Critics Consensus

Patriots Day and Silence Are Certified Fresh

Plus, Monster Trucks, Live By Night, and The Bye Bye Man are mediocre, and Sleepless wasn't screened for critics.

by | January 12, 2017 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have a real-life terrorist attack dramatized (Patriots Day, starring Mark Wahlberg and J.K. Simmons), monsters and trucks (Monster Trucks, starring Lucas Till and Jane Levy), a Prohibition rum-runner (Live by Night, starring Ben Affleck and Elle Fanning), pure evil (The Bye Bye Man, starring Douglas Smith and Lucien Laviscount), Jesuits in Japan (Silence, starring Andrew Garfield and Adam Driver), and some bad cops in trouble (Sleepless, starring Jamie Foxx and Michelle Monaghan). What do the critics have to say?

Patriots Day (2017) 80%

Mark Wahlberg loves himself a thriller based on actual events, especially if director Peter Berg is along for the ride. With this weekend’s Patriots Day, the duo cap a trilogy of action movies ripped from the headlines, following Lone Survivor and Deepwater Horizon — and given that this outing dramatizes the events of the 2013 Boston Marathon bombing in Wahlberg’s hometown, expectations were high for a particularly powerful film. While critics admit Patriots Day has its flaws — and a number of scribes have their issues with turning real-life tragedy into entertainment so soon — the consensus says the end result is still a fast-paced drama that manages to be respectful (and largely accurate) while keeping you glued to your seat.

Monster Trucks (2017) 31%

Countless times over the years, we’ve seen studios take what seems like a crass concept and turn it into a perfectly entertaining picture, so there was reason to believe that Monster Trucks — hatched from a four-year-old’s idea about trucks overtaken by, y’know, monsters — might actually turn out okay. Sadly, that isn’t the case: critics say this is one family-friendly outing that’s just as dunderheaded as its title would suggest, with thinly conceived characters deployed at the mercy of flashy but ultimately insufficient CGI. If you really want to see a monster at the wheel of a truck, go grab a ticket; otherwise (ahem), steer clear.

Live By Night (2017) 35%

Ben Affleck’s taken his lumps as an actor over the years, but he’s proven himself a pretty capable director, as his Best Picture Oscar for Argo can attest. On paper, it looked like Live by Night was just the thing to soothe the recent critical barbs from Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice — not only was Affleck directing himself, he was working from a novel by Dennis Lehane, the same bestselling author who wrote the Affleck-adapted Gone Baby Gone. Unfortunately, the reality is far less compelling: critics say this Prohibition-set gangster drama, about a police chief’s son falling into a life of crime, is nowhere near as narratively hefty as its epic scope would suggest. Although it demonstrates some visual growth from Affleck as a director, he could have been tougher on himself as a leading man — and he really let himself down as a screenwriter.

The Bye Bye Man (2017) 18%

January has a reputation as a dumping ground for Hollywood’s dregs, which isn’t always entirely deserved; why, just this week, we have a couple of Certified Fresh movies entering wide release. But when you see a horror movie on the calendar this time of year, you can pretty much guess it won’t be a critical winner — and such is unfortunately the case with The Bye Bye Man, which imagines the bloody campaign of terror wrought by a nefarious being capable of controlling the actions of anyone who so much as thinks his name. Critics say it’s all fairly derivative stuff, and in spite of a talented cast (including Faye Dunaway and Doug Jones), it adds up to considerably less than the sum of its parts.

Silence (2017) 83%

For film buffs, every Martin Scorsese movie is an event, but even in the context of this great director’s distinguished filmography, Silence is something special. An adaptation of Shūsaku Endō’s 1966 novel about the perilous journey taken by Jesuit priests to 17th century Japan in order to find a missing member of the order, it’s been a passion project of Scorsese’s for decades, and it comes to the screen boasting a talented cast that includes Liam Neeson, Adam Driver, and Andrew Garfield — as well as a hefty 161-minute running time. Fortunately, critics say the end result is worth the wait in both senses: reviews describe a thought-provoking, emotionally absorbing work that probes worthy themes with grace and intelligence, and rewards the patient filmgoer with enough payoff to justify the investment.

Sleepless (2017) 25%

Finally, we have Sleepless, starring Jamie Foxx and T.I. as a pair of crooked cops whose livelihood — and one of their sons — is threatened when they’re caught pilfering a druglord’s stash. Unfortunately, we can’t tell you more because it wasn’t screened for critics, so you know what that means: time to play Guess the Tomatometer!

What’s New on TV

A Series of Unfortunate Events: Season 1 (2017) 94%

Enjoyably dark, A Series of Unfortunate Events matches the source material’s narrative as well as its tone, leaving viewers with a wonderfully weird, dry, gothic comedy.

Taboo: Season 1 (2017) 76%

After a sluggish start, Taboo takes hold as a mysterious, dark, and often brutal period drama with plenty of promise as a series — most notably evident in Tom Hardy‘s exceptionally watchable performance.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

Schedule The Witch Quiz Pride Month Sundance TCM National Geographic unscripted Reality Competition dramedy cartoon biography ghosts ESPN Amazon Character Guide cancelled TV shows Hallmark Christmas movies Paramount GIFs Holiday criterion Amazon Studios rotten movies we love jamie lee curtis award winner A24 WGN Star Trek Chernobyl reboot Epix 21st Century Fox Fall TV crime drama stop motion NYCC BBC Captain marvel Fantasy science fiction Box Office Pet Sematary Set visit Family cults 2018 psychological thriller satire Adult Swim Biopics Mary Tyler Moore TNT FX theme song Discovery Channel Disney APB Spectrum Originals Sci-Fi twilight Tumblr all-time true crime video on demand Superheroe Apple Walt Disney Pictures zombie cops Year in Review period drama Best and Worst Rocky FOX Stephen King SundanceTV Marvel Television laika screenings documentary series DirecTV spinoff canceled Interview Columbia Pictures obituary composers Freeform Shudder discovery TBS mutant scary movies Disney Channel boxoffice Emmys Apple TV+ Hulu TV joker Awards Tour YouTube Red BET Awards TCA BBC One Nat Geo Travel Channel Brie Larson sports HBO Go Bravo Spike diversity comiccon universal monsters Trivia 45 CNN Music dc nbcuniversal CMT free movies American Society of Cinematographers President Sneak Peek Song of Ice and Fire critics USA Network directors BAFTA VH1 Turner Paramount Network Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt RT History VICE Esquire crossover USA zero dark thirty ABC Family facebook war 72 Emmy Awards Cosplay Video Games Reality asian-american NBC El Rey Premiere Dates Red Carpet children's TV Thanksgiving Toys political drama Netflix Christmas movies zombies classics Television Critics Association Rocketman DC Comics politics Pop TV blockbuster Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Superheroes Universal MCU mockumentary animated blaxploitation Nickelodeon Tarantino indiana jones stand-up comedy emmy awards San Diego Comic-Con spanish language GoT Lucasfilm RT21 game of thrones Women's History Month anime 4/20 Trailer Crunchyroll Mindy Kaling Classic Film OneApp Musicals disaster Elton John psycho parents Calendar LGBTQ OWN medical drama Amazon Prime Video Extras documentaries Rock History hist Netflix mission: impossible binge E3 PlayStation Film richard e. Grant tv talk TV renewals The Arrangement police drama revenge kids a nightmare on elm street Podcast TLC Valentine's Day Comedy Central Showtime YouTube golden globes quibi FXX Sony Pictures Warner Bros. doctor who Countdown Infographic Sundance Now dceu versus Martial Arts Musical Opinion Mary Poppins Returns Lifetime Christmas movies Disney streaming service Heroines CBS historical drama sequel LGBT WarnerMedia Binge Guide Marathons Photos cinemax 2016 Ellie Kemper Holidays news sequels CBS All Access dogs die hard comic Pixar reviews Grammys thriller best stoner Emmy Nominations Black History Month Anna Paquin fast and furious Acorn TV ABC YA Vudu Peacock Western Disney+ Disney Plus IFC Films justice league Arrowverse IFC foreign DC Universe movies 24 frames video Marvel Studios Awards toy story SXSW rotten Action Certified Fresh Mudbound Apple TV Plus Television Academy robots A&E romantic comedy Amazon Prime streaming canceled TV shows Writers Guild of America Film Festival cats finale TCA 2017 technology Mystery The Walking Dead 2019 Cartoon Network Lionsgate aliens Hallmark 2017 Super Bowl christmas movies cooking Winter TV Star Wars BBC America New York Comic Con crime thriller spider-man Oscars Creative Arts Emmys movie Summer Britbox superhero SDCC PaleyFest nature slashers Shondaland Starz crime what to watch Black Mirror transformers docudrama renewed TV shows Kids & Family Disney Plus Sundance TV based on movie witnail south america 71st Emmy Awards hollywood Trophy Talk DGA TruTV Teen child's play ratings Nominations Fox News space The Purge anthology ITV television screen actors guild Lifetime romance sag awards franchise Dark Horse Comics halloween The CW First Look Food Network PBS harry potter spy thriller cancelled TV series hispanic cancelled television spain Mary poppins HBO Max batman Election YouTube Premium singing competition Drama 2020 Avengers game show Watching Series natural history talk show serial killer Marvel festivals TV Land green book werewolf casting 2015 Endgame Tubi adaptation Spring TV vampires name the review Tomatazos MTV independent MSNBC Comic Book social media concert strong female leads FX on Hulu Cannes Winners cancelled VOD adventure DC streaming service cars TCA Winter 2020 Comics on TV breaking bad Christmas Academy Awards chucky Hear Us Out Rom-Com dark travel comedies Funimation BET E! Horror 007 Polls and Games films Ghostbusters X-Men Crackle Pirates latino Country See It Skip It TCA Awards Pop dragons Baby Yoda sitcom elevated horror teaser GLAAD CW Seed indie book Syfy Masterpiece worst HBO Comedy supernatural Turner Classic Movies First Reviews AMC Animation comics Ovation Logo TIFF 20th Century Fox miniseries