Critics Consensus

First Man Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Goosebumps 2: Haunted Halloween is disappointingly formulaic, Titans makes an impressive debut, and The Haunting of Hill House and Bad Times at the El Royale are also Certified Fresh.

by | October 11, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got one giant leap (First Man, starring Ryan Gosling and Claire Foy), one supernatural sequel (Goosebumps 2: Haunted Halloween, starring Wendy McLendon-Covey and Madison Iseman), and one wild night (Bad Tmies at the El Royale, starring Jeff Bridges and Chris Hemsworth). What are the critics saying?


First Man (2018) 87%

Sending people into space easily ranks among the most impressive achievements we’ve ever pulled off as a species, so it only stands to reason that our first manned flight to the moon remains a persistent subject of fascination for filmmakers. In fact, it’s inspired enough feats of cinema that a director would have to be blessed with a lot of moxie to try and add to the list — which is why it’s extra fortunate that this weekend’s First Man is being brought to us by the award-winning duo of Damien Chazelle and Ryan Gosling. Chazelle, who most recently directed Gosling in the acclaimed hit musical La La Land, reunites here with his leading man to tell the story of Neil Armstrong, the Apollo 11 astronaut who became the — wait for it — first man to walk on the moon. They’re obviously telling a very different type of story, but critics say their respective strengths are well served by this biopic, which foregoes a fair bit of the expected sweeping space vistas and epic narrative grandeur in favor of a more intimately focused drama that pulls back the curtain on Armstrong’s occasionally quite arduous personal journey. As an inspiring example of what we’re capable of when we work together or a gripping piece of solidly crafted entertainment that’s further elevated by stellar cinematography and an outstanding supporting performance by Claire Foy, First Man looks like a fittingly successful voyage.


Goosebumps 2: Haunted Halloween (2018) 47%

Hollywood famously pumps out mediocre horror sequels as if it were controlled by an occult hand. But while it was probably inevitable that the delightful Goosebumps would get a part two, critics say Goosebumps 2: Haunted Halloween is too slavishly devoted to the original template to take any — ahem — spook-tacular risks. Once again, a group of youngsters must stop the evil machinations of Slappy the Dummy, who escapes from the pages of an enchanted book; this time out, Slappy’s got a gang of monsters to help sow chaos in the small town of Wardenclyffe. The pundits say that kids will probably like this new Goosebumps just fine, but their parents or guardians are likely to wonder what happened to the wit and energy of its predecessor.


Bad Times at the El Royale (2018) 74%

In his feature debut The Cabin in the Woods, director Drew Goddard demonstrated an almost preternatural knack for wringing fresh surprises out of well-worn genre cliches. Now he’s back in the director’s chair with the Tarantino-inspired thriller Bad Times at the El Royale, and critics say Goddard and his cast are in top form. El Royale is the story of seven strangers (whose ranks include Jeff Bridges, Chris Hemsworth, Dakota Johnson, Jon Hamm, and Cynthia Erivo) who congregate at the titular motel and find out what happens when things start to get surreal. The pundits say the cast is terrific, the plot is deliciously twisty, and the production design is impeccable, and even if it doesn’t deliver all that it promises, the Certified Fresh El Royale is definitely worth a visit.


What’s New on TV

The Haunting of Hill House: Miniseries (2018) 93%

The Haunting of Hill House is an effective ghost story whose steadily mounting anticipation is just as satisfying as its chilling payoff.


Titans: Season 1 (2018) 78%

Despite a few tonal growing pains, Titans does justice to its source material and truly shines when its titular ensemble finally assembles.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Liyana (2018) , an animated adventure combining African tradition and actual events, is at 100%.
  • All Square (2018) , in which a small-town bookie comes up with a decidedly unorthodox way of fixing his failing business, is at 100%.
  • Over the Limit (2018) , a documentary look at the controversial system for training Russian Olympic athletes, is at 100%.
  • After Everything (Shotgun) (2018) , starring Maika Monroe and Jeremy Allen White as a young couple whose budding romance is threatened by some fateful news, is at 92%.
  • The Sentence (2018) , a documentary unspooling the aftermath of a woman’s imprisonment for crimes committed by her ex-boyfriend, is at 91%.
  • Sadie (2018) , a drama about a teen’s increasing determination to keep her mother from striking up a new relationship in her father’s absence, is at 86%.
  • B&B (2018) , a thriller about the unhappily memorable stay awaiting two men who sue for the right to book a room at a Christian lodge, is at 83%.
  • 22 July (2018) , a Paul Greengrass-directed dramatization of the events surrounding Norway’s deadliest terrorist attack, is Certified Fresh at 80%.
  • The Oath (2018) , a political comedy looking for dark humor in divided times, is at 77%.
  • The Happy Prince (2018) , a look at Oscar Wilde’s final years directed, written by, and starring Rupert Everett, is Certified Fresh at 72%.
  • Apostle (2018) , a period drama starring Dan Stevens as a man determined to wrest his sister from the clutches of a cult, is at 72%.
  • Beautiful Boy (2018) , an adaptation of the bestselling addiction memoir starring Steve Carell and Timothée Chalamet, is at 67%.
  • Stella's Last Weekend (2018) , in which a family reunites to say goodbye to their dog, only for two brothers to end up embroiled in a love triangle, is at 63%.

Tag Cloud

BBC documentary high school dogs TCA Awards Comedy Central reboot Grammys Trailer Comic Book Spring TV football FOX Tomatazos Summer Masterpiece Film book festivals australia Rocketman Pop TV TV Certified Fresh space pirates of the caribbean independent new zealand WGN A&E stoner Pet Sematary Awards Crackle zero dark thirty Country 2017 Kids & Family TCA quibi Avengers Western 99% TIFF Starz 72 Emmy Awards Biopics natural history Box Office medical drama transformers AMC halloween tv CBS CBS All Access worst movies spinoff 93rd Oscars Quiz Peacock Alien Legendary japanese Showtime LGBTQ Esquire godzilla movie mutant Video Games parents chucky Tokyo Olympics Exclusive Video Marvel Studios miniseries justice league Acorn TV travel adenture Arrowverse Ellie Kemper hollywood Rom-Com 2016 GIFs batman DC streaming service docuseries E! Reality Competition IFC Films cancelled TV series supernatural joker Best and Worst USA Trophy Talk VOD Captain marvel wonder woman monster movies Endgame CMT politics Disney+ Disney Plus MTV nbcuniversal Funimation concert Turner Classic Movies discovery telelvision Stephen King YouTube cancelled ESPN 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards screen actors guild Mary poppins boxing black RT History scary movies 007 Tumblr scene in color Image Comics Elton John PlayStation science fiction ratings sports Disney streaming service CW Seed japan disaster Christmas romance 2019 FX all-time king kong ABC Signature E3 rotten movies we love psycho cops Horror composers See It Skip It latino game of thrones target anime LGBT Oscars Amazon Watching Series new york Comic-Con@Home 2021 international hispanic festival cinemax Ovation Disney Plus SundanceTV anthology APB cats news best Music archives BET rom-coms Fox News blaxploitation cars DirecTV Broadway Shudder marvel cinematic universe Logo child's play video on demand casting remakes golden globe awards Universal Black History Month south america ABC Family YouTube Red OneApp Comedy The Walking Dead lord of the rings Amazon Prime toy story Paramount Star Trek Lifetime scorecard elevated horror canceled TV shows Action Television Academy Mindy Kaling Travel Channel biography Infographic Freeform A24 boxoffice halloween BBC America Set visit political drama Fantasy universal monsters based on movie twilight Holidays critics The Academy crime thriller french finale ViacomCBS dceu Photos BBC One TruTV 4/20 women X-Men free movies jamie lee curtis The CW witnail YA spanish language Spectrum Originals Amazon Prime Video DC Comics Black Mirror New York Comic Con Food Network Animation Toys spanish christmas movies romantic comedy Film Festival Television Critics Association Walt Disney Pictures richard e. Grant Drama video what to watch historical drama versus Emmy Nominations canceled TNT SDCC stop motion Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 2021 theme song Disney Channel HBO Go Musicals Ghostbusters NBC Baby Yoda blockbusters Schedule animated golden globes HBO Max basketball Academy Awards dark Polls and Games Binge Guide venice werewolf indie Lifetime Christmas movies die hard Rock USA Network Pacific Islander Chernobyl Superheroes GoT Cannes Valentine's Day Musical prank Spike Bravo American Society of Cinematographers binge true crime obituary superhero Emmys indiana jones nfl Lionsgate hidden camera Heroines Sneak Peek Creative Arts Emmys TCM renewed TV shows CNN comic books television VICE toronto Pixar kong satire suspense PBS Family slashers italian superman rotten Nominations Shondaland Election TCA Winter 2020 popular cults sequel tv talk Comics on TV Hear Us Out fast and furious jurassic park TV renewals NBA robots mission: impossible Superheroe IFC The Witch Hulu trailers talk show Martial Arts TCA 2017 know your critic live action breaking bad new star wars movies YouTube Premium deadpool revenge Columbia Pictures DGA TV One MCU Apple TV Plus movies rt archives The Walt Disney Company Sundance adventure Sundance Now Countdown Opinion TV Land dragons DC Universe 90s VH1 WarnerMedia comedies ABC children's TV Britbox saw Vudu films ID Warner Bros. Sundance TV Fox Searchlight nature National Geographic crime drama franchise kids 2018 21st Century Fox james bond cancelled TV shows The Arrangement legend doctor who Winners Discovery Channel reviews game show El Rey crime comiccon Trivia The Purge cooking Netflix NYCC spy thriller award winner Winter TV vampires asian-american Paramount Network Dark Horse Comics Thanksgiving Marvel facebook President 1990s ghosts MSNBC Sony Pictures heist movie stand-up comedy Epix blockbuster Podcast Apple TV+ Star Wars worst First Look TV movies zombie Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Awards Tour 45 Marvel Television Cosplay Writers Guild of America book adaptation razzies Super Bowl Holiday GLAAD sitcom Turner Disney PaleyFest series Cartoon Network dramedy laika 71st Emmy Awards Lucasfilm unscripted Sci-Fi comics Hallmark 20th Century Fox war 2015 SXSW social media singing competition Mystery documentaries Pride Month criterion cancelled television Teen zombies Classic Film Reality 2020 Amazon Studios Crunchyroll First Reviews streaming movies fresh TLC aliens Adult Swim Interview Netflix Christmas movies Nickelodeon Marathons Nat Geo hist FXX Wes Anderson Mary Tyler Moore diversity Premiere Dates kaiju ITV Mary Poppins Returns aapi Women's History Month San Diego Comic-Con emmy awards thriller spider-man spain psychological thriller directors police drama sequels crossover OWN Rocky Pirates Syfy Song of Ice and Fire streaming History Paramount Plus mockumentary cartoon Mudbound TBS serial killer technology Pop adaptation period drama harry potter classics Tarantino FX on Hulu teaser Character Guide Apple screenings Calendar Brie Larson Hallmark Christmas movies foreign comic BET Awards Red Carpet Tubi sag awards Year in Review Extras green book name the review olympics Anna Paquin a nightmare on elm street Fall TV strong female leads dc RT21 docudrama HBO BAFTA 24 frames