Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Prisoners is Certified Fresh

Plus, Battle of the Year has two left feet.

by | September 19, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a frantic search (Prisoners, starring Hugh Jackman and Jake Gyllenhaal) and an international dance-off (Battle of the Year, starring Josh Holloway and Laz Alonso). What do the critics have to say?



A dark, grim police procedural, Prisoners isn’t exactly feel-good cinema. However, critics say it’s a suspenseful, gripping thriller, thanks to an outstanding ensemble cast and a mystery that remains ambiguous to the end. Keller Dover (Hugh Jackman) is the father of a six-year-old girl who goes missing, along with her best friend. A suspect is arrested, but released for lack of evidence; fearing the worst for his child, Dover decides to take the law into his own hands. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Prisoners is haunting, tense, and disturbing, with a weighty sense of moral complexity. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down co-star Jake Gyllenhaal’s best-reviewed movies

Battle of the Year


Nobody goes to a dance movie expecting high art, but critics say Battle of the Year is flimsy even by the standards of the genre, spending too much time on its hackneyed story and not enough on the dancefloor. With an international dance competition only months away, a down-on-his-luck basketball coach (Josh Holloway) is recruited to coax a squad of 12 street dancers into fighting shape. Will this ragtag band of breakers bring home the title — and will their coach find a measure of personal redemption in the process? The pundits say Battle of the Year delivers a few slick dance moves, but its plot is hopelessly hokey and the dialogue is unintentionally hilarious.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • The Wizard of Oz: An IMAX 3D Experience, starring Judy Garland in a timeless classic about a girl who isn’t in Kansas anymore, is Certified Fresh at 99 percent.
  • Enough Said, starring Julia Louis-Dreyfus and James Gandolfini in a drama about a divorced woman who meets a man who seems perfect until she finds out a little more about him, is Certified Fresh at 93 percent.
  • After Tiller, a documentary that profiles doctors that perform late-term abortions, is at 85 percent.
  • Generation Iron, a doc about the world of professional bodybuilders, is at 80 percent.
  • The Short Game, a doc about the highly competitive world of junior golf, is at 78 percent.
  • C.O.G., a dramedy based on a David Sedaris story about a man who ditches his modern devices and works as an apple picker in Oregon, is at 74 percent.
  • Haute Cuisine, a comedy about a little-known provincial chef who becomes the French president’s personal cook, is at 71 percent.
  • Thanks For Sharing, starring Mark Ruffalo and Gwyneth Paltrow in a dramedy about the lives of an interconnected group of recovering sex addicts, is at 57 percent.
  • Ip Man: The Final Fight, an action drama about the legendary martial arts master in the twilight of his life, is at 58 percent.
  • A Single Shot, starring Sam Rockwell and Jeffrey Wright in a thriller about a hunter who inadvertently kills a woman and tries to cover it up, is at 52 percent.
  • Men at Lunch, a documentary about the famous photograph Lunch atop a Skyscraper, is at 50 percent.
  • Newlyweeds, a comedy about a young couple that smokes an awful lot of marijuana, is at 44 percent.
  • My Lucky Star, starring Zhang Ziyi in a spy spoof about a cartoonist who gets involved in a plot to obtain a valuable diamond, is at 44 percent.
  • Zaytoun, starring Stephen Dorff in a drama about an Israeli pilot who travels with a Palestinian orphan to see the kid’s family’s hometown, is at 39 percent.
  • Weekender, a dramedy about a pair of friends who organize warehouse raves in the early 1990s, is at nine percent.
  • The Colony, starring Laurence Fishburne and Bill Paxton in a sci-fi thriller set in a post-apocalyptic ice age, is at six percent.
  • Jewtopia, starring Jennifer Love Hewitt and Jamie-Lynn Sigler in a romantic comedy about a guy who pretends to be Jewish in order to win the heart of a rabbi’s daughter, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

mcc DirecTV foreign 93rd Oscars Martial Arts Pirates cancelled Reality science fiction werewolf TNT BET Hallmark Christmas movies Nominations rotten movies we love telelvision streaming discovery Turner Classic Movies feel good The CW singing competition Interview NBC Spectrum Originals Hulu Warner Bros. Heroines 71st Emmy Awards BBC One Musical The Witch Brie Larson Masterpiece anthology toronto women Video Games comic Food Network Teen disaster The Walt Disney Company The Purge space BET Awards Nickelodeon Exclusive Video FXX crime Television Critics Association saw Starz tv talk DC Comics debate olympics 2018 zero dark thirty RT21 Ghostbusters universal monsters Vudu YouTube Red Holiday YouTube Elton John Box Office hist heist movie Thanksgiving VOD Valentine's Day child's play dc venice batman CBS black 2015 monster movies Tarantino Disney+ Disney Plus Animation TCA Winter 2020 Star Wars HBO MSNBC lord of the rings jurassic park American Society of Cinematographers Superheroe elevated horror diversity Endgame Fantasy docuseries Comics on TV talk show 1990s Horror festivals Marvel Studios spy thriller new star wars movies GLAAD Pixar Podcast 90s japanese Polls and Games Mystery documentaries sequels strong female leads spain Pacific Islander nbcuniversal Legendary critic resources book facebook joker BAFTA Binge Guide Image Comics superhero Extras japan Amazon Prime Black Mirror slasher 007 cats technology travel sports Sony Pictures fresh dogs spinoff sequel Western ID SXSW Paramount Plus Hear Us Out golden globes HBO Go Apple Avengers TBS Spring TV Logo concert Disney Channel harry potter Marvel a nightmare on elm street 2021 Rock President marvel comics stoner scorecard cartoon biography remakes Oscars scary movies 99% spanish language Showtime Awards renewed TV shows cooking films YA Writers Guild of America E3 PBS DC streaming service football mutant movies Action Drama Acorn TV Apple TV+ 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Marathons Lifetime Christmas movies binge Pride Month 2017 Marvel Television gangster Quiz Star Trek reviews CW Seed ABC Signature Mudbound aliens YouTube Premium ABC Family Summer Lifetime CMT Comedy worst movies Universal Premiere Dates Red Carpet rotten award winner rom-coms Sneak Peek Epix Sundance TV 2020 breaking bad crime thriller based on movie Sundance fast and furious halloween tv Kids & Family Infographic canceled TV shows Sundance Now indie CBS All Access mockumentary Television Academy Travel Channel Tubi Chernobyl The Walking Dead Lucasfilm Shudder theme song Classic Film Rocketman Apple TV Plus young adult PlayStation Toys TV renewals GIFs transformers cops Arrowverse australia See It Skip It History TV movies Freeform TV Land razzies chucky Song of Ice and Fire Funimation First Reviews Creative Arts Emmys stand-up comedy TCM boxing USA free movies medical drama game of thrones what to watch twilight Esquire Election cinemax book adaptation El Rey finale PaleyFest comic book movie sag awards Superheroes A24 National Geographic toy story TV One revenge suspense Mary poppins Photos Amazon Prime Video E! Schedule kong Amazon Studios adventure name the review Family Captain marvel slashers ViacomCBS television hollywood latino parents nature Netflix Christmas movies prank Ovation ITV Rom-Com Emmys rt archives Cartoon Network godzilla LGBT DGA Best and Worst game show true crime Disney streaming service 20th Century Fox cancelled TV series Disney biopic Pet Sematary video AMC witnail VH1 supernatural IFC Films italian social media Turner cancelled TV shows cars quibi politics BBC America 45 MCU Countdown hidden camera ESPN Black History Month french classics psychological thriller Emmy Nominations RT History Peacock historical drama SDCC news San Diego Comic-Con action-comedy adenture directors critics crossover romance Academy Awards Certified Fresh Musicals 2019 Watching Series Bravo Comic Book Paramount Network Super Bowl USA Network Holidays worst Walt Disney Pictures popular 4/20 documentary teaser vampires zombie marvel cinematic universe Awards Tour satire Lionsgate Tomatazos NYCC Crackle reboot Country cults rt labs critics edition Trailer Pop dramedy dragons ghosts dark Spike laika Set visit Ellie Kemper Broadway Fall TV Crunchyroll Grammys Music Stephen King animated richard e. Grant blockbusters A&E 72 Emmy Awards blockbuster Syfy Film Festival Britbox Discovery Channel VICE target posters TV golden globe awards anime video on demand rt labs adaptation spanish emmy awards Tokyo Olympics Opinion 24 frames OWN Wes Anderson basketball Women's History Month hispanic green book ABC Columbia Pictures FX Mindy Kaling Winter TV zombies festival asian-american halloween FX on Hulu X-Men Netflix indiana jones New York Comic Con Year in Review king kong Comic-Con@Home 2021 die hard Character Guide screen actors guild CNN Christmas mission: impossible 2016 LGBTQ political drama streaming movies NBA Tumblr criterion archives Amazon Alien Rocky robots 73rd Emmy Awards composers Reality Competition sitcom romantic comedy Calendar kaiju APB TIFF Dark Horse Comics WGN jamie lee curtis DC Universe trailers kids crime drama best Chilling Adventures of Sabrina aapi comiccon Sci-Fi christmas movies casting serial killer GoT TCA Awards canceled live action Pop TV Fox Searchlight HBO Max comics boxoffice royal family hispanic heritage month Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Disney Plus Mary Poppins Returns comic books scene in color franchise legend 21st Century Fox new zealand MTV BBC SundanceTV Comedy Central Trophy Talk First Look screenings nfl movie Cannes wonder woman Trivia international Anna Paquin know your critic deadpool dexter TLC TruTV superman justice league james bond unscripted obituary Adult Swim high school ratings cancelled television psycho IFC comic book movies Film Paramount all-time period drama police drama Biopics WarnerMedia Cosplay Nat Geo The Arrangement FOX TCA pirates of the caribbean Fox News war miniseries TCA 2017 series Shondaland thriller OneApp stop motion Baby Yoda blaxploitation The Academy spider-man doctor who Winners versus king arthur Mary Tyler Moore natural history docudrama Hallmark children's TV dceu south america new york comedies independent