Critics Consensus

John Wick: Chapter 3 is Certified Fresh

Plus, A Dog's Journey completes its mission and The Sun is Also a Star could shine brighter.

by | May 16, 2019 | Comments

The third chapter in the story about a character who avenges his dog (Keanu Reeves stars in John Wick: Chapter 3 – Parabellum), a new film about a pup’s adventure (Josh Gad voices the titular pooch in A Dog’s Journey) and a teen drama based on a dog-eared best-seller (Yara Shahidi and Charles Melton play young lovers in The Sun is Also a Star), make up the movies heading into wide release this weekend. Which one gets the critics’ top pick?


John Wick: Chapter 3 - Parabellum (2019) 90%


Keanu Reeves returns to the slick action-adventure franchise as the titular ace assassin who now has a $14 million bounty on his head after he killed a member of the international assassin’s guild, the High Table. Chad Stahelski, who directed the first films (David Leitch co-directed with him on the original), returns with original John Wick writer Derek Kolstad, among others, penning this script. Laurence Fishburne also returns as the crime boss and ornithophile, The Bowery King. This film is tracking slightly better than the prior two from the franchise, which, respectively, have 87% and 89% Tomatometer scores.

A Dog's Journey (2019) 50%


Director Gail Mancuso, an accomplished television director whose recent credits include family-friendly series like Modern Family and Black-ish, has gone not just for sweet, but the saccharin with her first feature film. Josh Gad voices a dying dog named Bailey who promises his “boy” Ethan (Dennis Quaid) that he’ll keep tabs on Ethan’s granddaughter as his soul prepares to enter the body of a new dog. Whether critics see this gimmick as manipulative or moving, the film will probably still find a box office showing with families looking for an afternoon activity – and so far reviews say it’s a hard tearjearker to resist.

The Sun Is Also a Star (2019) 51%


Tracy Oliver, who has made a name for herself for writing or co-writing female-positive films like Girls Trip and Little, is trying her hand at the teen romance genre with this adaptation of Nicola Yoon’s novel, The Sun is Also a Star. Yara Shahidi – whose Black-ish co-star, Marsai Martin, coincidentally, starred in Little – plays a Jamaica-born quantum physics student named Natasha who falls for Charles Melton’s sweet exchange student, Daniel. The young lovers soon face real-life consequences when Natasha’s family faces deportation. Despite the topicality of Sun, and the winning performances of its talented leads, most reviews say the film flames out as it stretches believability.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Walking on Water (2019) : Bulgarian director Andrey Paounov’s documentary about environmental artist Christo’s attempts to complete his first major project after the death of his wife — and long-time collaborator — Jeanne-Claude: “The Floating Piers,” a floating yellow walkway on Italy’s Lake Iseo. It’s Certified Fresh with a score of 100% on the Tomatometer.
  • The Souvenir (2019) : Writer-director Joanna Hogg’s #MeToo-relevant story about a film student who finds her voice as an artist while embarking on an emotionally fraught relationship with an older man is 93% Fresh.
  • All Creatures Here Below (2019) : David Dastmalchian and Karen Gillan star as impoverished Angelenos whose criminal act sends them on the lam. It’s at 86% on the Tomatometer.
  • We Have Always Lived in the Castle (2019) : Taissa Farmiga stars as a young woman who is one of her few family members to survive an arsenic poisoning. She’s making do – until her controlling cousin Charlie (Sebastian Stan) arrives. Based on the Shirley Jackson novel, this film is 86% Fresh on the Tomatometer.
  • Photograph (2019) : The Lunchbox’s Ritesh Batra directs this romance about a shy street photographer in Mumbai who asks a woman to pose as his fiancée in an effort to appease his grandmother.
  • Amaurosis (The Unseen) (2019) : In the Hands of the Gods’ Gary Sinyor writes and directs this mystery drama about a couple grieving the loss of their son.
  • Trial by Fire (2019) : Jack O’Connell and Laura Dern star in director Edward Zwick’s adaptation of the true story of a death row inmate and the woman who fought to get him free.
  • ANIARA (2019) : This sci-fi fantasy film about humans who don’t cope well when they leave Earth for a resettlement on Mars falls mostly flat with a 47% Tomatometer score.
  • Perfect (2019) : Steven Soderbergh executive produces this film about a troubled man who gets reprogrammed to help with his dark thoughts. Things don’t go as planned for the characters or for the film itself, which is at 29% currently.
  • The Professor (2019) : Johnny Depp plays a college professor who lets loose when he finds out he has six months to live in this dark comedy. Critics give the film a failing grade of 0%.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Funimation historical drama harry potter Western foreign cooking VICE Avengers green book MSNBC movies sequel chucky BBC Infographic documentary GoT supernatural a nightmare on elm street Martial Arts concert rotten movies we love DC Comics Podcast independent classics YouTube remakes travel Family nature Trivia Esquire Food Network USA social media Emmys BET Awards TCA Pet Sematary superhero Trophy Talk Lifetime politics Rom-Com Elton John IFC Films batman Women's History Month screenings ESPN crime thriller NBC asian-american Lionsgate Film parents El Rey news Warner Bros. A24 FXX Spectrum Originals Vudu Showtime 4/20 hist Watching Series latino zombies discovery comedies VOD breaking bad spanish language Winners Paramount Network movie what to watch child's play casting Logo E! animated FX Rock thriller cancelled TV series sitcom See It Skip It SXSW Year in Review festival Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt quibi 2017 Awards Grammys President canceled Election TCM USA Network mission: impossible Disney streaming service Fox News Schedule jamie lee curtis Nominations Opinion Turner game of thrones series LGBT Stephen King CW Seed MTV Video Games versus RT History Quiz binge Pixar indiana jones Rocky Arrowverse worst children's TV serial killer Tumblr romantic comedy VH1 YouTube Red 24 frames films crossover Star Wars Winter TV anime Reality Competition Captain marvel best Holidays cartoon dark Netflix Comedy Central TCA Awards Pop TV natural history sequels Sci-Fi Disney+ Disney Plus Drama festivals rotten MCU WGN Television Critics Association San Diego Comic-Con unscripted streaming Turner Classic Movies Sundance Now Lucasfilm Starz spider-man Apple TV+ zombie joker Thanksgiving Ellie Kemper Pop 71st Emmy Awards PaleyFest dragons X-Men comic OneApp facebook richard e. Grant Comic Book toronto award winner Peacock The Witch witnail TruTV Ovation police drama Brie Larson Walt Disney Pictures TV renewals cancelled TV shows Cannes Tarantino YouTube Premium 2020 werewolf screen actors guild satire BET Awards Tour cancelled television Shudder revenge History RT21 TV Sundance TV NYCC true crime cinemax tv talk diversity scary movies political drama Netflix Christmas movies HBO Max name the review DC Universe 20th Century Fox APB Trailer TCA 2017 FOX Mary Poppins Returns Calendar Creative Arts Emmys Marvel Studios Hear Us Out crime drama golden globes Black Mirror composers 2015 adaptation vampires space HBO strong female leads TIFF Mary Tyler Moore Epix hollywood disaster 72 Emmy Awards television universal monsters spy thriller GIFs Comedy fast and furious Hulu Spike Rocketman Best and Worst FX on Hulu Song of Ice and Fire ghosts Red Carpet Academy Awards TLC spain period drama Kids & Family The Arrangement slashers Pirates Tubi Teen Marathons American Society of Cinematographers Baby Yoda technology dc Anna Paquin Disney TBS Sneak Peek TCA Winter 2020 kids Crackle stoner The Walking Dead New York Comic Con teaser Binge Guide anthology die hard CMT football Paramount DGA ITV Valentine's Day Certified Fresh Cartoon Network canceled TV shows CNN Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Disney Plus Reality mutant cops all-time The Purge reboot Mystery transformers aliens 2018 First Reviews Universal LGBTQ Toys IFC Apple robots Amazon Prime Video Extras cars south america comics renewed TV shows Mary poppins nfl Amazon Prime emmy awards Photos Writers Guild of America Character Guide scorecard psycho Superheroes spinoff cults dogs Hallmark Christmas movies Acorn TV Marvel Film Festival laika PBS dceu Holiday venice Amazon Summer video Star Trek directors doctor who DC streaming service SDCC Sony Pictures Country ABC Amazon Studios documentaries free movies indie Emmy Nominations A&E BBC America Shondaland ratings Travel Channel YA boxoffice video on demand stand-up comedy BBC One WarnerMedia Interview Adult Swim Spring TV SundanceTV Crunchyroll Nickelodeon BAFTA sag awards Countdown CBS All Access 2019 Masterpiece Comics on TV psychological thriller Box Office Oscars Set visit biography Disney Channel Endgame Hallmark Syfy stop motion Animation zero dark thirty DirecTV National Geographic Ghostbusters obituary Chernobyl romance Television Academy Superheroe finale Lifetime Christmas movies GLAAD cats talk show justice league critics Pride Month Action book science fiction hispanic based on movie Marvel Television Sundance OWN mockumentary TV Land crime PlayStation AMC Super Bowl Britbox reviews Bravo Cosplay 45 criterion Discovery Channel Polls and Games 21st Century Fox dramedy Mudbound Fantasy elevated horror Dark Horse Comics franchise HBO Go twilight medical drama The CW singing competition sports Freeform adventure E3 blaxploitation Columbia Pictures miniseries Mindy Kaling Black History Month halloween 007 Premiere Dates worst movies christmas movies CBS Tomatazos Heroines theme song Music Biopics Christmas Classic Film Musical toy story game show comiccon First Look Nat Geo Apple TV Plus docudrama 2016 nbcuniversal war ABC Family Musicals Horror Fall TV TNT cancelled blockbuster