Critical Consensus: Grim for "Brothers," Dark for "Cave"

by | August 25, 2005 | Comments

At the movies this week, there’s an undercurrent of collectivism in the face of adversity. “The Brothers Grimm” features two con men in the 1700s who get in over their heads. In “The Cave,” a group of attractive spelunkers find some pretty scary stuff. And in “Undiscovered,” a bunch of aspiring artists deal with the pratfalls of climbing the celebrity ladder. What will the chorus of critics have to say?

In an age where remakes and rehashes reign supreme, it’s nice that Terry Gilliam remains as wildly imaginative as ever. But there’s a distinction between imagination and discipline; while Gilliam’s best work has tiptoed the line between the two, critics say his latest, “The Brothers Grimm,” is a muddle. The film stars Matt Damon and Heath Ledger as brothers and con men who spin tall tales for fun and profit. The scribes say that Gilliam needs to contain his wild flights of fancy, as there are many great ideas but nothing to unify them. At 37 percent on the Tomatometer, this is Gilliam’s worst reviewed film yet. But it’s not wrecking his Tomatometer average, which is solidly fresh at 80 percent. It’s also Matt Damon’s worst reviewd film since 2000’s “All the Pretty Horses,” which was sent to the glue factory with a 32 percent.

“The Cave” features a group of attractive spelunkers, an unknown species of monster, lots of rock climbing, and, naturally, the portal to Hell. Believe it or not, critics say the movie, starring Cole Hauser and Morris Chestnut, is a tad on the silly side. At 36 percent on the Tomatometer, things are looking dark for this “Cave.”

“Undiscovered” tells the story of some aspiring musicians and actresses hoping to make it. It’s such a completely original, daring idea that it’s surprising that Terry Gilliam didn’t write the screenplay. Critics are saying to leave this film, starring Kip Pardue, Pell James, and Ashlee Simpson, ahem, undiscovered. So far, it’s notching a big zero on the Tomatometer.

Most Recent Terry Gilliam Movies:
39% — Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas (1998)
87% — 12 Monkeys (1995)
86% — The Fisher King (1991)
87% — The Adventures of Baron Munchausen (1988)
93% — Brazil (1985)

Tag Cloud

FX Television Critics Association ITV Star Wars Thanksgiving Crunchyroll Star Trek 2017 legend HBO FX on Hulu YA X-Men kaiju Fall TV Disney Channel 20th Century Fox Tags: Comedy The Witch President TV One free movies worst ABC Signature king arthur Paramount Tokyo Olympics based on movie streaming movies Teen cinemax king kong Fox Searchlight ViacomCBS new york Cartoon Network all-time true crime Mary Poppins Returns MCU Song of Ice and Fire PlayStation 24 frames Pixar universal monsters SundanceTV Nat Geo Winners OWN Year in Review Video Games talk show scary dc dreamworks Fargo MGM cancelled TV shows Chilling Adventures of Sabrina fresh BET reviews dark obi wan BBC One Music Best Picture hist The CW CBS History black news Turner Classic Movies police drama blockbuster gangster The Walking Dead Best Actor sequels BBC America technology ratings 2016 summer preview harry potter 93rd Oscars Awards best finale Rom-Com monster movies razzies historical drama slashers crime drama japan Sundance First Look Animation screenings DGA 1990s canceled TV shows 71st Emmy Awards pirates of the caribbean travel boxoffice james bond saw scene in color Arrowverse scary movies doctor who WarnerMedia nature Pop comic book movies Showtime Holidays cancelled Freeform Schedule asian-american Amazon rt labs trailers crime BAFTA Comic-Con@Home 2021 latino TruTV Black Mirror spanish language Sony Pictures name the review Paramount Network PBS dogs Netflix BET Awards Neflix GoT toy story composers streamig movie zombie criterion Disney streaming service mission: impossible Paramount Plus elevated horror ID adaptation diversity Syfy Marvel godzilla heist movie Emmy Nominations nfl DC Universe christmas movies Calendar australia children's TV YouTube Red Country Superheroes Discovery Channel cults Cosplay Travel Channel teaser Disney+ Disney Plus IMDb TV golden globe awards 2015 quibi video Martial Arts Creative Arts Emmys stoner comic books USA Network The Arrangement stop motion chucky AMC Plus revenge Bravo spain DC Comics Rock Trophy Talk Turner FXX reboot stand-up comedy summer TV boxing obituary venice 2021 TCA aapi spider-man TLC sports Academy Awards VOD RT History Reality Competition LGBT young adult aliens TV movies Legendary Winter TV hidden camera DC streaming service art house comics Netflix Christmas movies war dceu Disney Plus CMT cars TV renewals zero dark thirty Countdown TCM new zealand supernatural satire 2019 Black History Month marvel cinematic universe Rocketman Action strong female leads rt archives psycho USA Emmys YouTube Premium marvel comics HBO Max docudrama halloween tv TIFF anthology award winner political drama Box Office french A24 Film 45 Comedy Central E! HFPA TCA Winter 2020 series superman MSNBC hollywood critic resources versus Infographic Marvel Studios BBC adventure medical drama batman See It Skip It Polls and Games biopic anime animated rom-coms Britbox Peacock archives Walt Disney Pictures Cannes jurassic park popular werewolf Ghostbusters First Reviews justice league Best Actress Nominations Lifetime 007 Quiz richard e. Grant Mudbound Captain marvel Endgame SXSW 90s Watching Series Premiere Dates Masterpiece book golden globes Comics on TV Classic Film screen actors guild cancelled TV series ghosts SXSW 2022 Stephen King sag awards Podcast prank IFC Films japanese video on demand ABC Family crime thriller SDCC 99% Set visit adenture black comedy franchise joker jamie lee curtis Sundance TV comiccon toronto space The Walt Disney Company remakes theme song Broadway twilight festivals fast and furious Epix hispanic heritage month 79th Golden Globes Awards facebook international NBA comedies spanish Hollywood Foreign Press Association indiana jones blaxploitation football vampires game of thrones APB posters films Universal tv talk disaster Tarantino Nickelodeon kids vs. child's play romance Hear Us Out Television Academy television Comedy DirecTV what to watch feel good summer TV preview Spring TV dragons royal family TNT casting 94th Oscars Amazon Prime Video science fiction comic book movie Apple TV+ cooking PaleyFest Horror Trivia Opinion high school MTV OneApp Comic Book Avengers Amazon Studios Heroines Sundance Now AMC know your critic a nightmare on elm street GIFs singing competition Spectrum Originals Funimation Valentine's Day politics Character Guide Super Bowl ABC Vudu dexter Sneak Peek Hallmark Christmas movies The Academy Interview Tomatazos LGBTQ 73rd Emmy Awards movies Amazon Prime Disney Rocky Trailer comic cats Grammys Pacific Islander game show TV Land ESPN cancelled television halloween Ovation debate Pop TV crossover Pet Sematary basketball women action-comedy Adult Swim telelvision new star wars movies Holiday olympics Musicals live event GLAAD nbcuniversal Focus Features Spike Dark Horse Comics hispanic South by Southwest Film Festival Oscars Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt VICE Anna Paquin Ellie Kemper slasher documentary transformers superhero 72 Emmy Awards Best Director suspense lord of the rings indie A&E Binge Guide Shondaland Summer 2018 Drama Fantasy Hulu Paramount Pictures deadpool CNN Acorn TV book adaptation period drama social media spy thriller NYCC Family RT21 Instagram Live parents Lionsgate Baby Yoda spinoff docuseries canceled Starz Warner Bros. Chernobyl San Diego Comic-Con Reality TCA Awards Writers Guild of America Certified Fresh biography cartoon Apple TV Plus emmy awards Lucasfilm Exclusive Video Sci-Fi Brie Larson rotten movies we love foreign 21st Century Fox breaking bad 2020 italian dramedy Shudder unscripted Mindy Kaling miniseries streaming Mary poppins discovery CW Seed binge YouTube Image Comics target critics blockbusters green book genre American Society of Cinematographers concert Awards Tour rt labs critics edition Biopics Tumblr directors Western Marvel Television Musical Women's History Month classics NBC Tubi TV interviews mob Logo broadcast Film Festival serial killer Christmas romantic comedy leaderboard Wes Anderson trophy sopranos thriller Hallmark Columbia Pictures Superheroe Food Network spider-verse witnail Photos zombies wonder woman Apple worst movies sitcom independent robots Fox News E3 Kids & Family Oscar Toys rotten Alien festival Mystery National Geographic Red Carpet natural history VH1 live action scorecard 4/20 laika IFC Esquire El Rey The Purge New York Comic Con sequel cops TCA 2017 kong mcc Marathons die hard psychological thriller CBS All Access mutant 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Prime Video Mary Tyler Moore Election Pride Month Crackle Best and Worst renewed TV shows Pirates TBS mockumentary Lifetime Christmas movies Universal Pictures WGN documentaries Elton John Extras south america HBO Go FOX