Critics Consensus

Guess Winchester's Tomatometer

Plus, Netflix's Altered Carbon is ambitiously pulpy and Chliean drama A Fantastic Woman is Certified Fresh.

by | February 1, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, Hollywood’s sitting out the Super Bowl with a potential prestige horror picture inspired by the Bay Area’s most infamous haunted house (Winchester, starring Helen Mirren and Jason Clarke) as well as a handful of limited releases. What are the critics saying?


Winchester (2018) 13%


While we tend to think of her as the type of award-winning talent who’s mostly seen in serious adult fare, Helen Mirren — on the stage and screen just as, we presume, in real life — does whatever the heck she wants. Yes, she’s one of the most acclaimed working actors in the business, and yes, she can command an arthouse audience with the best of ’em — but sometimes she feels like rolling up her sleeves and firing off a few rounds in some genre fare, and this weekend marks just one such occasion. Winchester presents a fictionalized — and presumably pretty scary — take on the story of Sarah Winchester, who inherited her husband’s vast fortune after the pioneering arms manufacturer’s sudden death in 1881. Convinced her family was haunted by the vengeful spirits of the countless people killed by her family’s wares, the widow Winchester was said to have kept crews working on her mansion constantly throughout the latter decades of her life, all in an attempt to keep the other side at bay. It all adds up to the stuff of a compelling paranormal feature, and Mirren is absolutely up to the task; unfortunately, the review embargo for Winchester hasn’t been lifted yet, so we can’t tell you what the critics think. It would seem to portend a spooky fate for this film’s critical reputation, but we don’t know for sure — and in the meantime, you know what that means: it’s time to play a chilling round of Guess the Tomatometer!


What’s New on TV

Altered Carbon: Season 1 (2018) 70%

Altered Carbon leans hard into its cyberpunk roots, serving up an ambitiously pulpy viewing experience that often overwhelms, but never bores.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • 24 Frames (2017) , the final film from acclaimed director Abbas Kiarostami, is at 92 percent.
  • A Fantastic Woman (2017) , a drama depicting the complicated aftermath of a man’s death and its impact on his trans lover, is Certified Fresh at 88 percent.
  • The Cage Fighter (2017) , a documentary about an aging fighter struggling to make his peace with a profession that may be slowly killing him, is at 83 percent.
  • In the Intense Now (2017) , a documentary survey of cultural uprisings in China, France, Czechoslovakia, and Brazil, is at 80 percent.
  • Before We Vanish (2017) , a sci-fi alien invasion drama from director Kiyoshi Kurosawa, is at 73 percent.
  • Braven (2018) , an action thriller starring Game of Thrones vet and current Aquaman Jason Momoa, is at 73 percent.
  • Driving While Black (2015) , a comedy about a man’s consistently thwarted attempts to make it to a job interview, is at 50 percent.
  • Bilal: A New Breed of Hero (2015) , an animated outing inspired by Muslim history, is at 47 percent.
  • The Music of Silence (2017) , a fictionalized biopic loosely inspired by the life of singer Andrea Bocelli, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

BBC One Fox News worst 1990s History adventure The Arrangement Comic Book game of thrones remakes GLAAD Opinion debate Red Carpet south america Freeform Disney Plus marvel cinematic universe Apple TV+ game show adenture cats Television Critics Association parents witnail ABC Family YouTube Premium adaptation golden globe awards canceled TV shows slasher natural history classics comic book movies Box Office award winner Nat Geo The Walt Disney Company 2021 YouTube Red black Toys Biopics Netflix Western Image Comics mockumentary Bravo Adult Swim action-comedy Hallmark Starz stop motion satire Rocketman Video Games Food Network Polls and Games miniseries MTV Superheroes razzies werewolf tv talk Columbia Pictures Ellie Kemper X-Men monster movies ABC Signature universal monsters festivals twilight TV Land 72 Emmy Awards Shondaland Sundance Now San Diego Comic-Con independent dark unscripted Elton John casting anthology medical drama zombies Britbox Black History Month Ghostbusters video on demand Reality Syfy PaleyFest new york diversity Emmys Paramount Network cancelled TV shows Spike indiana jones hollywood joker batman spanish language Action Travel Channel Cannes ITV gangster target dramedy USA christmas movies Calendar free movies PlayStation TLC TruTV vampires comiccon Disney obituary OneApp high school OWN Showtime anime Ovation best E3 LGBT what to watch Premiere Dates 90s Star Wars crime drama cults richard e. Grant superman toronto james bond thriller jamie lee curtis mcc Tubi hispanic hist ghosts Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cancelled TV series Trivia dragons romantic comedy social media movie DC streaming service President true crime Song of Ice and Fire BAFTA Pet Sematary 2019 Stephen King Watching Series legend critics Musicals strong female leads Wes Anderson 21st Century Fox WarnerMedia ViacomCBS mutant Fantasy 2017 crime thriller Christmas psycho psychological thriller Tomatazos Valentine's Day cooking Paramount Binge Guide FOX MSNBC Universal biopic feel good criterion 24 frames new zealand Spectrum Originals movies VOD Year in Review book adaptation sitcom golden globes Pop TV sports Crunchyroll Comics on TV Broadway Academy Awards Nominations kaiju Photos streaming movies child's play quibi 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards TV renewals A&E Writers Guild of America facebook disaster green book nbcuniversal BBC elevated horror breaking bad Drama New York Comic Con Walt Disney Pictures Pride Month Comedy Central zero dark thirty ID comic japan Kids & Family 2015 Best and Worst hispanic heritage month know your critic comic book movie DC Universe Spring TV french WGN Comic-Con@Home 2021 marvel comics CMT comedies Sci-Fi Fox Searchlight screenings Oscars scene in color fast and furious scorecard all-time TCA 2017 Heroines Tokyo Olympics TV movies superhero book NBA Epix VH1 cops DC Comics Lucasfilm Amazon Prime Video HBO Max Set visit canceled dceu news YouTube period drama streaming scary movies concert Super Bowl Mudbound directors toy story singing competition Awards Hallmark Christmas movies fresh SDCC Classic Film Emmy Nominations cartoon Lionsgate Disney streaming service Chernobyl Interview Trailer olympics Black Mirror Marathons Hear Us Out sequels Turner Classic Movies DGA 99% a nightmare on elm street Rom-Com ESPN Certified Fresh discovery comics Peacock Tumblr Arrowverse 73rd Emmy Awards sequel 007 MCU crime Infographic Disney Channel The Purge indie king arthur rotten movies we love science fiction CW Seed nfl Esquire aliens Quiz films Endgame NYCC CNN halloween tv BBC America Horror A24 HBO Go rotten Amazon Studios blockbusters Exclusive Video spider-man pirates of the caribbean heist movie GoT TCA Winter 2020 Schedule Legendary serial killer football comic books young adult spanish women Film Festival FX on Hulu talk show 4/20 Apple Funimation Summer video boxoffice IFC Films Sneak Peek Awards Tour FXX Music venice screen actors guild Shudder ratings Mary poppins Lifetime Warner Bros. live action First Reviews TNT HBO australia FX Disney+ Disney Plus Television Academy asian-american animated technology DirecTV transformers Cosplay AMC Turner Reality Competition Pop Country justice league Podcast 2020 boxing reviews Apple TV Plus Sundance TV slashers NBC cancelled television Netflix Christmas movies IFC Mary Tyler Moore trailers posters blaxploitation The Walking Dead Countdown doctor who Nickelodeon cinemax BET TCA Awards critic resources die hard Cartoon Network Tarantino 2018 Paramount Plus docudrama romance war mission: impossible VICE crossover CBS Holidays Election deadpool Pacific Islander Mindy Kaling Rocky CBS All Access rt labs critics edition TV Alien basketball versus dexter documentary BET Awards stoner Star Trek rt labs Acorn TV godzilla The Academy spain Extras 2016 First Look PBS Winter TV YA composers TIFF E! teaser Winners lord of the rings nature cars popular El Rey Women's History Month 71st Emmy Awards police drama APB prank Teen The CW The Witch Marvel reboot Brie Larson binge TCA Masterpiece italian LGBTQ TV One royal family zombie RT21 Martial Arts festival Crackle spy thriller saw foreign ABC based on movie Musical hidden camera Lifetime Christmas movies finale laika blockbuster rom-coms revenge National Geographic Pixar jurassic park japanese Holiday kong Marvel Studios Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt rt archives Fall TV chucky international space travel Character Guide Anna Paquin telelvision aapi kids Discovery Channel supernatural theme song political drama SundanceTV politics Mystery Avengers Amazon Prime suspense TBS Sony Pictures Superheroe SXSW Grammys Baby Yoda Creative Arts Emmys Film Amazon stand-up comedy dogs Pirates archives Rock Mary Poppins Returns Captain marvel latino TCM sag awards RT History spinoff cancelled Thanksgiving emmy awards harry potter GIFs series Marvel Television halloween documentaries biography See It Skip It Animation new star wars movies 45 20th Century Fox Vudu Hulu renewed TV shows Dark Horse Comics historical drama worst movies wonder woman children's TV American Society of Cinematographers Family king kong Sundance television Logo name the review USA Network robots dc Comedy 93rd Oscars franchise docuseries Trophy Talk