RTIndie: Can Indie Studios Survive Without Big Studio Backing?

by | October 31, 2006 | Comments

With the sale of independent-minded ThinkFilm last week, can indie film distributors survive without big studio backing?

Author: Juliana Tringali

ThinkFilm, best known for releasing 2004’s "Born Into Brothels," was recently purchased by the Capco group for $25 million. Group head David Bergstein plans to merge ThinkFilm with Capitol Films (another formerly fledgling distribution company), creating a "formidable new force in the independent marketplace."


We’re not going to tell you how the wheels on "Shortbus" go.

For five years, ThinkFilm has built a reputation for distributing daring films that many others wouldn’t touch. Its current theatrical releases include John Cameron Mitchell‘s sexually explicit "Shortbus" and "Half Nelson," the story of a drug addicted inner city teacher. Meanwhile, Capital Films has helped to sell such fare as "A Prairie Home Companion" to international markets.

Before the purchase, ThinkFilm was the one Canadian company distributing movies in the states. Their game plan was generally to acquire documentaries or daring low budget films and subsequently attempt to sell them to more mainstream audiences.

The strategy won an Oscar for "Brothels" (which scored a 96 percent on the Tomatometer), and garnered further nominations for other releases ("The Story of the Weeping Camel," "Murderball"). But despite some critical and moderate commercial successes (including "Spellbound"), none of the ThinkFilm’s offerings broke through to widespread box office popularity. Capco says the merger will allow ThinkFilm to be a bigger player in the global film market.


"Murderball": Better than "Rollerball!"

In the expensive world of film production, perhaps the acquisition of smaller companies has always been an uncomfortable but irrevocable truth. After all, when indie first went boom in 1994, its most powerful mainstays had already been snatched up.

Miramax was purchased by Walt Disney Co. in 1993 (just before releasing "Pulp Fiction," the shot that sounded out the new era in film). In 1994, Turner Broadcasting System purchased New Line Cinema, which had dared to produce movies from unknown filmmakers since 1967.


No, this isn’t a metaphor for the indies and the majors.

But 1994 was a time of optimism. Making films outside the studio system was not only possible, it was hot, and bright-eyed believers were standing up to be counted. Among them were Newmarket Films, then a new privately-owned production and distribution company (purchased by New Line/HBO in 2005), and the Independent Film Channel (IFC). Palm Pictures was started in 1998, and ThinkFilm began in 2001.

Studios had their finger on the pulse as well. In 1994, Fox Searchlight was introduced as the indie wing of 20th Century Fox and it went on to produce some of the most successful "independent" films of the 1990s. NBC Universal followed suit in 2002 with Focus Features. Not surprisingly, these smaller sectors of major studios have had more staying power than their more authentic counterparts.

Top Reviewed Limiteds

Opening last week in limited release: "Shut Up & Sing," a rockumentary about the Dixie Chicks, is at 93 percent with 30 reviews; "Exit: The Right to Die," a documentary about assisted suicide, is at 88 percent (8 reviews); "Absolute Wilson," a documentary about avant-gardist Robert Wilson, is at 82 percent (11 reviews); "Cocaine Cowboys," a documentary about drug smuggling in Miami in the late 1970s and early 1980s, is at 78 percent (23 reviews); "Babel," Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu‘s globetrotting film about despair and interconnectivity, starring Brad Pitt and Cate Blanchett, is at 74 percent (61 reviews); and "The Bridge," a doc about suicides on San Francisco’s Golden Gate Bridge, is at 64 percent (28 reviews).


Dixie Chicks flick: a hit with crits!

Top Performing Limiteds

"Babel" was the biggest indie winner this week, grossing $366,000 for a big per-screen average of $52,258, despite playing in only seven theaters in New York and Los Angeles. Stephen Frears‘ "The Queen," starring Helen Mirren, continued its strong performance, grossing $1.9 million, with a $12,638 per-screen average (it’s made $6.3 million during its theatrical run). "Shut Up & Sing" made $51,000 in four theaters, for an average of $12,750. But something of a disappointment was "Death of a President" which, despite the hum of controversy, made only $167,000 with a per-screen average of $1,835.


Why so blue, Cate? Critics and audiences like "Babel."

Tag Cloud

CW Seed rom-coms news Trophy Talk independent latino IFC psychological thriller E! kaiju unscripted TV One comiccon TV movies ID OneApp renewed TV shows art house Oscars PaleyFest First Reviews joker HBO Legendary New York Comic Con YouTube CBS All Access Nominations Arrowverse ABC Signature Sundance anime E3 GLAAD 2015 japanese Disney Plus WGN comics 73rd Emmy Awards directors crime drama Pet Sematary worst Exclusive Video vampires classics international cartoon composers SXSW boxoffice Mystery video political drama kids live action Television Critics Association 007 Bravo sag awards Apple TV Plus diversity documentary south america Film period drama reviews doctor who Vudu The Witch 99% A&E Winter TV Lucasfilm young adult what to watch parents Stephen King 45 Valentine's Day National Geographic 4/20 Tubi Spectrum Originals scene in color women genre space Mary Tyler Moore Election Freeform disaster SDCC Nat Geo Lifetime Christmas movies revenge spider-man game show Horror BET Awards Peacock 2021 debate biopic slasher rotten movies we love ESPN binge animated know your critic Alien docuseries NYCC Columbia Pictures fresh docudrama adenture 93rd Oscars Cannes versus Watching Series lord of the rings FXX Year in Review concert Set visit DC Universe dc Travel Channel Action remakes Nickelodeon crossover Trivia BBC Heroines stand-up comedy Marvel Television trailers screen actors guild Starz batman Universal Pictures richard e. Grant football comic books comic book movies ratings ABC Family true crime chucky criterion Broadway historical drama Tokyo Olympics strong female leads X-Men indiana jones Biopics Mary poppins Shudder IFC Films king kong DC streaming service sequel Shondaland Showtime halloween tv romantic comedy Thanksgiving 2016 TLC facebook dramedy Polls and Games laika Cosplay blockbuster Emmy Nominations ITV Sundance TV war aliens satire Winners Marvel Studios romance game of thrones IMDb TV elevated horror Reality medical drama book twilight Black History Month screenings Comic-Con@Home 2021 Ghostbusters The Arrangement HBO Max GoT crime thriller Universal DC Comics boxing australia talk show Instagram Live prank BET hist children's TV CMT halloween breaking bad nfl transformers Video Games Sneak Peek theme song emmy awards Food Network Writers Guild of America casting jamie lee curtis Amazon toronto king arthur science fiction mcc dexter LGBTQ VH1 24 frames Masterpiece Rom-Com zombie Turner Classic Movies streaming movies Hulu Epix green book Martial Arts TBS Pride Month blaxploitation tv talk television Paramount Plus ghosts Marvel Image Comics dceu stoner sopranos reboot San Diego Comic-Con Lionsgate Captain marvel Amazon Prime rotten YA TIFF Hallmark YouTube Red Logo movies italian Cartoon Network Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt teaser Sci-Fi Extras MTV ViacomCBS DirecTV cancelled TV shows Acorn TV Pop HBO Go TNT scary Rocky Paramount Network Awards posters BBC One Reality Competition Red Carpet cats Ovation quibi 90s Certified Fresh series 2020 Pop TV nature superhero Superheroes Holiday Holidays A24 wonder woman singing competition die hard Christmas deadpool The Walking Dead marvel cinematic universe Brie Larson new star wars movies Best and Worst trophy Discovery Channel NBA foreign MSNBC discovery 72 Emmy Awards slashers Spike indie Family Television Academy Chernobyl award winner BBC America high school worst movies Funimation 71st Emmy Awards El Rey heist movie travel YouTube Premium adaptation mutant adventure Kids & Family zombies justice league new york serial killer Elton John Star Wars kong Comics on TV festivals Quiz The Academy Western hollywood cancelled witnail new zealand BAFTA best Paramount pirates of the caribbean Neflix Black Mirror james bond films Toys spain Binge Guide rt labs critics edition 1990s olympics sitcom FX CBS golden globes OWN psycho natural history Comedy Comic Book GIFs DGA Animation nbcuniversal History police drama TCM mockumentary Country rt labs Comedy Central aapi spinoff superman basketball dragons ABC thriller mission: impossible hispanic heritage month TV Awards Tour finale Syfy The Purge gangster PlayStation scorecard cancelled television canceled Fall TV dark Mary Poppins Returns WarnerMedia harry potter cancelled TV series USA Network all-time Adult Swim sequels Anna Paquin Podcast black 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards 21st Century Fox critics SundanceTV RT History Fantasy Mudbound toy story free movies Crackle VOD dogs politics royal family Amazon Studios comic book movie stop motion Amazon Prime Video mob Musicals MCU Turner crime blockbusters japan 2018 based on movie Character Guide TCA 2017 Premiere Dates Star Trek hispanic Mindy Kaling child's play TCA Awards Britbox PBS Superheroe President 20th Century Fox movie godzilla Song of Ice and Fire TCA franchise Academy Awards See It Skip It canceled TV shows cars video on demand Schedule jurassic park live event Hallmark Christmas movies Trailer spy thriller supernatural spider-verse cooking rt archives Pirates name the review robots action-comedy The CW Apple TV+ razzies TV Land American Society of Cinematographers Baby Yoda First Look Endgame fast and furious Disney streaming service Box Office Countdown APB Disney sports comic Fox News Disney Channel Music Tumblr asian-american Film Festival spanish Interview anthology Disney+ Disney Plus french Photos vs. target legend Fox Searchlight miniseries christmas movies NBC obituary TCA Winter 2020 VICE Classic Film popular Rocketman universal monsters Creative Arts Emmys Rock Musical Sony Pictures Avengers AMC Plus documentaries spanish language hidden camera FX on Hulu Summer Tarantino Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Spring TV CNN FOX LGBT biography venice Fargo golden globe awards Wes Anderson Crunchyroll Pacific Islander Tomatazos archives saw Walt Disney Pictures suspense dreamworks Netflix Christmas movies Lifetime Grammys Super Bowl AMC Netflix Emmys Esquire RT21 feel good Pixar monster movies The Walt Disney Company TruTV social media Hear Us Out Drama a nightmare on elm street cults critic resources technology cops telelvision Sundance Now Women's History Month 2017 TV renewals black comedy Warner Bros. scary movies Infographic Dark Horse Comics Opinion streaming cinemax Calendar 2019 Marathons Teen leaderboard Ellie Kemper book adaptation zero dark thirty USA marvel comics Apple werewolf comedies festival