Does The Master of Disguise Deserve Cult Status?

Sub-Cult is Nathan Rabin’s ongoing exploration of movies that have quietly attracted devoted followings and are on the verge of becoming full-on cult sensations.

by | November 17, 2015 | Comments



When I was 13 years old in 1989, Dana Carvey wasn’t just my favorite Saturday Night Live cast member; I thought he was the funniest man alive. And if you were a tween or an early teenager in the late 1980s, Dana Carvey really was the funniest person in the world. There was something about his persona that appealed particularly to small children, a goofy, man-sprite playfulness that implicitly conveyed that while Carvey may look like a grown-up (albeit an eternally boyish one), inside he was the class clown every Saturday Night Live fan wished they sat next to.

Carvey was known for his political impressions, but even these had a distinctly child-like sensibility. Carvey didn’t impersonate the real George H.W. Bush — a Connecticut war hero who ran the CIA before spawning a political dynasty and becoming the most powerful man in the world — but rather embodied a child’s broad conception of this strange man as a funny-talking goober spouting catchphrases.

Then Carvey’s fans got older and the beloved Saturday Night Live cut-up more or less disappeared from the world of television and film, following the failure of his brilliant and uncharacteristically edgy and dark sketch comedy vehicle The Dana Carvey Show. The zeitgeist-capturing success of Wayne’s World — a film Mike Myers famously tried to cut the then- more popular Carvey out of — and its sequel notwithstanding, Carvey made a couple of limp vehicles (Clean Slate, Opportunity Knocks) and co-starred in some disastrously received studio films like The Road To Wellville and Trapped In Paradise. Aside from cameos in The Shot, Little Nicky, and the documentary Fire On The Track: The Steve Prefontaine Story, Carvey did not appear in a movie between his costarring role in 1994’s Trapped In Paradise and 2002’s The Master Of Disguise, which he also co-wrote with Harris Goldberg.


The Master Of Disguise isn’t just pitched towards children; it feels like it was made by children as well.”

Partially out of childhood nostalgia and partially out of fondness for the Carvey era of Saturday Night Live, I had casually been looking forward to Carvey’s return, but The Master Of Disguise taught me and a generation that grew up on Carvey’s comedy to be careful what we wished for. The Master Of Disguise isn’t just a comedy very overtly pitched towards children; it feels throughout like it was made by children as well.

The fact that The Master Of Disguise is a children’s film does not render it any less perverse. If anything, the bizarre friction between the never-ending stream of weird sexual innuendos and self-indulgent references to R-rated movies released decades before the film’s core audience was born makes it even weirder. Most Hollywood executives might have a problem with creepy sexual content in a kid’s movie, but The Master Of Disguise feels like it was greenlit and overseen not by Joe Roth, the head of Revolution Studios, but rather by Sir Mix-A-Lot, who has always been refreshingly honest about his sexual preferences.

One of the film’s running jokes, for example, is that protagonist Pistachio Disguisey (Carvey) is sexually attracted to women with enormous posteriors that remind him of his beloved Mama’s (Edie McClurg, the original Edie McClurg type) zaftig rump. This is no one-off gag. On the contrary, it appears over and over again throughout the course of the film. In the most appalling instance, Pistachio and his grandfather (the great character actor Harold Gould) stare longingly at the big ass of a long-haired stranger walking away from them and are so shocked to discover the plus-sized bottom belongs to a dude that the ice cream cones they are conveniently snacking upon rocket straight into their mouths. It looks disconcertingly like two butt-obsessed men are performing oral sex on frozen treats — a rare example of a double gay panic joke in a PG-rated children’s film.

Early in The Master Of Disguise, Pistachio’s father (James Brolin) makes a getaway by pretending to be not just Bo Derek but specifically 10-era Bo Derek. That might seem like an awfully adult reference for a movie that would need to drink from a sippy cup if it were a human being, but The Master Of Disguise outdoes the 10 reference for jarringly inappropriate adult content by paying reverent homage to such beloved favorites of the pre-school set as The Exorcist, Scarface (Carvey spends an endless scene imitating Tony Montana as alter-ego “Mr. Peru”) and Jaws, which is lovingly resurrected by Carvey when he performs what appears to be Robert Shaw’s entire role late in the film.

Just about the only reference children might actually get is an unexpectedly melancholy moment when Pistachio tries to impress a little boy (whose mother ultimately becomes his assistant and love interest) by imitating Shrek, a movie whose primary voice is provided by a man famous for his troubled and tension-filled relationship with Carvey.

But before The Master Of Disguise can be glaringly, gallingly inappropriate, it first establishes an elaborate mythology for its title character, who we learn is part of a clan that has furtively protected society for ages through its uncanny gift for impersonation. The legacy of the Disguiseys has been kept a secret from Pistachio, who works in the family restaurant and, like Jerry Lewis long after his prime, is a grown-ass man in his forties who dresses and behaves like a mentally challenged child. Pistachio is a blinkered innocent, but during stressful situations he enters something of a fugue state where he can’t help but impersonate whoever he’s with.


“No one who ever sees one of his horrifying get-ups is ever likely to forget the trauma.”

Then one day, bad guy Devlin Bowman (Brent Spiner) shows up — he has an unfortunate predilection for laughing so hard and sinisterly at his evil plans that he unleashes explosive flatulence (because when you’re making a movie for kids you’ve got to explore the comic possibilities of both butts and farts to their full potential). Bowman kidnaps Pistachio’s parents and forces his father to use his uncanny powers of impersonation to steal priceless artifacts like the U.S Constitution. This is when Pistachio lazily lurches into action under the guidance of his grandfather to try to find his missing parents and thwart Devlin’s evil plan to sell beloved artifacts on a black market Ebay.

Now the purpose of a disguise, generally, is to fit into your surroundings so thoroughly that you are unnoticeable and can go about your important business uninterrupted, but Pistachio Disguisey pursues an antithetical strategy. Instead of blending in so well that he becomes borderline invisible human camouflage, able to swarm in and out of dangers inconspicuously, Pistachio makes such a bizarre, surreal spectacle of himself that not only is he destined to be noticed, but no one who ever sees one of his horrifying get-ups is ever likely to forget the trauma.

This extends to the audience. In The Master Of Disguise‘s signature scene — the reason the film has attracted such a strangely loyal following — Pistachio decides that the best way to go undercover at an exclusive enclave known as the Turtle Club is to disguise himself as a bald, turtle-shaped, amphibian-man hybrid who croaks “Turtle!” to no one in particular in a strangled voice redolent of deep mental illness and unimaginable damage.

Though he is presented as a lovably eccentric nut, Pistachio frequently comes across more like a deeply disturbed man who has suffered a definitive break from reality and lives in an insane world of his own imagining. His rampaging madness insists than an institution called the Turtle Club could only have acquired that name because it caters to a clientele of freakish man-animals who look and act like turtles, screeching the word “turtle” for no discernible reason when they aren’t retreating into a homemade shell (i.e. a turtle-shaped suit so enormous Pistachio is able to hide within it when threatened). “Am I not turtle-y enough for the Turtle Club?” Pistachio inquires aggressively — words I am ashamed to admit I will remember long after I forget the birthdays of my wife and son.

The turtle scene is at once the film’s nadir and its apex. Once seen, it cannot be unseen. It signals a shift from spectacularly stupid slapstick silliness to something that borders on avant-garde. The Master Of Disguise doesn’t have much use for a plot, but after the Turtle Club it all but abandons logic and linear storytelling altogether. The half-assed narrative becomes simply an excuse for Carvey to cycle through a series of characters that he obviously adores playing but which make very little sense within the context of the film, like a Tony Montana doppelgänger who also possesses the grace and moves of a ballet dancer.

The other actors in The Master Of Disguise don’t act with Carvey so much as they respond to his mugging and over-the-top shenanigans. This is particularly true of Jennifer Esposito, whose role is a never-ending assault on her dignity (at one point, Pistachio and his grandfather obsess about her “scrawny” posterior and how it fails to measure up to McClurg’s butt) but it’s also spectacularly unchallenging. All she really has to do is be attractive and seem appropriately embarrassed to be in the company of someone like Pistachio Disguisey, which is definitely within her wheelhouse.


“The turtle scene is at once the film’s nadir and its apex. Once seen, it cannot be unseen.”

The Master Of Disguise wraps up what little story it has around the 71-minute mark. This renders it barely feature-length, so the filmmakers eke another 10 minutes or so out of this nonsense with an endless series of outtakes and bloopers. What’s fascinating about this is that many of them are clearly from deleted scenes. Wikipedia lists fictional politician Mayor Maynot, real-life painter Bob Ross, a vampire, legendary ventriloquist dummy Charlie McCarthy, Groucho Marx, Gluteus Maximus (a parody of the protagonist of Gladiator), Forrest Gump, and a caveman as characters Carvey plays in the end credits but not in the film itself.

This raises the horrifying and fascinating prospect that the filmmakers shot way more footage than they ended up using (not difficult to imagine when the end credits show up shortly after an hour has passed) and that there were scenes that were written, costumed, and filmed but were edited out because they did not work as well as The Turtle Club scene or the one when Pistachio and his grandfather ogle the man’s ass.

I like to imagine that there is a four hour cut of The Master Of Disguise with every scene and character and costume included, but that anyone who watches it would go stark raving mad, and the people behind the film could not have that on their conscience. I would totally watch this fabled, probably theoretical cut because I find the film so hypnotically terrible and so joyously, wonderfully devoid of logic and sanity. It really feels like Carvey got an opportunity to realize every bad idea he’d ever had as a writer or performer and shoehorn them into one crazily overstuffed, overstuffed-with-crazy, impossible-to-forget extravaganza.

Though The Master Of Disguise is a commercial success that I imagine also did well on cable and home video, Carvey has not written or starred in a movie in the 13 years since the film was released. In a weird way, he doesn’t have to, because it feels like he did everything he ever wanted to do, film-wise, with The Master Of Disguise. It represents a strong, uncompromising vision no less fascinating for being insane and just barely a movie, rather than an extended highlight reel for the even longer film the end credits threaten.

My Original Certification: Rotten
My Re-Certification: Fresh
Tomatometer: One percent

Follow Nathan Rabin on Twitter: @NathanRabin

  • Sabrina Wilson

    Thank you for your review and reminding me of how cute and strange this film is. This is a great, fun, romp of a movie! Leave your brain at the door and just enjoy the silly antics. It’s very weird but enjoyable. I put it in the same category as, ‘Dude, Where’s My Car,’ ‘Mystery Men,’ and ‘Bubble Boy.’ Don’t try to analyze it or find too much meaning – just be a kid and laugh. 🙂

    • Sabretruthtiger

      Ummm no. Mystery men was a great, clever comedy, a genius send-up of the super hero genre.

      Do not EVER put it in the same category.

      • Greg Phillips

        Genius is incredibly strong for a movie as average as Mystery Men.

  • Connors

    I’m a huge Carvey fan, but aside from the Scarface impersonation, I hated this movie. Saw it in the theater back in ’02 and felt very embarrassed to be there. That said, I’m glad to hear it may have made him some money, because Carvey is cool and very likable. I only wish he’d re-launch the Dana Carvey Show…or at least do something.

  • Bryton Cherrier

    If you mean it gaining cult status as an infamously bad movie. Then yeah, I agree.

  • Vits/Vicente Torres

    It does.

    I can’t look pass the obvious mistakes and the campy visuals (who thought it would be a good idea to hire Happy Madison’s production designer as the director?!), but it still made me laugh. I admired Dana Carvey’s ability to disguise, but now I realize that it doesn’t automatically the impression is funny. It was… only at times.

    [Mild spoilers ahead]

    This features one of the worst scenes in the history of cinema: When PISTACCIO is escaping from the henchmen, he disguises a bunch of times. Then, while still disguised as “grass”, he hides behind a newspaper. Why the f*ck would he do that if he’s the master of disguise?! The reason why is one of the worst is because it was obvious that everyone on set had turned off their brains while filming that scene.

    • david

      I don’t think you really need a spoiler alert for a movie this bad. It just doesn’t matter.

      • Vits/Vicente Torres

        Quality has nothing to do with it. Spoiling is always wrong.

        • david

          Dana Carvey spoiled the movie by simply making it.

  • MidnightNoon

    My brother and I went to see this when it hit the dollar house circuit. My brother was 6 at the time, and even with the low standards of a child he thought it was terrible and we walked out.

  • Jack Dee

    Your movies are not cult movies. They are pure sh_t movies.

    • chrisk

      ^not turtley enough.

  • Jackie Jormpjomp

    I have little kids and I am a big Carvey fan. While I acknowledge it is imperfect I kinda liked it. My kids laughed pretty hard. At the end of the day all that really matters is of you like a movie or not. Not if someone else liked it.

    • James Allard

      Aaaand there it is. My rationale for liking/disliking just about everything. If you like something, then enjoy it. If not, then avoid it.

  • keithcozz66

    This might be the funniest film review I’ve ever read.

    Thank you, Nathan.

  • david

    Comedies are supposed to be funny. This movie was everything BUT funny.

  • Man size meatballs!

  • p waddy

    Ok Hipster.

  • Didn’t Carvey stop making films and being on TV because he had a medical problem? I seem to remember something about how he had heart surgery that wasn’t done right or something.

  • William Johnson

    One of the worst movies that I have ever seen. Nothing funny at all. Dana Carvey’s career ender.

    • Alex Flores

      Ok swagtard.

  • John Draper

    My brother and I are in the cult.

    90% of people don’t get or hate this movie, and the 10% that get or adore this movie are super devoted. Sounds like a cult classic to me.

    Join the turtle club.

  • Bloost
  • ETL

    The film plays like Carvey had a bunch of characters left over from SNL and decided to string a film together with them. I can see The Turtle Club working as an absurdist 12:50 skit on SNL for the stoners, Grammy Num-mum harassing Dennis Miller at the Update desk, or Terry Suave showing up completely out of place in a spy thriller sequence. However the film doesn’t give the characters any of the build that a well constructed sketch would have despite having more time to do so.

    It sounds strange, but if they had given Turtle Guy some more screen time and something to do other than stand there and say “Turtle” a lot they would have had something as strange and disturbing as Massive Headwound Harry.

  • Where’s the “Halloween III: The Season of the Witch” review?
    It deserves another look!
    I can’t believe it’s rated 24% by the audience.

  • Clark

    I’m a Carvey fan also, but I remember this being so terrible to sit through I walked out and went into Austin Powers 3 instead. Sorry Garth, but Wayne’s the better comedian.

    • Connors

      Carvey was better on SNL, and Myers could never put together anything as funny as the Dana Carvey Show.

  • Jamoche

    I remember when ads for this ran *constantly*. Even 60 seconds of it was cringe-generatingly horrible. I was so glad when it tanked and dropped out of theatres because the ads finally ended – only to be besieged again when the DVD came out.

Tag Cloud

2019 Spring TV romantic comedy screen actors guild mission: impossible hist Arrowverse TCA Winter 2020 Sony Pictures Ghostbusters The Witch Netflix Star Wars Nickelodeon Schedule USA archives The Arrangement scary movies DGA spider-man best blockbuster cults die hard directors spanish BBC One BET Awards streaming APB Rocky comiccon Syfy cancelled Grammys nature kids Sci-Fi CBS All Access Netflix Christmas movies cooking Best and Worst YouTube witnail FXX 2020 Travel Channel harry potter Superheroes international Oscars ratings women AMC based on movie Election cars CW Seed psycho 4/20 RT21 Sundance TV VOD NBC doctor who festivals TBS Anna Paquin game show Teen Set visit Legendary Comedy Central SXSW docudrama Heroines know your critic Elton John Logo science fiction Black Mirror superman ghosts revenge Binge Guide Emmys Apple TV+ BBC Photos worst X-Men cancelled TV series The Purge casting Winter TV news cartoon Lifetime Opinion Stephen King GLAAD Family 72 Emmy Awards The Walt Disney Company Freeform Sundance 24 frames MCU dramedy fast and furious Brie Larson slashers 21st Century Fox TV renewals Universal emmy awards Chernobyl WarnerMedia Ovation Disney+ Disney Plus movie Spike Western Amazon stop motion satire Television Academy zombies boxoffice dc Pride Month The Walking Dead spy thriller strong female leads Columbia Pictures venice The Academy Shudder foreign crossover monster movies TV One social media Nat Geo HBO Max worst movies First Reviews HBO HBO Go Comic Book ESPN screenings jurassic park BBC America 007 Amazon Prime Video a nightmare on elm street Song of Ice and Fire all-time Sundance Now 2017 MTV batman Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt See It Skip It Cartoon Network space war Christmas diversity sag awards LGBT fresh crime thriller Superheroe canceled TV shows BAFTA what to watch blaxploitation trailers documentary south america Star Trek indie BET TV Land Character Guide films Britbox Biopics hispanic GIFs finale TNT First Look The CW Tumblr Rock book adaptation Avengers Bravo CBS FX Fox Searchlight San Diego Comic-Con crime Lifetime Christmas movies Super Bowl Masterpiece lord of the rings teaser mutant Alien Academy Awards Red Carpet chucky Valentine's Day PaleyFest book Lucasfilm 2016 Hear Us Out 99% YA cats sports werewolf Cannes anthology universal monsters Premiere Dates TV Esquire hollywood Paramount Plus Walt Disney Pictures kaiju 20th Century Fox FOX Pet Sematary tv talk Tomatazos christmas movies Mystery DirecTV Endgame GoT golden globe awards laika ID halloween Film Festival new star wars movies Mindy Kaling crime drama Adult Swim elevated horror award winner TCA Awards Drama animated VH1 adventure ABC Signature indiana jones technology Holiday telelvision Comics on TV godzilla canceled Sneak Peek E! 45 reboot obituary razzies rt archives singing competition American Society of Cinematographers supernatural Turner Classic Movies Pacific Islander concert romance OneApp rom-coms President FX on Hulu french Extras historical drama Television Critics Association dogs new zealand Emmy Nominations YouTube Red OWN Trailer Marathons Countdown ABC Family child's play IFC Films series Amazon Prime Tubi halloween tv aapi high school theme song politics Animation New York Comic Con pirates of the caribbean political drama psychological thriller medical drama Fox News Marvel quibi zombie king kong black Paramount Network Reality Competition joker TV movies Apple Dark Horse Comics golden globes justice league Trophy Talk Video Games composers Thanksgiving Mary Tyler Moore El Rey dragons 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards E3 dark australia Polls and Games rotten Disney rotten movies we love MSNBC Apple TV Plus criterion period drama Image Comics blockbusters richard e. Grant free movies mockumentary robots live action RT History 93rd Oscars Acorn TV television breaking bad anime Chilling Adventures of Sabrina football sequel Rocketman Musical Country ITV spinoff Martial Arts asian-american YouTube Premium Starz natural history Showtime spain PBS Year in Review renewed TV shows classics IFC TCM Mary poppins Creative Arts Emmys ABC talk show docuseries Kids & Family hidden camera 2015 cancelled TV shows Ellie Kemper Toys 2018 Vudu Disney Plus VICE name the review Summer discovery Reality Mary Poppins Returns Turner facebook Baby Yoda Comedy video Disney Channel saw binge Funimation transformers police drama Awards Tour children's TV 2021 marvel cinematic universe Pop 71st Emmy Awards unscripted Horror dceu Lionsgate zero dark thirty thriller Hulu twilight Watching Series Cosplay Pixar Captain marvel Tarantino vampires SundanceTV Quiz Fall TV Podcast critics NYCC Disney streaming service Pirates TCA 2017 Infographic WGN CNN Black History Month Food Network serial killer Crackle Calendar cinemax streaming movies Fantasy toy story green book remakes miniseries latino superhero franchise scorecard aliens DC Comics Classic Film Interview TIFF Discovery Channel toronto Awards prank A24 Pop TV comic Musicals Amazon Studios jamie lee curtis LGBTQ Marvel Television Hallmark parents Women's History Month Hallmark Christmas movies movies Film Certified Fresh DC Universe stand-up comedy sequels stoner spanish language nbcuniversal adaptation comedies cops Spectrum Originals Peacock Warner Bros. scene in color SDCC japanese disaster independent nfl A&E ViacomCBS popular Broadway Shondaland Nominations PlayStation Trivia Rom-Com CMT james bond versus USA Network reviews Marvel Studios Epix TCA Box Office Mudbound Crunchyroll comics target game of thrones Writers Guild of America festival documentaries Winners TLC cancelled television Paramount new york video on demand sitcom Exclusive Video DC streaming service italian deadpool comic books heist movie kong true crime TruTV History Action National Geographic Holidays Music biography boxing travel