Next year, one of the odder and, in some ways, most ambitious projects in Warner Bros. Pictures’ attempts to turn DC Comics characters into feature films will debut: The Joker. To be directed by Todd Phillips (The Hangover, Old School) from a script he co-wrote with Scott Silver, the film will star Joaquin Phoenix in a new origin story for the typically origin-less Clown Prince of Crime. It will also be something of a departure from the way Warner Bros. has used the DC Comics characters in the last few years. And while it first seemed like a joke itself to some, production is now underway and the studio has let the world know some true facts about the film. Here is what we know about the project so far.
Despite Warner Bros’ efforts to create a cohesive film universe for its superheroes and assorted villains, The Joker will not be part of the same story continuity as Man of Steel, Wonder Woman, or the upcoming Aquaman. Instead, it will stand alone as its own separate reality. The concept is not unlike DC Comics’ own Elseworlds brand. Though long discontinued, Elseworlds told remixed superhero stories featuring such concepts as the Waynes finding the infant Kal-El instead of the Kents or Batman as an actual vampire. Though published before Elseworlds became a formalized concept, The Dark Knight Returns was considered one of these tales. In the years since, DC returned to the idea with the “Earth-1” line and the upcoming “DC Black Label,” which could be a very good name for a line of films separate from the Justice League continuity.
Meanwhile, the Joker of that universe, Jared Leto, is developing his own Joker feature film.
There might be a punchline embedded in that name, but The Joker is dispensing with the mystery surrounding the character’s real name. This sets it apart from previous Joker tales like The Dark Knight and The Killing Joke, the defining Joker comic book story by Alan Moore and Brian Bolland. In each, the character is treated as unknowable – even in The Killing Joke, the extended flashbacks of a failed comedian embarking on a life of crime are later revealed to be unreliable – with his name obscured. In 1989’s Batman, he was given the name “Jack Napier,” which became the character’s real name in comic-book continuity for a time. But in giving Joker this new name, Phillips and Silver boldly announce the movie will not be as ambiguous about the character’s background as The Dark Knight. Which is probably a good idea as The Dark Knight was the definitive screen take on the unknowable, force-of-nature character.
In the film, Arthur (Phoenix) will be a “man disregarded by society,” in a story the studio considers both a “gritty character study” and a “broader cautionary tale.”
In fact, the “gritty character study” phrase used by the studio has been floating around since the time Phoenix confirmed his participation in the project. According to the actor, part of the film’s appeal is its $40 million “low budget” nature. The modest spend is both a departure from the tentpole sort of films Joker appears in and even the sort of films Phillips makes.
The director came to prominence with The Hangover series, which started with a seemingly modest $35 million budget – granted, that figure is on the higher end for comedies of the time – but spending on Hangover films ballooned to $103 million by The Hangover 3. And though The Joker appears to be a return to smaller budgets, the subject matter as described in interviews and press releases suggests Phillips will be leaving the zany comedy of Old School or Starsky & Hutch (and even the darker tinged action-comedy of War Dogs) behind for something much more contained and potentially serious.
In the earliest reports on the project, legendary director Martin Scorsese was said to be attached as a producer. The scuttle around that report centered on Scorsese securing the participation of his frequent collaborator Robert De Niro. Though Scorsese’s name is absent from official press releases – in fact, he seems to have been replaced by Phillips’ old Hangover compatriot, Bradley Cooper – De Niro is a confirmed part of the film’s cast. Reportedly, he will play a Gotham City talk show host whose action or inaction will lead Arthur toward his destiny. Many are seeing the casting as an inversion of his role in Scorsese’s 1982 film, The King of Comedy, in which he played a man like Arthur who takes a talk show host (Jerry Lewis) hostage.
Other actors in the film include Deadpool 2’s Zazie Beetz, reportedly as a single mother who becomes “involved” with Arthur, American Horror Story’s Frances Conroy as Arthur’s mother, and a wide group of performers including Bill Camp, Glenn Fleshler, Douglas Hodge, Marc Maron, Josh Pais, and Shea Whigham.
Brett Cullen will also appear as Thomas Wayne, father of Arthur’s eventual nemesis, Bruce Wayne (Cullen also appeared as a congressman in The Dark Knight Rises). According to reports circulating at a time when Alex Baldwin was in early talks to play the part, Wayne will be re-envisioned as a spoiled 1980s land baron. The rather obvious pastiche of a role Baldwin regularly plays on Saturday Night Live may have led to the actor withdrawing from negotiations, though he later said scheduling was the primary cause. It remains to be seen if Cullen will play a vain version of Wayne, but a wild change to the charitable and caring Wayne patriarch would represent one of the great leaps in DC Comics mythology the film intends to make. It may also indicate more changes to the lore are on their way.
The Joker is in theaters October 4, 2019