"Men Smear!": Revisiting Seminal LGBTQ Comedy The Birdcage

Critic Manuel Betancourt says his relationship with the hit American comedy has evolved, just as he has.

by | June 12, 2019 | Comments

This year, Rotten Tomatoes expanded our list of the best-reviewed LGBTQ movies of all time to 200 films. To celebrate those works and mark Pride month, we asked a number of Tomatometer-approved critics to reflect on the LGBTQ movies that influenced their lives and their work. 

As the kind of sissy boy whom my schoolmates scolded for my lack of soccer skills and my predilection for choir practice (I was a soprano, naturally), I spent much of my childhood wrestling with my own seemingly insufficient masculinity. Despite how obviously I failed at performing manliness, I was wracked with anxiety about how I knew I should act. This is not as uncommon an experience as I felt it was. Whether you grew up in Colombia, as I did, or in the South of France or in Miami, the pressures of acting like a man were as soul-crushing as they were laughable. This is what one of my favorite movies growing up taught me, though not until I revisited it decades later.

The Birdcage is, above all, a farce about masculinity. About its frailty and its attendant anxieties. Based on Édouard Molinaro’s La Cage aux Folles, Mike Nichols’s broad comedy stars Robin Williams (in khakis and a Selleck-ish mustache) and Nathan Lane (in linen pants and the occasional wig) as Armand and Albert Goldman. The couple run the The Birdcage, a drag club in South Beach where Albert (as “Starina”) is its greatest star. When Armand’s son Val (Dan Futterman) informs him that he’s going to  marry his girlfriend Barbara (Calista Flockhart) he caveats the good news with a request: might he go along with the white lie Barbara told her ultra-conservative parents, Senator Kevin Keeley (Gene Hackman) and his wife Louise (Dianne Wiest), that Armand is a straight cultural attaché?

The Birdcage (MGM Home Entertainment/Everett Collection)
(Photo by MGM Home Entertainment / Everett Collection)

The comedy stems from the failed attempts at keeping the charade of a heterosexual (and heteronormative) Goldman family. If Albert cannot present himself to the Keeleys as Armand’s partner, by god he’ll do it as Val’s definitely-not-gay uncle, a scenario that gives Lane every delicious comic beat he could ever hope to play. In one of the scenes that I could probably still perform from memory, Albert tries to butch himself up. He practices spreading some mustard on some toast only to be scolded by his frustrated lover: “Don’t use the spoon! And don’t dribble little dots of mustard: men smear! Smear!

The film was a staple of my teenage years. Whenever it was on cable we’d watch it as a family. We’d laugh in unison as we saw Lane’s flailing attempts to walk straight, only to end up deciding to pass himself off as Val’s mother in surprisingly convincing Old Lady drag. My laughter was, during those family viewings, comforting and discomfiting in equal measure. I laughed at Lane’s femininity in a way that I hoped inoculated my own. What a laughable stereotype, I thought. Thank god I’m not that gay, I reassured myself, still in the closet. I may be called a ‘marica’ in school, but surely I pass more easily than this out-of-drag drag queen. I loved the film precisely because it gave me room for such distance.

The Birdcage (MGM Home Entertainment/Getty Images)
(Photo by MGM Home Entertainment / Getty Collection)

By the time I got to college, that kind of thinking led me to a revisionist understanding of the film that felt all the more insidious: it’s films like these – big broad comedies trafficking in caricature – that fuel the homophobia around me. Couldn’t we do better? Couldn’t we be more than punchlines? Did we have to be effeminate gay men with high-pitched voices who couldn’t hold their pinkies in check when “smearing” our toast?

It’s only slowly dawned on me how much I came to project onto The Birdcage which, Hank Azaria’s lisping “Guatemalanness” aside, is a wholly assured satire about homophobia and masculinity. Nichols walks a fine line between finding Val’s request and the subsequent comedy of errors it precipitates as preposterous and hilarious, insulting and entertaining. And while Albert may look like a fey stooge, it is his sensibility which runs through the film; it’s his drag which saves the day and reveals the Keeleys’ (and Val’s) hang-ups as utterly laughable. In its campy theatrics, The Birdcage encourages us all to be more like Albert, to see in his gay femininity a kind of strength we all too often mock and disparage. Sometimes even within ourselves.

Manuel Betancourt is a culture writer and film critic interested in all things queer and Latinx.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.


The Birdcage (1996)

Adjusted Score: 81.241%
Critics Consensus: Mike Nichols wrangles agreeably amusing performances from Robin Williams and Nathan Lane in this fun, if not quite essential, remake of the French comedy La Cage aux Folles.
Synopsis: Armand Goldman owns a popular drag nightclub in South Miami Beach. His long-time lover, Albert, stars there as Starina. "Their"... [More]
Directed By: Mike Nichols

Tag Cloud

sports Turner Classic Movies Mary Tyler Moore Thanksgiving Extras disaster Awards Valentine's Day Biopics Oscars Disney Plus vampires elevated horror FXX Box Office FX TLC Christmas singing competition strong female leads spanish language green book BBC America Photos dceu Fantasy IFC Films Film Festival anime miniseries A&E Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt aliens Cartoon Network Apple TV Plus Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Nominations DC streaming service werewolf Martial Arts psychological thriller Comic Book Binge Guide Country RT21 The Witch Spike YouTube Red comic Winners 2015 Paramount Network APB robots Logo Certified Fresh First Look USA Network Starz cinemax Shondaland Superheroes Polls and Games GLAAD teaser Character Guide Trivia 71st Emmy Awards DirecTV Freeform witnail justice league TCM Heroines TV renewals dramedy Marvel Studios Western 007 TIFF 21st Century Fox Writers Guild of America Arrowverse X-Men discovery Masterpiece Women's History Month true crime Black Mirror Britbox psycho Spring TV ESPN movies Emmys Comedy cancelled TV series Song of Ice and Fire Marvel Television Film 2018 Spectrum Originals facebook President DC Universe CBS crime thriller YouTube Rock Pixar Captain marvel Family Crackle Sundance E3 Podcast Vudu Pet Sematary Stephen King Awards Tour GoT The CW 24 frames Nickelodeon The Walking Dead San Diego Comic-Con Hulu Watching Series Comedy Central New York Comic Con Columbia Pictures Premiere Dates doctor who boxoffice Tomatazos Sneak Peek Holidays medical drama Year in Review television 45 Mary poppins thriller Marvel police drama Adult Swim cooking ghosts YA biography Schedule independent Calendar Sony Pictures VICE Tarantino Teen PBS TV Land binge The Arrangement romance spinoff Hallmark latino CBS All Access children's TV game show unscripted Emmy Nominations American Society of Cinematographers cartoon Ovation toy story spain hist theme song kids spider-man comics game of thrones technology Video Games Winter TV politics versus war mockumentary Dark Horse Comics Lionsgate series political drama USA Set visit A24 Apple Pirates ratings LGBTQ Mudbound Superheroe TCA sitcom Lifetime Christmas movies Netflix Epix stand-up comedy Pop breaking bad anthology TNT HBO halloween what to watch casting natural history Best and Worst Turner south america Reality Opinion TruTV Animation Showtime Disney streaming service ABC Walt Disney Pictures ABC Family Mystery Countdown diversity SDCC TBS blaxploitation Ellie Kemper Warner Bros. canceled TV shows dragons canceled social media Tumblr Bravo composers talk show indie Anna Paquin Universal finale Super Bowl FOX foreign Elton John WGN cars NYCC transformers Summer Rocketman cults Amazon Disney zero dark thirty OWN romantic comedy travel cats GIFs Cosplay NBC animated video adaptation Amazon Prime AMC Creative Arts Emmys Fox News Rom-Com slashers based on movie tv talk richard e. Grant Trailer CMT National Geographic award winner Quiz Horror MTV hispanic Nat Geo adventure quibi Music zombies festivals Comics on TV comiccon Mindy Kaling crime supernatural 2019 Mary Poppins Returns See It Skip It golden globes Sundance Now nature book Disney+ Disney Plus Sci-Fi Musical Infographic ITV Reality Competition Ghostbusters LGBT spy thriller crime drama Apple TV+ Crunchyroll christmas movies dc Fall TV The Purge Syfy Pride Month Toys Kids & Family crossover Trophy Talk Rocky PaleyFest rotten movies we love Musicals Lucasfilm Star Wars space Paramount cancelled Hallmark Christmas movies Esquire DC Comics Chernobyl First Reviews SXSW RT History 2016 batman free movies Interview Election Classic Film MCU 2017 Cannes MSNBC Drama cops Television Academy El Rey mutant BBC streaming WarnerMedia TCA 2017 20th Century Fox science fiction Marathons History Holiday period drama Star Trek SundanceTV HBO Max Shudder Red Carpet Brie Larson Netflix Christmas movies cancelled TV shows YouTube Premium Food Network serial killer revenge BET Action DGA docudrama jamie lee curtis Peacock VH1 IFC historical drama renewed TV shows CNN Acorn TV TV Disney Channel zombie Amazon Prime Video cancelled television CW Seed screenings blockbuster Lifetime joker Grammys E! harry potter sequel