Critics Consensus

Guess Winchester's Tomatometer

Plus, Netflix's Altered Carbon is ambitiously pulpy and Chliean drama A Fantastic Woman is Certified Fresh.

by | February 1, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, Hollywood’s sitting out the Super Bowl with a potential prestige horror picture inspired by the Bay Area’s most infamous haunted house (Winchester, starring Helen Mirren and Jason Clarke) as well as a handful of limited releases. What are the critics saying?


Winchester (2018) 14%


While we tend to think of her as the type of award-winning talent who’s mostly seen in serious adult fare, Helen Mirren — on the stage and screen just as, we presume, in real life — does whatever the heck she wants. Yes, she’s one of the most acclaimed working actors in the business, and yes, she can command an arthouse audience with the best of ’em — but sometimes she feels like rolling up her sleeves and firing off a few rounds in some genre fare, and this weekend marks just one such occasion. Winchester presents a fictionalized — and presumably pretty scary — take on the story of Sarah Winchester, who inherited her husband’s vast fortune after the pioneering arms manufacturer’s sudden death in 1881. Convinced her family was haunted by the vengeful spirits of the countless people killed by her family’s wares, the widow Winchester was said to have kept crews working on her mansion constantly throughout the latter decades of her life, all in an attempt to keep the other side at bay. It all adds up to the stuff of a compelling paranormal feature, and Mirren is absolutely up to the task; unfortunately, the review embargo for Winchester hasn’t been lifted yet, so we can’t tell you what the critics think. It would seem to portend a spooky fate for this film’s critical reputation, but we don’t know for sure — and in the meantime, you know what that means: it’s time to play a chilling round of Guess the Tomatometer!


What’s New on TV

Altered Carbon: Season 1 (2018) 65%

Altered Carbon leans hard into its cyberpunk roots, serving up an ambitiously pulpy viewing experience that often overwhelms, but never bores.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

Comedy Central Pirates composers crime thriller Rom-Com X-Men MTV Syfy BBC DC Comics Super Bowl ABC ABC Family Food Network harry potter supernatural Cosplay political drama robots Dark Horse Comics PaleyFest Freeform American Society of Cinematographers Music Photos WGN Grammys GLAAD YA binge Pixar Comedy Opinion Oscars sitcom romance talk show First Look Countdown TBS Animation TruTV Trailer social media Ellie Kemper boxoffice Trivia based on movie 24 frames Hulu dceu Shondaland dc Infographic Mary Tyler Moore Character Guide cooking Valentine's Day USA biography Rocky Acorn TV Holidays cops war National Geographic TLC Nickelodeon SundanceTV Winners Creative Arts Emmys transformers Sony Pictures Masterpiece Amazon spy thriller Podcast Premiere Dates Disney Channel Schedule Marathons crime 2015 vampires Showtime Writers Guild of America Marvel thriller cats Spike VH1 period drama The Arrangement Musicals technology Action Nat Geo Awards Box Office Star Trek Biopics LGBTQ discovery Toys Pop E3 ratings FX HBO Fox News APB adventure Video Games USA Network historical drama Esquire ESPN Universal Netflix Polls and Games 2016 Sundance BBC America Crackle 21st Century Fox IFC Films YouTube Red Paramount Network TV VICE CBS diversity FOX Set visit A&E singing competition cults CBS All Access Election medical drama Cartoon Network Thanksgiving RT History OWN Paramount Calendar Disney crossover TV Land Sundance Now Horror SDCC Logo Certified Fresh Red Carpet Britbox Country Rock hist 45 Reality Lionsgate Drama 007 DC streaming service 2017 ITV Comic Book travel Warner Bros. Mindy Kaling Fall TV NYCC PBS DC Universe serial killer See It Skip It cinemax Watching Series unscripted TNT President Tumblr politics Star Wars Reality Competition History Best and Worst IFC Starz festivals Winter TV Kids & Family Superheroe E! Ghostbusters Spring TV The CW Tomatazos TCA 2017 MSNBC CMT Interview SXSW Year in Review CNN comiccon docudrama GIFs TCA aliens BET CW Seed Sci-Fi El Rey Fantasy AMC science fiction dramedy Nominations GoT psycho 20th Century Fox justice league DirecTV crime drama Superheroes Sneak Peek Emmys Martial Arts Musical golden globes zombies Teen Lifetime Western TCM TIFF what to watch Summer Extras police drama Adult Swim Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt NBC FXX Lucasfilm Christmas finale Mystery zombie Bravo sports