Critics Consensus

Fantastic Four Is Fatally Flawed

Plus, Shaun the Sheep is Certified Fresh; Ricki and the Flash carries a decent tune; The Gift is a terrifically tense thriller; and Wet Hot American Summer: First Day of Camp is Certified Fresh.

by | August 6, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a quartet of superheroes (Fantastic Four, starring Miles Teller and Michael B. Jordan); runaway livestock (the stop-motion animated feature Shaun the Sheep); a veteran rocker (Ricki and the Flash, starring Meryl Streep and Mamie Gummer); and a creepy acquaintance (The Gift, starring Jason Bateman and Rebecca Hall). What do the critics have to say?


Fantastic Four (2015) 9%

Pity the poor Fantastic Four. Marvel’s original superhero team has never been particularly well served on the big screen, and critics say that trend continues with Fantastic Four, a jumbled attempt to reboot the franchise that boasts talented actors stranded in an oddly morose, badly paced misfire. It’s yet another origin story: Reed Richards (Miles Teller) and his pals figure out how to teleport to another dimension, but after an ill-fated trip they all end up with superpowers — and make an enemy of the evil Dr. Doom. The pundits say that Fantastic Four has a few interesting ideas that are quickly pushed aside in favor of overripe dialogue, endless exposition, and so-so special effects.


Shaun the Sheep Movie (2015) 99%

The cheeky Brits over at Aardman Animations — the folks who brought you Wallace & Gromit and Chicken Run — are masters of the witty, whimsical stop-motion comedy. However, critics say they may have topped themselves with Shaun the Sheep, an astonishing achievement that blends Chaplinesque silent-movie  slapstick with a surfeit of hilarious visual gags. Shaun the Sheep encourages the rest of his flock to take a day off, which eventually leads to the disappearance of their owner into the big city. The sheep attempt to recover the farmer, and hilarity ensues. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Shaun the Sheep is truly inspired in its comic lunacy, and while some of the jokes might fly over the heads of the youngest viewers, it’s sure to enchant the whole family.


Ricki And The Flash (2015) 63%

Meryl Streep classes up everything she touches, so it’s a little surprising to see her play a down-and-dirty rocker in Ricki and the Flash. But critics say the film has a few more tricks up its sleeve — despite its shopworn premise, Ricki and the Flash offers enough great acting and toe tapping tunes to be a little more than just the same old song. Streep stars as a singer who ditched her family to chase musical stardom. But with her estranged daughter in the midst of a personal crisis, Ricki heads home in an attempt to heal old wounds. The pundits say Ricki and the Flash isn’t earth-shaking, but it’s energetic and raggedy enough to make its formulaic elements feel fresh.


The Gift (2015) 92%

If you’ve seen Warrior or The Great Gatsby, you know Joel Edgerton has a commanding screen presence. And critics say that if the chilling, intelligent thriller The Gift is any indication, he’s got a promising future behind the camera as well. Well-to-do Simon (Jason Bateman) has a seemingly chance encounter with Gordo (Edgerton), an old high school classmate. But Gordo starts showing up everywhere Simon goes, and leaving odd gifts at his house; is there something in their pasts that prompted such behavior? The pundits say The Gift is a deeply unnerving psychological drama that sustains its tension from beginning to end.


What’s Hot On TV:

Strike Back: Legacy (2015) 100%

Strike Back‘s final season promises a big finish fueled by compelling characters and sensational video game-style action.


Wet Hot American Summer: First Day of Camp (2015) 92%

Wet Hot American Summer: First Day of Camp offers more of the the goofy hijinks that fans of the cult classic crave, but outsiders might not be quite as enamored.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Two Step (2015) , a noirish thriller about a down-on-his-luck man who gets ensnared by a con artist, is at 100 percent.
  • Dragon Ball Z: Resurrection 'F' (2015)the latest installment of the venerable anime franchise, is at 100 percent.
  • The Diary Of A Teenage Girl (2015) , starring Bel Powley and Kristen Wiig in a coming-of-age drama about a promising young artist with a growing drug problem and a host of family issues, is at 92 percent.
  • Call Me Lucky (2015) , a documentary portrait of standup comic-turned-activist Barry Crimmins, is at 80 percent.
  • The Falling (2015) , a drama about a mysterious fainting epidemic at an all-girls boarding school in Britain, is at 80 percent.
  • Cop Car (2015) , starring Kevin Bacon and Shea Whigham in a thriller about a pair of teenagers who face dire consequences after taking a police car for a joyride, is at 78 percent.
  • Kahlil Gibran's The Prophet (2015) , an omnibus animated film that dramatizes the poems from the bestselling spiritual text, is at 67 percent.
  • Sneakerheadz (2015) , a documentary about obsessive athletic shoe collectors, is at 60 percent.
  • Dark Places (2015) , starring Charlize Theron and Nicholas Hoult in a thriller about a woman still suffering deep emotional scars from the murder of her family years before, is at 33 percent.
  • The Runner (2015) , starring Nicolas Cage and Connie Nielsen in a drama about a politician whose attempts to deal witht the BP oil spill are stymied by scandal, is at 31 percent.

Tag Cloud

DC streaming service Sundance Now Year in Review CW Seed 20th Century Fox 2019 Anna Paquin Awards Tour YA See It Skip It PBS technology 45 A&E award winner Pirates blaxploitation Winners Set visit sitcom Thanksgiving TIFF Music romance ITV San Diego Comic-Con historical drama unscripted New York Comic Con Masterpiece Nominations VICE Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Awards crime Nat Geo El Rey dc SundanceTV justice league Kids & Family Podcast YouTube Premium FXX what to watch cults Toys Creative Arts Emmys police drama politics APB Photos crossover OWN boxoffice Bravo ratings TBS Premiere Dates jamie lee curtis Mary poppins Red Carpet Sneak Peek Reality Competition Character Guide E! Best and Worst Lucasfilm Oscars vampires biography zombies doctor who Hulu Pixar festivals Comedy streaming Action Nickelodeon Quiz Infographic Lifetime medical drama Rock Western period drama science fiction Syfy BBC America Grammys Christmas spider-man 2018 SDCC Rocky TNT CBS All Access cops Horror IFC Films Emmys Paramount Network hist AMC robots MSNBC TCA diversity cooking golden globes Musicals MTV Amazon Prime Certified Fresh Paramount FOX USA Lionsgate 2015 DC Comics Shondaland casting Reality Comic Book Super Bowl TV Epix WGN 2016 aliens Freeform cinemax Mystery Polls and Games Biopics Box Office Country Adult Swim Trailer Watching Series CNN Shudder RT History Sci-Fi comic X-Men talk show 24 frames The Arrangement Star Wars Comedy Central miniseries Cartoon Network Marathons Musical Opinion Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Brie Larson The CW spy thriller Video Games Universal TCM ABC Family 007 Starz CMT singing competition comiccon President Martial Arts Disney Channel dramedy Ghostbusters Superheroes Holidays ESPN travel crime thriller Fantasy Cosplay Rom-Com GIFs Tumblr Apple mutant transformers dceu Crackle Drama Amazon binge E3 First Look Fox News discovery Song of Ice and Fire facebook Valentine's Day GLAAD Britbox Netflix harry potter Mary Poppins Returns MCU ABC Sundance TV Land Esquire Disney Pop Interview VH1 Tomatazos LGBTQ Calendar Spring TV finale USA Network Logo Comics on TV docudrama Black Mirror IFC Showtime History FX Food Network supernatural GoT 2017 Writers Guild of America YouTube Red National Geographic Winter TV cats NYCC Countdown adventure TLC DGA Superheroe Extras Election Teen political drama Ovation BBC Summer Animation zombie CBS crime drama sports DC Universe DirecTV Dark Horse Comics BET Warner Bros. Marvel PaleyFest Walt Disney Pictures Schedule NBC composers psycho Fall TV Mindy Kaling 21st Century Fox HBO TruTV war television based on movie Mary Tyler Moore Trophy Talk Spike Sony Pictures Star Trek thriller American Society of Cinematographers serial killer green book Captain marvel Trivia TCA 2017 social media Acorn TV Columbia Pictures SXSW Ellie Kemper anime