Critics Consensus

Critics Mostly Take a Shine to Doctor Sleep

Plus, Last Christmas is mildly diverting, Midway means well but falters, Playing with Fire is strictly for the kids, and Jojo Rabbit, Marriage Story, and Honey Boy are Certified Fresh.

by | November 7, 2019 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a shiny sequel (Doctor Sleep, starring Ewan McGregor and Rebecca Ferguson), a holiday romance (Last Christmas, starring Emilia Clarke and Henry Golding), wartime heroics (Midway, starring Woody Harrelson and Patrick Wilson), overwhelmed firefighters (Playing with Fire, starring John Cena and Brianna Hildebrand), and a Nazi satire (Jojo Rabbit, starring Taika Waititi and Scarlett Johansson). What are the critics saying?

Doctor Sleep (2019) 77%

Stephen King was rather famously unhappy with Stanley Kubrick’s adaptation of his novel The Shining, even if the film went on to be a bona fide classic, beloved by millions of fans who mythologized and analyzed it endlessly. So even with a new novel from King to work with as source material, it was always going to be a daunting task for director Mike Flanagan to adapt Doctor Sleep, a sequel to The Shining, for the big screen almost four decades later. But Flanagan may have proven to be the best choice for the job — he’s a huge Stephen King fan and even wrote one of his own acclaimed horror films (Hush) at the Stanley Hotel, where King was inspired to write The Shining. The end result, according to reviews, is a faithful translation from page to screen — if different from its predecessor — that does a decent job balancing its genre thrills with its more contemplative themes. Ewan McGregor stars in Doctor Sleep as a grown-up Danny Torrance, who offers his help to a teenage girl (Kyliegh Curran) with the same extrasensory “shine” that he possesses. She’s on the run from a nefarious cult known as The True Knot, who seek out others like her and Danny to feed on their special abilities. Critics say the film has its flaws — it plays at times like mere Shining fan service and seems to feel the need to offer too-tidy solutions — but manages to feel both like it’s a part of Kubrick’s vision and a unique beast all its own, with great performances (Rebecca Ferguson in particular, ahem, shines as the villain) and poignant themes that help bring an element of depth to the scares. It’s probably not going to go down as a horror classic, but it’s more than serviceable as an addition to the still-growing list of Stephen King adaptations.

Last Christmas (2019) 47%

This week brings us our first true holiday film of the season in the form of a Paul Feig romantic comedy starring the Mother of Dragons and the hot guy from Crazy Rich Asians. We’re talking about Emilia Clarke and Henry Golding, respectively, the latter of whom previously worked with Feig on last year’s Certified Fresh A Simple Favor. In Last Christmas, Golding plays another love interest as Tom, the mysterious man who seems to pop up at the most convenient times in the life of an unlucky, self-destructive woman named Kate (Clarke). Kate is a struggling would-be singer who takes a job working at a year-round Christmas shop in London when she runs into Tom, and the two of them begin to fall for each other, as Tom helps Kate put her life back on track. Critics say this piece of holiday magic — co-written by and co-starring Emma Thompson — is certainly aided by the immense likability of its stars, and audiences in search of a feel-good flick will get what they’re looking for. However, the film does fall prey to some cliches commonly found in the genre, and there’s no denying that it all feels like something you might find airing on Lifetime or the Hallmark Channel, with all the requisite cheesiness that implies. Whether or not that’s appealing will be up to the viewer.

Midway (2019) 41%

Director Roland Emmerich, one of Hollywood’s foremost purveyors of “disaster porn,” isn’t exactly known for his somber filmmaking or nuanced storytelling, so it wouldn’t be unreasonable to presume his cinematic retelling of World War II’s Battle of Midway, aptly titled Midway, would be a grandiose display of explosions and exaggerated human peril. To Emmerich’s credit, the film is more ambitious than that, but reviews so far say its reach far exceeds its grasp. Woody Harrelson and Patrick Wilson headline a testosterone-fueled ensemble cast (Dennis Quaid, Aaron Eckhart, Luke Evans, Ed Skrein, and more) as the story covers the events of Pearl Harbor, the U.S. code-breakers deciphering Japanese communications, and the pivotal titular battle itself, pitting American and Japanese forces against each other in a dramatic naval and aerial conflict. While critics concede Emmerich does his best to portray events in a balanced fashion, they also found that the film, which runs well over two hours, is chock full of stale dialogue and loses its way in a cacophony of special effects-heavy action sequences. There’s a powerful story to be told here about one of the most important battles in American history, but Roland Emmerich may not be quite the right man to tell it, unless you’re looking for an equally trite companion piece to Michael Bay’s Pearl Harbor.

Playing with Fire (2019) 22%

Being that we here at Rotten Tomatoes are located in California, just miles away from the sites of multiple wildfires, it’s admittedly a little difficult not to cringe a little bit every time we pass by a billboard for Playing with Fire, complete with a smirking John Cena and its flippant tagline — “0% Contained” — emblazoned across it. Thankfully, though the film wasn’t widely screened for critics ahead of time, those who have seen it report that the majority of the action takes place at the fire station, where Cena’s superintendent and fellow smoke-jumpers (played by Keegan-Michael Key and John Leguizamo) are tasked with babysitting a trio of kids they’ve rescued until their missing parents can come pick them up. What results is a broad slapstick comedy that critics say might appeal to the youngest viewers but might grow tiresome for anyone older. Cena, Key, and Leguizamo are reliable comic talents, and with a supporting cast that includes Brianna Hildebrand, Judy Greer, and Dennis Haysbert, there are bound to be some great moments. But the final product is a fairly standard children’s film that makes use of a familiar formula — macho men paired with precocious children — in service of a silly, predictable comedy, and unless you’re part of the target audience, there isn’t a strong chance there’s much for you to see here.

Jojo Rabbit (2019) 80%

Lastly, we have rather unique film expanding into wider release with quite a bit of buzz surrounding it. Thor: Ragnarok director Taika Waititi‘s Jojo Rabbit is a World War II satire that centers on a young Hitler Youth named Jojo (Roman Griffith Davis) whose imaginary friend happens to be a decidedly less sinister incarnation of Der Führer himself (played by Waititi). When Jojo learns his mother (Scarlett Johansson) is harboring a young Jewish girl in the attic, he’s forced to come to terms with his beliefs and decide what is right. The ensemble cast includes Sam Rockwell, Rebel Wilson, Stephen Merchant, and as the girl seeking refuge, Thomasin McKenzie. Critics admit Jojo Rabbit‘s irreverent treatment of a rather serious subject may not be broadly appealing, but for those in tune with Taika Waititi’s off-kilter sense of humor, it’s a smart, funny, surprisingly sweet comedy that benefits from some strong performances and largely succeeds in communicating its larger themes. It’s a risky, ambitious proposition, for sure, and some moviegoers will find it a little awkward in its execution, but Waititi is nothing if not unconventional, and it would appear he’s accomplished what he set out to do.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Marriage Story (2019) , starring Scarlett Johansson and Adam Driver in Noah Baumbach‘s drama as an actress-director couple whose marriage slowly disintegrates, is Certified Fresh at 97%.
  • Honey Boy (2019) , starring Shia LaBeouf (who also wrote the screenplay) in an autobiographical drama about his relationship to his demanding father (played by LaBeouf himself), is Certified Fresh at 95%.
  • The Kingmaker (2019) , a documentary chronicling the exploits of the famously corrupt Marcos family, and specifically former First Lady Imelda Marcos, who once governed the Philippines, is at 92%.
  • Sunday Girl (2019) , a romantic comedy about a woman involved in relationships with five men who must make a difficult decision, is at 80%.
  • Klaus (2019) , featuring the voices of Jason Schwartzman, Rashida Jones, and J.K. Simmons in an animated holiday adventure about the origins of Christmas mythology, is at 75%.
  • Crown Vic (2019) , a thriller about a veteran LAPD officer and his rookie partner on patrol over the course of one night with two cop killers on the loose, is at 73%.
  • Danger Close (2019) , a Vietnam War film recounting the Battle of Long Tan, in which Australian soldiers fought against the Viet Cong, is at 65%.
  • Primal (2019) , starring Nicolas Cage in an action thriller about a hunter trapped on a ship with the white jaguar he captured and a dangerous prisoner who has broken free, is at 54%.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Arrowverse police drama Anna Paquin Schedule cancelled 71st Emmy Awards Endgame Disney Plus comics reboot Black Mirror Pirates series scorecard streaming Comics on TV sitcom thriller best X-Men australia renewed TV shows dc comic CNN french Infographic Nickelodeon Superheroe jamie lee curtis mutant adaptation psycho book green book travel The CW GoT The Walking Dead italian animated A24 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Logo cartoon Netflix zombie Starz DGA LGBT Extras archives 2017 2020 MSNBC 72 Emmy Awards Paramount Network foreign Hallmark transformers Britbox ITV FXX Sneak Peek Best and Worst Paramount politics RT History Ovation Freeform casting psychological thriller President Music indie twilight child's play TNT harry potter doctor who fast and furious Winners Apple Apple TV Plus a nightmare on elm street stoner chucky Mary poppins nbcuniversal kids HBO Go Reality Competition Netflix Christmas movies boxoffice cinemax independent TCA Winter 2020 El Rey Thanksgiving YouTube Red sequel stop motion Fox Searchlight crime Spike franchise CBS All Access NYCC History IFC Films Film Festival Tubi screen actors guild NBC IFC GIFs robots emmy awards composers Spectrum Originals Marvel Studios Crackle A&E SundanceTV Red Carpet MCU anthology vampires Rocky dark elevated horror New York Comic Con WGN SXSW romantic comedy miniseries Election Quiz Premiere Dates Super Bowl VICE First Look USA witnail theme song teaser Biopics batman Heroines Pop TV spain discovery Epix mockumentary Academy Awards Sony Pictures video on demand sag awards SDCC The Academy 4/20 movies HBO superhero Hear Us Out Cannes cancelled TV shows golden globes ESPN Western Song of Ice and Fire spinoff nature Animation Nominations PBS ghosts Peacock 2019 BET Awards Nat Geo VH1 Certified Fresh Pop all-time E! TruTV Photos classics rotten movies we love documentaries Columbia Pictures TCA Awards Martial Arts Marvel Television Disney Channel Masterpiece period drama Trophy Talk spanish Emmy Nominations social media remakes 2018 BAFTA TLC Holiday YouTube Premium Apple TV+ Funimation Spring TV crime thriller breaking bad Musicals disaster hispanic Brie Larson RT21 Disney streaming service CBS zero dark thirty Mystery Dark Horse Comics GLAAD The Purge parents joker Amazon Studios children's TV christmas movies docudrama criterion finale TV Disney+ Disney Plus Esquire Comic Book science fiction serial killer cops BBC One hist TBS mission: impossible Teen Box Office Superheroes asian-american AMC Opinion adventure 45 TV Land television Interview singing competition Syfy PaleyFest war movie Avengers Marathons natural history 24 frames medical drama what to watch diversity TIFF 20th Century Fox reviews Crunchyroll cults Sundance TV crime drama APB Awards Drama Emmys Elton John revenge cars latino Star Trek Fall TV WarnerMedia blaxploitation name the review Kids & Family Toys Set visit BBC America Disney Mary Tyler Moore Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt MTV E3 Vudu universal monsters Hallmark Christmas movies Mary Poppins Returns Warner Bros. south america Tarantino historical drama 007 dramedy TCA 2017 National Geographic Comedy Central game of thrones Turner Classic Movies worst movies spider-man FOX DC Comics binge ratings Black History Month Universal Stephen King Acorn TV rotten scary movies Horror Fantasy Musical ABC Calendar Rom-Com Rocketman Bravo justice league cats Winter TV dragons award winner TV renewals Walt Disney Pictures Cosplay DirecTV FX cancelled television Grammys sports zombies concert screenings Summer Pet Sematary Sci-Fi talk show Trivia critics Baby Yoda sequels news japanese Year in Review indiana jones Film biography based on movie DC streaming service Oscars Podcast Valentine's Day free movies San Diego Comic-Con tv talk TCM festival Lucasfilm Lionsgate VOD Fox News werewolf Binge Guide video true crime football See It Skip It supernatural cooking The Arrangement Tumblr Classic Film spanish language Women's History Month canceled TV shows documentary PlayStation CMT Amazon Prime Video Adult Swim HBO Max Ghostbusters OWN Reality Travel Channel nfl Hulu romance The Witch Shondaland facebook laika YA USA Network Captain marvel Watching Series films venice game show anime Sundance aliens toy story Awards Tour toronto Amazon Prime versus Sundance Now ABC Family Food Network Turner Ellie Kemper Showtime canceled Video Games Christmas Character Guide 2015 Lifetime Mindy Kaling Holidays strong female leads Polls and Games Lifetime Christmas movies Marvel Trailer dceu stand-up comedy hollywood OneApp die hard TCA halloween tv spy thriller CW Seed BBC worst Comedy BET Tomatazos comiccon festivals obituary political drama YouTube Country Countdown Television Academy Cartoon Network halloween space Mudbound Pride Month 2016 Amazon LGBTQ 21st Century Fox Creative Arts Emmys American Society of Cinematographers First Reviews Discovery Channel comedies quibi slashers technology Television Critics Association satire Chernobyl Writers Guild of America Family DC Universe unscripted Star Wars crossover FX on Hulu blockbuster cancelled TV series dogs Action Pixar Shudder Rock richard e. Grant directors