys PlayStation Winners Premiere Dates Sundance Now Rock Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Video Games Crunchyroll Ghostbusters DC Comics worst movies Tarantino Superheroes golden globes news telelvision Marathons die hard Pixar toy story elevated horror Tokyo Olympics screen actors guild CBS All Access science fiction Freeform Kids & Family Holidays 24 frames VICE 2020 Martial Arts Baby Yoda reviews Set visit streaming movies Comedy dceu medical drama ABC Family scene in color south america See It Skip It Shudder screenings documentaries witnail comiccon Mystery 2019 Captain marvel FX on Hulu zombie Spike SDCC adaptation 2018 First Look child's play X-Men composers japanese The Academy Pop archives Sci-Fi President Sony Pictures Academy Awards TCM new star wars movies ABC Signature Funimation dramedy comedies romantic comedy green book best spanish language MCU Tumblr Emmy Nominations Schedule YouTube Red RT History Year in Review Winter TV facebook based on movie Fall TV Lifetime Star Wars ID unscripted Mudbound Awards San Diego Comic-Con Disney streaming service japan period drama Musical live action FX Fantasy Ovation Black History Month spanish reboot HBO Max casting name the review TCA 2017 Opinion Calendar new york Hallmark scary movies Awards Tour American Society of Cinematographers batman Elton John saw 2016 classics MTV Esquire superman 4/20 aapi high school Grammys jurassic park asian-american movie ratings jamie lee curtis slashers chucky Turner Classic Movies films ESPN Certified Fresh Hear Us Out 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards true crime Comic-Con@Home 2021 93rd Oscars Family Lucasfilm technology Photos GLAAD Paramount emmy awards Heroines latino Film Festival stop motion Fox Searchlight crime thriller aliens remakes ABC 90s Western The CW GoT series Tomatazos Discovery Channel Binge Guide TCA Awards YouTube heist movie CNN Quiz laika Red Carpet Film transformers Television Academy Teen 2017 The Walt Disney Company binge halloween Writers Guild of America police drama Disney Plus hispanic National Geographic BET renewed TV shows Netflix Pet Sematary New York Comic Con Spring TV nature Amazon Prime joker 1990s The Walking Dead sequels anthology Image Comics 72 Emmy Awards 007 Dark Horse Comics tv talk vampires DirecTV Christmas mission: impossible cars Warner Bros. A&E historical drama kids sports LGBTQ HBO quibi theme song Lifetime Christmas movies Pirates E! worst DC streaming service target Marvel Studios werewolf dogs Endgame adventure Character Guide trailers robots TLC cults MSNBC OWN spinoff RT21 Creative Arts Emmys video on demand Chernobyl Rocky book LGBT obituary Sundance TV italian doctor who BBC America Emmys stand-up comedy NYCC Disney Channel festival IFC HBO Go BET Awards Bravo SXSW Spectrum Originals football The Arrangement TV Land Women's History Month PBS blaxploitation YA Turner Logo natural history sitcom critics Best and Worst parents Sundance VOD Britbox Comic Book TV Classic Film 21st Century Fox Summer directors IFC Films Amazon 71st Emmy Awards ghosts indiana jones Cosplay canceled dragons cartoon women prank FXX james bond Anna Paquin Thanksgiving Country crime pirates of the caribbean Crackle Peacock cinemax ViacomCBS Polls and Games CW Seed crossover Nickelodeon razzies rom-coms Pacific Islander Adult Swim Television Critics Association TCA Epix Animation Broadway cancelled TV series justice league Disney blockbuster war Starz The Witch fresh children's TV miniseries supernatural serial killer Cartoon Network basketball Legendary kaiju Star Trek disaster free movies 99% rt archives Acorn TV Paramount Plus 45 nbcuniversal NBC legend TBS Extras superhero all-time anime psycho Pop TV Netflix Christmas movies Lionsgate SundanceTV revenge zero dark thirty Nominations indie video E3 zombies wonder woman docuseries Interview Disney+ Disney Plus Nat Geo Apple TV Plus Holiday Hallmark Christmas movies Oscars criterion Comics on TV 2015 space The Purge Rom-Com Tubi Infographic Exclusive Video diversity television Trivia Countdown new zealand festivals movies Trailer what to watch Showtime kong hist comic versus king arthur mutant olympics Columbia Pictures Podcast Amazon Prime Video australia TV renewals APB golden globe awards DC Universe Mary Poppins Returns AMC Paramount Network spain breaking bad Stephen King canceled TV shows dc Avengers VH1 game show hollywood Superheroe deadpool psychological thriller international Brie Larson