Five Awards Season Takeaways from the Toronto International Film Festival

Jojo Rabbit rebounds to win Audience Award, Adam Sandler continues to impress, and Jennifer Lopez emerges as a contender.

by | September 17, 2019 | Comments

The curtain closed on the 44th Toronto International Film Festival this past weekend, and while several crucial pieces of the awards season puzzle are still missing, we can just about decipher the image, and it is looking glorious. Taika Waititi’s Nazi satire Jojo Rabbit rebounded from a mixed initial critical reception to win the Grolsch People’s Choice Award, while previous festival favorites Marriage Story and Cannes Palme d’Or winner Parasite were the first and second runners-up, respectively. A few notable contenders were missing from Toronto’s screens this year, including James Gray’s Ad Astra, the yet-to-be-completed Little Women starring Saoirse Ronan and Meryl Streep, the Fox News sexual harassment tale Bombshell, and the Martin Scorsese gangster epic The Irishman, featuring Robert De Niro, Al Pacino, and Joe Pesci.

As the unofficial end of the festival season’s opening act, the Toronto International Film Festival remains an essential stop on the way to Oscar glory, and the Grolsch People’s Choice Award has become an increasingly prescient indicator of Best Picture chances — nine of the last 10 winners of the former have earned nominations for the latter, including last year’s eventual Best Picture-winner, Green Book. As we move into the heart of awards season, it will take more than just star power and reputation to take home that golden statuette, but with such heavyweights as Martin Scorsese, Quentin Tarantino, Meryl Streep, Joaquin Phoenix, Leonardo Dicaprio, Laura Dern, and Brad Pitt in the mix, competition will be fierce. Here are our key takeaways from this year’s Toronto International Film Festival.

Festival Favorites Continue to Impress

Dominique Charriau/WireImage
(Photo by Dominique Charriau/WireImage)

Waves, Uncut Gems, Marriage Story, and Ford v. Ferrari each left Telluride on a wave of momentum and have continued to ride high praise into Toronto. Adam Sandler, whose performance in the Safdie brothers’ Uncut Gems earned him his best reviews since Punch Drunk Love, was beyond pleased with the reception when we spoke to him. “That’s one of the reasons I wanted to work with [the Safdies] — they’re pretty fresh.” Fresh is right: at 93% on the Tomatometer, the film’s sterling reception proved to be the best birthday present the SNL alum could have asked for (Sandler turned 53 the night of the TIFF premiere).

Uncut Gems wasn’t the only A24 title that fared well with audiences and critics, though. Waves, the third effort from Trey Edward Shults, continued to earn praise for the Texas-born director and star Sterling K. Brown, who many now think is a serious threat in the Best Supporting Actor race. The family drama about love and loss is a brilliant and quiet examination of perspective and familial expectations. Robert Eggers’ The Lighthouse also impressed critics at 94% on the Tomatometer, while the other Cannes Film Festival winners, Portrait of a Lady on Fire and Parasite, shone brighter. Echoing the general consensus on the latter, Brian Tallerico from said, “It’s unquestionably one of the best films of the year.” The Korean socio-political thriller topped our TIFF Scorecard and tops our list of the year’s best films, and it remains Certified Fresh at 100%.

Meanwhile, Noah Baumbach’s Netflix drama Marriage Story firmly cemented its lead actor Adam Driver in the lead for the Best Actor race. “A stirring performance with raw emotion that towers over everything else this season,” says Dustin Chase of Texas Art & Film. Joaquin Phoenix’s Joker may have the flashier performance, but Baumbach’s heartbreaking script, Stephen Sondheim (when you see the film, you’ll know what we mean), and an upcoming worldwide promotional tour for Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker give the Juilliard-trained actor a slight edge.

Joker’s Oscar chances? So Serious!

Without question, the buzziest title of the festival was Todd Phillips’ Joker, starring Joaquin Phoenix. As most of the Toronto attendees packed their bags for the festival, word broke that the DC standalone title had won the Golden Lion at the Venice Film Festival. The achievement quieted many doubters, and if the star-studded premiere at Toronto was any indication, even A-listers are anxious to see what the three-time Oscar nominee can do with The Dark Knight’s oldest foe. Stars Joaquin Phoenix, Zazie Beetz, Robert De Niro, and Bradley Cooper (who also served as producer) were all expected at the film’s TIFF premiere, but the likes of Jon Hamm, Luke Wilson, Finn Wittrock, Charlie Hunnam, and countless others also made their way to the Princess of Wales theater to see the ultra-violent King of Comedy-meets-Batman mashup. Still faring well on the Tomatometer at 77%, the film’s long-term Oscar hopes are still questionable, but just about everyone agrees that what Phoenix does on-screen is going to resonate with voters. The Times UK staff writes that Phoenix is “febrile and wiry, the focus of all attention, and delivers an easy Best Actor Oscar nomination, if not a win.”

Supporting Surprises: Janney, Snipes, Lopez

(Photo by STXFilms)

Of all the performances that screened last week, perhaps none shocked more than Allison Janney, Wesley Snipes, and Jennifer Lopez. For Lopez, who plays the acrobatic and deadly stripper-turned-“mini mob boss” in Hustlers, the hardest obstacle she faces this awards season isn’t the four-inch heels she wore for the production, but getting everyone to recognize how exceptional she is in the role. After the film’s impressive $33 million debut, people are taking notice, and we’re hoping word of mouth will continue to circulate that Hustlers is not just the actress/singer’s best performance since Out of Sight, but possibly her best ever. Meanwhile, fresh off her win for I, Tonya, Allison Janney is also back in the conversation, starring alongside Hugh Jackman in the drama based on the New York school embezzlement scandal, Bad Education, while Wesley Snipes reminded everyone just how hilarious he could be as the campy D’Urville Martin in Dolemite is My Name. Craig Brewer’s biopic of the underground comedian and blaxploitation star is a story of hustle and determination, and despite acting alongside the likes of Eddie Murphy, Mike Epps, and Tituss Burgess, Snipes manages to steal every scene.

The Knives Are In?

Knives Out
(Photo by © Lionsgate)

The Last Jedi writer-director Rian Johnson premiered his new mystery movie Knives Out at the Toronto International Film Festival, and it did not disappoint. After multiple breaks for applause during its first screening and an extended standing ovation at the end, the star-studded whodunnit is Fresh at an impressive 98% on the Tomatometer. Everyone agrees Johnson’s return to his murder mystery roots is a welcome one, and critics raved about the stellar ensemble cast, the side-splittingly hilarious performances, and the inventive story, which doesn’t give anything away until the climax. But it remains to be seen if the film can also impress voting groups, and it’s still unclear where it fits among more traditional Oscar films like Marriage Story, Parasite, and Ford v Ferrari. Maybe Knives Out can push itself into the conversation on reviews alone, but if it pulls off an impressive box office haul to match its first wave of reviews, we would not count Knives (yes, we really had to do this) Out.

JoJo Rabbit Rebounds

The morning after Taika Waititi’s latest, the World War II satire Jojo Rabbit, premiered in Toronto, things didn’t look so bright. A few critics found its balance of humor and tragedy jarringly difficult to reconcile: “There are brief flashes of something worthwhile… but it takes so long to get there,” said Hannah Woodhead of Little White Lies. A low-ish early Tomatometer score seemed to belie the brilliance of the talented cast and the hilarious script, but by the end of the festival, things had righted themselves, and the comedy now rests happily Fresh at 74%, with critics like Joshua Rothkopf of Time Out saying, “In its precision, Jojo Rabbit may remind you of Wes Anderson’s The Grand Budapest Hotel, another comedy in which clownish forces of fascism squared off against love, humor and elegance.” Coupling that turn-around with a Grolsch’s People Choice Award win, Jojo Rabbit rebounded from a lukewarm reception signaling the end of its Oscar hopes to becoming a serious contender for a Best Picture nomination. With Marriage Story and Parasite as the Grolsch People’s Choice runners-up, history suggests that at least two of the three — if not all of them — will be nominated for Best Picture, as has been the case for the past four years.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

OWN obituary 21st Century Fox comics Trivia IFC Films rotten movies we love Baby Yoda critics facebook TV renewals Tarantino worst directors Brie Larson CBS All Access theme song Fall TV dark Quiz Music Hallmark cancelled television 007 Grammys spider-man Classic Film Pride Month Dark Horse Comics TCA Winter 2020 American Society of Cinematographers jamie lee curtis Box Office Ovation asian-american DirecTV video halloween mission: impossible Ellie Kemper FX on Hulu disaster series The Purge cancelled TV shows LGBTQ slashers Endgame revenge Epix Funimation El Rey Cartoon Network Chilling Adventures of Sabrina dramedy The Arrangement sequel IFC SundanceTV Comic Book cancelled sports romantic comedy 2019 PBS crime thriller Hallmark Christmas movies Warner Bros. chucky Paramount Sundance werewolf Family Anna Paquin 2018 Superheroes renewed TV shows MTV 72 Emmy Awards Black History Month Disney Channel book docudrama sitcom green book nbcuniversal doctor who Hulu criterion Heroines social media Tomatazos cancelled TV series GIFs VOD aliens classics south america Sci-Fi richard e. Grant Lifetime Christmas movies GoT Action latino AMC robots Winners SXSW documentary Travel Channel parents Masterpiece crime drama game show films Television Critics Association fast and furious NBC Binge Guide Adult Swim laika Holidays HBO Max Horror Film FXX hispanic teaser CW Seed crossover universal monsters justice league Pop Star Trek canceled TV shows political drama X-Men Freeform A&E concert Pirates Chernobyl anime blockbuster Arrowverse Calendar Turner Classic Movies OneApp GLAAD TV Shudder adventure Spring TV Disney streaming service Shondaland 20th Century Fox Rock Disney+ Disney Plus Mindy Kaling science fiction spanish language emmy awards Bravo romance adaptation cops San Diego Comic-Con Logo MCU zombie anthology witnail franchise Food Network Showtime Star Wars Character Guide twilight Amazon Prime Video comic CBS stand-up comedy Marathons Film Festival First Look Sony Pictures PlayStation Best and Worst Captain marvel Podcast Cannes Lucasfilm TCM VH1 Set visit sequels festivals vampires TruTV Holiday harry potter joker Avengers reviews Vudu miniseries Universal Britbox Superheroe Certified Fresh Marvel Television ITV Christmas Western E3 The Witch politics Spike Amazon Studios Nominations TCA 2017 The CW Fox News Creative Arts Emmys Country dceu versus Elton John comedies YouTube Red TNT dogs Walt Disney Pictures die hard mutant Tumblr Super Bowl rotten transformers natural history Interview hollywood screen actors guild Countdown medical drama independent Sundance Now child's play Rocketman animated travel Musical cats 71st Emmy Awards RT History Song of Ice and Fire Pixar HBO Go LGBT YouTube Martial Arts Acorn TV Esquire blaxploitation First Reviews Nat Geo indie scary movies discovery USA serial killer DC streaming service quibi historical drama Ghostbusters Lifetime BBC One hist Thanksgiving Opinion E! NYCC based on movie reboot Crackle Amazon Prime Extras History Red Carpet talk show President best Year in Review elevated horror cartoon MSNBC Comedy Central singing competition ratings kids Peacock 24 frames TCA Valentine's Day cars DGA period drama space tv talk Amazon The Walking Dead Stephen King Toys Summer zombies Comics on TV Pet Sematary Mary Tyler Moore 45 Mudbound unscripted award winner diversity Mary poppins cinemax dc BET Awards screenings Awards Tour APB crime DC Comics movie composers DC Universe canceled psychological thriller Winter TV police drama ABC Family Kids & Family ESPN 2016 comiccon USA Network cooking Starz a nightmare on elm street name the review Discovery Channel Tubi See It Skip It Premiere Dates foreign YA New York Comic Con christmas movies Biopics Comedy Oscars Women's History Month game of thrones Mary Poppins Returns TLC Musicals Photos Trophy Talk Watching Series WarnerMedia Election zero dark thirty Sundance TV strong female leads spy thriller Polls and Games Cosplay news TV Land spain Syfy Emmys true crime Schedule BAFTA Emmy Nominations 2020 BET television finale A24 binge WGN ABC HBO Rocky BBC America Video Games golden globes Crunchyroll war Academy Awards dragons Awards FOX CMT PaleyFest Pop TV Sneak Peek mockumentary Turner VICE Mystery satire supernatural Disney CNN video on demand Netflix Christmas movies Writers Guild of America breaking bad biography 2017 technology cults stoner movies Marvel Studios free movies Spectrum Originals ghosts Paramount Network Reality 2015 batman Netflix spinoff stop motion Trailer toy story Marvel Animation Lionsgate Teen Reality Competition YouTube Premium Disney Plus TCA Awards TIFF what to watch Television Academy 4/20 RT21 BBC Hear Us Out superhero Black Mirror streaming Columbia Pictures SDCC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Apple TV Plus Fantasy casting boxoffice Apple TV+ indiana jones documentaries thriller psycho National Geographic nature children's TV TBS Rom-Com Apple Drama all-time FX Infographic sag awards Nickelodeon