Critics Consensus

Dark Tower Condemned

Plus, Kidnap is a middling thriller, and Detroit and The Sinner are Certified Fresh.

by | August 3, 2017 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have a Stephen King epic brought to life (The Dark Tower, starring Idris Elba and Matthew McConaughey), a mother in a desperate race to save her child (Kidnap, starring Halle Berry), and a mournful look back at a fatally violent chapter in America’s past (Detroit, starring John Boyega and Anthony Mackie). What are the critics saying?


The Dark Tower (2017) 15%


Everyone wants a cinematic universe these days, which is just one of a handful of reasons why it’s a little hard to understand the way Hollywood’s dragged its feet adapting Stephen King’s The Dark Tower. A mystical fantasy girded with fate-of-the-universe stakes, populated with distinctive characters, and tinged with the author’s trademark horror, it’s got plenty of blockbuster potential — and it ties into a whole bunch of King’s bestselling books. It’s also narratively sprawling, incredibly ambitious, and beloved among a devoted fanbase, which are just a few of the potential problems that have helped keep this project languishing in studio limbo for so long. Unfortunately, all that extra time in development doesn’t seem to have helped: this Tower is under siege from all sides by critics who’ve scaled its cinematic heights and found them sadly lacking. Lacking the scope of the source material or the focus of a compelling fantasy thriller, it’s being maligned as a near-total misfire — and a truly unfortunate beginning to what was once conceived as a major film and television franchise.


Detroit (2017) 82%


There’s a unique power to a well-made docudrama, but any director who attempts one bears the unique responsibility of trying to craft compelling cinema while also honoring the facts of the events being dramatized — and the people who experienced them. With Detroit, director Kathryn Bigelow shoulders that burden heavier than most; in looking back on one of the most violent race riots in American history 50 years after it occurred, her film probes wounds that are still painfully raw for many — and does so at what feels like a particularly fraught time. It’s a tough job, in other words, but critics say it’s a good thing Bigelow was the one to do it: the director’s award-winning experience with intense fact-based drama is well suited to the material, and that also applies to screenwriter Mark Boal, who earlier collaborated with her on The Hurt Locker. The end result certainly isn’t easy to watch, but reviews describe a hard-hitting achievement that might be something more important: a brutally honest look at our past that’s just as timely — and essential — today.

Kidnap (2017) 35%


Liam Neeson’s career-altering turn in Taken proved that sometimes, all it takes is the right action vehicle to remind audiences how much they love you, and with this weekend’s Kidnap, Halle Berry joins the list of big-screen veterans ready to avenge a loved one by violently incapacitating bad guys. Berry plays Karla Dyson, a single mom whose son’s sudden abduction — in the midst of a custody battle, natch — sparks an action-packed struggle that’s only the start of their fight for survival. It sounds like the setup for a perfectly serviceable late-summer diversion, and as far as a handful of critics are concerned, that’s pretty much what it is; the majority, however, can’t get past the picture’s occasionally inexplicable plot and overall perfunctory air. If you’re really in the mood for an August action thriller, a huge Halle Berry fan, or just seeking out a darkened, air-conditioned room, Kidnap will do — but otherwise, it looks like you’re better off waiting to stream it at your extreme leisure.

What’s New on TV

The Sinner: Miniseries (2017) 94%

Smartly unpredictable and led by powerful performances from a talented cast, the darkly compelling The Sinner sinks its hooks in fast and doesn’t let go.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Columbus (2017) , starring John Cho as a young man waylaid in the titular Indiana city after his father falls ill, is at 100 percent.
  • 68 Kill (2017) , about a down-on-their-luck duo who hatch a highly illegal scheme to improve their financial fortunes, is at 100 percent.
  • It's Not Yet Dark (2017) , a documentary about filmmaker Simon Fitzmaurice‘s life with ALS, is at 100 percent.
  • Some Freaks (2017) , about young lovers forced to reexamine their relationship after one undergoes a major physical change, is at 100 percent.
  • Step (2017) , a documentary about an all-girls’ step squad in Baltimore, is at 93 percent.
  • Wind River (2017) , a Wyoming-set murder mystery starring Elizabeth Olsen and Jeremy Renner, is at 87 percent.
  • 4 Days in France (Jours de France) (2017) , about a young man’s Grindr-led journey through the French countryside after abandoning his lover, is at 86 percent.
  • Fun Mom Dinner (2017) , about four moms who pause looking after their preschoolers long enough to head out on the town for a fun dinner, is at 44 percent.
  • Brave New Jersey (2017) , a comedy imagining the chaos that erupts in a New Jersey town whose residents fall for Orson Welles’ “War of the Worlds” radio broadcast, is at 38 percent.

Tag Cloud

Mindy Kaling Crackle composers Starz BBC DirecTV dramedy TBS biography Disney Opinion Star Trek cinemax E3 Extras Reality President Fox News harry potter Grammys CBS GIFs social media Holidays FX Set visit Superheroes Countdown Spring TV Premiere Dates 45 war comiccon TNT Photos 24 frames Election TV TruTV Musical SDCC TCA TIFF cats CBS All Access RT History FOX Lifetime Drama Hulu Animation sitcom cooking Video Games GLAAD TCM singing competition talk show Interview E! IFC Infographic Teen docudrama Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Sundance Mary Tyler Moore Esquire Thanksgiving Cosplay GoT vampires crime adventure Rocky 2017 007 Podcast Showtime Box Office serial killer politics Marathons PaleyFest VICE SundanceTV BET BBC America Best and Worst Trailer Year in Review Horror El Rey Certified Fresh MSNBC Winter TV Tomatazos Schedule The Arrangement Nickelodeon Pop Mystery APB Universal PBS ABC Winners VH1 Fantasy technology Rom-Com Musicals Action travel crime drama Polls and Games Lionsgate Toys Oscars Awards boxoffice AMC Warner Bros. aliens Comedy NYCC Nominations TLC Valentine's Day Sci-Fi science fiction Syfy Masterpiece Watching Series Reality Competition Writers Guild of America Rock Nat Geo Biopics History Character Guide crime thriller TV Land Cartoon Network Red Carpet The CW DC Comics Amazon YA Kids & Family historical drama ABC Family transformers Trivia political drama Star Wars Bravo Martial Arts zombie romance thriller Fall TV TCA 2017 Comic Book period drama NBC Calendar Dark Horse Comics First Look WGN discovery Comedy Central MTV DC Universe Logo Netflix psycho Ellie Kemper cops what to watch Emmys Country CMT Paramount 2016 Food Network diversity police drama sports Pirates based on movie A&E Sneak Peek ESPN Disney Channel American Society of Cinematographers 2015 Music Marvel USA binge CNN HBO Freeform FXX Summer Ghostbusters Super Bowl LGBTQ Tumblr supernatural X-Men OWN ITV Adult Swim