Critical Consensus: Grim for "Brothers," Dark for "Cave"

by | August 25, 2005 | Comments

At the movies this week, there’s an undercurrent of collectivism in the face of adversity. “The Brothers Grimm” features two con men in the 1700s who get in over their heads. In “The Cave,” a group of attractive spelunkers find some pretty scary stuff. And in “Undiscovered,” a bunch of aspiring artists deal with the pratfalls of climbing the celebrity ladder. What will the chorus of critics have to say?

In an age where remakes and rehashes reign supreme, it’s nice that Terry Gilliam remains as wildly imaginative as ever. But there’s a distinction between imagination and discipline; while Gilliam’s best work has tiptoed the line between the two, critics say his latest, “The Brothers Grimm,” is a muddle. The film stars Matt Damon and Heath Ledger as brothers and con men who spin tall tales for fun and profit. The scribes say that Gilliam needs to contain his wild flights of fancy, as there are many great ideas but nothing to unify them. At 37 percent on the Tomatometer, this is Gilliam’s worst reviewed film yet. But it’s not wrecking his Tomatometer average, which is solidly fresh at 80 percent. It’s also Matt Damon’s worst reviewd film since 2000’s “All the Pretty Horses,” which was sent to the glue factory with a 32 percent.

“The Cave” features a group of attractive spelunkers, an unknown species of monster, lots of rock climbing, and, naturally, the portal to Hell. Believe it or not, critics say the movie, starring Cole Hauser and Morris Chestnut, is a tad on the silly side. At 36 percent on the Tomatometer, things are looking dark for this “Cave.”

“Undiscovered” tells the story of some aspiring musicians and actresses hoping to make it. It’s such a completely original, daring idea that it’s surprising that Terry Gilliam didn’t write the screenplay. Critics are saying to leave this film, starring Kip Pardue, Pell James, and Ashlee Simpson, ahem, undiscovered. So far, it’s notching a big zero on the Tomatometer.

Most Recent Terry Gilliam Movies:
39% — Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas (1998)
87% — 12 Monkeys (1995)
86% — The Fisher King (1991)
87% — The Adventures of Baron Munchausen (1988)
93% — Brazil (1985)

Tag Cloud

IFC Films name the review strong female leads spanish language Endgame NYCC Discovery Channel Best and Worst Opinion cars romance Sundance SundanceTV Superheroes Sony Pictures serial killer boxoffice Classic Film Marvel Brie Larson game show VICE Columbia Pictures foreign tv talk CBS All Access Shondaland History halloween Logo spider-man television 21st Century Fox Rock adaptation sag awards Avengers talk show Super Bowl vampires Paramount Network stand-up comedy Hallmark Disney Channel Showtime Character Guide Hulu Film Festival Certified Fresh Tubi HBO Max period drama biography Biopics A24 2016 Grammys Pop CNN Extras joker political drama Arrowverse National Geographic Apple TV Plus mockumentary Elton John TruTV VH1 justice league politics 71st Emmy Awards cancelled 2019 reboot Calendar TCM Sci-Fi Premiere Dates HBO 2015 theme song DGA Bravo true crime binge Spring TV Action Vudu Comedy Mystery Sundance Now Starz Podcast latino Trailer Cartoon Network screen actors guild supernatural Mary poppins Fox News 24 frames Toys book Martial Arts WarnerMedia Creative Arts Emmys Writers Guild of America DC Universe Reality Year in Review Awards Tour First Reviews President Western christmas movies spy thriller Box Office El Rey renewed TV shows Baby Yoda Disney streaming service Freeform sequel Winners cancelled television Lifetime Christmas movies BET ABC Family TNT revenge YouTube Red Rocketman transformers ESPN Rom-Com ABC docudrama The CW green book crossover Oscars nature WGN blaxploitation SDCC Holiday YouTube Premium TCA Syfy composers adventure diversity Musical zombies Disney Plus casting crime thriller Song of Ice and Fire AMC aliens 20th Century Fox Crackle Paramount GoT Nickelodeon Warner Bros. Amazon 2018 canceled Amazon Prime Video DC streaming service MCU SXSW Ellie Kemper south america comiccon comic Netflix Christmas movies USA Network unscripted elevated horror Food Network cats Spike police drama Interview golden globes Pirates Holidays PaleyFest psychological thriller Universal movie Pride Month historical drama Apple TV+ Hallmark Christmas movies spain movies Sundance TV Ghostbusters Adult Swim IFC MSNBC Marathons Turner Classic Movies FOX technology Stephen King dramedy jamie lee curtis witnail Academy Awards cults 2020 BBC Rocky Tarantino Women's History Month Tomatazos werewolf medical drama TCA 2017 science fiction sports BBC America Polls and Games discovery See It Skip It Infographic anime harry potter animated Cannes what to watch Film TV Land doctor who Mudbound Superheroe award winner CBS Mindy Kaling OneApp spinoff Pixar TCA Winter 2020 disaster anthology Set visit Fantasy LGBT RT21 Fall TV The Arrangement social media toy story war Music Emmys Black Mirror TBS FXX Turner directors Lionsgate RT History Apple GIFs Tumblr Peacock streaming Amazon Prime facebook Animation Countdown Reality Competition Crunchyroll E! thriller ghosts GLAAD cops X-Men miniseries Photos comics children's TV dceu DC Comics E3 USA dc OWN Schedule Walt Disney Pictures Binge Guide Video Games cancelled TV series teaser A&E crime drama Sneak Peek slashers MTV Anna Paquin Heroines NBC Epix Star Trek TIFF sitcom Drama indie Marvel Studios natural history rotten movies we love batman The Purge zombie independent singing competition Britbox FX Esquire finale festivals canceled TV shows Netflix Family dogs Christmas Country Comic Book CMT Comedy Central Cosplay quibi San Diego Comic-Con psycho Valentine's Day space hist Nominations Disney+ Disney Plus ITV dragons Acorn TV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt crime Musicals series YA Emmy Nominations Dark Horse Comics Mary Poppins Returns Quiz travel game of thrones Shudder zero dark thirty APB video cancelled TV shows Nat Geo Chilling Adventures of Sabrina blockbuster kids Teen American Society of Cinematographers mutant Summer Chernobyl 45 cinemax PBS Red Carpet robots DirecTV 007 Trivia YouTube Spectrum Originals richard e. Grant screenings Disney Horror Kids & Family Amazon Studios cooking Television Academy hispanic romantic comedy ratings 2017 versus Lucasfilm Election Mary Tyler Moore Watching Series Pet Sematary Awards Star Wars breaking bad Captain marvel documentary Marvel Television TLC The Walking Dead TV Winter TV TV renewals LGBTQ Trophy Talk Ovation New York Comic Con Comics on TV Lifetime CW Seed The Witch Masterpiece Thanksgiving cartoon free movies based on movie First Look