Is Jason Reitman's Upcoming Ghostbusters Sequel A Great Idea? Vote Now

It's reportedly set in the world of the original 1980s films, but no cast has been confirmed.

by | January 17, 2019 | Comments

Two days ago, we learned that a new Ghostbusters movie would be on its way in 2020, and that the man delivering the new movie will be Jason Reitman, director of Juno, Up in the Air, and last year’s Tully and The Front Runner. He also happens to be the son of original Ghostbusters director Ivan Reitman.

The news came via an exclusive report from Entertainment Weekly, which didn’t tell us much else about the new film, except that it’s expected to take place in the universe of the two original Ghostbusters films — a separate timeline, if you will, from the events of the 2016 reboot directed by Paul Feig and starring Melissa McCarthy, Kristen Wiig, Kate McKinnon, and Leslie Jones. That was followed by a short teaser the very next day that prominently featured the iconic Ghostbusters vehicle, the Ecto-1, gathering dust under a tarp in a barn, and the internet understandably geeked out.

But do we need a follow-up of any sort to the original Ghostbusters movies, or should we let them rest in peace? We think this is another topic worth debating, so we’ve gathered two competing viewpoints from RT staffers for you to mull over. Read on for each argument, and then vote in the poll below!

Yes, I Ain’t ‘Fraid of No Sequels

Columbia Pictures

(Photo by Columbia Pictures)

First of all, let’s just address the elephant in the room and say that the recent Paul Feig Ghostbusters wasn’t remotely as bad as the internet would have you believe. That said, it was never going to live up to the original film — or, to a degree, even its admittedly less successful sequel — if only because of its iconic cast and legacy. It inevitably invited comparisons to those 1980s classics and suffered for it, and if nothing else, it reminded us how much we loved those earlier films. The cast hasn’t been announced yet, but this is our (perhaps last) chance to get a proper third movie, albeit without the late Harold Ramis, and we’ll happily take it to spend more time with Peter, Ray, Winston, Dana Barrett, and Louis Tully. Hell, we’d love to see Annie Potts’ Janine again, too. On top of all that, the film is being directed by Jason Reitman, son of Ivan, and not only is he a self-proclaimed lifelong fan of the movies, he himself said that he avoided taking on the project until he had a good enough idea for a story worth telling. When his father read it, he said it was “so emotional and funny” that it made him cry. Taking all of that into account, a new sequel to the original series sounds like a fantastic idea, and the new teaser has effectively put me in the front seat of the hype train.

No, I’d Rather Get Slimed

Look, I love the original Ghostbusters as much as the next fan, and possibly even more; I watched The Real Ghostbusters cartoon religiously, owned action figures, and when I was nine, I lobbied my parents hard (but unsuccessfully) for a proton pack so I could dress up as one for Halloween. I also wasn’t a huge fan of the 2016 Paul Feig reboot, so it would make sense to assume I’d be all for a new film set in the universe of the original film. Would I love to see Bill Murray snark it up as Peter Venkman again? Who wouldn’t? Do I think it would be fun to see the return of Sigourney Weaver’s Dana — and her now grown-up son Oscar? Absolutely. There are, however, a lot of reasons why I don’t think a new sequel is a good idea, and here are just a few.

First, as much as I love the originals, I’d rather Hollywood spend their time and money on some new material. We’ve already got plenty of other remakes, reboots, reimaginings, and sequels without beating another (un)dead horse. Second, Harold Ramis (R.I.P.) is no longer with us, and it just wouldn’t feel right to do a Ghostbusters film without good old Egon, not to mention the fact that we don’t even know if the original cast is returning. Third, yes, Jason Reitman is blood-related to original Ghostbusters director Ivan Reitman, but in no way does that automatically qualify him as a good candidate to direct a sequel. He had a pretty excellent track record for a while, but three of his last four films have ranged from less than stellar to downright inexplicable (Labor Day, anyone?), and he’s never helmed a big, effects-driven blockbuster before. At this juncture, there are just too many unknowns and too many risks involved to make this a good idea.

Tag Cloud

Election transformers movie Super Bowl supernatural Tarantino American Society of Cinematographers CBS BBC Star Wars Best and Worst 71st Emmy Awards Schedule SDCC Premiere Dates politics FX space elevated horror romance Amazon Studios remakes Pixar doctor who Trophy Talk Set visit Marvel Television quibi Freeform Apple TV+ FXX Rom-Com ghosts robots 24 frames GIFs versus award winner halloween DC streaming service OWN crime drama Heroines Comic Book Tumblr Amazon Prime Video scorecard children's TV football Nat Geo true crime TNT casting Chilling Adventures of Sabrina foreign twilight diversity Television Academy PaleyFest Hallmark Christmas movies Syfy VICE Star Trek concert Cosplay stoner Chernobyl thriller Vudu scary movies Calendar independent Brie Larson archives slashers asian-american Country Fantasy comics dragons Lifetime facebook Travel Channel Creative Arts Emmys joker vampires See It Skip It adaptation Discovery Channel Mindy Kaling boxoffice GLAAD Paramount sequel hispanic Awards Tour Biopics A&E Year in Review Disney Channel NBC Fox Searchlight screenings what to watch richard e. Grant zombies Box Office animated Red Carpet political drama Epix all-time Disney+ Disney Plus RT21 4/20 superhero Esquire Crackle TCA 2017 cops Valentine's Day binge latino Lucasfilm Captain marvel Shudder 20th Century Fox screen actors guild indie Emmys 007 Britbox LGBT BBC One natural history X-Men Baby Yoda The CW Disney TV zombie rotten golden globes cancelled television FOX E! unscripted worst Extras History game show travel dc Comedy Starz New York Comic Con psychological thriller Lionsgate directors PlayStation tv talk werewolf PBS game of thrones critics Nominations Toys Endgame TCA Awards NYCC Animation theme song Universal biography news venice Watching Series kids Turner Interview stop motion criterion dramedy Mary Tyler Moore Sundance TV Sci-Fi talk show Television Critics Association anthology Hulu Acorn TV Photos Reality Competition dark jamie lee curtis romantic comedy canceled A24 comic rt archives james bond composers Netflix Christmas movies australia toronto miniseries toy story DC Comics The Arrangement The Witch festivals Hear Us Out mission: impossible medical drama Character Guide cartoon period drama Mary Poppins Returns cooking Spring TV black christmas movies 45 Pirates name the review AMC The Walking Dead TV Land Academy Awards Drama First Look YouTube El Rey serial killer Warner Bros. Western dceu Showtime Peacock Opinion TBS worst movies Musical IFC VOD Ovation Adult Swim documentary ABC Family comedies 2016 justice league Grammys Cartoon Network Winter TV Sundance Now police drama nature Mudbound Action discovery blaxploitation hist Holiday chucky sports Food Network TIFF Bravo Stephen King Superheroe 2019 singing competition book Infographic Black Mirror ESPN reviews YouTube Premium OneApp Nickelodeon cancelled TV series WGN VH1 technology TruTV HBO Musicals streaming YouTube Red GoT based on movie Lifetime Christmas movies USA festival disaster First Reviews spanish revenge video Turner Classic Movies Emmy Nominations Netflix Rocketman Tubi ratings teaser rotten movies we love HBO Go emmy awards television The Purge ITV crossover Disney streaming service LGBTQ canceled TV shows E3 reboot halloween tv Oscars mockumentary TV renewals video on demand DGA San Diego Comic-Con 2018 comic books crime MTV WarnerMedia war Polls and Games Film Pop TV a nightmare on elm street Elton John TCA spider-man Family harry potter spy thriller best CNN Shondaland HBO Max 2020 Rocky zero dark thirty series Thanksgiving Binge Guide cancelled TV shows mutant Certified Fresh Paramount Network CW Seed Anna Paquin Amazon Prime sequels nfl DirecTV Trailer Summer Countdown ID TCA Winter 2020 Kids & Family docudrama Avengers 21st Century Fox Ghostbusters RT History Rock DC Universe National Geographic Black History Month ABC historical drama renewed TV shows blockbuster SXSW witnail Pet Sematary Marvel classics adventure Superheroes 2015 Hallmark Logo universal monsters cars cancelled fast and furious Dark Horse Comics TCM psycho Mary poppins obituary Film Festival finale Quiz cats breaking bad hollywood dogs parents crime thriller Mystery YA Marathons Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt nbcuniversal Amazon Awards MCU Fox News CBS All Access social media spanish language Fall TV free movies Christmas Comics on TV BET Awards Ellie Kemper satire Columbia Pictures President french USA Network Video Games spinoff strong female leads Crunchyroll Spectrum Originals Sneak Peek spain Pop BET Song of Ice and Fire 2017 Writers Guild of America Apple Teen Funimation Masterpiece Disney Plus Horror The Academy south america die hard Marvel Studios 72 Emmy Awards Music MSNBC APB child's play aliens indiana jones Apple TV Plus TLC laika Winners Reality Walt Disney Pictures green book comiccon Sony Pictures BBC America Spike Martial Arts IFC Films italian cinemax batman BAFTA CMT Pride Month science fiction Cannes franchise documentaries japanese sag awards SundanceTV films Podcast deadpool Arrowverse Holidays Sundance movies anime stand-up comedy cults Women's History Month Classic Film Trivia sitcom FX on Hulu Tomatazos Comedy Central