Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Gravity is Certified Fresh

Plus, Runner Runner is a losing bet, and Metallica Through the Never is Certified Fresh.

by | October 4, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got stranded astronauts (Gravity, starring Sandra Bullock and George Clooney), a gambling racket (Runner Runner, starring Ben Affleck and Justin Timberlake), and some heavy metal thunder (the concert documentary Metallica Through the Never). What do the critics have to say?



It’s too soon to tell whether Gravity will join 2001 and Apollo 13 in the pantheon of classic films featuring astronauts in peril. What we can say for certain, however, is that critics are over the moon for Alfonso Cuarón’s outer space thriller, calling it a marvel of technical wizardry, white-knuckle tension, and emotional resonance. Sandra Bullock and George Clooney star as a pair of astronauts who become stranded in the atmosphere when an unexpected debris shower destroys their shuttle and leaves them without a way to return to Earth. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Gravity is a singular movie achievement: it’s bold, immersive, formally trailblazing, and achingly moving. (Check out our interviews with Bullock and Cuarón, as well as our gallery of memorable movie astronauts.)

Runner Runner


A great cast and an intriguing premise do not a successful thriller make. Critics say Runner Runner is a surprisingly dull, by-the-numbers crime film that is made only slightly more watchable by virtue of its tropical setting and its overqualified acting ensemble. Justin Timberlake stars as Richie, an Ivy Leaguer whose online poker winnings are financing his education. But when Richie gets scammed, he travels to Costa Rica to confront Ivan (Ben Affleck), the site’s CEO; soon enough, Richie is drawn into Ivan’s high-roller lifestyle. The pundits say Runner Runner is predictable, short on suspense, and unconvincing in its depiction of the gambling demimonde. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Affleck’s best-reviewed films.)

Metallica Through the Never


After a week in limited release, the Certified Fresh Metallica Through the Never goes wide this weekend; critics say it’s one of the most inventively filmed, viscerally powerful concert documentaries to come along in quite some time — though they also note that its fictional narrative, which features Dane DeHaan as a young roadie who encounters a variety of strange situations and people while on a mission for the band, is slightly less assured. Still, the pundits say that even non-metalheads are likely to be impressed by the sheer power of Metalica’s live set, which is captured in eye-popping 3D.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • A.K.A. Doc Pomus, a documentary about the legendary R&B songwriter behind many of Elvis Presley’s hits, is at 100 percent.

  • Let The Fire Burn, a documentary about a violent attack on an activist group by Philadelphia police, is at 90 percent.

  • The Dirties, a black comedy about a pair of high schoolers whose plan to make a film about getting revenge on a bully goes too far, is at 82 percent.

  • A Touch of Sin, an action drama about four different men in China who turn to violence after becoming victims of circumstance, is at 80 percent.

  • The Summit, a doc about the deaths of a number of climbers attempting to scale K2, is at 78 percent.

  • Concussion, a drama about a woman whose staid suburban existence is upended after taking a baseball to the head, is at 75 percent.

  • Bad Milo!, starring Ken Marino and Peter Stormare in a horror comedy about a demon living in a man’s intestine, is at 71 percent.

  • Linsanity, a doc about NBA guard Jeremy Lin’s seemingly out-of-nowhere success, is at 56 percent.

  • A.C.O.D., starring Adam Scott and Richard Jenkins in a comedy about a guy who learns he was part of a divorce study when he was a kid, is at 50 percent.

  • Parkland, starring Zac Efron and Paul Giamatti in a drama about the events that followed the assassination of President Kennedy, is at 48 percent.

  • All Is Bright, starring Paul Rudd and Paul Giamatti in a comedy about two ex-cons who try to go straight by selling Christmas trees in New York City, is at 20 percent.

  • Argento’s Dracula 3D, starring Asia Argento and Rutger Hauer in the Italian horror maestro’s take on Bram Stoker’s classic novel, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

Paramount Plus NYCC BBC One PaleyFest Schedule romantic comedy 94th Oscars Sundance TV Country stop motion zero dark thirty Infographic streaming Legendary quibi Prime Video Fox Searchlight rt labs Crunchyroll Best Actor animated Sony Pictures Mary Tyler Moore Song of Ice and Fire legend Image Comics RT History indiana jones SundanceTV Shudder new york TNT young adult Mystery teaser 2021 heist movie new zealand 20th Century Fox james bond Hollywood Foreign Press Association HFPA toronto kids ESPN elevated horror TCA Winter 2020 San Diego Comic-Con technology MGM DC streaming service crime Pirates Rocketman royal family mockumentary CW Seed Epix jurassic park rt labs critics edition kong documentaries Chilling Adventures of Sabrina The Walt Disney Company Columbia Pictures king arthur Paramount Pictures streaming movies stand-up comedy Best Actress Sundance Reality marvel comics AMC Plus Fargo Superheroes batman documentary FX suspense spanish language composers Interview video on demand GoT rotten asian-american Instagram Live prank Extras romance saw sitcom breaking bad festivals Disney streaming service blockbusters 71st Emmy Awards pirates of the caribbean Tumblr Western live action TV renewals green book Amazon Studios BBC criterion police drama Sony Comic Book vs. The Academy TIFF NBA hollywood japan adenture scary movies Red Carpet reboot Mary poppins Film Festival Comics on TV jamie lee curtis Apple TV+ 79th Golden Globes Awards Spike Hallmark obituary aapi godzilla Year in Review die hard Television Academy VH1 CBS USA new star wars movies The CW Video Games Set visit Creative Arts Emmys robots HBO Cannes SXSW telelvision Photos archives FXX TCM Indigenous psychological thriller facebook Netflix Christmas movies 72 Emmy Awards Family boxing transformers spider-verse fast and furious sports PlayStation know your critic Biopics cops 2017 comic books A24 dreamworks foreign adventure DC Comics IFC children's TV Binge Guide Paramount Grammys south america Adult Swim Election Fantasy Elton John 1990s sag awards obi wan free movies joker french DGA WGN NBC name the review biopic Broadway supernatural theme song First Look YA Writers Guild of America Fall TV news mcc video independent spain Amazon Prime SDCC Premiere Dates Kids & Family Ellie Kemper Turner Classic Movies hispanic heritage month RT21 Sci-Fi docudrama science fiction Hear Us Out films football slashers Crackle Travel Channel popular chucky E! comic 2015 summer TV 007 Reality Competition series Winners screen actors guild superman casting BET Lifetime Christmas movies IFC Films SXSW 2022 Star Trek National Geographic feel good 2018 debate dogs Tags: Comedy Spring TV Best and Worst Pop TV nfl South by Southwest Film Festival TV One hispanic disaster MSNBC TV Land Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt VOD worst movies ID serial killer Native The Witch movie 24 frames Thanksgiving 2019 justice league Nat Geo mob 93rd Oscars The Purge Avengers vampires Comic-Con@Home 2021 marvel cinematic universe Tarantino Endgame TLC Tubi BAFTA History TBS LGBT GIFs laika PBS Starz parents TCA Awards Mindy Kaling Trivia critics Funimation Black Mirror based on movie ViacomCBS women Tomatazos El Rey miniseries versus YouTube Red Heroines Certified Fresh space cults cinemax natural history Horror halloween tv emmy awards Pet Sematary Musicals Box Office Hulu YouTube Premium crime drama politics Cosplay TCA 2017 MCU cancelled Lionsgate slasher Baby Yoda First Reviews Mary Poppins Returns YouTube indie posters harry potter Comedy Central Apple TV Plus DirecTV Disney+ Disney Plus Arrowverse Lifetime tv talk FOX directors japanese 90s boxoffice Pixar classics concert Emmys Peacock TV Brie Larson Classic Film superhero richard e. Grant DC Universe war Christmas doctor who monster movies Tokyo Olympics witnail MTV Vudu black comedy Universal Pictures wonder woman spanish Rom-Com Hallmark Christmas movies Sneak Peek New York Comic Con trailers dexter 2020 rom-coms political drama aliens Animation Food Network blockbuster Britbox 4/20 TruTV renewed TV shows spy thriller Masterpiece olympics Netflix italian target scene in color CBS All Access Martial Arts Best Picture sequel X-Men Oscars 2016 Marvel Studios Summer singing competition Bravo Star Wars sopranos Musical lord of the rings Emmy Nominations Toys Ghostbusters true crime best Wes Anderson action-comedy strong female leads Apple Awards toy story Universal TCA dragons Holiday all-time cooking Marvel HBO Max Focus Features LGBTQ golden globes dceu latino adaptation Paramount Network Quiz Neflix spider-man hidden camera Captain marvel summer preview comics Podcast Polls and Games 21st Century Fox APB Discovery Channel Trailer Valentine's Day game show festival satire leaderboard Esquire comiccon Ovation broadcast AMC scene in color film series Holidays Academy Awards FX on Hulu king kong television The Arrangement 45 Character Guide universal monsters IMDb TV Star Wars Celebration Freeform Best Director talk show razzies Lucasfilm Winter TV game of thrones HBO Go streamig stoner crime thriller crossover travel medical drama ghosts nbcuniversal Pacific Islander rt archives movies Pop GLAAD Geeked Week historical drama Countdown A&E BET Awards revenge Warner Bros. Logo Music Comedy President Stephen King mutant franchise high school unscripted critic resources dc Superheroe ABC Fox News what to watch Showtime 99% 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards ITV sequels ABC Signature anthology Cartoon Network E3 golden globe awards discovery social media Disney scene in color ratings scene in color series Film Action Walt Disney Pictures American Society of Cinematographers scorecard OneApp twilight canceled TV shows Marathons Sundance Now anime cancelled television period drama cartoon child's play CNN Anna Paquin CMT Nominations cars 73rd Emmy Awards Teen BBC America basketball blaxploitation Trophy Talk OWN australia remakes docuseries comedies USA Network nature cancelled TV series target The Walking Dead Oscar See It Skip It live event ABC Family reviews screenings Super Bowl biography mission: impossible Alien Turner psycho rotten movies we love diversity black fresh dramedy Acorn TV Women's History Month thriller canceled a nightmare on elm street zombie binge Dark Horse Comics VICE book scary Watching Series Spectrum Originals Calendar Awards Tour award winner Nickelodeon Marvel Television cancelled TV shows interviews Television Critics Association comic book movie hist trophy Exclusive Video finale Rock werewolf zombies halloween gangster Syfy WarnerMedia spinoff Opinion Amazon Prime Video Pride Month Drama kaiju TV movies Amazon worst deadpool cats Chernobyl christmas movies book adaptation Disney Channel Shondaland comic book movies Rocky summer TV preview Mudbound venice dark Disney Plus art house international genre Black History Month