Five Lessons Hollywood Learned from Tim Burton's Batman (1989)

To mark the 30th anniversary of its release on June 23, 1989, here are five ways Burton’s visionary film about "a man dressed as a bat" changed everyone's approach to comic book movies.

by | June 23, 2019 | Comments

In the summer of 1989, Batman was everywhere, with its revamped emblem plastered on billboards, T-shirts and bumper stickers, in the windows of toy and comics stores — and hell, even on the drinks at Taco Bell. Likewise, seemingly everyone wanted to see it: Tim Burton’s dark reboot boasted a box-office gross of more than $411 million, making about 11 times its $35 million budget, and earning a cool $100 mil in just 11 days. The PG-13 pic’s appeal was massive, piquing the interest of kiddos (look at that cool new Batmobile!), comic-book nerds, everyday Joes, and even cineastes interested to see how its young director would follow up his goofy (Pee-Wee’s Big Adventure) and gothically gonzo (Beetlejuice) comedies.

Yet, despite being Certified Fresh at 71%, Batman is critically bested by its sequel, Batman Returns (78%), its campy ’60s predecessor, Batman: The Movie (78%), The Lego Batman Movie (90%) and, you guessed it, every installment in Christopher Nolan’s trilogy. (It did manage to top Joel Schumacher’s twofer, so… there’s that.) What’s more, Burton himself confessed to Empire in 1992: “I liked parts of it, but the whole movie is mainly boring to me. It’s okay, but it was more of a cultural phenomenon than a great movie.”

Let’s agree to disagree. An occasionally messy masterpiece? Sure. But as Batman enters its dirty thirties, here is why we think it still dazzles — and what future franchises can glean from its success.

You Don’t Need a Huge Star in the Lead

Strictly speaking, Michael Keaton was a star at this point, as the stand-up-turned-actor had held leads in comedies like Mr. Mom and Johnny Dangerously, flexed dramatic chops in Clean and Sober, and wowed in unhinged glory as titular role in Burton’s previous effort, Beetlejuice. But was he near the level of stardom of, say, Harrison Ford, Mel Gibson, or Kevin Costner, who were all considered to don the Batsuit? Hardly. In fact, fans of the beloved character were so miffed by Keaton’s casting that droves of complaints were mailed to Warner Bros. The seemingly odd choice — he hardly had the build of a superhero, let alone the action-star demeanor some at the studio envisioned — paid off, with Keaton grounding billionaire Bruce Wayne with an everydude charisma and shifting into low-voiced seriousness as Batman, a move informed by Frank Miller’s The Dark Knight Returns (and later used by Christian Bale).

Yet Keaton wasn’t the film’s top billing — that distinction belonged to Jack Nicholson, who took home a tidy $6 million payday, as well as an estimated $60 million bite of the box-office, and whose contract included demands like not having to shoot during Lakers home games. And in many ways, Nicholson’s villain is very much the star of this show, with the actor zig-zagging around Gotham as a candy-colored Pop-Art terrorist, delivering tasteless zingers (“This town needs an enema!”) and reveling in that psychotic laugh.

Audiences Respond to Darker, More Adult Comic-Book Fare

Back before franchises being grim or deep or serious or important was pretty much de rigueur, Batman was something of a shock — a popcorny shock, but a shock nonetheless. Compared to the frothy 1960s TV show that bore its name — most moviegoers were likely not familiar with the edgier Batman comics and graphic novels of the 1980s — Batman was a decidedly bleak onscreen left-turn. In creating Gotham City, designers Nigel Phelps and Anton Furst, collaborating with Burton, concocted a cityscape that screamed seedy New York, with trash-strewn streets billowing with portentous steam and intimidating skyscrapers stacked atop each other, like in an Andreas Feininger photograph. The characters, too, reeked of urban decay, with sickly-looking corrupt cops (William Hootkins’s Eckhardt), prostitutes, spiky-haired punks, a maimed muse (played by Jerry Hall) and an un-kiddie-friendly scene where a young Wayne watches his parents bite the dust.

Outside-the-Box Directors Should Tackle Mainstream Material

Michael Germana/Everett Collection
(Photo by Michael Germana/Everett Collection)

We shudder to think what would have become of Batman without Burton behind the helm. (For one thing, Keaton would have definitely been nixed, as producers were much keener on a stereotypically macho lead.) Part of the joy of watching it three decades later is how it comes off like the creation of an art-school kid with a blockbuster canvas. There’s a stirring opening-title sequence, nods to the Batman of the ’60s and some still-nifty action sequences, for sure. But it’s the director’s gothic fingerprints — the shoutout to Francis Bacon’s grisly painting Figure with Meat, the mood of Alan Moore’s graphic novel Batman: The Killing Joke, which the director called “the first comic that I ever loved” — that stick with you after the closing credits. Now, years later, Hollywood happily gives huge superhero movies to exciting directors outside the blockbusterverse.

Music Matters

Earlier this month, on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, Mark Ronson explained that he was the youngest intern ever at Rolling Stone, when, at age 12, he’d alert the art department about the best-selling albums. Topping the charts during his tenure? Prince’s Batman soundtrack, which held that spot for a whopping six consecutive weeks. That’s how big of a deal it was. Onscreen, Prince’s “Partyman” and “Trust” add some funky levity and spectacle to scenes where the Joker literally gasses Gothamites to death. (Originally, the project was supposed to be a collaboration between Prince, handling Joker’s bits, and Michael Jackson, doing romantic numbers.) And that wasn’t all: The film inspired another entire soundtrack composed solely of Danny Elfman’s rousing score.

But So Does Merch

In fact, Batman raked in more than $500 million in merchandise sales — that’s higher than its blazing box-office gross — with cereals, pinball machines, piggy banks, toy cars, and a trillion other things. Three years later, Batman Returns would double down, tossing in pre-release commercials for the likes of McDonald’s and Diet Coke, living up to the credo, to misquote Nicholson’s Joker, to “make art until someone buys.”

Batman was released on June 23, 1989.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.


Batman (1989)

Adjusted Score: 76.636%
Critics Consensus: An eerie, haunting spectacle, Batman succeeds as dark entertainment, even if Jack Nicholson's Joker too often overshadows the title character.
Synopsis: Jack Nicholson is the Joker, who emerged from a horrible accident as a maniacal criminal. Michael Keaton is the Caped... [More]
Directed By: Tim Burton

Tag Cloud

San Diego Comic-Con Mudbound sports Mary Tyler Moore Toys Dark Horse Comics Brie Larson Sneak Peek Western Horror talk show comiccon Emmys Masterpiece Superheroes FOX crime drama IFC ABC Polls and Games mutant political drama TNT animated Pet Sematary Set visit Quiz Britbox crime thriller technology Nickelodeon cults singing competition Paramount Cosplay boxoffice Syfy Calendar Spring TV natural history anime CMT 2018 Countdown WGN VH1 NBC Schedule HBO Black Mirror Starz Amazon doctor who Shondaland robots Spectrum Originals Tomatazos Character Guide travel MTV A&E Netflix 20th Century Fox mockumentary police drama Mary poppins Teen Emmy Nominations spy thriller CBS Tarantino period drama 45 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Hulu First Look Women's History Month Oscars witnail E! OWN TLC TCM hist Country TV Fantasy LGBT YA Showtime facebook Fall TV nature The CW true crime psycho American Society of Cinematographers LGBTQ Summer aliens Reality historical drama supernatural discovery blaxploitation psychological thriller adventure RT History Disney Channel Box Office diversity Sci-Fi television Nat Geo Ghostbusters zombies TCA 2017 Pixar war Election ratings Anna Paquin sitcom The Arrangement PaleyFest Walt Disney Pictures Watching Series streaming Musical President space HBO Max zombie Rom-Com DirecTV Song of Ice and Fire Red Carpet GoT dc Cartoon Network Columbia Pictures Extras CNN vampires 2015 Winter TV Rock teaser Drama transformers Lucasfilm GLAAD USA crime binge X-Men Film Festival Crackle Cannes TIFF Logo Podcast social media Year in Review Martial Arts Nominations Paramount Network serial killer FXX Fox News spider-man Awards Tour zero dark thirty Musicals WarnerMedia DC Universe Freeform Thanksgiving SundanceTV Writers Guild of America Pride Month Opinion Creative Arts Emmys festivals Amazon Prime 24 frames game show Lionsgate AMC Sundance adaptation Star Trek Bravo sequel Comedy TruTV Christmas dramedy cats harry potter BET Comic Book Pirates theme song APB ESPN BBC Certified Fresh cinemax Biopics Photos Rocky Pop Kids & Family strong female leads composers CBS All Access Mystery disaster USA Network Acorn TV Superheroe thriller Sony Pictures DC Comics comic cooking Vudu green book 007 New York Comic Con History DC streaming service Lifetime IFC Films Rocketman 2016 SXSW Grammys See It Skip It Music Tumblr Trailer Esquire Marathons elevated horror Action Epix Trivia Comics on TV Winners unscripted E3 Video Games TBS Marvel Animation GIFs 2019 Spike Chernobyl Stephen King MCU Apple toy story Chilling Adventures of Sabrina dceu casting Sundance Now Comedy Central romance El Rey award winner dragons miniseries spinoff RT21 Awards politics richard e. Grant Valentine's Day ITV biography Heroines BBC America Mindy Kaling FX Premiere Dates Best and Worst Disney DGA Shudder Super Bowl TCA Holidays Infographic what to watch 2017 NYCC Reality Competition golden globes Adult Swim TV Land Elton John MSNBC Mary Poppins Returns SDCC Trophy Talk cops CW Seed Interview National Geographic medical drama The Witch justice league Captain marvel jamie lee curtis docudrama VICE YouTube Premium Ovation based on movie Warner Bros. Star Wars crossover PBS Food Network science fiction Ellie Kemper 21st Century Fox finale ABC Family Universal anthology YouTube Red