Critics Consensus

Disney's Aladdin One Jump Ahead of The Fresh Line, For Now

But will it stay there? Plus, Booksmart is smart and cool and Brightburn messes with the superhero trope.

by | May 23, 2019 | Comments

Can Prince Ali, mighty is he, slay at the box office? Aladdin, Disney’s live-action remake of its 1992 animated musical stars Will Smith as the sometimes-blue genie with the power to grant three wishes and Mena Massoud as the titular small-time thief-turned-imposter prince. It’s also the flashiest film opening this weekend – even if it doesn’t come with the highest reviews. That honor goes to director Olivia Wilde’s teen comedy Booksmart. Also in wide release is horror film Brightburn, which serves as a send-up of superhero films. All three movies offer reinventions of staid genres. But, which one will rule this weekend’s multiplexes? The critics have some thoughts.


Booksmart (2019) 97%

The movie trope of high school students wanting one last hurrah before graduation has been done, more often than not leaning on the male gaze (and let’s face it, often come with some sexist overtones that don’t always age well). That’s why Olivia Wilde’s directorial debut is so refreshing. Kaitlyn Dever and Beanie Feldstein play self-confident Ivy League-bound seniors on the precipice of adulthood who don’t want some virginity-themed raunchy night out. They just want their classmates to remember them as the smart and fun ladies they – and clearly, the critics – know they are.

Brightburn (2019) 57%

Thanks to the legend of Superman, we’re taught to expect that a lot of good will happen when a child from another world crash-lands on Earth. Director David Yarovesky’s new horror film messes with this misconception, in the process earning some mixed reviews – and an R-rating, which  probably doesn’t help in regards to ticket sales. But the film does come with some interesting pedigree, as its written by Brian and Mark Gunn (a cousin and brother to Guardians of the Galaxy’s James Gunn, who also produced) and stars Slither actor Elizabeth Banks as the mother caring for the alien boy. It’s also on Rotten Tomatoes’ list of most-anticipated horror films of the year.

Aladdin (2019) 57%

Despite the hesitation that ensued among fandoms when footage of Will Smith as a blue genie first appeared online, (How hard is it going to be to take this film seriously? Someone else is playing the part made famous by the late Robin Williams? Is nothing sacred?) most critics say that Disney’s latest live-action remake of one of its animated classics is fine — maybe not totally necessary, but passable. Given the way these new versions rank at the box office (even Dumbo, which opened in March and has a Tomatometer score of 47%, eventually grossed $112 million, despite a $170 million production budget), the Mouse House shouldn’t worry too much. If this movie isn’t to your liking, Disney has many other films on the horizon.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Diamantino (2019) is a sci-fi tinged drama that follows a disgraced former soccer star on the hunt for a new purpose – confronting, along the way, neo-fascism, the refugee crisis, genetic modification, and abuse at the hands of his evil twin sisters. It is Certified Fresh at 87%.
  • Avengement (2019) is, as suggested by the title, a film that follows a criminal on furlough from prison who uses his time on the outside to take down those who made him a cold-blooded killer. It is Fresh with a 100% Tomatometer.
  • Echo In the Canyon (2019) is a music documentary that looks at influential artists like The Beach Boys, The Byrds, The Mamas and the Papas and others who were part of the Laurel Canyon scene of the mid-’60s and contributed to what would be known as the California Sound. It is Fresh with a 100% Tomatometer.
  • Woodstock: Three Days That Defined a Generation (2019) is another music doc set around the turbulent ’60s, and includes never-before-seen footage of the concert that would define a generation. It is Fresh with a 100% Tomatometer.
  • Funny Story (2019) is described as a tragi-comedy and follows an aging heartthrob who attempts to reconnect with his grown daughter – by hitching a ride with her friend and crashing her vacation in Big Sur. It has an 89% Tomatometer score.
  • Halston (2019) is a documentary that looks at influential 1970s fashion designer Halston. Frédéric Tcheng, who also did films about Diana Vreeland and Valentino, writes and directs. It is Fresh with an 80% Tomatometer.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

TCA comiccon President Shondaland discovery miniseries Winter TV MSNBC Song of Ice and Fire Sneak Peek Starz Quiz Mindy Kaling Music Ovation Emmy Nominations series Countdown Horror Masterpiece Reality Winners dc VICE Rock Christmas revenge ghosts GoT Sony Pictures Vudu Acorn TV Musical binge natural history Walt Disney Pictures Hulu Freeform Action docudrama YA Tumblr Western Fall TV Mary poppins Bravo Valentine's Day A&E sitcom Captain marvel Rom-Com Disney Creative Arts Emmys Trailer Epix Black Mirror Shudder Crackle streaming ABC Family police drama TruTV Emmys PaleyFest Drama space award winner Martial Arts Paramount adventure Tarantino elevated horror nature TV Sci-Fi Musicals Fantasy Apple GLAAD tv talk zombie Amazon Prime Pixar based on movie Syfy First Look Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Ellie Kemper Rocky festivals ABC FXX mockumentary cats NYCC IFC ESPN quibi boxoffice Chernobyl facebook Pirates The CW Lifetime crime Britbox E3 Certified Fresh kids Photos MCU jamie lee curtis theme song Cartoon Network TIFF Best and Worst RT History sequel NBC justice league Thanksgiving Biopics green book CBS Mary Tyler Moore movies Country DC streaming service Mudbound cooking Premiere Dates DirecTV BBC America YouTube Premium VH1 Watching Series Star Trek what to watch BET Sundance Now YouTube Red Brie Larson Schedule 2017 SundanceTV RT21 Comic Book Writers Guild of America FX Reality Competition dragons Calendar romance Spectrum Originals Polls and Games Awards Tour thriller Holidays political drama Pet Sematary Disney streaming service cars Animation vampires Esquire Kids & Family The Arrangement X-Men Logo Superheroe spinoff DGA CBS All Access Superheroes Fox News children's TV TCA 2017 E! politics 2019 Trophy Talk AMC Pop Super Bowl LGBTQ Cannes Video Games Mary Poppins Returns sports Women's History Month zero dark thirty Family Lionsgate WGN DC Comics Anna Paquin USA Network true crime ratings aliens American Society of Cinematographers Cosplay cops Chilling Adventures of Sabrina historical drama hist Spring TV 007 Nat Geo Spike National Geographic dceu Set visit cults 2018 El Rey TBS Awards richard e. Grant crossover harry potter Opinion Infographic teaser psychological thriller Film Lucasfilm SDCC Grammys doctor who Tomatazos Paramount Network strong female leads Comics on TV MTV technology Comedy Mystery 2015 finale Rocketman witnail Year in Review medical drama TNT CMT Showtime The Witch Comedy Central OWN spy thriller San Diego Comic-Con Stephen King FOX Box Office Interview book SXSW BBC war Trivia Universal crime drama Dark Horse Comics 24 frames TV Land TCM Election Red Carpet zombies robots crime thriller composers blaxploitation HBO Max Toys Disney Channel Teen comic WarnerMedia serial killer transformers Film Festival Heroines Pride Month History diversity unscripted Star Wars IFC Films anthology TLC 20th Century Fox social media APB period drama Food Network golden globes Extras spider-man singing competition 21st Century Fox GIFs Warner Bros. television Summer casting 45 Ghostbusters adaptation dramedy HBO LGBT Nickelodeon 2016 Oscars Nominations anime stand-up comedy Marathons Adult Swim Podcast Marvel supernatural cinemax Amazon Prime Video disaster Netflix toy story game show CNN Amazon USA biography PBS Elton John talk show Columbia Pictures mutant CW Seed Binge Guide See It Skip It ITV Character Guide Sundance animated DC Universe psycho travel New York Comic Con science fiction