POW! Read Comics & Graphic Novels vs. The Critics!

by | July 23, 2010 | Comments

To celebrate the 2010 Comic-Con, we present to you Comics & Graphic Novels vs. the Critics, an exhaustive countdown that includes movies based on everything from superheroes to graphic novels, from manga to strips from the funny pages — in order of critical approval.

We can see those thought bubbles above your heads — you’re wondering how we compiled this thing. Here’s the breakdown: every movie here originates from a comic book source of some kind, not another medium (we know about the Alien vs. Predator graphic novels, but the movies aren’t based on the comics). Only movies with 20 or more reviews are included (sorry, Fritz the Cat), and we use a weighted formula that takes release year and number of reviews into account (see How It Works for more). We also omitted all TV or straight-to-DVD flicks.

Now remove the protective plastic bag, flip to the first page, and dig into Comics & Graphic Novels vs. the Critics!

Tag Cloud

Marvel Studios sports Summer Disney Channel Sci-Fi Syfy CNN GLAAD news documentary laika SDCC Box Office Rom-Com Creative Arts Emmys zero dark thirty Rocky Tomatazos First Reviews films Trailer CBS All Access BBC RT History award winner Television Academy ABC USA Network Mindy Kaling Endgame 24 frames Women's History Month American Society of Cinematographers cancelled TV series festivals sequel concert Lifetime Christmas movies Netflix Christmas movies spy thriller docudrama dceu south america animated Chernobyl spinoff Pop TV USA TCA 2017 video Grammys supernatural technology ESPN Emmy Nominations Thanksgiving zombies LGBTQ IFC Films Watching Series discovery Rocketman Horror toy story Britbox harry potter Red Carpet Captain marvel National Geographic justice league Year in Review Baby Yoda Columbia Pictures YouTube werewolf sequels crime Winners BET political drama Infographic romantic comedy History psycho YouTube Red travel indiana jones Ghostbusters Sundance TV Musical TLC Peacock twilight PaleyFest 2020 anime fast and furious mission: impossible Interview Cartoon Network The Walking Dead Cosplay cancelled television TCA Winter 2020 Tumblr CW Seed foreign Fall TV President TV Best and Worst Epix Mary Poppins Returns Lionsgate BBC One Polls and Games MSNBC period drama Pet Sematary Holidays classics hist Warner Bros. Teen SundanceTV superhero Arrowverse tv talk diversity Apple TV Plus true crime TV renewals OneApp Awards serial killer BAFTA HBO biography Food Network Musicals Funimation teaser vampires Rock A24 Netflix cats movie Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt CBS IFC mutant renewed TV shows New York Comic Con cars rotten movies we love franchise APB FX jamie lee curtis latino Mary Tyler Moore Shondaland cancelled TV shows 2019 21st Century Fox 2018 PBS Animation 2017 Esquire Crackle Country Amazon Studios Opinion aliens ghosts Fox News ITV Marvel Television Drama WarnerMedia Comic Book Biopics FOX RT21 2015 PlayStation Black Mirror Hear Us Out Cannes SXSW Amazon Prime Amazon versus hollywood Crunchyroll AMC crime drama Tubi Turner Classic Movies natural history green book elevated horror Pixar spanish language war DC Comics Mystery composers The CW DC streaming service witnail Schedule DC Universe screenings streaming movies Elton John Lucasfilm strong female leads Disney streaming service cinemax Classic Film indie based on movie 72 Emmy Awards Premiere Dates Valentine's Day Tarantino YA die hard stop motion 4/20 Superheroe Star Trek joker Black History Month Marvel comics Christmas The Witch politics Sony Pictures Spectrum Originals Disney Plus TCA canceled Countdown casting TNT child's play Masterpiece crime thriller Apple TV+ Hallmark Disney canceled TV shows adaptation Kids & Family Brie Larson ratings See It Skip It VOD Certified Fresh screen actors guild Spring TV game of thrones Showtime nature Nominations Character Guide GIFs Universal spider-man theme song Nat Geo blaxploitation 007 cults kids breaking bad Discovery Channel A&E LGBT Pride Month what to watch Reality Comics on TV Western 71st Emmy Awards best singing competition sag awards romance space rotten Election VICE Video Games Hulu Marathons Emmys Sneak Peek universal monsters Super Bowl Ellie Kemper MCU The Purge Bravo anthology Binge Guide Superheroes Reality Competition Acorn TV richard e. Grant mockumentary comiccon HBO Go Sundance robots TCM sitcom critics Action TBS E3 children's TV Fantasy batman BBC America comedies video on demand X-Men slashers dark obituary television Ovation BET Awards TV Land Paramount Network book Turner golden globes series Shudder police drama reviews spain Quiz Paramount Sundance Now Winter TV Hallmark Christmas movies blockbuster FXX a nightmare on elm street Writers Guild of America TIFF parents cancelled Song of Ice and Fire Mary poppins Nickelodeon asian-american cooking Comedy Central adventure unscripted reboot doctor who Amazon Prime Video Oscars Adult Swim ABC Family NYCC psychological thriller stoner Avengers documentaries 20th Century Fox HBO Max NBC Comedy Set visit OWN dramedy talk show criterion Toys Anna Paquin GoT Academy Awards First Look Podcast VH1 directors Lifetime Family miniseries 45 CMT boxoffice San Diego Comic-Con Calendar christmas movies independent emmy awards Film finale Freeform medical drama game show Television Critics Association Music Apple nbcuniversal DirecTV Vudu thriller Awards Tour hispanic Star Wars Trophy Talk TCA Awards science fiction Photos binge Pop Chilling Adventures of Sabrina chucky DGA WGN Travel Channel The Arrangement crossover transformers satire Pirates cops revenge Extras Film Festival YouTube Premium Walt Disney Pictures social media cartoon Disney+ Disney Plus El Rey historical drama dogs 2016 dragons Heroines E! Dark Horse Comics disaster facebook MTV Logo stand-up comedy comic worst halloween quibi Mudbound FX on Hulu all-time Holiday Starz Martial Arts Spike dc scary movies TruTV free movies Trivia name the review Stephen King zombie