RTIndie: Can Indie Studios Survive Without Big Studio Backing?

by | October 31, 2006 | Comments

With the sale of independent-minded ThinkFilm last week, can indie film distributors survive without big studio backing?

Author: Juliana Tringali

ThinkFilm, best known for releasing 2004’s "Born Into Brothels," was recently purchased by the Capco group for $25 million. Group head David Bergstein plans to merge ThinkFilm with Capitol Films (another formerly fledgling distribution company), creating a "formidable new force in the independent marketplace."


We’re not going to tell you how the wheels on "Shortbus" go.

For five years, ThinkFilm has built a reputation for distributing daring films that many others wouldn’t touch. Its current theatrical releases include John Cameron Mitchell‘s sexually explicit "Shortbus" and "Half Nelson," the story of a drug addicted inner city teacher. Meanwhile, Capital Films has helped to sell such fare as "A Prairie Home Companion" to international markets.

Before the purchase, ThinkFilm was the one Canadian company distributing movies in the states. Their game plan was generally to acquire documentaries or daring low budget films and subsequently attempt to sell them to more mainstream audiences.

The strategy won an Oscar for "Brothels" (which scored a 96 percent on the Tomatometer), and garnered further nominations for other releases ("The Story of the Weeping Camel," "Murderball"). But despite some critical and moderate commercial successes (including "Spellbound"), none of the ThinkFilm’s offerings broke through to widespread box office popularity. Capco says the merger will allow ThinkFilm to be a bigger player in the global film market.


"Murderball": Better than "Rollerball!"

In the expensive world of film production, perhaps the acquisition of smaller companies has always been an uncomfortable but irrevocable truth. After all, when indie first went boom in 1994, its most powerful mainstays had already been snatched up.

Miramax was purchased by Walt Disney Co. in 1993 (just before releasing "Pulp Fiction," the shot that sounded out the new era in film). In 1994, Turner Broadcasting System purchased New Line Cinema, which had dared to produce movies from unknown filmmakers since 1967.


No, this isn’t a metaphor for the indies and the majors.

But 1994 was a time of optimism. Making films outside the studio system was not only possible, it was hot, and bright-eyed believers were standing up to be counted. Among them were Newmarket Films, then a new privately-owned production and distribution company (purchased by New Line/HBO in 2005), and the Independent Film Channel (IFC). Palm Pictures was started in 1998, and ThinkFilm began in 2001.

Studios had their finger on the pulse as well. In 1994, Fox Searchlight was introduced as the indie wing of 20th Century Fox and it went on to produce some of the most successful "independent" films of the 1990s. NBC Universal followed suit in 2002 with Focus Features. Not surprisingly, these smaller sectors of major studios have had more staying power than their more authentic counterparts.

Top Reviewed Limiteds

Opening last week in limited release: "Shut Up & Sing," a rockumentary about the Dixie Chicks, is at 93 percent with 30 reviews; "Exit: The Right to Die," a documentary about assisted suicide, is at 88 percent (8 reviews); "Absolute Wilson," a documentary about avant-gardist Robert Wilson, is at 82 percent (11 reviews); "Cocaine Cowboys," a documentary about drug smuggling in Miami in the late 1970s and early 1980s, is at 78 percent (23 reviews); "Babel," Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu‘s globetrotting film about despair and interconnectivity, starring Brad Pitt and Cate Blanchett, is at 74 percent (61 reviews); and "The Bridge," a doc about suicides on San Francisco’s Golden Gate Bridge, is at 64 percent (28 reviews).


Dixie Chicks flick: a hit with crits!

Top Performing Limiteds

"Babel" was the biggest indie winner this week, grossing $366,000 for a big per-screen average of $52,258, despite playing in only seven theaters in New York and Los Angeles. Stephen Frears‘ "The Queen," starring Helen Mirren, continued its strong performance, grossing $1.9 million, with a $12,638 per-screen average (it’s made $6.3 million during its theatrical run). "Shut Up & Sing" made $51,000 in four theaters, for an average of $12,750. But something of a disappointment was "Death of a President" which, despite the hum of controversy, made only $167,000 with a per-screen average of $1,835.


Why so blue, Cate? Critics and audiences like "Babel."

Tag Cloud

Spike 2016 Anna Paquin travel Amazon Studios a nightmare on elm street Winners Spectrum Originals Character Guide Musicals Mary poppins cancelled Disney Podcast technology IFC Films strong female leads Box Office doctor who TCM Thanksgiving Warner Bros. science fiction joker Musical Sneak Peek Pop TV Valentine's Day OWN sequels Disney Channel cinemax spanish language Music zombies Adult Swim A&E witnail renewed TV shows WarnerMedia rotten movies we love Hear Us Out Academy Awards Black History Month unscripted Rock finale Sundance El Rey police drama movie sag awards Chernobyl romance VOD Grammys spinoff spider-man crime reboot DC streaming service anime cops Ellie Kemper Ghostbusters Awards Comedy Central documentary Holiday television canceled TV shows Pride Month Dark Horse Comics Oscars werewolf BBC Black Mirror Bravo DC Universe TLC slashers Epix all-time President cancelled TV series Universal 4/20 72 Emmy Awards satire Mystery TCA batman PaleyFest SDCC TV Television Critics Association Discovery Channel Rocky movies Pirates Shondaland Heroines Watching Series Marvel Television FX on Hulu child's play Classic Film critics Awards Tour GIFs what to watch Peacock asian-american DC Comics superhero LGBTQ Hallmark Christmas movies Trivia Mudbound Superheroes Calendar First Reviews Super Bowl chucky CNN Captain marvel versus 2017 Opinion stoner game show History biography latino 24 frames mission: impossible TCA Winter 2020 Tumblr Hulu Lionsgate Quiz award winner Apple Mary Poppins Returns SXSW Marathons animated Star Trek ratings ABC Paramount The CW theme song singing competition APB Cosplay kids Elton John Infographic TV Land twilight book zero dark thirty Netflix Polls and Games directors Tomatazos Rom-Com Schedule Comedy AMC zombie indie Shudder USA Network foreign BBC One OneApp classics historical drama dceu psycho TV renewals Sundance Now Mary Tyler Moore Freeform MTV Year in Review ghosts Tubi BAFTA NBC Masterpiece Binge Guide Travel Channel elevated horror Stephen King BET Awards south america dramedy Amazon Prime cooking adaptation canceled ABC Family indiana jones Crackle TIFF blockbuster sports Nickelodeon Comics on TV binge Pop Christmas First Look Countdown Funimation revenge parents YouTube emmy awards cars Superheroe Mindy Kaling Cannes 2019 Turner anthology children's TV crime drama political drama spain Hallmark vampires Fox News Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Pet Sematary transformers MSNBC Cartoon Network dc festivals hollywood scary movies Crunchyroll Amazon Prime Video Acorn TV cults politics robots jamie lee curtis nbcuniversal Sci-Fi Star Wars TNT IFC Toys Holidays National Geographic psychological thriller Western Lifetime Christmas movies sequel free movies New York Comic Con stop motion Television Academy docudrama Song of Ice and Fire documentaries concert blaxploitation boxoffice Ovation Chilling Adventures of Sabrina space screen actors guild Best and Worst Marvel Studios YA Film Festival Baby Yoda Disney+ Disney Plus 2020 E3 See It Skip It war Certified Fresh facebook YouTube Premium Writers Guild of America 2018 Set visit dogs Lifetime Film SundanceTV Turner Classic Movies spy thriller Starz The Walking Dead BET stand-up comedy Netflix Christmas movies hist justice league Columbia Pictures TruTV The Arrangement true crime game of thrones Lucasfilm Teen CMT Brie Larson based on movie Rocketman Tarantino dark Nominations mutant Pixar series Vudu comedies cancelled TV shows medical drama Reality streaming best nature BBC America TBS Animation Trailer obituary Endgame 45 Family PlayStation Syfy Summer Trophy Talk CBS Sundance TV CBS All Access diversity RT21 ESPN PBS Nat Geo comiccon Emmy Nominations rotten 007 Spring TV Election toy story Extras fast and furious HBO Go name the review Comic Book DirecTV comics TCA 2017 Walt Disney Pictures serial killer Reality Competition Apple TV Plus WGN Drama Paramount Network natural history Red Carpet Logo X-Men mockumentary adventure harry potter teaser worst Emmys VH1 A24 thriller The Purge HBO LGBT NYCC CW Seed comic Apple TV+ supernatural Video Games Photos films composers news golden globes Food Network Britbox American Society of Cinematographers talk show FXX Disney streaming service Arrowverse aliens cats screenings 2015 tv talk casting crossover Martial Arts Sony Pictures TCA Awards discovery Winter TV Premiere Dates Kids & Family Biopics Esquire sitcom video on demand halloween GoT Fall TV Marvel ITV crime thriller christmas movies independent RT History HBO Max Creative Arts Emmys richard e. Grant USA romantic comedy The Witch DGA social media laika hispanic Disney Plus Amazon criterion 71st Emmy Awards disaster cancelled television YouTube Red Showtime 20th Century Fox 21st Century Fox FX GLAAD San Diego Comic-Con breaking bad video Country Fantasy green book MCU E! universal monsters Horror Action VICE dragons die hard miniseries Women's History Month quibi franchise Interview reviews period drama cartoon FOX Avengers