How Godless Helps Revive the Western, According to Its Stars

Jeff Daniels, Scoot McNairy, and Merritt Wever discuss the Netflix period drama, a seven-part limited series.

by | November 17, 2017 | Comments

Scoot McNairy grew up watching Westerns — so when he read the script for the movie that eventually became the Netflix miniseries Godless, he was thrilled at the prospect of living out a childhood fantasy.

The Man From Snowy River; Silverado; The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly — me and my family had a farm outside of town in Paris, Texas, so we spent a lot of your summers up there and holidays … just [watching] old VHS Westerns,” McNairy, who plays sheriff Bill McNue, told Rotten Tomatoes recently. “We only had maybe 20 of them underneath the TV, so we obviously watched the same ones over and over and over.”

Godless, however, is different from those films he watched as a kid.

“I think the Westerns back then were probably a little bit more polished, a little bit safer,” McNairy said. “And I just think that sort of, the medium of entertainment or television or storytelling has broadened in regards to making things a little bit more real or showing things that society or people or the viewers aren’t necessarily ready for … I definitely think that this is a lot more grittier of a Western than some of the John Waynes and polished-off stuff.”

Like McNairy, star Jeff Daniels was wondering how the feature film script he read would turn into a series (he was originally interested in the project 15 years ago in the role that eventually went to the younger actor). But once he read the episodes, he knew the project was special.

“You go through every script and you stop every 10 pages and you go, what happens next? Guess five things. And if it’s well written, what happens isn’t one of those things. And [creator Scott Frank] is really good at that. So now you’ve got this town inhabited by primarily just women, because of whatever, the mining accident and all that, and you’ve never seen this before. Right? Certainly not in a Western,” Daniels said. “Let’s write towards something no one’s ever seen before. That’s what makes it. It’s just good writing.”

Godless takes place in the 1880s in the rundown mining town of La Belle, New Mexico, a town inhabited nearly entirely by women after a mining accident kills most of the town’s male population. Jack O’Connell plays Roy Goode, a man on the run from his outlaw boss, Frank Griffin (Daniels), and winds up in widow Mary Fletcher’s (Michelle Dockery) La Belle barn. McNairy plays Mary’s widowed brother, Sheriff Bill McNue, and Merritt Wever stands out as a La Belle resident who tries to unite the women of the town so they can support each other and themselves.

“It’s a more realistic version of a Western,” McNairy said. “The women back then did all the work. The men, they would go to the mines and they would go and obviously hunt and whatnot, but it was really the women who were the foundation of these towns, raising kids, and cooking the food, doing all these things that are obviously in this world view, ‘being in the kitchen.’ But without that at that time during these harsh environments of the Wild West in the 1880s, if you didn’t have these women around, I don’t know that the people of the town could thrive.”

Added Wever, “And the idea that the women in these towns weren’t tough to begin with? I think they were all pretty tough.”

The filming of the series was also literally tough — the locations were remote, and the actors filmed scenes from hours’ worth of material completely out of order over the course of the shoot. That means it was difficult to maintain a through-line for where her character was at any given point in her development.

“Understandable — because I don’t know how you would get the cast even together in the room on the same date for a read-through — but I had a hard time navigating my way through where Mary Agnes was on what day and at what point in the story because of that,” Wever said. “And I told Scott I’d never left a part before wishing that I had another stab at it so badly. I always feel like that, but never like this, where I got to the end and sometimes I would realize something from doing one scene in episode 2 that we’re shooting month three that would inform the whole rest of the piece that I just did.”

While the show is called Godless and Daniels plays a ruthless killer, his character is also a religious, church-going, scripture-quoting man. Daniels said he thinks religion is his character’s way of coping with the dysfunction in his life.

“He was stolen by a guy and taken away and raised by this guy who was brutal. He’s completely in need of a team of shrinks, which they didn’t have in the 1880s. So, his only therapy, I think, was the Bible. He’d put a bullet in a guy’s head and then quote the Bible,” he said. “I never played it as any kind of conscious, ‘And now I’m going to cleanse myself.’ It’s just, out of desperation, he would start to hang on to the good while he did the bad. And then, cause that’s the way life is. I didn’t make sense of it. I wanted to be as confused about it as he was. So, every time he’s quoting the Bible, he’s absolutely talking to God.”

Godless premieres on Wednesday, November 22  on Netflix.

Tag Cloud

Awards Superheroe heist movie psycho Sundance TV CMT zero dark thirty romantic comedy RT21 TCA Winter 2020 Rocketman spanish language Comedy comic books Cannes Disney Plus Funimation The Walt Disney Company joker Tumblr Trophy Talk DC Universe unscripted Pacific Islander HBO video Amazon Studios remakes Women's History Month 2018 Country video on demand spider-verse Britbox Ovation name the review Musicals Drama Music prank reboot cancelled TV series Spectrum Originals Peacock Rom-Com Marvel Television breaking bad legend Ghostbusters strong female leads best genre MCU comiccon critic resources natural history Disney Animation south america NBC justice league E3 animated sitcom Epix HBO Max Discovery Channel Pop TV TIFF Universal Pictures Nat Geo Shudder police drama First Look Fall TV hist monster movies superhero serial killer finale Dark Horse Comics science fiction debate Marathons Food Network Neflix blockbuster TruTV scary Logo Valentine's Day Infographic Set visit Family Mary poppins disaster marvel comics doctor who Stephen King Oscars Holidays YouTube Premium emmy awards 2017 richard e. Grant space chucky game of thrones The Witch dragons Baby Yoda Turner Classic Movies movies SundanceTV spanish canceled TV shows popular travel Song of Ice and Fire werewolf 20th Century Fox elevated horror TCA stop motion venice Brie Larson Netflix crossover facebook slashers GIFs quibi Christmas independent satire VOD nbcuniversal USA nfl Syfy LGBTQ documentaries cancelled TV shows 21st Century Fox WarnerMedia spain Rocky SDCC Biopics cults trailers crime drama Cosplay OneApp Podcast Legendary Trailer feel good Exclusive Video NYCC asian-american robots TCA Awards criterion adenture directors target LGBT scary movies sopranos laika Apple theme song ABC Family deadpool worst Watching Series Lucasfilm green book documentary 72 Emmy Awards scorecard Fox Searchlight 4/20 Sundance Now historical drama king arthur Wes Anderson Arrowverse action-comedy BET Awards kong Endgame E! cartoon kaiju hidden camera President 2020 Certified Fresh rt labs 99% DirecTV Trivia Disney streaming service anthology godzilla USA Network 2016 Netflix Christmas movies Toys children's TV a nightmare on elm street CBS All Access jamie lee curtis Pop TNT rom-coms Marvel Studios 71st Emmy Awards casting HBO Go Amazon Schedule Thanksgiving rotten movies we love Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt slasher Musical Apple TV+ Fantasy romance Chernobyl American Society of Cinematographers TV Land DGA ViacomCBS hispanic football indiana jones reviews cancelled television Warner Bros. crime Heroines Pixar Acorn TV 2021 Grammys die hard mutant Awards Tour true crime universal monsters foreign dexter mission: impossible Creative Arts Emmys Tubi mcc Rock all-time game show scene in color streaming CNN Video Games rotten Mary Poppins Returns rt archives Interview women Television Academy dark festivals Walt Disney Pictures transformers new zealand Comic-Con@Home 2021 comics PaleyFest war adventure cinemax YouTube Red Crackle Captain marvel teaser Television Critics Association witnail blockbusters ID live action IMDb TV french CW Seed Horror Reality First Reviews Super Bowl Year in Review Showtime 2015 sequel thriller hispanic heritage month docudrama Esquire toy story art house Box Office Amazon Prime Video Lionsgate classics Star Wars know your critic The Arrangement movie See It Skip It new york TV renewals BBC America Turner book Comedy Central FX boxing DC Comics golden globes versus Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Calendar medical drama diversity Countdown award winner olympics 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards indie supernatural based on movie renewed TV shows Superheroes comic book movies period drama Tokyo Olympics spider-man dceu suspense IFC Comics on TV The Purge RT History parents obituary AMC Plus biography Election The Academy social media Mary Tyler Moore Sci-Fi Emmys TV movies marvel cinematic universe free movies zombies TV One binge tv talk Martial Arts posters comic book movie high school composers Nominations A24 zombie Columbia Pictures 73rd Emmy Awards Star Trek Pet Sematary ESPN jurassic park TLC Writers Guild of America vampires television A&E Image Comics singing competition Binge Guide Sony Pictures Paramount Network Spike cars Teen comic 007 Paramount Cartoon Network Mudbound Disney+ Disney Plus Shondaland X-Men FXX CBS BBC One Fox News razzies political drama Broadway 2019 mockumentary dc FX on Hulu fast and furious Hallmark Christmas movies Mystery Sneak Peek wonder woman Winners kids AMC FOX franchise james bond stoner toronto halloween tv Extras BBC Action international nature dogs crime thriller Winter TV 45 films The CW APB australia Opinion Elton John Classic Film black comedy Bravo cancelled Spring TV Hear Us Out ITV Comic Book archives DC streaming service Polls and Games NBA TCA 2017 San Diego Comic-Con Nickelodeon Crunchyroll harry potter 90s MSNBC screenings italian Film Festival Reality Competition 24 frames Amazon Prime Emmy Nominations Kids & Family Masterpiece Sundance dramedy sequels cooking Paramount Plus Marvel dreamworks El Rey Ellie Kemper what to watch technology boxoffice canceled IFC Films adaptation VICE new star wars movies Holiday Film stand-up comedy Adult Swim Disney Channel batman series Apple TV Plus japanese mob BAFTA YouTube Tomatazos golden globe awards cats Lifetime ABC Signature king kong TBS Best and Worst Lifetime Christmas movies black Premiere Dates psychological thriller fresh Hulu Instagram Live rt labs critics edition japan royal family Red Carpet BET young adult YA aapi Summer hollywood screen actors guild Hallmark 1990s Mindy Kaling History Avengers 93rd Oscars The Walking Dead vs. child's play book adaptation pirates of the caribbean Alien Travel Channel PBS streaming movies sports saw revenge Freeform GLAAD live event miniseries spy thriller aliens ghosts comedies biopic news Quiz telelvision Anna Paquin Black History Month Black Mirror MTV festival WGN cops Tarantino sag awards National Geographic Starz Photos ABC gangster anime Pride Month Academy Awards lord of the rings OWN basketball twilight halloween worst movies docuseries New York Comic Con spinoff latino critics VH1 discovery talk show Western PlayStation TV TCM concert ratings Pirates blaxploitation Vudu GoT SXSW christmas movies politics Universal superman Character Guide