Five Favorite Films

Neil Gaiman's Five Favorite Films

The Sandman graphic novel series writer and author of Good Omens – now a streaming series – chooses classics, including If…, His Girl Friday, and All That Jazz.

by | May 30, 2019 | Comments

LONDON, ENGLAND - MAY 28: Neil Gaiman attends the Global premiere of Amazon Original "Good Omens" at Odeon Luxe Leicester Square on May 28, 2019 in London, England. (Photo by Mike Marsland/WireImage)

Debbie Day

Beloved novelist Neil GaimanCoraline, American Gods, Stardust, and The Sandman graphic novel series — took charge of the book-to-screen adaptation of the 1990 novel Good Omens: The Nice and Accurate Prophecies of Agnes Nutter, Witch to fulfill a promise to his good friend and collaborator Terry Prachett, who died in 2015. Now that the series Good Omens has arrived as an Amazon Prime offering, we caught up with Gaiman to talk about the new comedic fantasy series and his favorite films.

The limited series boasts a stellar lineup of acting talent, including Michael Sheen (Frost/Nixon) as angel Aziraphale, who botches his gig as Garden of Eden chief of security by allowing demon Crowley, played by David Tennant (Doctor Who), to tempt Eve with an apple from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. In the subsequent millennia, the two find themselves repeatedly at odds, and form a friendship of a sort that only two mutually admiring adversaries can. Their bond transcends the modern bromance and is more celestial in nature, with Crowley regularly tempting Aziraphale into small transgressions on his path, and Aziraphale occasionally coaxing out Crowley’s better angel. Their friendship meets the ultimate test when the Antichrist arrives and is promptly misplaced. The duo must work together to stop End Times lest humanity, good wine, and fine cuisine perish in the Apocalypse.

Mad Men’s Jon Hamm is a brash, Americanized Archangel Gabriel, who is captain of Team Heaven, while Anna Maxwell Martin (The Bletchley Circle) appears as Beelzebub, leader of the forces of Hell. Josie Lawrence (Enchanted April) appears as 17th century witch Agnes Nutter, who produces the only accurate book of prophecies ever written. Adria Arjona (True Detective) is Anathema Device, a witch and Agnes Nutter’s descendant, while Miranda Richardson appears as part-time medium and prostitute Madame Tracy, who cares for her righteous neighbor, Witchfinder Sergeant Shadwell played by Michael McKean. Frances McDormand is the voice of God, Benedict Cumberbatch voices Satan, and Sam Taylor Buck is reluctant Antichrist Adam Young.

The series, a coproduction of Amazon Studios and BBC Studios, is directed by Douglas Mackinnon (Doctor Who) and also features Jack Whitehall, Mireille Enos, Brian Cox, Nick Offerman, Ned Dennehy, Ariyon Bakare, Nina Sosanya, Steve Pemberton, and Mark Gatiss.

Gaiman, whose Starz adaptation of American Gods was recently renewed for a third season, shared his five favorite films and another fantasy he’s working on: retirement.


Debbie Day for Rotten Tomatoes: We’re doing a feature called “Five Favorite Films.” Were you able to give that any thought?

Neil Gaiman: You know I really wish somebody had said, “They are doing a feature called ‘Five Favorite Films,’ please have five films ready.” Then I could have just had it for you, rather than what I’m going to have to do now which is grab a piece of paper and a pencil and scribble. Just give me a few seconds, I’m just going the scribble. The nice thing about lists of favorite films is … they always change. Let’s see, there’s four and … OK, there we are, there’s five favorite films jotted down. Don’t know that they’d be the same five favorite films that I would come up with …Tuesday next. But, they’re a good start.

If.... (1968) 91%

The first one would be Lindsay Anderson’s If… It’s a film that I love because it allows me sometimes try and explain what it was like to be a kid at an English Public School — I was a scholarship boy in the early 1970s — late ’60s where you were in — even though it’s set earlier than that and was made earlier than that — you were in a culture that hasn’t changed.

I remember just watching it and suddenly feeling understood. Which was a completely new one for me. I’d be, you know, This is my world. It was like, OK, here is something Malcolm McDowell–starring, the idea of kids — while we didn’t actually shoot up the school in rebellion, it was the kind of strange stuffy environment that needed to come tumbling down, and I’d never seen that before depicted on film. For years I wondered about why some sequences were in black and white, and many years later I was reading an interview with Lindsey Anderson and discovered it was because they ran out of money for color film, so they just went over to black and white stock, which works in several places through the story.

All That Jazz (1979) 86%

Second film: All That Jazz, Bob Fosse. It’s an incredibly hopeful, uplifting art journey and you know, on the one hand it’s about a man who is killing himself through over-work and who is over-extended and miserable and is going to die of a heart attack, and on the other hand, it’s Bob Fosse’s celebration of the fact that he didn’t die of a heart attack. He came through, and now he’s going to take the events that precipitated him into his heart attack, create a roman à clef around them, and build something magical, which he does. There’s a sort of strange and lovely honesty to it that, the first time I saw it when I was about 15/16 and it was on television, I found arresting, and it’s magic.

Drowning by Numbers (1988) 92%

A third film I’m going to list is Peter Greenaway’s film Drowning by Numbers. And Drowning by Numbers, a few years ago my wife and I at the Brattle Theater in Cambridge, [Massachusetts,] got to show each other films that we loved, and the one that was the hardest for the Brattle to get hold of was a cinema print of Drowning by Numbers. I really wanted to see it on a big screen again; I’d seen it on a big screen when it first came out, and in the intervening years, seen it on video, but loved it. It’s a film about games, it’s a film about numbers, it’s a film about murder, men being murdered by women, who may all be the same woman, but are, at least the way that I read it, aspects of the triple Goddess — the maiden, the mother, and the crone — but all of them are having the same relationship with men. All of them are profoundly killing off these rather abusive and appalling men in their life, and it’s a strangely beautiful and absolutely surreal film that plays by its own rules.

And one of its rules is it makes you in the audience count. You start noticing numbers showing up on screen and realize they are counting to 100. So when you are at number 50 on the screen and a character is explaining to you the rules of the game, you realize that you have another 50 to go and you’re exactly halfway through. Beautiful performances and beautifully filmed, and just one of those places where, as far I am concerned I wish there was so much more cinema like that, but there doesn’t seem to be.

His Girl Friday (1940) 98%

No. 4, I’d go for His Girl Friday. There’s just that Howard Hawks rapid dialogue, the glory of Cary Grant [at his] most Cary Grant-ish. It’s funny. It moves, it actually has huge social responsibility, and they did a thing where they gender-swapped the lead. Hilly, in the play The Front Page and in other films made of The Front Page, is a guy going off to get married and having that be sabotaged by his editor. Howard Hawks’ twisting things, so that Rosalind Russell played Hilly and was the ex-wife of Cary Grant’s, her abusive and appalling editor who was also determined to get a story and have her get the story and have her not leave. There was brilliance in that, and it’s feisty, and it’s funny, and it’s something that I can watch over and over again and never get tired of.

Beauty and The Beast (La Belle et la bête) (1946) 95%

And then you get into the contentious fifth film, and I’ve jotted down a bunch of things I thought, well Ran is a possibility. I love Akira Kurosawa‘s take on King Lear, I love what he did to it. I love the movement, the battles. You know, there’s nothing about that film I do not enjoy. Laurel and Hardy’s Way Out West, because I thought that would be a wonderful choice, and it does have, to my mind, the finest dance in the whole of film. But, I thought about A Matter of Life and Death, which was a film that was enormously inspirational when making Good Omens. I felt like that was of the same DNA as the thing that we were doing … Also Bedazzled, the original Peter Cook and Dudley Moore Bedazzled, which again has a lot of the DNA of Good Omens in it.

But eventually I came down on Belle et la bête, [Jean] Cocteau’s Beauty and the Beast. I remember watching it and feeling transported. For me, it’s like dreaming. It does the same that Bride of Frankenstein does, where I can never quite remember the plot when it’s over, I’m just aware that it’s finished now and this wonderful place that I went has gone away.

My children do not like black-and-white films, and once, for Father’s Day, my daughters asked what I wanted for Father’s Day, and I asked, “Will you watch this film with me? It’s a foreign language film, so you won’t like it, and it’s black and white, so you won’t like it, but will you watch it with me?” They said, “Well yeah, for Father’s Day we will.” And what I loved was that after 10 minutes, they had forgotten that it was a foreign language film, and they had forgotten that it was a black-and-white film, and they were entranced by this retelling of Beauty and the Beast, made by Cocteau not even on a shoestring; he’s in post-war France, immediately post war, and they had no money for anything. Everything is being improvised. Everything is being created on the fly, and yet what they come up with is something that is so much cooler than any infinite amount of CGI.


Speaking of heart attacks and artists, how’s TV development treating you? I mean you seem extraordinarily busy.

Gaiman: I am, although, you know, a week from now on the 31st of May, Good Omens comes out and happens, and I get to retire as a showrunner. I guess I might have to come out of retirement if we get nominated for awards — just turn up at award dinners and things. But basically as far as I’m concerned I made this thing that I promised Terry Pratchett I would make and now I’m done. I don’t have to be a showrunner anymore. I love talking all the things that I’ve learned in the four years I’ve been making Good Omens and getting to apply them to other things and getting to help other people make things.

So you know, it’s nice to be a producer of Gormenghast, for example, and I’m very actually looking forward to seeing and helping Toby Whithouse along and looking forward to Toby going out to the world with his Gormenghast. I’m looking forward to being more involved in adaptations of my own stuff coming up in the future, but I don’t really want to write them again, I don’t want to showrun again. I would really like to become a writer, and possibly even a novelist again.

I hear you have some talent for that.

Gaiman: As I’ve said, I will become a retired showrunner, and in my retirement, I may take up writing.


Michael Sheen and David Tennant in Good Omens (Amazon Studios)

(Photo by Amazon Prime)

Good Omens looks like it was a blast to film. What was that experience like?

Gaiman: It was a blast to film. Good Omens was fascinating because it was an incredibly long shoot. We were making Good Omens, I think we shot altogether for about 120 days, and it’s a lot like making a 6-hour-long movie. And when we finished, it was then followed by 11 months of post-production, so that was long, long days, hard work, making something huge, but also — more by luck than anything else, because it just came down to me and director Douglas MacKinnon so much of the time — we wound up making something that feels very, very handmade and feels pretty personal. We got to make personal choices, and there wasn’t anybody leaning over our shoulders saying, “No you need this. You can’t do that.”

Is that one of the joys of working with a streaming company?

Gaiman: I think Amazon trusted us, which was great, and the BBC who were technically our producers, nobody had ever done anything like this before, and they didn’t really know what it was, and they just left us alone to get on with it.

Well, you can’t argue with the result – it’s a joy to watch your work come to life with such talented actors.

Neil Gaiman: Thank you. I’m so proud of it. I made the show for Terry Pratchett, he asked me to make it before he died, and then he died. I wanted to make a show that Terry would have loved, and make a show that Terry would have laughed at, but also that contained all of the ideas and the textures of Good Omens, and I think we did it.

May I ask, what is going on with The Sandman? That’s one I’ve been really looking forward to.

Gaiman: Sandman has been interesting, because for the last 30 years … people have failed to make all sorts of versions of Sandman because the time was not right. In the ’90s people were going, “We don’t know how to make a $70 million R-rated film that would have any CGI in it … that doesn’t work for us,” and all of this kind of stuff. What’s great about now is we’ve reached an era in which the fact that there are well over 80 Sandman stories becomes a feature, it becomes an advantage, rather than a problem with how you cram all that into 120 minutes.

So, we now have the CGI, we now have the technology, and we now have an adult audience, and we have millions upon millions of people who love Sandman and would love to see it. So I would be very, very surprised if we do not actually get some cool Sandman thing happening in the next two or three years. But then again, there have been many things over the years with Sandman where I’ve gone, “Ah, OK. Well, they’re going to make this. And this is going to be great then.” And it has never happened. So anything is possible.


Good Omens debuts on Friday, May 31 on Amazon Prime.

Tag Cloud

jamie lee curtis mutant mission: impossible The CW TIFF YouTube Red APB GoT ID finale composers Superheroe doctor who Warner Bros. a nightmare on elm street Apple TV+ true crime casting TCA 2017 zero dark thirty facebook spider-man San Diego Comic-Con singing competition based on movie quibi nfl Acorn TV Pop TV Academy Awards kids BBC One DGA Peacock Star Trek Action Pirates hispanic IFC Films Television Academy TCA Winter 2020 sitcom A&E A24 Logo Hear Us Out screenings Biopics rotten RT History game of thrones Ellie Kemper book 2016 directors Marvel Studios Cosplay HBO Go laika technology werewolf The Arrangement Crunchyroll social media The Academy ABC Disney Channel italian Reality Competition crime drama movies japanese reboot PBS aliens ESPN stoner TV renewals sequel transformers Certified Fresh romantic comedy crime Sundance TV Tomatazos Amazon Prime worst Tarantino films Comic Book Funimation Emmys franchise Music SundanceTV Television Critics Association Awards Film Festival Super Bowl Nominations Turner Disney Plus El Rey ratings Opinion diversity theme song adventure Universal Infographic Classic Film Mudbound Brie Larson documentaries disaster name the review serial killer Watching Series halloween BBC America adaptation batman Western ITV elevated horror Tubi halloween tv OneApp canceled TV shows TV Box Office Schedule psycho Summer FX stand-up comedy TCM universal monsters Women's History Month 007 Spike FXX series zombie Heroines critics 21st Century Fox sag awards medical drama documentary boxoffice HBO Max psychological thriller Ovation fast and furious IFC Winners MCU animated Anna Paquin Mary Poppins Returns Britbox festival 2018 Black History Month CMT comedies Cartoon Network USA Network cooking Syfy Disney asian-american Interview Creative Arts Emmys space cancelled TV shows classics Sony Pictures Mary Tyler Moore latino Animation satire venice PlayStation video on demand The Purge Masterpiece foreign Hulu cops child's play Valentine's Day VOD Grammys Chilling Adventures of Sabrina nature spy thriller Trivia WGN anthology independent binge christmas movies Spring TV blaxploitation New York Comic Con Year in Review Film Amazon Prime Video Holidays 2015 Netflix Christmas movies tv talk TruTV Pride Month Fantasy war Avengers robots Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt DC Comics CNN Podcast video Disney streaming service criterion Thanksgiving ghosts Cannes spanish language Endgame comic Kids & Family spain political drama cancelled 2017 TCA Toys crossover Oscars archives docudrama Black Mirror witnail VICE dc screen actors guild 24 frames news Lucasfilm First Look 2020 Musical X-Men Quiz Rom-Com GLAAD Chernobyl toronto cinemax Awards Tour Showtime twilight LGBTQ green book parents cars science fiction joker Rock GIFs Stephen King Musicals blockbuster First Reviews Hallmark best festivals 2019 YouTube Family scorecard hist Columbia Pictures australia hollywood TBS historical drama sports Best and Worst james bond Nat Geo Reality politics Elton John harry potter dceu Amazon Studios Captain marvel Pet Sematary Discovery Channel Mary poppins scary movies Spectrum Originals indiana jones E! VH1 Paramount Hallmark Christmas movies President strong female leads rt archives BET Awards Comics on TV indie Mindy Kaling Emmy Nominations American Society of Cinematographers 45 comic books 71st Emmy Awards Shudder Horror TV Land Pixar deadpool Food Network renewed TV shows concert south america LGBT justice league biography Extras DC Universe Drama Rocketman superhero Election Set visit dogs DC streaming service RT21 Country discovery Song of Ice and Fire History children's TV Tumblr Christmas MSNBC toy story romance Esquire Adult Swim Apple TV Plus Martial Arts vampires Teen Binge Guide USA NBC cancelled TV series BAFTA streaming cults slashers Epix Sci-Fi canceled period drama Dark Horse Comics TLC Bravo movie supernatural free movies unscripted spanish Disney+ Disney Plus AMC award winner breaking bad Fox Searchlight cancelled television travel teaser Fall TV versus Paramount Network DirecTV comiccon stop motion TNT Crackle Rocky talk show Lifetime Christmas movies black mockumentary NYCC See It Skip It comics rotten movies we love Character Guide Sundance Now Freeform Arrowverse obituary Fox News police drama CBS PaleyFest Starz Red Carpet dragons Premiere Dates Mystery Marvel Television Trophy Talk FX on Hulu golden globes Superheroes MTV anime Marathons 4/20 SDCC Marvel Countdown reviews YA revenge Turner Classic Movies The Walking Dead Amazon CW Seed miniseries Baby Yoda nbcuniversal football Apple french game show Ghostbusters Vudu Trailer Sundance chucky Nickelodeon CBS All Access zombies Photos Calendar BBC FOX richard e. Grant WarnerMedia Holiday cats Video Games Sneak Peek OWN HBO Comedy Central thriller Winter TV Walt Disney Pictures BET what to watch Travel Channel Star Wars Writers Guild of America Pop all-time Lionsgate SXSW cartoon Lifetime TCA Awards spinoff dramedy dark sequels remakes worst movies YouTube Premium National Geographic crime thriller Netflix The Witch Polls and Games Shondaland television die hard Comedy E3 natural history 72 Emmy Awards emmy awards ABC Family 20th Century Fox