Why So Seriously Good? Five Things The Dark Knight Did Differently, and Better, Than the Rest

We're still feeling the impact of The Dark Knight and Heath Ledger's Oscar-winning Joker 10 years on.

by | July 17, 2018 | Comments

Heath Ledger in The Dark Knight

(Photo by ©Warner Bros./Courtesy Everett Collection)

The Dark Knight, released 10 years ago on July 18, 2008, is a landmark superhero movie: It nabbed awards, deified Christopher Nolan, and is one of the best reviewed superhero flicks ever – 94% on the Tomatometer.

The movie is part of a rarefied group in the comic-book movie subgenre when it comes to accolades: it earned a Best Supporting Actor Oscar nomination for Heath Ledger. But unlike its fellows in that regard – Al Pacino in 1990’s Dick Tracy and William Hurt in 2005’s A History of Violence – Ledger actually won the category for his startling portrayal of Batman’s archenemy, the Joker. And, as it happens, The Dark Knight’s exclusion from the Best Picture category is often cited as one of the reasons for a change in the Academy’s procedures, allowing up to 10 films to be nominated in subsequent years.

Yes, it was that good.

Clearly, The Dark Knight did things differently from its superhero brethren and pretty much any other film based on a comic-book character that had come before. But what did it do, exactly, that made it stand out so much back then, and stand up so well today? Let’s take a look back to 10 years ago and examine five things The Dark Knight did differently.

1. It Redefined the Joker In The Popular Consciousness

Heath Ledger’s award-wining performance as the Joker was such a change in the character’s status, it is sometimes hard to remember what the character was like when played on screen by Jack Nicholson and Caesar Romero. Ledger locked himself away with a diary and a handful of Batman comics to prepare for the film, and emerged with a leaner, nameless criminal genius dedicated to chaos and lacking in almost all the theatrics of his predecessors. While still made up as a clown, his scars and make-up reflect more internal damage than an ill-fated encounter with a chemical bath. Instead of circus-themed deathtraps or parade floats, the Dark Knight‘s Joker preferred knives, bombs and an outdated camcorder. He is more terrifying as a consequence. Comic-book fans instantly recognized this interpretation – various writers and artists often portrayed him in this force-of-nature fashion – but to moviegoers, he was a revelation.

Ledger’s Joker would become such a definitive take, Jared Leto could only push the character into a more visually extreme place in Suicide Squad, an interpretation that owed much to Ledger’s take. And while 10 years of this take might seem reason enough for another radical reinterpretation of the Clown Prince of Crime, it is doubtful audiences would accept anything but the pure strain of chaos Ledger brought to the part. Joaquin, you’re up.

2. It Utilized The Scope of IMAX Effectively

The IMAX film format, which runs horizontally through its camera, can capture roughly three times the information of a traditional 35mm camera, which runs vertically through the camera. Because the cameras were large and the available shooting time per roll of film was quite limited (30 seconds-to-2 minutes versus 35mm’s 15-20 minutes), IMAX tended to be used for science documentaries displayed on IMAX’s specially designed screens.

Director Christopher Nolan’s long-stated desire to shoot a film in the large-film format finally came to fruition when he and cinematographer Wally Pfister utilized IMAX cameras in a number of the The Dark Knight’s key scenes. The 10-minute bank heist which opens the film was shot entirely in the format and remains breathtaking. The impact may be lost on home video, but on even the faux-IMAX screens of 2008 multiplexes, the clarity of the helicopter shot passing over Chicago (doubling for Gotham City) is striking. The bright sunlight makes a sharp visual departure from the muted light of Batman Begins and the subsequent shots of the bank robbers completing their assigned tasks just feels different from previous Batman films and other comic book movies of the time. All of it, of course, ends up in service of the Joker’s proper introduction at the end of the sequence.

Subsequent Gotham City master shots and the later nighttime chase are all master classes in using the large format for commercial action films. Nolan would continue to favor the format in his subsequent films, but it never again had the impact it has here.

3. It Refined Its Predecessor’s So Serious Tone

The previous Batman cycle did away with the public’s memory of Adam West’s Batman, but it still had a cartoonish edge under the supervision of Tim Burton. That edge turned into full-bore self-parody when Burton was replaced by director Joel Schumacher. His neon-colored, merchandise-pushing recreation of West-era camp in Batman and Robin forced Warner Bros. to “rest” the character for nearly a decade.

Nolan, like the few filmmakers who attempted to develop a “Batman 5” before him, pitched a stripped-down, naturalistic take on the character. And while Batman Begins is certainly less a caricature of the character and his world than even the 1989 Batman, it was only a proof-of-concept for the way Nolan and his creative partners would further strip away the artifice in The Dark Knight. Gone were the set-bound feel of the Narrows and the artificial brown palette in favor of a far more naturalistic atmosphere borrowed from the production’s time in Chicago. While still exaggerated comic book characters, Batman (Christian Bale) and the Joker feel less removed from the viewers’ reality than ever before. Gary Oldman’s Commissioner Gordon is about as haggard a cop as you’re likely to find in any crime movie of the era. In fact, the film as a whole feels less like a superhero movie than a crime thriller which just happens to feature a guy who plays dress-up.

At the same time, the film maintains the spirit of the characters: Batman disappears from view while Jim Gordon finishes his thoughts and Joker’s “magic trick” with the pencil comes off as one of the most in-character moments ever committed to the screen. The results show these characters to be so malleable that they can remain true even when placed in the most naturalistic Gotham either will likely ever visit.

4. It Sent Its Fans on Scavenger Hunts

Why So Serious? Poster

(Photo by © Warner Bros.)

While other films like A.I.: Artificial Intelligence utilized Alternate Reality Game ad campaigns, few employed the tactic as well as The Dark Knight. The “Why So Serious?” game opened with an website in support of the character’s bid for Gotham City District Attorney. It encouraged fans to sign up for updates from the candidate. Eventually, the website was “vandalized” by the Joker as fans who signed up for updates received an email from the character that led to a puzzle game. When the puzzle was solved, it revealed the first publicity shot of Ledger as the Joker. Well done, Warner Bros.

At the 2007 Comic-Con International: San Diego, the focus moved to the Joker and a new website: It sent fans at Comic-Con on a scavenger hunt to unlock a new Joker photo and the film’s teaser trailer. Subsequent scavenger hunts saw fans finding cakes, taking photos of themselves as Joker, and receiving tickets to a special screening of The Dark Knight’s opening IMAX sequence. Following Ledger’s untimely death on January 22, 2008, the game pivoted back to Harvey Dent, offering fans the chance to show their support for the character as “I Believe In Harvey Dent” campaign buses toured the country.

While the promotions targeted larger cities and once-a-year events like Comic-Con, it was still thrilling to keep up with those engaged in the scavenger hunt. Twitter, then relatively new, made the constant updates from those finding the cakes – and then cellular phones inside the cakes – a far more communal event.

Film marketing would move away from Alternate Reality as Twitter’s ultimate ubiquity made it possible for Deadpool to talk to his fans “directly” via the social media platform. “Why So Serious?” was a singular advertising campaign for a singular film experience.

5. It Lent Itself To Serious Discourse

OK, let’s get academic. To some commentators, The Dark Knight is the first real examination of the American psyche following the events of 9/11. In stripping away many of Batman’s gadgets and broader facets, viewers were left to confront his interrogation tactics and his use of widespread wire-tapping. To a nation still debating the PATRIOT Act, the emergence of ICE, and revelations of waterboarding, Batman’s methods suddenly felt very raw. Some argued the film supported then-president George W. Bush’s approval of torture as a means of gathering intelligence during the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, while others argued Batman’s choice to destroy his surveillance apparatus at the end of the film rebuked the unprecedented access to private information Congress gave law enforcement agencies when it passed the PATRIOT Act.

The other Batman films certainly touched on the cultural zeitgeists of their day, but only The Dark Knight confronted those issues in such a meaningful and elegant way. Or, at least, built up its world enough for those interpretations to carry serious weight and support arguments about American attitudes toward civil liberties and torture at the time. In this respect, The Dark Knight transcends its pulpy, summer action movie roots, and becomes a very different sort of film.

The Dark Knight was released in theaters July 18, 2008

Tag Cloud

Sundance action-comedy Showtime Rom-Com Chernobyl saw Sneak Peek Creative Arts Emmys Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Starz Sundance TV The Academy Netflix Christmas movies ghosts unscripted TCA Awards razzies First Look rt labs 2016 AMC Plus Toys biopic young adult independent comic book movies live event australia criterion VOD rotten Sci-Fi name the review batman hidden camera screen actors guild boxoffice Extras versus children's TV olympics streaming teaser Exclusive Video nbcuniversal hollywood TBS critics Television Academy The Walt Disney Company OneApp YouTube Premium comic books Rock diversity police drama FOX ABC Native Thanksgiving 93rd Oscars mission: impossible cancelled television parents know your critic South by Southwest Film Festival ViacomCBS pirates of the caribbean spanish Musicals french Image Comics kaiju Geeked Week Hulu strong female leads scorecard toy story psychological thriller romantic comedy rt labs critics edition marvel cinematic universe HBO Max serial killer black mcc superman Spectrum Originals TCA Pacific Islander news Trivia live action japan BAFTA stand-up comedy USA 24 frames 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Classic Film Tags: Comedy Women's History Month CNN sag awards Crackle 79th Golden Globes Awards Cosplay Funimation Logo Disney Channel wonder woman legend WarnerMedia Columbia Pictures MTV Comic-Con@Home 2021 dogs Polls and Games Broadway canceled Acorn TV blaxploitation women based on movie foreign A24 leaderboard indie target finale CMT high school Nickelodeon Mystery Paramount Network scary Peacock Oscars 007 Rocky asian-american The Arrangement cartoon Countdown Apple Lifetime Christmas movies worst movies hist richard e. Grant Horror BBC summer TV preview DirecTV Warner Bros. Spike Shudder adaptation streaming movies 99% HBO rotten movies we love Super Bowl documentaries Action Pirates The Walking Dead Dark Horse Comics Endgame Mary Poppins Returns obi wan Alien jurassic park VICE political drama Food Network biography 2015 movies summer preview Fargo Quiz comic Mary Tyler Moore Reality Competition Best Actress gangster natural history First Reviews YA technology DC Universe Cannes SundanceTV Arrowverse Academy Awards PBS critic resources vampires Tokyo Olympics Interview Focus Features ABC Family Star Wars Celebration laika spider-man Fox News Pet Sematary Trophy Talk 2018 Paramount Pictures Tomatazos Set visit 4/20 Instagram Live quibi deadpool anime scene in color series Election dreamworks BET Awards Marvel Studios spider-verse trophy revenge VH1 die hard Film Festival singing competition New York Comic Con venice 2019 Universal Netflix period drama stop motion hispanic heritage month concert sports CBS Comics on TV prank interviews adenture blockbuster Amazon ratings award winner superhero popular 72 Emmy Awards Cartoon Network social media classics Oscar comedies jamie lee curtis Box Office Ghostbusters archives toronto joker a nightmare on elm street dc El Rey 20th Century Fox animated dramedy disaster italian dexter Valentine's Day target scene in color Winners Spring TV Disney streaming service Awards Tour Television Critics Association Elton John SDCC anthology new zealand TIFF Stephen King Fantasy TCA 2017 Video Games Superheroes all-time Ovation Star Wars talk show what to watch composers Amazon Studios satire canceled TV shows theme song Watching Series ITV AMC WGN SXSW Best Director Character Guide chucky streamig TV Land Reality Vudu justice league Lifetime james bond Best Actor halloween tv 2020 TCM APB Hallmark Christmas movies cinemax President Rocketman Infographic Lionsgate crime Animation HFPA Nominations HBO Go medical drama Avengers golden globe awards king arthur sequels posters TV Teen harry potter kids Pixar USA Network royal family Best Picture adventure Indigenous game show Schedule 45 japanese Comic Book Crunchyroll NBC YouTube Comedy Adult Swim romance witnail black comedy TLC Premiere Dates 71st Emmy Awards monster movies 90s south america science fiction Writers Guild of America GoT football television Tarantino slasher cops Wes Anderson cooking Black History Month Marvel Television cancelled TV shows twilight X-Men comic book movie feel good Hollywood Foreign Press Association Bravo Marathons zombie LGBT comics See It Skip It rt archives E! travel cults SXSW 2022 stoner aapi Mindy Kaling video on demand BET Martial Arts binge Turner Awards Red Carpet NBA genre ESPN Tubi miniseries directors book PlayStation spain green book Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt reviews crossover boxing slashers vs. Paramount documentary Disney+ Disney Plus Kids & Family Fall TV Britbox Brie Larson cars Film space DC streaming service Drama Podcast Best and Worst new star wars movies FX on Hulu A&E American Society of Cinematographers crime drama Syfy cancelled TV series thriller DGA best dark ID Pride Month historical drama PaleyFest Emmys The Witch Pop TV LGBTQ Summer spanish language king kong golden globes politics movie TCA Winter 2020 Winter TV game of thrones psycho Lucasfilm latino docuseries BBC America cats Sony Pictures films sitcom IFC Films sequel summer TV MCU tv talk reboot Sundance Now dceu fresh supernatural San Diego Comic-Con GIFs kong obituary Grammys ABC Signature festivals scene in color Tumblr Biopics MSNBC YouTube Red free movies renewed TV shows MGM aliens Amazon Prime Video Comedy Central 1990s zombies emmy awards Prime Video Holiday series OWN Sony Western christmas movies Ellie Kemper 2017 facebook 2021 Star Trek Mudbound CW Seed Heroines Song of Ice and Fire Baby Yoda spinoff FX Epix National Geographic Music Masterpiece casting mockumentary universal monsters telelvision Neflix franchise remakes Paramount Plus video halloween E3 RT History nfl war The CW 73rd Emmy Awards new york Legendary robots Freeform IFC mutant Calendar Country Walt Disney Pictures Year in Review fast and furious Nat Geo zero dark thirty Family indiana jones Disney Pop basketball Captain marvel IMDb TV heist movie sopranos Black Mirror TV renewals Apple TV Plus 21st Century Fox 94th Oscars Anna Paquin Photos dragons art house Binge Guide Musical Universal Pictures worst Trailer marvel comics Opinion blockbusters Disney Plus godzilla GLAAD Amazon Prime Turner Classic Movies Shondaland TV movies breaking bad CBS All Access FXX crime thriller Superheroe The Purge RT21 Christmas Esquire rom-coms Apple TV+ lord of the rings book adaptation Marvel TruTV Travel Channel Emmy Nominations comiccon Certified Fresh DC Comics nature TV One festival doctor who mob child's play elevated horror international History debate transformers spy thriller Hallmark scene in color film series werewolf suspense cancelled true crime broadcast screenings Mary poppins Holidays NYCC Hear Us Out hispanic Fox Searchlight scary movies docudrama Discovery Channel discovery trailers BBC One TNT